Jump to content

The FM24 Youth Academy Challenge


Recommended Posts

  • Replies 4.3k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

1 hour ago, TerminalPortugal said:

 

On a different note, we have taken over on the 29th June 2024 and in a few days a few players are due to arrive at the club arranged by the previous regime. I believe I would not be allowed to use these players, so I will be releasing them as soon as they arrive at the club.

 

Not sure if this will be to late, but... If you can't cancel the transfers you are allowed to use them.

Link to post
Share on other sites

image.png.28857a7ae4ee2e6576f67d51b4de0d06.png

Karsiyaka 2nd Season

Just one of them seasons where no progress was made

Three more retirements, the youngsters are going to be first teamers pretty quick here as I have lost half of my original team already 

image.thumb.png.decae90fb5d75194049d45fa837d2bf7.png

I just managed to stay in the division, poor performances all round and my best player is in the last year of his contract, he wants 5k a week and I can only pay 1.2k max so I might try and get a fee for him

image.thumb.png.260e6c66cd1dc3f7f78cbca7b992659c.png

I will miss him and his goals, was my top scorer last season and plays cm

The club still wont let me do a training course, so no progress there 

I managed to get one upgrade on the youth recruitment, I'm now up to fairly basic :hammer:

 

with all my strikers retiring or not signing contracts I'm going into the next season with two 17 year olds upfront 

image.thumb.png.163a7f629e2ca4cfedf98f75d0ada48a.png

image.thumb.png.7dc1c242a4f954677e043f7e8079da0e.png

Both look good for this level tbf

Aims for next season is to hopefully get a few more goals than last year and some kind of facility upgrade, I'm miles off promotion etc.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Great updates everyone, thank you for the inspiration!

I have my own Youth Only save, but I don't participate here since I allow myself to sign back players from the academy.

 

One question for the seasoned pros in this:

I can't seem to fix my squad's personalities. I am on year 12, I have 16 Determination and from all my staff, the lowest is 15 (both main and youth coaches).

The first screenshot is from my main squad, the second one is from the youth squad. Am I doing something wrong? How can I fix this?

The main problem is that even the ones who come with good personalities through the intake get worse over time. Any suggestions?

Link to post
Share on other sites

18 minutes ago, BillHoudini24 said:

Great updates everyone, thank you for the inspiration!

I have my own Youth Only save, but I don't participate here since I allow myself to sign back players from the academy.

 

One question for the seasoned pros in this:

I can't seem to fix my squad's personalities. I am on year 12, I have 16 Determination and from all my staff, the lowest is 15 (both main and youth coaches).

The first screenshot is from my main squad, the second one is from the youth squad. Am I doing something wrong? How can I fix this?

The main problem is that even the ones who come with good personalities through the intake get worse over time. Any suggestions?

I am by no means an expert, but professionalism is the main stat that I have seen that allows for quick development in players. Therefore you would want to have staff members with Professional, Resolute, Model Citizen (there other personalities that have high professionalism). Your Head of Youth Development I believe probably has the biggest impact on the the starting personality of the youth players (not every single one, but on some).

If you are saying that the personalities are getting worse, this often is because they spend a lot of time around players with worse personalities. You often get a message saying that the club has had a positive or negative impact on a particular player. If both your first team and youth team are filled with bad personalities that is a tough situation, it might be worth culling some of those that have particularly bad personalities. If you had some good personalities in the main squad then you could bring up youth players that have good personalities into the main squad, where they wouldn't be as affected by bad personalities in the youth squad. Admittedly I have never seen youth players badly affected by being a player with a good personality in a sea of bad personalities in the youth team but it may happen.

If you have a few players in the main squad that have good personalities you could also attempt to mentor young players coming through the youth ranks. That should mean that they will be mostly affected by the mentoring group.

Determination is an important stat but not the most important stat. The other thing you might want to consider is that personality in staff is not a replacement for actual coaching quality. So if you have great personalities but bad coaches, they probably will hold back development considerably, albeit you would expect them to positively impact personalities if they are Resolute, Professional etc personalities.

Not sure this totally helped but hopefully it does.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Vikeologist's Víkingur Ólafsvík 2022 Report - Part 2

Youth Intake

vikingur.jpg.f41ce227c0b83ec93d5189b6de702022.jpg

My youth intake came in immediately before our last regular season match, but I couldn’t register them, which given I was reduced to starting a striker as a central defender, (and spoiler alert, it was a pretty important game) would have been helpful.

I signed them all.

They’re mostly 5 stars potential, but who knows if any of them are actually any good. I’m sure 2 or 3 of them will be starters immediately from next season though.

20240206113027_1.thumb.jpg.6be47a0c0241c1c1051c1f04e07cf4d4.jpg

 

 

Edited by vikeologist
Link to post
Share on other sites

image.png.eb331cf40a4e19a2d2c6f5f32f06e0a4.png

 

Karsiyaka 3rd Season Review

We hold on to 1. Division Status with a lot of youth playing first team football

I decided to cull some of the older members of the team and also has a few retirements, 

Best performer only just turned 18 with an impressive goal record, too bad he is talking about leaving 

image.thumb.png.256c81ef37e51d2d8c6513aa9ed1fee1.png

Managed to get my star midfielder to sign on for another year, did offer him for sale but no takers 

image.thumb.png.cc71a8223f1b61210f4279be34f4c951.png

 

Finished towards the bottom end of the table again, still got a fairly poor side for this level especially in defence, dont seem to be getting any full backs coming through so far, so i have had to resort to training midfielders into defenders

image.thumb.png.a0f9978f1c9f1a08d53018c6043fe8cc.png

 

Forgot to take a screen shot of the youth players, it was a supposed excellent take but I only signed 4 or 5 of them, was some terrible personalities and awful stats so I let most go.

star of the intake below and he doesnt look that great to me 

image.thumb.png.1fa1e294fcc0655c3a0cbdf971f6710f.png

got a couple of upgrades, one for junior coaching and one for youth recruitment

Still no coaching badges :rolleyes: onto the next year

 

image.png

Edited by djsterry
Link to post
Share on other sites

5 hours ago, libbyshuss said:

lyraliersebadge.png.c39952428569accca81b0476fe30e6a6.png

Lyra Lierse - Belgium

Challenger Pro League (tier 2) - 2029/30

League finish: 8th

Well, this season perfectly encapsulated why Belgium can be so frustrating! First season in the second tier, and due to a quirk where 4 of the sides cannot be promoted due to being affiliated with clubs in the top tier, our mid-table finish actually qualified us for the play off stages!

30leaguetable.jpg.a94a62dd9af05096fbe09e9afd71eeca.jpg

And once in the play off stages, we were suddenly fantastic:-

30playoffresults.JPG.af50f2eefd3ce70fc2f20457cbc6ae59.JPG

so we got through to the final, against the team who won the relegation play off for the top division. So 3 of my best players decided to get injured and another had to go on international duty.....

30playofffinal.JPG.9d009ed1af081c6dc2228b6dd185fd3a.JPG

So close to an unlikely promotion from a mid-table finish! i love Belgium!

so how do the board reward such as successful season? by announcing this:-

30backtosemipro.thumb.JPG.2e83b4e0103e89abbf134f382142797f.JPG

aargh! i hate belgium!

 

Players

Top Scorer: Leandro De Pauw 26C (21 goals in 34 games)

Player of the Season: Leandro de Pauw 26C (7.34 in 34 games)

A busy season for our star man! pre-season I signed him up on a 6 year contract, 1 week later the board accepted a stupidly low £400k offer from toulouse, a week after that he rejected it, only to then decide he wasn't happy with us after all!

But despite all that he performed on the pitch and is now rated a Jupiler Pro League player, so it's unlikely I can hold on to him for much longer

30depauew.thumb.JPG.3c5f23fbd1376ceb257e3af267ca0ab8.JPG

 

Youth

A lovely preview and a very exciting intake!

30youthpreview.thumb.JPG.11c57fd53c10b0031d00996f45f5507f.JPG

look at this!

30youthintake.thumb.JPG.cabfeefa872412120940e7033d00de54.JPG

Axl Thill!!!!! Jupiler Pro League quality at 15???? possibly my best ever intake player! shame he's a left back, but what can you do? He immediately insisted on a 4m release clause so he'll be cashed in as soon as i get a decent offer with a 50% clause. He could be the saviour of this save!

30axlthil.thumb.JPG.a96b43f18198b8d426b47182b49a6371.JPG

 

Career

30career.thumb.JPG.f587d5809212ca6b96d5c207212355a4.JPG

 

That lb looks unreal 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Also, this happened:

46U9jcy.png

0beaCKF.png

So keeping financial stable is important I see, as Kashima Antlers are in the mud. Luckily, I'm not in Belgium like @libbyshuss! ;) 

Link to post
Share on other sites

7 hours ago, Padders said:

Hungerford_Town_F.C._logo.png

Season 46 - 2069/70 - SBC

First season in the Championship and a decent mid table finish in 14th

Will take that for the first season

Off the pitch, a fair bit happened

Extra 2,995 seats added to the stadium

image.png.9f4dcb79a7051e4b81fe17e61808e82a.png

Planning for Youth Category increase

image.png.107e3dbabb4350201bdc4064d4a2791e.png

Considering we are £1m in the red, done well to get those improvements

Recouped some of the money by selling Richie Gillard, top player but wouldn't sign a new contract so had to sell to get the cash in

image.png.7b50bd1e57d9e39a1a1ddd658cc42d93.png

image.png.adebc89df9e6dbc38efad1b4f1496a40.png

20240108202143_1.thumb.jpg.308a21802194b9a1feda59d95e990544.jpg20240108192117_1.thumb.jpg.b2703f5751f5c61bc3d912eb8c5e2633.jpg20240108192136_1.thumb.jpg.6d2a49d8a8e791d5b9474e9711cdbef1.jpg20240108202127_1.thumb.jpg.35b2ccf5cfd779e141ee85791b96fa51.jpg20240108202140_1.thumb.jpg.3308adcd6cce4ee447314b42a9b82b5f.jpg

image.thumb.png.2b3fb4759e7dd5cbc23b3cbe0f7117ed.png

So it will only take until 2070 for my beloved Charlton to get back to the Premiership!

Link to post
Share on other sites

Every new fm for the last few i have tried this but never got past the first season.. It's that time to try it in fm24... I loaded a lot of leagues up and holidayed to give me the new teams. I narrowed it down to these. 

 

Screenshot 2024-02-06 152434.png

Link to post
Share on other sites

I don't think ive ever managed in Germany so the challenge takes me there, I didn't realise how many players you start with in Germany a lot more than you usually do.

 

Screenshot 2024-02-06 214930.png

Link to post
Share on other sites

55001104.png.797264764fb856eb5eeec67a145

ELECTRICO FUTEBOL CLUBE (PORTUGAL)

SEASON 6 – 2029/30

Finances | League Results I | League Results II | League Table | Portuguese Cup Results | League Cup Results | Squad | U19 Squad | B Team Squad | Under 19 Results | Under 19 Table | Under 19 Championship Results | Under 19 Championship Table | Youth Preview | Youth Intake I | Youth Intake II | Transfers

YOUTH CANDIDATES

ELITE | Rui Simoes | Joao Silva | Pedro Silva | Rufino Junior | Leonel Pulver | Pedro Paulo | Hugo Barradas | Paulo Roberto |

TOP | Bruno Nkondi | Rui Vallejo | Miguel Jesus | Sana Dabo | Antonio Nunes |

GOOD| Jorge Silva | Diogo Aragonez | Ricardo Almeida |

INTERNAL MATTERS

The board announced after the last season that we would be building a new stadium, this was because the expanding stadium we had just gotten would not be permitted in the league as all stadiums need at least 4,000 capacity. The new stadium is anticipated to hold 9,833 people.

Early in the season we learned that Rui Pires made the Liga SABSEG Team of the Year

With our not permitted with that capacity we did a deal with the council in another city to play there until the new stadium is built. We will be playing in Alcanena, a little way north of Lisbon at the Estadio Municipal Joaquim Maria Baptista, that holds 5,400 people.

Having moved up to the top division it was time to make some sweeping changes in the staff. The following staff came in Joao Sousa, Luis Mesquita, Marcio RamosPau Marti (a new assistant manager), Said ZaibilaRui TavaresMariana CamposPedro EmanuelDavid LucasAlexandre Melo, Shadel Samuel, Joao RaimundoDamia Abella

Towards the end of the season we signed a new 3 year deal again with another pay increase.

PLAYER MOVEMENTS FOR THE SEASON

This season there were some tough decisions to be made with the Under 19s. I could have brought up more, but I don’t want people to be blocked from playing time. So, in the end we brought up Goncalo Casqueiro, Miguel Ribeiro, Fabio Leite and Vitor Ferreira.

Jan Reffert could have come up, but I am trying to retrain him to left back and I want him to get more accustomed to the position before he comes up. Nuno Compadrinho could come up as goalkeeper, but we are already pushing Alexandre, so it is important that Compadrinho gets football before he becomes a backup. Aneximandro Carmelo is probably ready to play a part in the first team, but with Casqueiro a little further along and both playing of the right wing, I don’t want them to compete with each other in the first team.

Ivan Monteiro was another candidate, but Miguel Ribeiro came from last years intake looking ready, so he will have another season behind the strikers with the Under 19s. In the early part of the season, I start to see the team a little differently and brought him up as I felt he could get enough football this season.

In the January window we had to sell young goalkeeper Henriques as he was never going to be up to the standard and he wanted to leave, so this meant that Compadrinho was brought up to the first team, to the backup.

In mid February Casqueiro got a long term injury and this meant it was time to bring up Aneximandro Carmelo

RESULTS

We absolutely smashed it this season. All the beliefs I had that it would probably be a step too far were not correct as we managed to get 6th place in the league and thanks to the Portuguese Cup result, this qualified us for UEFA Europa Conference League football next season. We did get a few batterings along the way which contributed to us ending with a negative goal difference, such as the 7-1 battering we got at the hands of Benfica early in the season, but the boys really rose to the challenge and we were never really in danger of relegation. We mostly flirted around mid table, then looked nailed on for Europe, then wavered before on the final day securing qualification with a 1-0 win at Casa Pia and other results going our way.

In the Portuguese cup we went a step further than we have ever gone going all the way to the semi final, where we lost to Familicao over two legs, so that was a great achievement.

In the League Cup we only made as far as the 2nd Round, it was early in the season and not really a big priority for me, plus we were up against Sporting CP.

A superb season.

The link shows the gulf between us and remainder of the league. This was taken part way through the season. Our total wage expenditure per year is just under £500k, and Benfica's is £109m

PERFORMANCES

Both young goalkeepers this season went from strength to strength and had over a 7 rating with Joao Alexandre with a 7.03 and Nuno Compadrinho with a 7.12 albeit with much less games played, as he only filled in when Alexandre was injured. Alexandre is even nominated this season for Goalkeeper of the Season which a great achievement at just 17 years old.

Rui Pires defies logic, a player that was already on the books in the youth team when we showed up somehow continues to contribute at every level we pass through. His ability rating had fallen relative to the talent we now have but he is still solid. He got 14 goals this season and wasn’t even playing every game.

Ivan Monteiro came up past way through the season and was a revelation, he got the highest average rating at 7.10 of those that played a lot and he got 14 goals from attacking midfield.

Ismael Toure has really improved and was the top goalscorer last season with 19 goals as well as 6 assists. A great all round performance from him.

Then we had some players who didn’t really stand out on the pitch but have really come on this year in Goncalo Casqueiro, Fabio Leite, Aneximandro Carmelo, Miguel Ribeiro and Pedro Guilherme. They have all really improved and I am excited to see the team next season.

Another thing to mention is that we now quite a few players away with the youth international set ups.

We also have our first internationally capped player with the team as Innocent Ishimwe made his debut for Rwanda.

Ismael Toure is also considered Number 1 in the NXGN 2030 - Best Wondkids

UNDER 19s

The Under 19s performed well again, once again making through the Southern League, finishing in second place. However the Championship Group didn’t go to plan and we finished 7th, only above Estoril Praia. Still a great performance from the youngsters.

LOCATIONS OF YOUTH INTAKE

c1f66507fccd953f48fdc916030f6310.jpg

Link to Map

SUMMARY

c5dd379edd177a690a877a02be14a99e.png

Edited by TerminalPortugal
Link to post
Share on other sites

5 hours ago, Padders said:

Hungerford_Town_F.C._logo.png

Season 48 - 2071/72 - SBC

Not huge amount to report, another mid table finish, 14th

Was towards the higher end of midtable earlier in the season

Improvement in Youth Facilities and training facilties

image.png.917eb7573f05e38470dc4b2f0c95157c.png

image.png.da24b1734234c61c291d6df9cddc3dad.png
 

20240112153915_1.thumb.jpg.0ce3ba2043faef9bf4c926eb526b18fd.jpg20240112113722_1.thumb.jpg.9bceaed221018b7324e674d1ae6b09d2.jpg20240112113740_1.thumb.jpg.8011b63b794268f992a72ba7533aa5b1.jpg20240112153903_1.thumb.jpg.e2a10bd5ab05b716a2bbac58949fa8d4.jpg20240112153912_1.thumb.jpg.97b0398f307a24667996a0a4c41c7f8e.jpg

image.thumb.png.546ec5dacd543b98d74ec14e37238578.png

I know its 2072 but I have to ask about Man City

Link to post
Share on other sites

Season 2 ended just outside the playoffs. It was disappointing because we were in control of our own fate, but failed to win on the last day. Honestly I don't think this team was ready to go up, but it would have been nice to give it a go. For the team of the season Quintongo, Salisbury, White, and Crichlow were all additions from the first intake. So the team is starting to transition to the homegrown players. Also including transfer history for the first 2 seasons to comply with the rules of the challenge.  

Season 3 is starting out promising as well. Wil check in with the Intake Preview later. 

Thanks for reading!

-R

image.thumb.png.d362a68e99332068b1b57c3eb2b4fb02.png

image.thumb.png.ef0f34c87012cbadb49c2548c9ca16d1.png

image.thumb.png.1f8f00c9068e45ff52e08f7c77e1579f.png

image.thumb.png.a05784278d4d480080c7a05fd940291f.png

image.thumb.png.53b389dea630be3dc18057b2172b8611.png

image.png.ef6ec70350d5fe0f350bc1e44bb4cb22.png

image.thumb.png.fae765dff144aec8ae9ba3a6a50b2fd5.png

Edited by chsot68
Link to post
Share on other sites

16 hours ago, Anners said:

Previous Post:

 

2059/60 Season Report

Club: Tranent FC (Scotland)
League: Scottish Premiership

image.png.65bf1c2ffe28f2b853a910daaa57f10d.png

League:

image.thumb.png.a89555529f9947568e515c9e480cc0bb.png

Nearly the most sane and calm league we've had in Scotland for about 20 years now. Everyone roughly finished whereabouts they should finish, with Celtic and Hearts underachieving quite a bit here. We had a bit of a shocking start (8 points from the first 7 games) which meant we lost ground on Hibs who almost led from start to finish. We're now at the point where we've got one of the best defences in the league finally (it helps when you're able to keep your players!) with the back-ups being of a decent enough standard to sub in as well. We finished poorly as well which didn't help, although reasons for that are below...

Europe:

image.png.fdbfedd856f9d472b572305be595e4f5.png

Still not the big trophy, but we're getting closer and closer every few years! 

Results:

  Hide contents

image.png.549abff4919ef3340069f56e78327e33.png

We lost 3 games in the Europa League and somehow both of them were to teams that I really shouldn't have been losing to! We really should have breezed past Betis in the Semi Final too, but we surrendered a 2-0 lead to somehow lose 4-2 and then blew them off the park in the return leg in Scotland.

On first glance, facing Liverpool in a European final, I expected a bit of a battering considering my record against English sides. However they're actually a mid-table team at the moment, only getting into Europe by finishing 7th, only 2 points ahead of 11th! 

image.png.0f1b6ed17c5d4c6c9ab8ecc1e2b7dda8.png

We left it a liiiiitle bit late, but Zhelyazkov is becoming a bit of a hero for us! Top scorer in the Europa League itself with 14 goals, he left his most important 2 till the last moment! I'd have actually been incredibly disappointed if we lost considering how tight it was.

Cups:

In the words of a great poet, "Oops, I did it again!".

image.png.d908652ef0f8f595530b651e59bb8a6e.png

That's 4 consecutive Scottish Cups for us now. We're apparently a cup team now. Might actually help in the Champions League if we can get out the League Phase next year! We're still not good enough to go far in the main cup though, so anything past the Round of 16 in the Champions League would be a success for us really.

Youth Intake:

image.thumb.png.1b0590c06505652312bda0d7bc6f4905.png

Although what does help is a rather decent intake! 2 Full 5 star potentials, both with Perfectionist personalities? Loving. It.

Cameron Macdonald and Bede Simon both look rather decent, although the last few prospects we've had like this haven't actually got anywhere close to decent ability so I'm a bit more cautious now! They will obviously be helped by our beloved Solomon Frimpong in the under 18s whilst he finishes his career. He's still not fallen off from the last screenshot (although the physicals are starting to go). Still popped up with another 11 goal season in 32 league games, so he's still very useful.

He's also on 969 total appearances for the club, so there might be some lovely 90th minute sub appearances for him next season to get him to the 1000 mark!

Full History:

  Hide contents

image.png.9b13b43d9b1905532560f36329262b43.png

Last 5 Years:

image.thumb.png.f105370a25825ccb7176e62ca666dc3b.png

What are your two 5* perfectionist youth intake starting atts like? With the perfectionist personalities they will develop rapidly I would imagine.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share

×
×
  • Create New...