Jump to content

The FM23 Youth Academy Challenge


Recommended Posts

  • Replies 6k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

2 hours ago, The7Striker said:

To be fair, I didn't really look at the 2nd nationality, but in Bulgaria, despite the rules, didnt catch any player from nearby countrys in the intakes.

Yeah, the kid has Portuguese/Angolan/English nationality, so he doesn't have any issues with work permit! :D 

Link to post
Share on other sites

10 minutes ago, XaW said:

Yeah, the kid has Portuguese/Angolan/English nationality, so he doesn't have any issues with work permit! :D 

I got an Angolan/Portuguese/English in my first intake in the Vanarama National League South. :lol:

Link to post
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, MadCatPT said:

I got an Angolan/Portuguese/English in my first intake in the Vanarama National League South. :lol:

Can you beat the Scot/Senegalese I got though? :p 

Link to post
Share on other sites

3 minutes ago, HenTheChicken said:

Think I just might have with my scot/lithuanian I just got

That's also a nice one!

2 minutes ago, MadCatPT said:

No, Guyana/English and Australian/Welsh is the closest .

Close, but no cigar!

Link to post
Share on other sites

10 hours ago, JAwtunes said:

Just looking through screenshots from FM20 and FM22 saves an I have increases in Ambition, Determination and Professional.  Ive also had decreases in Ambition but dont have any saves of decreases for determination or prof - but might have missed them.

  Reveal hidden contents

image.png.5a6e77043228c9fce1e28c00694c5dbe.png

image.png.67a2b780caba140c37952e1b977197c0.png

image.png.90dbc468c9743b3a765940f637f994aa.png

image.png.63726216d5e3ac9637c61c008b6048b8.png

image.png.c18c5d9df4482009e0c773b26d4fca0c.png

DETERMINATION

image.png.3a5018eb6f9ba1b1fa0f9fd119b400fa.png

PROF

image.png.9301202e5640ce13dbdc821bc7961195.png

 

I've gotten increases in Determination and Professionalism in FM23. I need to figure out how to get consistency better for a player.

Spoiler

18PrxPA.png

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

In my 6th season, two promotions and great progress, you would think the board should be positive towards improvements. I think I've asked the board 25 times if we can get an affiliate club to loan out players to. 25 enquiries, 25 times I have been declined. Consider that also loans are pretty much bugged this is very, very poor. Playing this challenge is as fun as ever, but this FM version really has some odd flaws.. 

Link to post
Share on other sites

51 minutes ago, hubwub said:

I've gotten increases in Determination and Professionalism in FM23. I need to figure out how to get consistency better for a player.

  Reveal hidden contents

18PrxPA.png

 

Ah, I was referring to the 'off-field events' emails you sometimes receive. XaW did confirm he has seen the ones I was missing.

Consistency and big matches can increase from game time so are more common in older players.  This is what SI said back in 2020 and I assume it's still correct.

https://www.footballmanager.com/the-byline/why-your-squad-needs-older-players-wednesday-wisdom

image.png.c8e8c88796ac2f227eccbf00e8ebc65e.png

Link to post
Share on other sites

11 horas atrás, JAwtunes disse:

Just looking through screenshots from FM20 and FM22 saves an I have increases in Ambition, Determination and Professional.  Ive also had decreases in Ambition but dont have any saves of decreases for determination or prof - but might have missed them.

  Mostrar conteúdo oculto

image.png.5a6e77043228c9fce1e28c00694c5dbe.png

image.png.67a2b780caba140c37952e1b977197c0.png

image.png.90dbc468c9743b3a765940f637f994aa.png

image.png.63726216d5e3ac9637c61c008b6048b8.png

image.png.c18c5d9df4482009e0c773b26d4fca0c.png

DETERMINATION

image.png.3a5018eb6f9ba1b1fa0f9fd119b400fa.png

PROF

image.png.9301202e5640ce13dbdc821bc7961195.png

 

How i miss a good light skin:(

Link to post
Share on other sites

4 hours ago, hubwub said:

spacer.png

CDS Tampico Madero - Liga BBVA MX - 2026/2027

CLUB: PROFILE | FACILITIES | HONOURS | BOARD VISION | SUPPORTERS | FINANCES

MANAGER: CHARACTERISTICS | ATTRIBUTES

Liga BBVA MX Apertura

V1MmiWp.jpg

We finished 3rd with 10W-3D-4L at 33 points. This is our best points finish ever. We were equal on points with Chivas but we got seeded higher than them. We had a turning point when I took off Work Into The Box from our tactic.

KrAELia.png

We are now the Liga BBVA MX Apertura Champions!

Leagues Cup and Scotiabank CONCACAF Champions League

ASb26ds.png

Leagues Cup lost in the semi finals to penalties to America. The fact that we pushed America to penalties is a feat. They went on to win against Leon 1-0 in the final. I can't be too sad about that.

LF9eWpt.png

Scotiabank CONCACAF Champions League went undefeated. I managed to beat the juggernaut that was Cruz Azul in the closing minutes of the game. That game should've been a draw or a loss.

Squad

D0f5F0H.png

Jordi Rocha 23C got injured during the first leg against Querétaro FC in the quarterfinal of the Liga BBVA MX match.

Youth Intake Preview

6jQ3ntV.png

I'm not sure I need more goalkeepers! As for the rest, I will take it.

Miscellaneous

ngB04IA.png

Guillermo Valdéz 24A, he is now the backup goalkeeper for Mexico. Chelsea are now lurking at the wings for his services.

Congrats on winning the first division by 2026!!  

Meanwhile im still stuck in expansion league in 2029 haha

Link to post
Share on other sites

Image result for tampico madero

Season 6 - 2029 - Expansion League

Probably should go for a walk before posting but oh wells....

The year started off with two of my best players getting poached by First division teams. one where i could insert a sell on clause, the other that was approved by the Board which i couldnt do anything about.  Both players werent going to renew their contracts so I had no choice.

Players Sold:

Spoiler

Sol has been everpresent for us since he first came through the youth ammassing 135 league apperances for the club despite his tender age.  We managed to negotiate to keep him for the remainder of the year plus a 50% sell on clause

510821691_2022-11-22(7).png.298daa42e60b1dd0c015590c83793a39.png219107470_2022-11-21(3).png.b4cc140b1699d923572dfe07c3478366.png

 

Chacon had a breakout year last season scoring 14 goals and averaging 7.20 from left wing, would have been nice to keep him for another season or two

2022-11-21.png.ae035a1aaf2b836b132be070eb431c22.png367129935_2022-11-21(1).png.d6e8d69c2e3db01c9ced972e0907bd4f.png

Let's get straight into the leagues. Started off like a house on fire in the opening stage then went wayward towards the end but managed to finish second in the league. We then managed to play 1 good game in each of our 2x leg knockouts in the QF, SF and Final to book our place in the final playoff game at the end of the year. 

Spoiler

583710821_2022-11-22(8).png.7d1ed0d340da316edd46b13df7264799.png2065912956_2022-11-22(9).png.d92ed684e67a527ca0858e6b367787e8.png

 

Closing stage we were pretty awful considering the where we've been fnishing in the league. We even missed out on qualifying directly into the QF's as we finished 5th.  We won our prelim game but then got embarrassed by UdeG in the QF.

Morelia were the winner of the closing stage so it was a repeat of the opening stage final. Morelia had to win in pens against UdeG 4 days before playing us and their team was a little jaded as we had a couple weeks off. Both legs are in the spoiler...  Unfrickenbelievable!!!!!   Feels like im never gonna get out of this division!

Spoiler

1886869008_2022-11-22(2).png.09df7a409389ee9b9e75a3a49be34880.png1932292951_2022-11-22(5).png.55f6b1e5595c140e92f4273bcd071147.png38241549_2022-11-22(4).png.e3223ac6e18183cc51b7e18ddb5eee71.png233120324_2022-11-22(6).png.c3f04f62efeee03b39b6c9159966b4a7.png

To make things worse, we had our worst intake of the save:

2022-11-22.png.7f3b5119ab46514ba9df3c5136a104d0.png

Mascorro is the best of a bad bunch, dont really need a striker right now either:

1219764542_2022-11-22(1).png.ccffe8b205284ed154ba468cd330450e.png

Link to post
Share on other sites

10 hours ago, grff said:

Royale Union Tubize-Braine: 2025/26 Season Review

Our first season in the Belgian top flight was a very tough test and it felt at times like we were way out of our depth. However, we picked up enough points along the way to finish just above the relegation places.

table26.thumb.jpg.493c007a4b2c832954a9bd32e8d01be6.jpg

Player stats were way off what had been achieved before, however, this was always going to happen in a higher division.

stats26.thumb.jpg.c53da9c249c84ba4905914f6f7153346.jpg

The youth intake saw a fair few handy players come in. Last year's intake included a ball winning midfielder already valued at £8.4m.

yt26.thumb.jpg.5e570566dc54c021a4f2982c73dd72e0.jpg  lb26.thumb.jpg.5f0f3828d71793bef6df5da0b25613af.jpg

No transfers out but some will be released in the coming week as they never feature in the first team squad.

xfers26.thumb.jpg.63f170d59a5bca0613080888eb42f375.jpg

Unfortunately, it looks as though my star striker is off at the end of the season as he's refusing a contract renewal. I'll hopefully sell him beforehand, then get him back on loan for a season.

st26.thumb.jpg.e07cb2e96521d7f379dda2532fbdf2ee.jpg

Season history...

hist26.thumb.jpg.e1e2c9b7c943859810d225253d94f344.jpg

Great work. How are the finances?

Link to post
Share on other sites

FC United Of Manchester - Season 8

I am a bit stuck for progress at the minute, going into my 9th season shortly. My youth players are okay, everytime I get a new one who i think will add strength, one of my other good ones considers his options and wants to leave. The part time and only being able to offer 1 year deals is really frustrating currently. I am not sure how to get out of this but I am nowhere near the top, and unable to get anywhere near it!

I think if i did get promoted i would come back down with the least amount of points possible. But if i could somehow get to Pro status, i would be able to develop the players better and this will give me the best chance overall going forward! 

Have tried every formation going, cannot stop conceding the goals balls over the top and one and one. 

Progress below of the 8 seasons to date:

image.thumb.png.a355298d9c2482b6f5179ec8ab4cd8d6.png

Link to post
Share on other sites

13 minutes ago, The7Striker said:

Just need a help around. You guys like to improve facilities and Youth coaching/ recruitment all around or you like to max something first ?

Due to the increasing cost of each, normally due to money constraints it's all around.

Facilities you need the money upfront and then need to pay for increasing costs, the Youth Coaching and Youth Recruitment you increase your costs. Normally there is a tendency to improve this latter two more since you don't need the money upfront.

Link to post
Share on other sites

33 minutes ago, The7Striker said:

Just need a help around. You guys like to improve facilities and Youth coaching/ recruitment all around or you like to max something first ?

I prioritize JR Coaching as it's the most instantaneous effect on increasing the quality of intake players. In larger nations like England upgrading Youth Recruitment too quickly can snowball the academy costs to unsustainable levels. There, the top priority for me is Youth Rating and Youth Facilities whenever I get transfer windfalls or cup earnings while watching the Youth Setup costs to make sure I can remain in budget. Small nations like Luxembourg I don't feel Youth Recruitment really impacts the save all that much especially if you start as an urban club. You need reputation to pull in players from distance and small nation teams like my ASL Porto have zilch.

Link to post
Share on other sites

27 minutes ago, MadCatPT said:

Due to the increasing cost of each, normally due to money constraints it's all around.

Facilities you need the money upfront and then need to pay for increasing costs, the Youth Coaching and Youth Recruitment you increase your costs. Normally there is a tendency to improve this latter two more since you don't need the money upfront.

I do youth recruitment and Jnr coaching as much as I can, and then try to save as much as possible for the facilities. Need a big chunk of money for facilities so takes time!

Link to post
Share on other sites

Has anyone noticed differences in what does or doesn't work in FM23 regarding youth development, when compared to FM22? I still use the same approach, but the only change I've noticed is that fining young players for poor performances seems to be less effective this year. It's probably a good change too, because it felt a bit too easy raising Determination and Workrate last year with constantly fining.

Link to post
Share on other sites

3 minutes ago, Barnsley said:

I do youth recruitment and Jnr coaching as much as I can, and then try to save as much as possible for the facilities. Need a big chunk of money for facilities so takes time!

Pretty much the same I do. Would love to get facilities in earlier, but money is often hard to come by before reaching the top tiers.

Link to post
Share on other sites

15 minutes ago, Dereka said:

Has anyone noticed differences in what does or doesn't work in FM23 regarding youth development, when compared to FM22? I still use the same approach, but the only change I've noticed is that fining young players for poor performances seems to be less effective this year. It's probably a good change too, because it felt a bit too easy raising Determination and Workrate last year with constantly fining.

I haven't noticed a difference in the discipline-fine mechanic. They nerfed the effectiveness a few years ago so it wasn't every time you got the bump. Both in my England save and Luxembourg I've been able to see improvements with the fines. I even got the inbox notification that the discipline has improved the player once. It's maybe 1 pt a year, with Work Rate seeming to be easier to influence but that adds up.

Edited by WhiteCat33
Link to post
Share on other sites

Really struggling to get going on this one. Tried Estonia, but can’t get going after a few seasons. I’m also paranoid that additional added leagues aren’t going to function properly and it will be a waste. Estonia for instance, I beat a team in the relegation play-off only for them to still be promoted to the league the following season. 
 

Suspension rules as well!! 4 yellows is a ban, then a ban for every yellow on top of that. It’s been an absolute nightmare!! Not sure if that’s the actual rule, but it’s been crippling. 
 

Time to start again. Not sure where. Would probably prefer something already in the game and somewhere that hasn’t been completed yet. May even stray outside of Europe for once…

Link to post
Share on other sites

17 hours ago, OlivierL said:

ea6e148ca9ad904574c002a128eb9295.png

Season Preview | Competitions | League Player Stats | Club Vision | Supporters Profile | Honours

912b864f7ebc69aeb8cebeaaf3951f87.png

4.Deild B - 5th tier We started with 0 points out of 4 games but afterwards we start winning and finished X with a really poor senior squad.

Cup: No cup action for us because of the DB issues. 

U21no competition.

5690d63f7c6c0e068d7feec3e025e4fe.png

First XI| Overall Best XI | Transfers | Youth Intake 2023 

d9dc17c7ef2fbcc10f1d5e8a71888f6e.png

Not a very balanced squad and three of the first eleven players will retire.

a24bbed9dee91942a27392f9f164c43b.png

Cataño had a great season and is our best player, not sure if i will be able to keep him much longer.

5b814dc7c570ea4fb11dcd309055144b.png

d2c0c2935ac055580569e5bdf4aaff84.png
a2df979b3eed897c8c7a8b5f45b76cb4.png

Finances & Upgrades

Profile ClubFinances | Facilities

5256dcd42c2b491e833d1eb09d0a9db1.png

We turned semi-pro right before the start of the season but we can't offer semi pro contract at the moment.

f3ebd3dc02eda3d6387bfaec3b3c42e1.png

Iceland Watch

33676db4a84b94fd306e640aec11b3cd.png

Next Season

Not a bad first season with a very strange senior qquad. I hope to make a bit of progression every year but am still far away from becoming a promotion candidate

 

There is a big chance that I will restart this save since someone is planning to release a good database without any cup and u19 issues for iceland . If this is the case I'll restart this adventure with Afrika, luckily I'm only in season 2.

Link to post
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Barnsley said:

These graphic summaries are awesome - what do you guys use to create them?

I used Canva, just searched for something to do it and it was the first that appeared, did a very simple one with it, was simple to use.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...