Jump to content

player misses training after being spotted at a night club the day before


Recommended Posts

Google "imageshack" and upload it on there, then once it's uploaded copy it from there andd paste it here :)

That or Photobucket. Have a look at this thread http://community.sigames.com/showthread.php/92967-READ-ME-FIRST-PC-Mac-General-Discussion-Rules-Guidelines-Image-Posting-Tutorial. I think the fourth post shows you how to use Imageshack and Photobucket :thup:.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Yes due to legal issues.

This is a myth. FM does not claim to represent any prediction of reality. Things start to go fictional with the first click of the space bar. Thus, players have no standing to sue for anything represented in the game. Also, they would have a hard time showing how they were damaged by event X happening in Joe Blows game.

Link to post
Share on other sites

This is a myth. FM does not claim to represent any prediction of reality. Things start to go fictional with the first click of the space bar. Thus, players have no standing to sue for anything represented in the game. Also, they would have a hard time showing how they were damaged by event X happening in Joe Blows game.

Its not a myth, the wouldnt be given the licenses again if they protrayed any real players in a bad light, and its proberbly written into the terms of use of the license as well.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Its not a myth, the wouldnt be given the licenses again if they protrayed any real players in a bad light, and its proberbly written into the terms of use of the license as well.

They dont license players; they license leagues. The Leagues need the SI money more than SI need the licenses. Game makers dont need a license at all to use real players in their games. SI dont have a license for the EPL and no one really notices. It strikes at the heart of the games integrity and realism if real world occurrences are kept out of the game for silly PC reasons.

Link to post
Share on other sites

They dont license players; they license leagues. The Leagues need the SI money more than SI need the licenses. Game makers dont need a license at all to use real players in their games. SI dont have a license for the EPL and no one really notices. It strikes at the heart of the games integrity and realism if real world occurrences are kept out of the game for silly PC reasons.

The leagues do not need SI more than SI need them, FM would not be half as popular without the licensed leagues, its a huge selling point of the game, i doubt any of the leagues rely on the small amount (in the bigger picture) of money SI will pay each year for the licenses.

The bottom line is, players take how they are portrayed on FM very seriously in some cases, hence why Oliver Khan threatened SI with legal action unless he was removed from the game, because amongst other things, he was not happy with how he was rated in the game so i would imagine SI will not take any risks with portraying ANY player as being unprofessional because its not worth the law suit.

Link to post
Share on other sites

The game markets itself as intending to be realistic and accurate on the game as it is, in real life it may be realistic for Joey Barton to go around smacking people but its not for a lot of other players, now if they start doing it in FM then almost by extension its a judgement passed on their character. Putting the stats into the machine is coming out with "Player A is likely to get drunk the night before training" or "Player B is likely to begin punching opponents on the pitch". You start to get on very thin ice at that point as attributes are one thing, its a quantity to something which can only ever be a personal opinion. A persons history and what they've done are a fact, if they haven't been violent/drinking in the past it would be very risky to begin suggesting they would now.

Link to post
Share on other sites

It's great that this kind of stuff still happens in the game. It's just a shame that the pro's and there lawyers are so pathetic that SI cant implement things like this into real players on FM. The world has gone mad! :p

More worryingly, what happens when players and lawyers start getting involved with there stats!

Link to post
Share on other sites

This is a myth. FM does not claim to represent any prediction of reality. Things start to go fictional with the first click of the space bar. Thus, players have no standing to sue for anything represented in the game. Also, they would have a hard time showing how they were damaged by event X happening in Joe Blows game.

Wrong mate.... I remember the pod cast and the words from Miles mouth.

They can't do it with real players in case those players take exception and sue SI. Pretty simple explanation really.

Link to post
Share on other sites

More worryingly, what happens when players and lawyers start getting involved with there stats!

Like with Kahn (Jens Musterman) they would be removed and replaced with a made up player who basically has the same stats, im sure the Holland manager is a fake in the game as well, could be wrong with that one tho.....

Your right tho the world has gone completely mad!!

Link to post
Share on other sites

Like with Kahn (Jens Musterman) they would be removed and replaced with a made up player who basically has the same stats, im sure the Holland manager is a fake in the game as well, could be wrong with that one tho.....

Your right tho the world has gone completely mad!!

You mean somebody did actually complain and got taken out of the game because of there stats?

Link to post
Share on other sites

You mean somebody did actually complain and got taken out of the game because of there stats?

Yeah Oliver Kahn complained about how he was portrayed in game and threatened to sue unless he was removed, he became Jens Musterman in the game, think it was fm08 or 09.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Yeah Oliver Kahn complained about how he was portrayed in game and threatened to sue unless he was removed, he became Jens Musterman in the game, think it was fm08 or 09.

Thats who he was! I always wondered.

No surprises about one of the biggest egos (and jaws) in football being a complete ***** though eh.

Link to post
Share on other sites

One of my players was caught partying two days in a row. :-/ Two weeks fine for both - he took the first one alright, but clearly didn't listen! Go out partying, get fined, accept the fine, go out partying again...

A shame, because he was a decent player too... But thanks to his attitude, never played in Serie A when he could easily have done so.

Link to post
Share on other sites

You know, if this is in the game for regens, than there's gotta be a flag somewhere that says if a player's a regen or an actual player, and simply flipping that flag would make these kind of announcements pop up for players like Balotelli. Am I right?

possibly, but its not an editable option given to us using either the FM editor or FMRTE, it would be hidden somewhere and without knowlage of FM and its code it would be very difficult to find.

Link to post
Share on other sites

This is class! hahaha! SI are right in not letting real players have this! because money grabbing football players will do anything for more money!

but i wonder what else brings to the game after 25 seasons all the real players will be gone..... i wonder if SI have done different stuff for when all the real players have gone, like more stuff like this....

Link to post
Share on other sites

Wrong mate.... I remember the pod cast and the words from Miles mouth.

They can't do it with real players in case those players take exception and sue SI. Pretty simple explanation really.

The players would have no standing to sue..and that would be if SI INTENTIONALLY programmed it so real player X is forced to enter drug rehab. The game is random and fictional. If the EPL players could sue to stop SI from using their name and stats without being compensated, they would. This is a PR issue, not a legal issue.

Link to post
Share on other sites

The players would have no standing to sue..and that would be if SI INTENTIONALLY programmed it so real player X is forced to enter drug rehab. The game is random and fictional. If the EPL players could sue to stop SI from using their name and stats without being compensated, they would. This is a PR issue, not a legal issue.

your clearly ignoring the point of Oliver Kahn, it is a legal issue, he wanted to sue SI the only way out was to remove him from the game, it is a very big legal issue how you represent a person when using his name and details.

Link to post
Share on other sites

The players would have no standing to sue..and that would be if SI INTENTIONALLY programmed it so real player X is forced to enter drug rehab. The game is random and fictional. If the EPL players could sue to stop SI from using their name and stats without being compensated, they would. This is a PR issue, not a legal issue.

Leaving in the possibility that a player could behave in such a way is enough. Imagine, Player A is a model professional. He would never do something like Stringfellow. In FM, there is a reasonable representation of his ability, his personality traits, his appearance and his contract details. If his ingame persona goes to a nightclub and behaves unprofessionally, then the upshot is that SI have implied that player A would do this, as it is meant to be a reasonable representation of him as a person. To put it simply, it's a character slur.

I believe it is a legal issue that you can't represent someone as being this unprofessional at their job without expecting them to complain, and seek compensation for it.

Link to post
Share on other sites

It's not ok to run a newstory saying that Rooney has been on a killing spree under the pretence it could happen in the future or its just a random outcome of somethings programming. It could well be a computer program that determines the outcome, but putting it in public domain is damaging to his character, if it happened to someone like Barton you could argue its been targetted to him because of his past and even though hes trying to change (whether he is or not etc etc) its merely a game trying to profit over his questionnable past and it makes it harder for him to change. It is in the grand scheme insignificant, but its important enough to be pulled up. The truth may be that it could go to court and SI could come away comfortable winners thanks to an error by the prosecution in the 89th minute but its better not to risk it rather than have to pay out libel damages and all that other stuff.

Link to post
Share on other sites

your clearly ignoring the point of Oliver Kahn, it is a legal issue, he wanted to sue SI the only way out was to remove him from the game, it is a very big legal issue how you represent a person when using his name and details.

Kahn would not have been successful. SI was just playing it safe and avoiding a costly legal hassle. If SI is free to include other players without their express permission, why couldnt they also include Kahn, if they wanted?

Link to post
Share on other sites

Bababui needs to read up on personality rights: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Personality_rights

If you are correct, then why doesnt SI pay compensation to the players for using their image? In the USA, the Supreme Court has ruled that players names and stats (as opposed to images) are not protected and may be used without compensation in games and fantasy sites.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Leaving in the possibility that a player could behave in such a way is enough. Imagine, Player A is a model professional. He would never do something like Stringfellow. In FM, there is a reasonable representation of his ability, his personality traits, his appearance and his contract details. If his ingame persona goes to a nightclub and behaves unprofessionally, then the upshot is that SI have implied that player A would do this, as it is meant to be a reasonable representation of him as a person. To put it simply, it's a character slur.

I believe it is a legal issue that you can't represent someone as being this unprofessional at their job without expecting them to complain, and seek compensation for it.

But FM isnt a public representation. Its a game played by private individuals. As such, any footballer..a public figure..would have quite a hard time showing how they were harmed. Also, given the jist of some of the arguments in here, players would have the right to sue if they think they are being under-evaluated in the game. Which, of course, they cant.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Kahn would not have been successful. SI was just playing it safe and avoiding a costly legal hassle. If SI is free to include other players without their express permission, why couldnt they also include Kahn, if they wanted?

well if as you say the player had no leg to stand on SI would not have a legal bill, Kahn would they would have let him go ahead and waste his time, but the fact is they didnt and that says there definately must be a legal issue. The simple fact is you cannot use someones name and do whatever you want with it, and you cannot portray anyone as being unprofessional to that extreme.

SI pay the leagues for image rights, not players, so there will be a fee paid at somepoint.

Link to post
Share on other sites

But FM isnt a public representation. Its a game played by private individuals. As such, any footballer..a public figure..would have quite a hard time showing how they were harmed. Also, given the jist of some of the arguments in here, players would have the right to sue if they think they are being under-evaluated in the game. Which, of course, they cant.

being under valued and being made out to be unprofessional are two different things.

Link to post
Share on other sites

well if as you say the player had no leg to stand on SI would not have a legal bill, Kahn would they would have let him go ahead and waste his time, but the fact is they didnt and that says there definately must be a legal issue. The simple fact is you cannot use someones name and do whatever you want with it, and you cannot portray anyone as being unprofessional to that extreme.

SI pay the leagues for image rights, not players, so there will be a fee paid at somepoint.

It says that SI would rather change one malcontents name (and allow files to be posted on their editior site to change it back) than waste time and money on lawyers fees. And also they avoid the bad publicity.

SI have no deal with the EPL. They dont pay one penny to use EPL players names and stats. Also, image rights are different from just using names and stats. There is a reason why FM doesnt ship with player pics included.

Link to post
Share on other sites

being under valued and being made out to be unprofessional are two different things.

You do understand that what happens in our individual games isnt made public? And that therefor there is no damage to a real person. Also, since the game engine is random, SI couldnt be held liable for intentionally damaging anyone's reputation. As I said, SI do this for PR rather than legal reasons.

Link to post
Share on other sites

You do understand that what happens in our individual games isnt made public? And that therefor there is no damage to a real person. Also, since the game engine is random, SI couldnt be held liable for intentionally damaging anyone's reputation. As I said, SI do this for PR rather than legal reasons.

it is made public, on these forums, many people post experiences of their game, if even one person posted a screen shot of a real player missing training then it becomes public and then it becomes an issue for SI because publically their game has suggested x player is unprofessional, intentially or not. Plus real players will play FM, how happy would say Frank Lampard be if he saw himself acting unprofessioaly in the game, he would question why this is happening, if it happens in one game it could happen in another, and the way stats work, if the player is unprofessional in one game, he will be in every single game, before you know it everyone who plays FM will question if Lampard is professional or not, because all stats in this game are to an extent a replication of real life, they are all taken from the real world to the extent possible.

Link to post
Share on other sites

SI have no deal with the EPL. They dont pay one penny to use EPL players names and stats. Also, image rights are different from just using names and stats. There is a reason why FM doesnt ship with player pics included.

You see the EPL logo in the credits yes? Si do have an agreement with the EPL and their sponsers hence why they are allowed to use the logo in their game.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...