Jump to content

FM2009 Rate My Team Thread


arsenal_2111

Recommended Posts

Canal

GK: Mandanda - 8.5

DR: Srna - 9

DL: A.Cole - 8.5

CB: Terry - 8

CB: Zapata - 8.5

MC:Essien - 8.5

MC: Veloso - 9

AMR: Giovinco (retrained) - 8.5

AML: Guardado - 8.5

AMC: Robinho - 8.5

FC: Balotelli! - 9

Other Players:

Cech - 8

Demichellis - 8

Mancienne - 6.5

Radoi - 8

Kuzmanovic - 9

Arshavin - 7

Fausto Rossi - ?

Keirisson - 7.5

Oscar Cardozo - 7

Jack Wilshere - 7.5

Sergio Asenjo! - 8

Nice team, for you I guess it's a question of slowly replacing your ageing players as season progress :thup:

Link to post
Share on other sites

  • Replies 382
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Dvrormt

GK Mandanda - 8.5

DR Srna - 9

DL Kolarov - 7.5

DC Micah Richards - 8

DC Dunne - 6

MC Palombo - 7

MC Veloso - 9

AMR SWP - 8

AML Petrov - 8

ST Robinho - 8.5

ST Pogrebnyak - 7.5

Subs:

GK Joe Hart - 7

DC Onuoha - 7

DC Kompany - 7.5

MC Camacho - 8

AMR Balotelli - 9

AML Di Maria - 8

ST Caicedo - 5

Positions To Improve?

* CB, Dunne replacement.

* ST, Balotelli for Pogrebnyak in the long term.

* Improve your sub bench perhaps.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Seeing as this seems to all be top flight clubs, I'll throw out my Southampton team, Jan 09:

GK: Davis

LB: Insua (loan)

CB: Svensson

CB: Diawara

RB: James

MC(d): Cork (loan)

MC(a): Schneiderlin

AML: Nainggolan

AMC: Lallana

AMR: Thompson

ST: Saganowski

Subs:

DL/MLC: Surman

D/DM/MC: Wotton

AMRLC: Gasmi (loan)

AMRL: Dyer

AMRC/FC: McGoldrick

I'm guessing it's going to be "improve everywhere" :p

Link to post
Share on other sites

advents

GK Akinfeev - 8

DR Rafinha - 8.5

DC Dunne - 7.5

DC Richards - 8

DL Juan Manuel Vargas - 7.5 ( No experience with him)

MC Palombo - 8.5

MC Moutinho - 8.5

AMR Arshavin - 9

AML Di Maria - 8

ST Robinho - 9

ST Oscar Cardozo - 8

Link to post
Share on other sites

!st season did the treble Premier, champions cup and league cup

Chelsea

cech

bosingwa naldo/mancienne Terry A cole

Deco Lampard

J Cole Arshavin/malouda

Anelka Drogba

subs

Cudicini

kalou

sinclair

di santo

essien

mikel

willian

end of season transfers

saviet

Van der vaat

D sturridge

wijnaldum

K pearce

Zarate

Link to post
Share on other sites

Hi guys, here's my Wolves team, made some big signings.

GK - Wayne Hennessey / Jason Brown

DR - Fernando Ricksen / Uslies de la Cruz

DL - Razvan Rat / Emiliano Insua

DC - Eduardo / Mariusz Lewandowski

DC - Philippe Christanval / Bobo Balde

DMC - Binya / Alexey Smertin

MR - Jeremy Bokila / David Edwards

ML - Charlie Adam / Razvan Rat

AMC - Ciprian Deac / Eduardo

AMC - George Boyd / Eduardo

ST - Sylvan Ebanks-Blake / Macauley Christanus

Cheers guys ;)

Link to post
Share on other sites

Which young CB shall i get to replace Terry then? he is my oldest player and i dont really have adequate prospects going through (i have 15, 16, 17 year olds, but i need a 20,21 year old who is good enough for now but then to drop in a few seasons)...

Link to post
Share on other sites

Just about to start my third season as Real Madrid manager. Have signed a few new players to strengthen my treble winning side.

I have the luxury of being able to effectively pick two sides, my first choice line up and my 'B' team.

Starting 11:

team1ma2.png

w1360.png

Second string:

team2sf1.png

w1360.png

Some of you may reckon players from my 'B' side should be in the starting eleven and vice versa, but i have picked what i feel is my strongest side for my 'A' team currently.

Even after picking players to populate two teams i still have additional players: Danny Welbeck, Ben Foster and Martin Gavlan (Gavlan will be world class).

Some players in the 'B' team are just cover whilst players such as Saviet,Balotelli, Gavlan and Giovinco will eventually become first team regulars.

A very strong squad i feel.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Mandanda

Rafinha Richards Zapata Matthieu (underated)

Arteta Matias Fernandez Veloso Rodriguez

Gomez Huntelaar

Subs:

Hart

Robinho

Elano

Dunne

Kompany

Palombo

Vela

People will point out the weakness in probably Arteta and Matthieu, Arteta I just got in so not sure, but Matthieu is a great player trust me, has scored some real gems, set up a few and is very consistent. Very cheap and highly recommended. Got some great youngsters but im on laptop so I am just saying this off the top of my head. Any advice will be highly recommended I will be likely to get more money in shortly, probably let Arteta show me what he can do, and even though I recommended Mr. Matthieu, another LB I guess, any recommendations? My strike force is alright, but they aren't super consistent so another striker would be alright. Cheers.

Link to post
Share on other sites

My Liverpool 2010 Team.

This isn't a definite selection, I swap around often.

GK: Reina (Asenjo) - A. Wonderkid actually.

DR: Srna (Santon) - Another wondersub.

DL: Guilherme (Isua) - G. seem to hav a lot of PA on this save.

DCs: Carragher, +"spanish regen wonderkid, 18years" (Agger, Sakho)

RW: Babel - Retrained pos.

LW: M.Fernandez (Mata) -

MCs: Gerrard, Camacho (Diarra, Masch) - C. probably world greatest allready.

SCs: Torres, Balotelli (Eto'o, paloschi) - they cost me ap. 20M together.

+ a couple of rubish sups I cant recall.

Sorry for crappy enlish, I am swedish you know:)

Link to post
Share on other sites

Here's my Tottenham team

squadhb5.png

Looks like a good squad there:

GK: 7 Needs improvemedn later on.

DR: 7 A temporary solution. Santon will grow into a 9 perhaps.

DL: 8 Backup for Bale?

DCs: 8 Looks well covered, but where is Woody?

RW:6 Problems there, mate.

LW:8 Two good,young prospects.

MC: 9 Young and talanted.

AMC: Vukcevic is a favourite of mine. SHOOT!

FC: 7 Not good enough for top spot yet, but will develop a few notches.

That's my view. It's hard to comment on players who turn out different on every game but I hop you're happy anyways.

Link to post
Share on other sites

First season with Man Utd:

GK: Frey

DR: Srna

DL: Evra

DC: Ferdinand

DC: Vidic

DMC: Veloso

MC: Hamsik

MC: Diego

AMR: Ronaldo

AML: Guardado

ST: Berbatov

Subs: Van der Sar, Zapata, Marcelo, Camacho, Scholes, Nani, Balotelli

Looks like major changes to an already good squad, but what can I say they are all world class or soon to be world class. Did you finance them by selling Rooney and Anderson, perhaps?

Link to post
Share on other sites

Second season with Newcastle

GK: Asenjo

RB: Beye

LB: Enrique

CB: Colocini

CB: Carcares (sp, guy from Barca who is listed from the start)

MR: Jonas

ML: Guardado

CM: Bruins

CM: Gokhan Inler

ST: Vela

ST: Martins

Subs

Given

Taylor

N'zogbia

Barton

Heskey

Xisco

Guthrie

Link to post
Share on other sites

For the THIRD time of asking...

GK - Wayne Hennessey / Jason Brown

DR - Fernando Ricksen / Uslies de la Cruz

DL - Razvan Rat / Emiliano Insua

DC - Eduardo / Mariusz Lewandowski

DC - Philippe Christanval / Bobo Balde

DMC - Binya / Alexey Smertin

MR - Jeremy Bokila / David Edwards

ML - Charlie Adam / Razvan Rat

AMC - Ciprian Deac / Eduardo

AMC - George Boyd / Eduardo

ST - Sylvan Ebanks-Blake / Macauley Christanus

Can anybody rate my team?

Link to post
Share on other sites

For the THIRD time of asking...

GK - Wayne Hennessey / Jason Brown

DR - Fernando Ricksen / Uslies de la Cruz

DL - Razvan Rat / Emiliano Insua

DC - Eduardo / Mariusz Lewandowski

DC - Philippe Christanval / Bobo Balde

DMC - Binya / Alexey Smertin

MR - Jeremy Bokila / David Edwards

ML - Charlie Adam / Razvan Rat

AMC - Ciprian Deac / Eduardo

AMC - George Boyd / Eduardo

ST - Sylvan Ebanks-Blake / Macauley Christanus

Can anybody rate my team?

Wish I had the skills to rate it. Looks like you can achieve a PL mid position. You've got some real quality in there.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Looks like major changes to an already good squad, but what can I say they are all world class or soon to be world class. Did you finance them by selling Rooney and Anderson, perhaps?

Indeed i did, didnt fancy the look of either of their stats. Flogged Anderson to Man City for 20m and Rooney to Arsenal for 38m :)

Link to post
Share on other sites

dave byrd

Casillas – 9

Ramos – 9

Marcelo – 6

Zapata – 8

Pepe – 8.5

Obertan – 8.5

Guardado – 8.5

Hamsik - 8.5

Benzema – 8.5

Owen – 8

Subs:

Saivet – 8

Balotelli – 8

Giovinco - 8.5

Garay – 7

Foster – 7

Robben – 8

Torres – 7

Fiorillo – 7

Metzelder – 7

Heinze – 6.5

Diarra – 7

Galvan – 6

Podolski – 7

Welbeck – 6

Ratings are only based on how they are developed at the moment; of course ratings would increase when players are fully developed. But for now it’s not possible.

Link to post
Share on other sites

CenaJohnno

Mandanda – 9

Rafinha – 8

Richards – 8

Zapata -9

Matthieu – 8

Arteta – 7

Matias Fernandez – 8

Veloso – 9

Rodriguez – 8.5

Gomez – 7.5

Huntelaar – 8

Subs:

Hart – 7

Robinho – 8

Elano – 7.5

Dunne – 6

Kompany - 7.5

Palombo - 7.5

Vela – 8

Positions To Improve:

* RB

* ML

* ST (Don't rate Gomez so much)

Link to post
Share on other sites

Larsa

Hej! :D

Reina – 9

(Asenjo) – 7.5

Srna – 9

(Santon) – 7.5

Guilherme - 7.5

(Isua). – 7

Carragher – 8.5

(Agger) – 8

(Sakho) – 7

Babel – 7

M.Fernandez – 8

(Mata) – 7.5

Gerrard – 9.5

Camacho – 8

(Diarra) – 8

(Masch) – 8

Torres – 9

Balotelli – 8

(Eto'o) – 8

(Paloschi) – 7

Again for youngsters the rating is only based on there current state, ratings would improve once there developed etc.

Positions To Improve?

* RM

Link to post
Share on other sites

slipknot67

Got to be honest, not experienced or played with most of your players. However I’ll rate the players I have (that's the best I can do, sorry!).

Apam – 7.5

Ferreria – 6

Hernanes – 7

Carioca – 7.5

I'd look to improve at RB, Move Apam to the left and get a proper RB :thup:

Sorry it's short, but as I said I can only comment on players I know or have experience with etc, I don't manage in the SPL.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Deano565

GK: Frey – 8.5

DR: Srna – 9

DL: Evra – 8.5

DC: Ferdinand – 8.5

DC: Vidic – 9

DMC: Veloso – 9

MC: Hamsik – 7.5/8

MC: Diego – 8 (I presume that’s Diego from Werder?)

AMR: Ronaldo – 9

AML: Guardado – 8

ST: Berbatov – 8

Subs:

Van der Sar – 7

Zapata – 9

Marcelo – 6.5

Camacho – 7

Scholes 7

Nani – 7

Balotelli – 8

Nice team, probably more of a case for you of slowly selling off your older players. :thup:

Link to post
Share on other sites

Wesker27

GK: Asenjo – 7.5

RB: Beye – 7

LB: Enrique – 6.5

CB: Colocini – 8.5

CB: Carcares – 8

MR: Jonas – 7.5

ML: Guardado – 8

CM: Bruins – 7.5/8

CM: Inler – 7.5

ST: Vela – 7.5/8

ST: Martins – 7.5

Subs

Given – 7

Taylor – 7

N'zogbia – 7

Barton – 6.5

Heskey – 6.5

Xisco – 7

Guthrie – 7

Nice first team, I’d look to improve long term at RB and LB.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Third season now, few changes - i know i need a proper right back, but have an amazing 17 yr old regen at left back who is world class (if post a screen shot but don't know how - im on a mac!)

GK: Lloris

RB:Hargreaves ((retrained)

LB:Veloso (retrained)

CB:Vidic

CB:Fazio

MC:Camacho

MC:Anderson

AML:Nani/Giovincio/Wilshire

AMR: Ronaldo

FC:Rooney

FC:Balotelli

Subs

Foster

Ferdinand

Berbatov

Aguero

Tevez

Evans

Carrick

Brown

Link to post
Share on other sites

ot to be honest, not experienced or played with most of your players. However I’ll rate the players I have (that's the best I can do, sorry!).

thanx for the input you managed to give, will defo be looking to strengthen at the back in next transfer window. Been switching between Apam and Rafael (signed from man u) at RB.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Larsa

Again for youngsters the rating is only based on there current state, ratings would improve once there developed etc.

Positions To Improve?

* RM

Tack och bock.

Yes, the problem is RW. Just found a swedish(!) regen aged 18, who looks to be the reincarnation of Becks. ******** good. If I had time I would upload it for you.

Link to post
Share on other sites

valencia club d. f.

gk - renan

lwb - moretti

dc - albiol

dc - alexis

rwb - miguel (great physical attributes; rated best player last season by the fans; bombs forward tremendously)

dm - sunny

lm - silva

rm - joaquin

am - mata

am - aguero

st - villa

subs - del horno, albelda, vicente, hugo vaiana, joao moutinho, marchena, lequi

and laurito is brought up from the U19's when needed. he has a >1 average goals per game with them.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Everton 1st Season, after massive poaching by Man City and Real Madrid,

my new squad looks like this. Playing my own version of a Box Midfield.

Kindly rate my players.

I have 9 mil transfer budget left

GK Howard

DC Yobo (fast defender)

DC Lescott (fast defender)

WBL Baines (not the best)

WBR L Diarra (should be in midfield, but used here for now)

DMC Ruben Da La Red (good DM stats, tall and tenancious)

DMC M. Veloso (ball distributor, used in Pirlo style)

AMC Matias Ferdandez (advance playmaker role, younger version of Riquelme for me)

AMC Goran Pandev (skillful dribbler forward, used as secondary striker)

ST Oscar Cardozo (Huge target man, with ball skills and brain, ball at feet / to head)

ST James Vaughn (wonderkid, tall but with lightning pace, once technical stats

improve, wow)

Noteable subs

Phil Nevile (mr. versatile, DL, DR, DMC, MC)

Juan Mata (wonderkid, AMC, ST, good dribbler, needs to be trained to be more composed)

M. Fellaini (wonderkid, needs to improve attacking stats to be complete box to box player)

J Rodwell (youngster, potential to be good DC, destroyer DMC)

V Anichbe (not the finished article, doesnt seem to have potential like Vaughn, backup ok)

Ian Turner (young keeper, not enough potential to challenge Howard, backup ok)

Link to post
Share on other sites

OLLMEISTER1

Given – 7

Enrique – 6

Taylor - 7.5

Cyrgnoskwi (Shakatar CB? Do you mean?)

Boswinga – 7

Matiudi - ?

Zapater – 7

Elano – 7

Arshavin –7.5

Martins – 7

Agbonlahor – 7.5

subs

krul – 7

distin – 6

bassong – 6

nzogbia – 7

palacios – 7

tarrabat – 7

sturridge – 7

yeah hopey

the cb from shaktar donetsk

also matiudi from st ettiene in france. real promising player.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Galatasaray

GK - Fiorillo

LB - Hakan Balta

DC - Servet Cetin

DC - Fernando Meira

RB - Ugur Ucar

LM - Arda Turan

RM - Sabri Sarioglu

MC - Bolzoni

MC - Martin Galvan

ST - Paloschi

ST - Saivet

Subs:

GK - Makaridze / Orkun Usak

LB - Alpaslan Erdem

DC - Emre Gungor

DC - Emre Gungor

RB - Saunier

LM - Aydin Yilmaz

RM - Nainggolan

MC - Zuculini / Mehmet Topal

MC - Gokhan Tore / Yoon Bit-Garam

ST - Baros / Chrisantus

ST - Lewandowski / Asei /Mauricio

Some Turkish names might sound unfamiliar but they are all Turkish nationals. You should recognize foreign youngsters though. Thanks for your ratings in advance.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Manchester Utd

GK - Van der Sar (Experience)

LB - Evra (Allrounder)

RB - Diarra (Allrounder)

CB - Rio (Pacey and Intelligent)

CB - Vidic (No Nonsense)

DM - Hargreaves (Defensive)

CM - Veloso (Playmaker, and hard tackler)

LW - Nani (Fast, cuts inside)

RW - Balotelli (Wonderkid, same as Nani)

FC - Rooney (Target-to feet, HUB)

ST - Ronaldo (do whatever you want!)

Subs

Foster

O'Shea

Carrick

Anderson

Park Ji Sung

Berbatov

Tevez

Link to post
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...