I mean the stars as in the ability and potential ones as judged by your staff
I'd like it to be like previous FM/CM's where there were no stars and you had to judge players solely on attributes. It makes me lazy because it tends to affect my judgement of players when it can be wrong a lot of the time, especially when you manage low down like I do with terrible staff.
There was a Skin like this for FM21 but by all accounts the stars are on so many screens it is really hard to implement.
I've used the kind of skin involving the attributes that you refer to in the past and enjoyed it too, but it makes you have to devote an awful lot of time to the game and I found myself writing endless notes on players.
It can be quite realistic in my mind though, I used to use the attribute colour skin and have one colour for attributes 1-5 6-14 and 15-20. Gives you a nice at a glance picture of what players are really bad and good at.