This certainly is the way FM is going for me. Its identical each year a long save starting at grass roots is the same each edition, it starts off ok each team has it's current squad, then they get decimated through the seasons. Do the AI managers ever vary their tactic. You set up your marking duties for the next game which could be 21 days away and the opposition still will still be there come kick-off in the same tactic. The chairman are identical at each club, you may get the odd tycoon, but by and large their all too reasonable, no wild sacking after one game, no ultra committed to the manager type who stick by you through thick and thin and do the AI managers argue with the board?
F1 is interesting as yet it doesn't show what role you will play or will you get a choice?
I tried Motorsport manager which looked a bit FM graphically, but decided to add promotion and relegation. Its appeal was lost soon after the first season.
You do wonder if anyone took up the challenge and produced a FIFA style match view, with video styled interviews and interaction along with a huge database that didn't stick high end computers to a few 125,000 player limit it would make SI sit up?
If a sport as niche as F1 is successful with a driving and sports management simulator as two games then the ears of EA might twitch to try again in attempting a Football Manager game set with FIFA style graphics game?