Jump to content

Barry Cartman

Members+
  • Posts

    91,113
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    143

Everything posted by Barry Cartman

  1. **** side of the draw, Gareth screwing me over, Nkunku getting injured, having to face Messi My boys did well <3
  2. Thats the basics of football, its the only same as a defender sliding in and the difference between a clean tackle and a foul can be the other player kicking the ball at their foot/leg so it isn't a foul, or them chipping it over their foot causing a foul
  3. If he got a fingertip to it then it wouldn't be a foul, don't think that really needed answering as the whole debate is the goalie didn't get to the ball
  4. I wonder if air travel and different climates can cause conditions like this to worsen, seems strange how 3 have died and its happened at other World Cups also
  5. I wouldn't say Alvarez is in control of the ball, I think we'd all agree the only reason he wins a penalty is because his effort to put it over the goalie and into the net was tame, which lead to it still being in reach and the collision causes a foul. If Alvarez had made better contact and the ball say landed on the roof of the net, he wouldn't have won a penalty as the goalie wouldn't have deemed to have impeded him
  6. There should be more consistency of course, but if 2 players are going for the ball and 1 wins it and knocks it past the other, who has now blocked the path and a collision happens, then it should also be a foul, like it would be anywhere on the pitch. The idea of where is he supposed to go is just nonsense, if you go in to get the ball and you don't touch it, you are responsible for impeding the other player who did get the ball
  7. Wright seemed like someone who begrudgingly just wanted to fit in during that half time discussion
  8. One thing i'd like to bring up about the penalty, is I don't see the difference between that and the Lloris & Wilson incident, which at the time I insisted should have been a foul, but most on here was using the Neville where was he supposed to go excuse both Wilson and Croatian goalie stop, its Lloris and Alvarez who knock the ball past and then run into the other If you think it was a penalty last night like most in here seem to, I don't see how it was the opposite in the other thread
  9. I have no clue how they played in 1986, but if its the same as this side, then saying Messi carried Argentina to a World Cup would be extremely narrative pushing. Alvarez got them through against Australia, Martinez got them through against Netherlands etc
  10. Can you really say that when Alvarez has 4 goals and could still win the Golden Boot? Probably a disservice to other players aswell, Enzo Fernandez has been amazing, but he isn't a stats person like Bernado Silva, so doesn't get appreciated properly. Martinez in goal has been great at times as well
  11. Imagine no alcohol being allowed in football doesn't bear thinking about
  12. but where was the goalie supposed to go!!!! It would be perfect if they added Ally McCoist coming in saying he doesn't know what the lads in the studio are talking about
  13. Messi saying Alvarez deserved MOTM in a World Cup Semi whilst Ronaldo is trying to steal team mates goals saying they flicked his hair
  14. Alvarez would easily be Golden Boot winner if he played in the group stage more or was allowed to stay on the pitch past the 75th minute
  15. The same Neville who said the Mane studs in face of Ederson wasn't a foul
  16. Neville Yes if a striker knocks the ball past you and you impede his progress it's a foul every single time Go back to Bein you cretin
×
×
  • Create New...