Jump to content

abcdf

Members+
  • Posts

    280
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by abcdf

  1. How can I edit club visions? It seems to have disappeared from the club's page on the editor. In its place I find supporters objectives, which isn't supposed to be the same thing right? Is there any way to edit club vision in FM23 editor?
  2. Do you guys know why they removed the possibility to edit club vision from the editor? How can I do it? Now I can only edit "supporters objectives". Which in theory isn't the same thing as club vision right?
  3. I still see technical attributes developing less than mental and physical, as it came out from the analysis on the other post. Can we still see some adjustment to make it more even?
  4. As I said, I still see technicals lagging a bit behing mentals and physical in players development. Can we expect to see further balancing on the issue @Andrew James?
  5. Seems to me that technical attributes are still lagging behind with respect to mental and physical honestly. Even though the negative difference is lower after the update, there is still a negative difference with every single technical attribute at the moment.
  6. Hi Zachary, should we consider the issue to be completely fixed then? I'll run some tests to check
  7. I uploaded a savegame named "no rotation ai". You can notice it yourself. Even teams that in reality rotate a lot (for example, FIorentina's attacking line) because they have european games, in FM always use the same striker. Even in roles where they have players of similar value, that should be in competition between each other to start every game. The AI just picks one, and the other one never plays. In the savegame I uploaded, you can have a look at Artur Cabral: Never playing. The manager is always playing Jovic. While in reality, FIorentina manager is almost always switching between Jovic, Cabral and Kouame, that are constantly competing for a spot in the starting eleven. Completely ridicoulous, where is the "Improved AI" Headline feature? The AI is exactly the same, if not worse, than previous games. I will be returning the game soon. I am done for this year.
  8. Absolutely agree, am I the only one to notice that the AI is still exactly the same as last years? Where is this magic major overhaul? What does it concern exactly? AI managers still employ THE SAME formation every single game, they do not even rotate players always using the same 11, as I said in my post regarding the issue. And this should be realism? I feel like I have been tricked into buying when they have as a MAJOR FEATURE something that is completely non existent in game. I think I'll be returning the game this year, this is just ridiculous.
  9. I can indeed, but it is just a common fact. Managers do not rotate. Just load up a random save and you'll see AI constantly employing the same 11, with the other players only being subbed in. You can check it yourself with a random save
  10. Can someone from SI tell us something about this? The bug is there. The AI rotation is non existent and got a lot worse than it was in FM 22. I am still flabbergasted since better AI was supposed to be an "headline feature"
  11. I have posted for months some years ago, I think it was FM16, about the fact that AI managers are dumb and never change their starting 11 even with super tired and out of shape players. After 7 years, barely anything has changed. This year one of the HEADLINE features was smarter AI and what am I seeing? AI Managers that are dumber than ever, they literally play the same team every game, even in the first part of 2022/23 seasons where there are supposed to rotate since they have a game every 3-4 days. Is SI aware of this issue? Weren't smarter AI managers one of the biggest features this year? I struggle to understand how can you prodly announce something like that and then come out with FM16 AI. Incredibile Record actions
  12. Honestly, did anyone notice ANY change in how the AI managers behave? I have noticed none, they look identical as last year. If anything, worse, since I am noticing that they only play the same team and never rotate their starting eleven, even with super tired players. I barely see any turnover being done. And that was supposed to be an HEADLINE feature?
  13. Thank you Zachary. Can we expect the issue to be fixed with the final version of the game?
  14. Players DO NOT develop technically!! Huge game breaking bug here. I attach some screenshots of the development of Endrick, one of the biggest wonderkids in the game, from 2022 to 2032 to prove my point. Look at his stats. Technicals increased by max 1-2 points while mentals such as Composure, Decisions, Off the ball and Vision went trough the roof. Also the increase in physical is too big with respect to his technical attributes. Please SI fix this!! It is completely unrealistic to have a database full of techically horrendous players. For now I only have screenshot, will post a savegame as soon as I can
  15. Could you post this on the bug tracker section if you did not already? It will help speeding up the process of fixing the issue. I will post my findings as well
  16. Can you suggest me the most approriate bug tracker section for this issue?
  17. Players DO NOT develop technically!! Huge game breaking bug here. I attach some screenshots of the development of Endrick, one of the biggest wonderkids in the game, from 2022 to 2032 to prove my point. Look at his stats. Technicals increased by max 1-2 points while mentals such as Composure, Decisions, Off the ball and Vision went trough the roof. Also the increase in physical is too big with respect to his technical attributes. Please SI fix this!! It is completely unrealistic to have a database full of techically horrendous players.
  18. Look at hendrick in 3 years. Barely gained anything on the technical side while getting a ridiculous +5 in strenght, +6 in composure and anticipation and +8 (!!!!) in decisions. Wtf, this is a huge bug I uploaded 2 pics so you can see it yourself
  19. Did you guys notice too that young players seem to develop in a weird and unrealistic way? For example strikers do not develop on the technical side at all, not even finishing, while gaining a lot of points in mental and physical. Completely unrealistic and I believe it is a bug
  20. thanks. I think seeing a more realistic behaviour on the transfer market by the AI would immensely increase the immersion in the game
  21. I have actually uploaded another savegame that I used primarly to conduct experiment on the subject. I named it "No loaning example 2" Look at Chelsea and Liverpool reserves team. FULL of 20 to 23 years old that have not been loaned, and are very good players, some in the 140s CA as well. As you can see, just the overall amount of loaning those big teams carry out is just ridicolous. Liverpool just loaned 3 players in the whole season, Chelsea just two. United 2 as well. City only one. Barcelona loaned zero players. Look at Niko Takahashi in their B team. a 174 PA player that has been loaned only ONCE in like 9 seasons. As a result, his CA is still in the mid 120s at 24 years old and he is playing in Spanish second division
  22. Hello Kyle, I uploaded a 2030 savegame, the first one I hand available since the issue is so prominent it does not make much of a difference. It is named "No loaning example 1" Look at Arsenal B team (again, just picked a random team). They have 3 spanish newgen wonderkids (Aizpurua, Rojo, Aranburu) that are clearly TOO good to be playing in the reserves teams. Using the in game editor, I can see that they are all around 130-140 CA. And, as you can see, Arsenal is not loaning them, and above all making them UNAVAILABLE for loan. And NEVER playing them in the first team. As you can see it does not make any sense, and ruins some possibly incredibly good players in the future. Another example from the same save. Look at Bayern II. Some newgen youngsters like Duwel, Hasler and Fischer are clearly way too good to be playing in the German 3rd League, and will likely get no development out of it. Still, they are set as not available for loan. Look at Barcelona B as well. There are a bunch of 21 yrs old in the mid 120s CA that are just rotting in the spanish third division, when they could at least be good backup players for lower tier La Liga teams.
  23. I believe there is a big problem with AI transfers, that I already reported a few years ago but no improvement has been done, and possibily the situation is even worse First of all, AI teams don't loan out their best prospects just enough. This happens especially in countries that allow for B teams, such as Germany, Spain and also quite a lot in England. The situation is better in Italy where I guess the age limit for registering players in the U-20 teams kinda prevents them from doing so. Youngsters stay in second teams/reserves teams to rot for years (when they are CLEARLY too good to play in lower/reserves leagues and get no development out of it, but just not good enough to play first team) until they are 23-24 and now unable to reach their potential. I also see that not only they do not loan them, they expressly make some of them them "Unavailable for loan". This is just idiotic. B teams are there JUST to foster the development of young players, and not the opposite. The best talents SHOULD be loaned out to get playing time if they are not good enough to play in the first team. A 21-22 years old with 120/130/140 CA just gets no development at all playing in reserves league. The result of that is that most wonderkids get wasted and there are just NOT enough world class players around after a few years in the game, because AI don't make the most out of their youth teams. The same thing goes for unused players. I have seen players staying in the same team making 0 appearances for YEARS in row. They just do not make the request to be sold, and the AI teams just do not sell them, paying wages for players that are NEVER used. This appears particuraly striking when it happens to decent players, quite young as well, that just waste the prime of their career without making a single appearance on the pitch. Never happens in reality and definetly irrealistic. I hope this HUGE issue will be solved in the future.
×
×
  • Create New...