Furmanbp

What I would like? More transparency in everything. Why I see block of down facing arrows sometimes at my players details screen? Why I can not build bigger stadium if I fill up current for over 10 years (FM23 - but I have already heard that did not changed in F24)? Why my player move to team that offer them worse or similar contract(obviously I am not taking about situation that is my fault)? Why I can not offer better contract regardless of having way to much money. If someone from my team explore options, why I can not offer him a contract when others doing it, my team is also option! Why growing fan base is so slow? and way to increase that (yeah I am wining league every second year roughly, and fun base increase by really small amount - yes my team is from small town, but come on!). Some more things to do with the money. Show me in conversation screen when I last time prised player using particular option, so I do not use it too much. Sorry but it is stupid that I need to write that information down on a piece of paper. Also allow me to prise as many players as I want at once, no reason why I have to click one after another after another where I could just highlight those one I want and go with them. Why to have more medical team members, does it make a difference? Can medical staff have too much work on their shoulders? that is not communicated.

don't try, I am filling stadium up for roughly 10 years now (got like 99% in end of the year statistics 10 in row), I am the biggest end most recognised team in Polish league and I have the smalless stadium and board still deny every time. I personally gave up playing. Had this same issue in 2022 and 2023 version so it is ongoing problem with this game.

Lol and I am thinking for last couple of years that team talk does not do anything at all. I guess we have completely different experience in that term.

I am super happy with statistics as they are now, I do not really care for super realism, as long as game is pleasure to play. I would even argue that SI should be more transparent on mechanism of game rather than keeping so many things obscure, and that would mean even less realistic that real life. I think a lot of people fall into "realism" trap rather than enjoy the game. You said it yourself mate, you got skin that do everything you want so just use it, problem sorted.

I ma playing polish league and I have same problem. I have sold outs for 11 years now and my board does not approve new stadion. Also have like billion on my account.

Hi Kyle, It was a while ago, but from my memory, Junior coaching level got increased to exceptional level, something like 5-10 months latter. Without any information without any massage. I was checking it every game month. Also board allowed me to discuss facilities once, and agreed to upgrade as this is club vision, 4 years letter. Kind of long time if that is our vision and do not really struggle for money.

it may not be a bug, It may happen that your board does not see more upgrades viable at all. Yes button to ask for it should still be there just for sake of it. But it was already mentioned here in bug tracker that this is the case when button does not shows up.

well, maybe it is my imagination then but I think I see a lot of hints that I did not seen in FM22.

I do not think they got hints & tips for FM23

I also do not get it. I got very consistent players who constantly get bad match ratings and inconsistent players who constantly get good match ratings. Thou that was more visible couple seasons ago when they both ware same star ratings.

I never seen an option to decrease youth facilities. Are you sure you are not talking about something else, like youth coaching?

@Zachary Whyte Hi, so I got update. As Mentioned in first post about possibility, it seems that is rather cosmetic bug. It only shows at beginning stage. Grades do not represent actual intake.

Hi Zachary, Save file - puszcza youth candidates.

same here, did not worked once in FM23, it did work quite often in FM22.

xD

only devs can answer that question. all thing you find on internet is just guessing by players.

no mate, star rating going up from many reasons, if you buy the best player, then all star ratings for other players will go down, because stars are measured to average statistic of all of your player. That is what Jagster meant. Not to what they achieve during matches. That is not what Jagster meant. Again, player progress is compared to rest of team. so if you buy or sell player, or add new youngster to main team, etc, will influence star rating. that mean you can see a progress on progress graph, where in fact there is no progress but rather your team as a whole got weaker.

To properly use spreadsheet is good to know how it work. You know the value of attributes, so you saying you go take a look at person and see that person attributes value in real life? Regardless of that, knowing attributes value solves your game righ? As you know, higher attribute is better. No it does not, so your argument is not valid. True I can not look on Physio and see for how many percentage points he will reduce injuries. But I can take a look on physio and see if he have too much work. I can see if he is slacking in job, and many others things. Is it thou? Have you done statistical research on proper size scale with as small amount of variables as possible? Anyway, here I propose simple solution. Let us know how mechanic works, who will want to know it, can enable "deep explanation pop up window" in preferences, now when you hover over particular mechanic it will be described deeply. There we go, solution for both sides. So it does not solve game for you, and it does not solve game form me either. Everyone happy.

no there does not have to be a reason, or reason is it just look more cool. SI should tell us how all mechanic work exactly so there is no more wondering and guessing. But I do not see that happening. Are you sure it takie form into account? Do you have any evidences of that? Taking "form" into progress account, that would be vey weird! And I would give most credit to that answer. From my organoleptic measures, this is how this graph work. Which is very stupid. There should be some kind of neutral static benchmark so you can always compare your player to, so no misleading downward progres graph.

I do not think that would kill realism. On other hand I could say that being manager in dark is unrealistic. For sure manager would know if he have enough physios or sport scientist. We do not know, kind of unrealistic, don't you think? But it is not about realism in first place, it is about making informed decision in game, that is more important than realism. If I want 100% realism I would go and made coach licence myself xD. Do not misunderstand me, I am not against realism in any sense. I believe that if you play any game you should know the rules. This also could apply to coaches, don't you think that one with good motivation and one with good discipline would have kind of synergy? But not, you need one who have both attributes high to get more stars rating in training section.