fm09 vs fm08

hi anyone who looks at this, i recentlyish stumbled on the fact i could play fm09 on my oldish pc and was delighted so i played it like all the others and was excited about the neww featues, but then came a problem, my pc suffered unbelievle slow down, so i searched for an update of fm08 and found one, but now i sant decide wether i should not bother with fm09 and go back to fm08 with the recent update.

Let me add more, the fm09 i had didnt work with the 3d match engine so taking that into account what do people think? should i just play 08 with an update or is 09 that much better ti should persist even tho i cant use any other things on my pc and the game play is pretty slow?

http://www.community.sigames.com/showthread.php?t=103948

Not a poll, but basically the same thing. I voted 08 btw.

Why does this question keep getting asked?

I also think it's unfair to compare a game that has had its final patch with one that hasn't.

im sorry i didnt realise this had been asked sorry people

Don't worry about it mate - I would say play FM09, after the upcoming patch, it should be much better than FM08.

FM09 for me, but with 3D since it is in.

FM09 for me, but thats prob just cos its more upto date lol.

fm09 is a confusing counter-intuitive joke! waiting for the patch but doubt it can fix the problems with the game

another apple vs orange?