Jump to content


  • Content Count

  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Karnack

  1. 7th of November. Thats a guarantee because I go away on a laptop-free vacation that day.
  2. It feels like this thread is in a loop. Every time I return to check it a couple new pages have arrived but the same people still complain about the same things.
  3. Just saw the match engine footages, not sure why I do this to myself. I had a great final save in FM19 but now I just can't touch that game anymore. It's the same every year, as soon as I see the improved ME and animations/graphics I just can't play the old version :P Can't wait for FM20!!
  4. I think OPs examples where players from different clubs, so not sure that matters?
  5. So I did a test myself, just to see if this was true with my own eyes. I've been reloading the English youth take for the better part of 2 hours, I would say I have more than 50 youth intakes to draw from. I have a single newgen above 120 CA and a single player above 119CA. Both with a fair amount of growth potential. Not world beaters but surely sufficient to put doubt on OPs claim of 100% probability to not develop beyond their current self. Another issue I see based on this is the amount of 120+ CAs OP seems to get from so few intakes. I had to work "hard" for just these two.
  6. It's interesting that this post shows up now because I've just started to notice this in my current save. I'm only starting my 4th season and Zidane have already managed Chelsea, City and Arsenal. It's a very small pool of managers that seem to just rotate around the big clubs. But I'm only 4 seasons in so I guess things will even out when real managers start to retire.
  7. I can't remember last time I had a game without a woodwork hit from one of the teams. A lot of goals are also scored from woodwork bounces. Sometimes offensive football feels like pinball in FM.
  8. First of all, apologies, I accidently screenshotted a slightly different tactic than the one I've mainly used. The one you saw earlier was a desperate attempt to break down two of the bottom teams. Unsuccesfully of course. Secondly, as you can see by the OPs updated screenshot, I got fired and is now in a completely different league with much lower quality. I started to test a few changes according to your suggestions, unfortunately I got fired so things have taken a slightly different turn. But I will move forward with some of your changes. The DRs in this team are all below 9 i
  9. True, but I actually believe the players I have here are more fit to play this way (of course what I believe is usually wrong :P). I managed to get Bernardo Silva who in my mind is a better player than Firmino in that Treq position, for example. But quality might of course be a big deal here. I actually only have two attacking duties, the AF was only temporary, forgot to change him back to CF(S) or DLF(S) which have been my main roles up front and the Segundo has been on support as well. I will definitely look into changing the AMC role but I was so pleased to finally get the AMC to
  10. I'm absolutely useless when it comes to putting together tactics and I rarely know why anyhing works or not works, but I try to put out something that in my mind looks fairly balanced. So I was absolutely stunned when this tactic brought me 3 CLs, 3 PLs and a multitde of small trophies with Liverpool in three seasons. Feeling I had taken Liverpool as far as I could I went to Italy. Won Serie A first season with Fiorentina and had a good second season, despite losing in the group stages of CL, until now. We were 1st in january when this dry spell came. We don't create anthing anymore and e
  11. The four first seasons as Liverpool on my last save only Arsenal had a chance. Always runners up and gave me som serious competition.
  12. This is a slightly random question, but I just saw a guy on reddit who posted an FM19 clip of a ridiculous goal his team scored, now this wasn't what got my attention but rather that one of his players recieved a long pass on his chest and he controlled the ball. I have not once in 640+ hours of FM19 seen that animation, where a player controls the ball via his chest. Is this a common animation? About two seconds in to the clip: https://www.reddit.com/r/footballmanagergames/comments/c4m4ro/almost_cost_me_the_****ing_game/
  13. I've always been a create my own tactic-kinda guy with a focus on simplistic tactics with few TIs. But FM19 changed this, for some reason none of my "ideas" from past versions have worked for FM19. So I caved in and started to look for tactics to use but in my case it has almost completely killed the joy of FM. The problem for me is despite all the excellent guides and tips I've read and received I just can't create a decent tactic on my own. So I've been forced (unfortunately) to take the third path, stop playing FM.
  14. I'd like a shot at that game as well. Please upload. I have a pretty poor grasp of how things work tactically but I have no doubt I could win it by using the few things I have learned.
  15. I do have a left wing back on Attack and he is actually out there outside of the frame Thats also happens now and then, but we have trouble converting from crosses, my striker who is a tall fellow with 15 in heading rarely scores headers for some reason.
  16. Precisely the right person to answer my question. Thank you, won't feel to bad about those misses now
  17. I've been trying for quite some time to get my AM to consistently create good chances without much success. So I started to analyse the issue and I've noticed that the AM actually creates these kind of through balls pretty frequently (#19 passed via the red arrow to #22 Spalek). These chances have yet managed to turn into a goal and over the last season and I've had more than 10 of these. What often happens is that either my IF or my Striker gets the chance and they have ALWAYS shot straight at the keeper. Do I expect too much from a chance like this?
  18. Thank you, a lot of good ideas. I can also add that the current choice of players is not the most "optimal" starting eleven, so in general my players are more suited to the roles chosen. I played around with the AM in a supporting role but found that the BBM and the AM(S) often occupied the exact same area, this is not something you see when using support in the AM slot? I want to play possession based football, but I don't think we really have the creativity, flair and dribbling skills right now to break down stubborn defences so that's why I started to play around a bit with counte
  19. Hello, I should start by explaining that there is some unrealistic input in this save, this is a team I created from scratch with zero players (I bought the entire team during pre-season), I also changed the entire Swedish league system. This will of course affect everything, the team not being very well gelled and so on. I wanted to use an AM, having failed to get one to work succesfully since FM17. I wanted us to play possession football and probing the enemy defence. It worked quite well until, I guess, we claimed first place in the league with 9 points down to second and everyone
  20. I hear ya, but the wording doesn't really make that seem plausible. "They categorically dismissed Joakim Lundmark's interest in the job, stating that the club should not be considering HIS APPLICATION and will instead continue to appraise other candidates for the post". At this point it would seem likely that the manager, in this case me, would actually be interested in the job since an application has been brought forth
  21. I ended up in Leicester who was 7th in the Championship. I got offers from Watford and Bristol City as well, both in mid Championship. Burnley were the only ones who didn't like me.
  22. Could be But I actually applied for the job and they didn't even get me an interview, instead they hired Lee Johnson the manager of 16th positioned Nottingham Forest. Just a bit odd, maybe not even topic-worthy...
  23. Not sure what the editor could do that would affect all of this in such a way? I have money, I increase my budgets because that's how I like to play. I use TFFs Gladiator tactics which makes my teams overperform. My reputation is currently continental at 4 full stars. My starting reputation was the highest possible with the highest Licence. So the most unrealistic part here would probably be the tactic since money isn't exactly unrealistic. Still weird why the Burnley fans would laugh at me I think considering I get offers from Chelsea, Inter, Barcelona and now Dortmund.
  • Create New...