Johnny Bing

Thanks a bunch FrazT. I guess I'll just have to watch guys who have 20 in each attribute than try to find why they've been given the rating since there's no clear answer unless I speak to a head researcher. What is a player's CA and PA by the way? And does a player position mean certain attributes are lowered or can they still be high? E.g if you are a forward can you not have high tackling for example. If you can't answer all these questions it's no problem, I understand you don't have all the info, just putting it out there 👍

Hey guys, this discussion is basically to ask how you guys calculate the attributes for any football player across the world. And why a certain player may have less in a specific attribute than somebody else. Let's take dribbling for example. How is this attribute calculated? Is it done with data? Successful dribbles? Is there a formula used to give ratings in different attributes? The players with 20 in dribbling are Neymar and Messi. How did they achieve this rating from SI? Is it based on their technique ,and if so, what about their technique with dribbling that allows them to have this rating? Is their rating based of stats such as successful dribbles? Is there any formula or research done before giving them this rating? For example, let's say a random player in the Premier League wanted to achieve the same rating and was at 15. What would he need to show in games to achieve the same rating of 20, that he probably wouldn't be showing at 15?

Hey guys, this discussion is basically to ask how you guys calculate the attributes for any football player across the world. And why a certain player may have less in a specific attribute than somebody else. Let's take dribbling for example. How is this attribute calculated? Is it done with data? Successful dribbles? Is there a formula used to give ratings in different attributes? The players with 20 in dribbling are Neymar and Messi. How did they achieve this rating from SI? Is it based on their technique ,and if so, what about their technique with dribbling that allows them to have this rating? Is their rating based of stats such as successful dribbles? Is there any formula or research done before giving them this rating? For example, let's say a random player in the Premier League wanted to achieve the same rating and was at 15. What would he need to show in games to achieve the same rating of 20, that he probably wouldn't be showing at 15?

Discussing each attribute in depth and asking how a certain player is able to achieve a high rating like 20 in a certain attribute compared to another player.