Jump to content
Sports Interactive Community

kingking

Members
  • Content Count

    208
  • Joined

  • Last visited

About kingking

  • Rank
    Amateur

Recent Profile Visitors

The recent visitors block is disabled and is not being shown to other users.

  1. Defending from A.I and FM needs improving I've talked about AML/AMR defending responsibilities in the past.. SI doesn't agree It has been an issue for years what makes FM users think it will be fixed now
  2. Bournemouth v Man City.pkm The Problem. The ST (False Nine) acts as a ST (Poacher) during the Final Third ME EXAMPLE Red Circle. The ST (False Nine) acts as a ST (Poacher) during the attacking phase. What should happen. The ST (False Nine) should act as a CAM (Roaming) (Support) 1. Position & Movement. Defend as a CAM (Roaming) (support ) Attack as a CAM (Roaming) (Attack) during Build-Up and Final Third 2. Roam Around, Move Into Channel. To create space, support team-mates, and help create more options for player on the ball during attack 3. Hold Up the Ball. To allow players behind him and around him (AMLR/CM) to move forward Messi was a ST (False Nine) and acted as a Roaming CAM I'm not the only one facing the ST (False Nine) Problem it has been reported before
  3. i've done it now hopefully this can be investigated and fixed if there is a issue
  4. Bournemouth v Man City.pkm The Problem. The ST (False Nine) acts as a ST (Poacher) during the Final Third ME EXAMPLE Red Circle. The ST (False Nine) acts as a ST (Poacher) during the attacking phase. What should happen. The ST (False Nine) should act as a CAM (Roaming) (Support) 1. Position & Movement. Defend as a CAM (Roaming) (support ) Attack as a CAM (Roaming) (Attack) during Build-Up and Final Third 2. Roam Around, Move Into Channel. To create space, support team-mates, and help create more options for player on the ball during attack 3. Hold Up the Ball. To allow players behind him and around him (AMLR/CM) to move forward Messi was a ST (False Nine) and acted as a Roaming CAM I'm not the only one facing the ST (False Nine) Problem it has been reported before
  5. I'm not the only one facing the Strikers "False Nine" Problem it has been reported before The Problem. The ST (False Nine) acts as a ST (Poacher) during the Final Third ME EXAMPLE Red Circle. The False Nine acts as a Poacher during the attacking phase. What should happen. The False Nine should act as a Roaming CAM 1. Position & Movement. Defend like as CAM (Support) Attack as a Roaming CAM (Support) during Build-Up and Final Third 2. Roam Around, Move Into Channel. To create space, support team-mates, and help create more options for player on the ball during attack 3. Hold Up the Ball. To allow players behind him and around him (AMLR/CM) to move forward  Messi acts as a CM and Sometimes a CAM during Tiki Taka days of being a False 9 s
  6. I'm not the only one facing the ST (False Nine) Problem it has been reported before The Problem. The ST (False Nine) acts as a ST (Poacher) during the Final Third ME EXAMPLE Red Circle. The ST (False Nine) acts as a ST (Poacher) during the attacking phase. What should happen. The ST (False Nine) should act as a Roaming CAM 1. Position & Movement. Defend like as CAM (Support) Attack as a Roaming CAM (Support) during Build-Up and Final Third 2. Roam Around, Move Into Channel. To create space, support team-mates, and help create more options for player on the ball during attack 3. Hold Up the Ball. To allow players behind him and around him (AMLR/CM) to move forward Messi was a ST (False Nine) and acted as a Roaming CAM and Sometimes a CM during Tiki Taka days
  7. I agree with the OP The Problem. The False Nine acts as a poacher during the Final Third ME EXAMPLE Red Circle. The False Nine acts as a Poacher during the attacking phase. What should happen. The False Nine should act as a Roaming CAM/CM during the Final Third and build-up 1. Position Movement. Defend like a CAM or maybe a CM sometimes (Support) Attack as a CM (Attack) or CAM (Support) during build-up and Final Third 2. Roam Around, Move Into Channel. To create space, support team-mates, and help create more options for player on the ball during attack 3. Hold Up the Ball. To allow players behind him to move forward Messi acts as a CM and Sometimes a CAM during Tiki Taka days of being a False 9 s
  8. I hope SI are aware of the Strikers False Nine bug (maybe Target Man, Deep Lying Foward bug) The False Nine stay to high up the pitch during the FINAL THIRD.. they don't 1. Act as a CAM and support players around them by holding the ball, recycle possession, or pass to players around them. 2. act as a CAM and move around and close to the CM, AMLR, CAM during the final third or build-up play to support them I'm not playing FM until this is sorted because its hard to play a 4-3-3 like Barcelona and messi Tiki Taka era
  9. Thank You i'm glad im not the only one facing this problem
  10. FM is the only popular rpg/simulation where the users do not know what elements of the game actually do No one can clearly and confidently define what certain elements do such as such as tempo, play for set pieces etc... there is no proper definition on what it actually does in the game such as high tempo = more runs, more dribbling, High Time-Wasting = Less Runs, More Holding Up the Ball The tactic system needs a guide
  11. I love FM19, I posted this because I want to see if people agree or not
  12. (Thank you FM & SI Team for FM19, I love your work and the FM Series) FM19s formation are players defensive position. if you play a 4-3-3 you defend in a 4-3-3... The Issue and FM's Default defensive Formation A.I Pep Guardiola & Man City , A.I Arsenal & Unai Emery, A.I Bayern Munich & Niko Kovač default formation is 4-3-3 or 4-2-3-1 (therefore they defend and attack in a 4-3-3 or 4-2-3-1) ... why thats not what they do in real life..... Real Life. Most teams that attack with a 4-3-3 or 4-2-3-1 also defend with 4-4-2, 4-5-1 or 4-1-4-1, players change position when out of possession e.g. Pep Guardiola & Man City , Arsenal & Unai Emery, Chelsea & Maurizio Sarri, Bayern Munich & Niko Kovač, Liverpool & Klopp do this Reason & Benefits. Defending in a 4-4-2, 4-5-1 or 4-1-4-1 is more compact, leaves less gaps and space, and makes attacking midfielders defend more back. Top Teams do this.. I love FM19... however FM is supposed to be a simulation, lets simulate how managers and teams actually play in modern football
  13. (Thank you S.I & FM Team for your work, I love FM19) I see one massive problem for Top A.I Managers and there A.I Teams (e.g. A Liverpool, FC Bayern Munich, Man City) that no one in the whole forum has mentioned or even thought about.... FM 19 A.I Managers using 4-2-3-1/4-3-3. For A.I Managers and A.I Teams such as A.I Man City & A.I Pep Guardiola when they attack in a 4-3-3 they can only defend in a 4-3-3 shape or when they attack in a 4-2-3-1 they only defend in a 4-2-3-1 , this leaves gaps, space, reduces compactness and makes their defending worse. real life 4-3-3/4-2-3-1. In real life when Man City and Pep Guardiola attack in a 4-3-3 or 4-2-3-1, they defend in a 4-5-1, 4-4-2 or 4-1-4-1 because it improves defending, reduces gaps and space, improves compactness and shape. A.I not intelligent Enough The A.I Managers and A.I Teams such as A.I Man City & A.I Pep Guardiola they are not intelligent enough to intentionally defend in 4-5-1 and attack with a 4-2-3-1 or 4-3-3. Liverpool use a 4-3-3 or 4-2-3-1 but only defend in 4-3-3- or 4-2-3-1. The User. Its easy for us to intentionally attack with a 4-3-3 or 4-2-3-1 but defend using a 4-5-1.. but not for A.I Man City & A.I Pep Guardiola What can we do? How can we make A.I Managers and A.I Teams such as A.I Man City & A.I Pep Guardiola defend in a 4-5-1 or 4-1-4-1 but attack in a 4-3-3 like they do in real life?
  14. @Mensell76 Mate i Love your passion to improve the current system of FM, your analysis and ability to give solutions to current issues without holding back because you are afraid people will assume you hate the game. Possible Solutions. Improve ME for Attacking Possession-Based Football Issue in ME. Attacking Possession-Based needs improving Improve A.I Managers Improve squad management, building and development. this can always be improved Improve the tactical styles that A.I uses. The A.I cannot utilize roles and instructions like humans, therefore provide them better tactical styles to use. Introduce 2 formations Tactical System Possession Based formations (4-2-3-1 & 4-3-3) are Flawed for A.I. In real life when top teams use a 4-2-3-1 or 4-3-3 they defend using a 4-5-1, 4-1-4-1 or 4-4-2 for A.I that is not the case Reason. Weak Defense. Defensively 4-2-3-1 OR 4-3-3 is weak, it leaves gaps in defense. Realism. Teams change and switch defensive shape to a 4-4-2 or 4-1-4-1 or 4-5-1 when using a 4-2-3-1 or 4-3-3 because of the defending benefits of having a 4 or 5 in midfield
  15. @Totalfootballfan I'm glad im not the only one.. that thinks we should have a separate defending and attacking formation A. Current System You can achieve an defending and attacking formation.. Only through roles and instructions. The default formation in FM is the defensive one. Limitations of Current System. Complexity & A.I. . A.I lack of intelligence to utilize roles and instructions to create an attacking formation, it turns a complex issue into a simple one e.g. The A.I cannot intentionally choose a 4-4-2 defensive and 4-2-3-1 attacking shape, there are benefits to this approach Not realistic Modern Tactic System/creating . it is not realistic and not how managers create tactics, e.g. managers in real life A. Pick an attacking formation B. pick a defensive formation C. then sort out roles & instructions Not Realistic modern football matches. Real Modern Football matches are not as rigid as FM19. teams can easily move and shift into there defensive shapes when defending e.g. teams should be able to switch between a 4-2-3-1 attacking shape into a 4-4-2 or 4-5-1 defensive shape easily during a match. Not Structured or clearly define shape of attacking formation. the attacking shape defined through roles and instructions are limited, not strongly structured or defined when i look at the average position heat maps. E.g. its hard to have a solid 4-4-2 defensive shape and a 4-2-3-1 attacking shape in FM19 The Suggested New System The Process of creating a tactic should be selecting A. a in-possession formation, then B. out-of-possession formation then C. create instructions and roles C1. In-Possession Formation. 4-2-3-1 C2. Out-Of-Possession Formation. The user is only allowed to choose 1 out of 4 basic formations (basic formations that are easy/realistic for your current formation to change to during defensive play) Your Default attacking formation (4-3-3) or 4-4-2 or 4-5-1 (3 CM,ML,MR), or 4-1-4-1 (1 CDM, 2 CM,2 ML/MR) C3. Roles and instructions In-Possession instruction Transition Instructions Out-Of-Possession Instructions Player roles & Instructions Benefits/Reason of new system Benefits/Reasons of New System. Improves A.I It turns a complex process into a more efficient one that the A.I can benefit off e.g. the A.I can benefit of having a 4-4-2 or 4-5-1 defensive shape and attack with a 4-2-3-1 or 4-3-3 Realistic Tactic System/creation its how managers create tactics e.g. managers A. Pick an attacking formation B. pick a defensive formation C. then sort out roles & instructions Realistic Football Matches. Real Modern Football matches are played this way e.g. teams should be able to switch between a 4-2-3-1 attacking shape into a 4-4-2 or 4-5-1 defensive shape easily during a match Stronger defined structure and shape of attacking and defensive formation. Players will change position with intention and clear understanding, the defensive shape and the attacking shape will be stronger and more structured without it being loose. e.g. 4-2-3-1 attacking and 4-4-2 defending will be clear and structured
×