Jump to content

Kruj

Members+
  • Posts

    145
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Issue Comments posted by Kruj

  1. @Zachary Whyte


    How am I supposed to attach a save game when the Crash Dump happens while creating a save game?

    But I attached the custom league file that I used along with the "Playerfile with changes.fmf" which I already attached in the 1st post. Just use those two files while creating a save, use "Real World" game mode, and observe. I guarantee that there will be a crash dump for you. I just reproduced it once again, just to make sure.

    Fussball-Ligasystem Deutschland.fmf

  2. vor 21 Stunden schrieb Zachary Whyte:

    Hello @Kruj

    This issue looks to have occurred because you bypassed the verification process after making your changes. 

    But how am I supposed to verify files where I haven't done any changes to league rules? I cannot find anything in the editor to verify a file where I only set a past transfer.

    And since when is this necessary at all to verify non-league files?

     

    @Zachary Whyte

  3. vor 22 Stunden schrieb Zachary Whyte:

    Hello, we have this issue under review. 

    For now, there is a workaround for this issue. If the following is done in this order before creating a new test, the teams in the added division will not be changed to extinct:

    Add Nation Rules
    Add Division (Should provide a number of teams)
    Convert to Advanced Rules

    And what if you already have Advanced Rules? My file is from FM23 (where it worked like a charm) but after importing it into the FM24 editor, I got this issue.

  4. vor 2 Stunden schrieb Rygel16:

    Final Update:

    as someone else pointed out, if you set the number of teams in required teams of the nation rules, then the teams for that division will not be set to extinct if you create the test (and verify the league).

     

    => so this is probably not a bug, but a change in the requirements for creating rule files. I can imagine teams are marked as extinct if they are not used in the game to improve performance. But that is just speculation. The main thing is, I can start converting my rule files :)

    I'm facing the exact same issue and I would consider this a bug - a huge bug indeed, because I've got this issue with cups. And for cups, you are not setting the number of required teams in the Nation Rules.

    Example: I have a cup with 32 teams, the editor has a pool of 40 teams to pick (I use "Get All Teams From Division", so it's assured that there are always enough teams to pick from), but verification will fail, saying that only 19 of 32 teams can be found. Digging deeper into finding the solution, it turns out that lots of teams are being set to Extinct during the verification process.

    It's a FM23 file which I wanted to make run in FM24. In FM23, everything worked absolutely fine. This IS a bug, 100%.

     

    EDIT:
    I decided to attach a Screenshot. There you can see German clubs from Schleswig-Holstein, after trying to verify the rules, all the clubs that don't have a country anymore have been extinct. But they weren't extinct before, it happens during the verification process, that's why too few teams are being picked.

    extinct.jpg

  5. Maybe I should add the information that if a club only has two teams, everything works fine, and players of all ages are being sorted into the II. team and the 1st and the II team are being separated by the player's CA's. The described issue only emerges when a club has 3 teams.

    Looks to me like a club which is affiliated as a "3 Club" is automatically a U21 team, so it gets all U21 players which are too weak for the first team, and the rest (which is older than 22) then gets sorted into the "II Club". But this shouldn't be the case, a "3 Club" should be treated like a normal club, not a U21.

  6. I'm facing the exact same issue and lots of other people that I know who make league files as well. For us, there is no doubt that there is a bug in the editor, because of three reasons:

     

    1. The issue doesn't come up in every verification. If you try it several times, the editor will eventually verify the file, even though the specified rules are EXACTLY the same!

    2. When the file finally verifies and you test the rules ingame, everything works as intended, so the error message in the editor MUST be wrong. There is no other possibility.

    3. I'm making league files for 8 years now and I'm facing such verification issues only for 2-3 years now, so it seems like a bug that appeared back then (and has never been fixed ever since).

     

    It's definitely a matter it should be looked into, because it's a critical bug which makes it difficult to verify even simple Advanced Rules.

×
×
  • Create New...