Brentford Alan
-
Posts
313 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Forums
Articles
FAQs
Online Manual
Support: Blocks
Support: Games
Bug Tracker
SIGames Manual (beta)
Profiles
Issue Comments posted by Brentford Alan
-
-
6 hours ago, wesleymcuk said:
Why is Timber injured at the start of the game?
thought it was only injuries that happened before the season started and he got his against Forest in the first game of the season
also 10/12 months seems a bit harsh
Aug 31st is the cut off rather than the first game of the season.
1 -
Already a thread on this one.
0 -
9 hours ago, GB32 said:
Okay that's even weirder.
I started my game in 'original' mode, have you started in 'real world' mode?
0 -
1 hour ago, joe5p said:
Some thoughts on Rangers
Rabbi Matondo - Really struggling to see the justification for a big hike in value, starting at between 13 and 19.5 million. Not sure there is much to draw on to justify this hike in comparison to some other players.
Radvin Yilmaz - As above
Jack Butland - Could be higher value wise
Player values are not set in the database, they're calculated by the game based on a number of factors.
0 -
Showing as £23m on my game and in the database.
0 -
Thanks for the input, all players have been fully reviewed ahead of the FM24 release.
Regarding heights on the BFC website, I'm 6'3, I've stood next to Ethan Pinnock and believe me he's taller than I am
1.87m makes him 6'1, he's much taller than that. To me it looks like the website editor is underestimating the heights for whatever reason, I can't use it as anything more than a rough guide for this particular info currently.
0 -
7 hours ago, bananahk said:
https://www.brentfordfc.com/en/teams/profile/ivan-toney
1.85 meters should be more accarate?
The same website had him at 1.79 mtr last season. Comparing him visually to other players I'm happy with where we have his height.
0 -
On 01/10/2023 at 05:27, bananahk said:
Ivan Toney height is review yet?
In game he's 1.87 metres, or 6 ft 2 inches. Is this incorrect and can you provide evidence please?
0 -
On 08/03/2023 at 21:30, Mark Hayes said:
I played 20,21 and 22 with no issues with the wages, but yet it’s different for 23? But all I get back is useless excuses and people blaming others, I shouldn’t have to provide proof, I know exactly what I’m talking about.
As per your posts on another thread you are using a custom database https://community.sigames.com/bugtracker/football-manager-2023-bugs-tracker/transfers-and-contracts/player-wages-at-semi-pro-level-on-fm2023-r14290/page/2/?tab=comments#comment-90070
SI have no control over the data in this database as it's custom built, you would have to contact the creator (or creators) of this database to resolve any issues.
0 -
51 minutes ago, McClane29 said:
Has Oliver Skipp's ability/potential been raised as an issue.
Barely played for Spurs in 2022 due to injury and purely losing his place. At 22yo, I think we would know if he was going to turn out as a top PL player by now.
Often seems to end up being bought by top clubs which seems unlikely.
His PA was decreased significantly in October, are you using the beta database?
0 -
1 hour ago, The_Batmantis said:
Thanks for the info @Brentford Alan. But I'm still not fully understanding you. He outjumps players who have a "jumping reach" of 12, 13, 14 etc. We have repeated visual evidence of it.
Therefore, shouldn't his jumping reach be higher than 11?
End of the day, his height doesn't really enter into it. Its about how high he can jump. And he's incredible at it.
If you want to talk about height, most sources put him at about 172cm.
Many elite athletes can make static vertical jumps of 70cm+ : https://nrpt.co.uk/training/tests/power/sergeant.htm
Do that math and it's not unusual how he can elevate above even some CBs.from our research guidelines for the jumping reach attribute;
when considering his jumping ability, it makes sense to take into account the player's height.
For example, a player of 200+cm will still possess a high reach even if he is a poor jumper, and a player who measures in at 170cm will struggle to compete at the same height due to the 30cm difference in height between the two.Please note that some players may be over rated in certain attributes and require a decrease.
0 -
3 hours ago, The_Batmantis said:
Continuing my Spurs Mid-Season review. I'm now going to highlight some specific attributes or PPMs that I think are well wide of the mark for individual players.
I'll start with a weird one. Lucas Moura. He's one of Spurs shortest players, but any Spurs fan knows his jumping ability is insane.
At launch, he's rated with a "Jumping Reach" of 11 and I think that needs to be greatly increased.Just to pick up on a commonly misunderstood attribute - jumping reach. It's relative to each player's height rather than a rating on how good he is at jumping, so he'll always be limited in how high he gets by his relatively low starting height. To put it another way a 20 jumping reach would mean any player of any height could reach the maximum height the game allows humans to jump to, say 8 foot for arguments sake, with lower scores being lower maximum heights (I don't know the exact figures for each attribute, sorry).
His height is given as 1.72m and 11 is actually a very high jumping reach for his height, in fact higher than previous research guidelines would allow for this attribute which would have given him a maximum of 9 as per the attached chart which I still use as a template for 'my' players at Brentford.
0 -
1 hour ago, HNLFan said:
Ben Mee is one of the biggest earners in Brentford. Not sure is it true in real life.
Probably you should review and Baptiste's salary.
Cheers
I'm happy with where those salaries stand unless evidence to the contrary is available. (Brentford researcher).
0 -
4 hours ago, WanderersWay said:
I think that Liam Delap maybe has slightly too high a PA. I get that he was banging them in for the U23s in PL2 last season, but not exactly the highest of standards. He's struggled so far for Stoke City in the Championship, firmly the second choice strike option behind Tyrese Campbell atm.
Answer in spoiler due to discussing his PA value.
SpoilerHe has a -8 PA in the database, which will result in him being given a random PA at the start of each save between 130-160, if you got a high number he'll be a decent-good Prem striker, but many saves will have him as a low number and only a good Championship striker (assuming his potential is fulfilled in his in-game career!). His starting CA is effectively a back up striker number at that level.
1 -
3 hours ago, HNLFan said:
Some more observations and advice for Brentford.
Thomas Strakosha has first choice gk status at the beggining, while he is backup option for Brentford, or maybe cup gk.
Bryan Mbuemo dribling should maybe increased +1, he has approximetly 60% of succ. dribles, which is not so bad indeed ( https://www.sofascore.com/player/bryan-mbeumo/927083 ) Next, for example, Jack Harrison has dribbling 14, while his succ. of dribbles are 46% (https://www.sofascore.com/player/jack-harrison/829570 )
Strakosha has a lower CA than Raya, so should be the back up Gk. I've seen this mentioned about the Man Utd gks so could be a wider bug?
0 -
When editing the data researchers can't see how many of each role the in-game board will 'allow'. It's arguably more of a game bug, the real life board have allowed that many to be employed so the game should follow suit.
3 -
7 minutes ago, a7xZombie said:
Shay Willock is out on loan IRl at Worcester Raiders but isnt in game
Its a one month work experience loan, loans less than 6 months in length aren't entered in the database.
0 -
The Rico Henry international appearance clause has been in the database since we signed him.
0
1.87m makes him 6'1, he's much taller than that. To me it looks like the website editor is underestimating the heights for whatever reason, I can't use it as anything more than a rough guide for this particular info currently.
English Premier Division Data [Discussion]
in England Premier Division Data Issues
Posted
The Porto researcher wouldn't have access to Fernandes' likes field, so that accusation holds no ground.
I've found two links that say he is (or was when young) a Porto fan in a quick search.
https://www.goal.com/en-gb/lists/bruno-fernandes-fun-facts/blt3b0c9a82bc91f3a9#cs6a32ee75c012fc86
https://www.worldsoccer.com/best-of-ws/shooting-star-bruno-fernandes-409563
If it's a mistake, it happens. Please calm the language down, no one has put it in there to sabotage the game.