[Knap - FM24 and FM23 FM22_FM 21 - FM 20 -FM 19 Tactic List]

7 minutes ago, knap said:

@crossroader

You just need a player to play the position. All the role does is lower mentality within tactic structure.

Got it, i was thinking about that but game was confusing me when highlighting different attributes. Its same as before Natural position of the player is best. Tnx

[Knap - FM24 and FM23 FM22_FM 21 - FM 20 -FM 19 Tactic List]

@knap so many tactics are good by using both wingers with Defensive Winger roles and it so hard to find player with Natural position ML/R and to have exact role as main. Some of these players most of the time are even wing backs (40% of them), Do you think it better to be Natural ML/MR winger over being defensive winger? Which one is more important the role or position by your opinion. Because i see you use Luis Diaz as AML and ML in your tests, but his defensive winger role is worst compared being  IW, W or even WM as positioned ML.

[Knap - FM24 and FM23 FM22_FM 21 - FM 20 -FM 19 Tactic List]

Yup gonna give it a try to the new WoF 41212 P106 tactic. Besides that morale/condition and the player position should be as high as possible, do you think player attributes weight is still same as previous FM versions (like last 2-3 years). I still feel pace, acceleration, agility, work rate are still important attributes when chosing the right player. 

p.s i totally agree with that saying that tactic cannot be successful if you dont have proper squad - natural position, good morale, low or now weaknesses, good traits. 

[Knap - FM24 and FM23 FM22_FM 21 - FM 20 -FM 19 Tactic List]

Hello @knap, ive started with Wrexham in National League by using  BEOWULF  BAL SP 424 IF VOL [104 ALL CUPS (never switched to other tactic or different mentality while using it).  Immediately won 1st place in National League, then in League Two, League one and second place in Championship - 4 years in a row it took me to get to Premier league. Broke so many records for Most team goals, Most points and etc, but in my first season in Premier league i finished 12th. My team is with CA 110-130 while im at Premier League (lowest by far compared to other teams), i wanted to switch to similar tactic a little bit more solid defensive, but i struggle to decide which one is good for mid-table team. That formation 424 is really good finding players to suit positions so i dont wanna break the formation, when i looked at hub test it says BEOWULF 424 is best in slot, same in latest ME (p.s my FM23 is update to latest patch and ME). At latest patch sheet most of tactics are tested for top teams Arsenal/Liverpool, are you going to test at least top10  tactics how they perform for mid/low-table teams. It would be good for us your fans to have wider pool of choice. Really appreciate what you are doing, keep the good work! Cheers

 

[Knap - FM24 and FM23 FM22_FM 21 - FM 20 -FM 19 Tactic List]

41 minutes ago, fehleinkauf said:

@crossroader if using GS take a look at this thread:

https://fm-arena.com/thread/1949-fm22-positional-filters-what-are-the-best-attributes-for-each-position/

You will find ratings referring to the important attributes and everything explained.

 

I was wondering how accurate it would be compared to Genie's default rating file, i already switched after reading it. Just wanted to get another opinion regarding that. Tnx indeed mate.

[Knap - FM24 and FM23 FM22_FM 21 - FM 20 -FM 19 Tactic List]

@knap there is a file with posted Positional Attributes, but they dont match with Filters by the Prof. Are they still actual for FM22, because i see they are under FM21 section or it is Main section for filters, trainings and etc. My question is if we are using GS does it mean that rating file is not giving us 100% proper value of the player if tested weights from pdf are others. For example if i play with Parma and i use default player rating file of GS, it says Buffon is best player and GK of the team, but if i follow that pdf file with best positional weights and switch to rating file that is based on the pdf, it says Buffon is not great at all. Attributes like acc, pace, decisions and few more must be focused when picking up the squad.

[Knap - FM24 and FM23 FM22_FM 21 - FM 20 -FM 19 Tactic List]

13 hours ago, knap said:

@crossroader

There is no perfect test. The idea of the tests is to give an indication of which tactic could work for top/sub/under.

22.3 Tab are latest tactics and I am looking at another test that covers top/sub/under and test results tab a record of most of the tests carried out.so far.

Sometimes I will make a tactic on a test league so the stats will be meaningless compared to a Lpool tactic.

With MU/Brentford test I would treat MU Result as sub/top the Brentford under dog and total mid table.

The Chelsea test is a test league and any result over 100pt is good.

I was not looking for the best tactic, i was just wondering which tab is with latest test results. Actually im playing in a lower popularity eastern europe game and using ECHOES 451 P108 CC is just fine to me, i started first 10 matches using ECHOES 451 IF P104 EC FA, but P108 is more stable. I found out in previous pages someone to say - playing with DM is better for subtop and underdog team, so there we go... that tactic is giving me good results home and away.

- financial balance of the club is: -1M euro and no transfer budget;

- really unlucky loses;

- Ludogorets can afford buying players with budget of 5-8M euro, compared to mine - just free agents or players with expiring contracts.

[Knap - FM24 and FM23 FM22_FM 21 - FM 20 -FM 19 Tactic List]

Hello Knap, really enjoy using your tactics for past couple of years. I had no time for FM22 last year so i purchased it recently, but i'm a bit confused of choosing a tactic by using the tactic workbook you shared. Which sheet is the most actual tactic testing table. I see three different tabs - 22.3, 22.2/22.1 and Test Results and if 22.3 is latest table of tested tactics, there are some tactics with empty slots of GF/GA/GF and points are quite more or less.

[Pilgrimage 343 Knap FM 18]

i cant wait to see results of your latest tactics when testing resumes after summer break! I've been playing with west ham for a while using 343 lpool104 and finish first season (2020) with them 6th, despite top clubs has best players in the world

[Knap FM10 Tactics]

I dont have problems downloading these files/tactics, but Mr Knap i have problems sometimes when i switch with your tactics in my away games. I`m still searching for good away tactic, i`m not saying that your tactics are bad, even they are great for my team, but i have problems beating sometimes top teams, can you help me or give me advice about it?