So I've recently noticed this issue on FM24 (more so than previous versions but I can't verify that is a FM24 only issue) for instance I'm using Arsenal with Saka and Martinelli both linked to PSG in my 3rd season, Saka, 24 has a CA and PA of 186 with 4 1/2 star player reputation recently just signed a new 5 year deal and his valuation is 100-131m. Martinelli is 24, on181 CA 182 PA (I tried using the IGE to mimick dynamic potential on FIFA) with a 4 star rep and has 2 years left on his contract his valuation is 120-131m. As mentioned above I'm in my 3rd season with a clean sweep of all potential trophies so that should in theory boost all my player valuations since when you float your mouse over the player valuation it tells you it's based on the players age and reputation (guessing the CA/PA is a given). NOW what's mind boggling is when I came across Diogo Jota his stats are 157 CA 166 PA 3 1/2 stars rep 3 years left on his contract aged 29 his valuation is 171-188m (notice this is a range figure so it's the valuation the game gave him not a fee set by the club as if he was transfer listed). I have no idea how the game came to this valuation the only logical explanation I can think of is perhaps it's a reflection on the importance of Jota to Liverpool but he's the second choice AML/ST behind Luis Diaz and Nunez and Diaz's valuation is listed as "not for sale" but then again Saka and Martinelli are both my first choice starters but for some reason maybe the game doesn't recognise that as I do have rotation youth players coming thru and do rotate a fair bit. So yea I hope this shows how unpredictable the in game valuation system is. I recall on FM 23 I was able to sell Saka for over 200m to PSG and Martinelli on similar fee. Also I've been playing FM/CM since 98/99 and this is the first time I've noticed this issue so I was quite curious as to if others have noticed this as well.
