[Football Manager 2024 Official Feedback Thread]

Dont know how any of yous can put up with set pieces in this game, there a absolute mess from setting them up, Ai constantly switching players when u make changes.

Please for the love of god improve this disaster of a new feature for FM25 cause at the moment its unberable.

Am totally gob smacked that so many people play this game and dont complain about how badly implemented Set Pieces are.

[Team Interactions Rant]

18 Possible Options to reply to my players and only 1 out of 18 responses will satisfy these players(Yes i saved and tried every possible outcome of each reply) why have so many options to answer if theres only 1 black and white answer, broken nonsense if you ask me!

[Football Manager 2024 Official Feedback Thread]

Fantastic! Another slow and boring match engine, granted the match engine released at the beginning had problems but at least it wasnt boring, another FM ive wasted money on and refuse to play yet again, thats 2 years running now.

[Difficulty]

On 07/12/2023 at 14:08, DP said:

The challenge I want is the one Pep has right now with City. 
 

Does that sort of challenge exist in the game?

Am sorry but Pep Guardiola has had a minor blip compared to complete meltdown of a team and club, ive seen title winning sides completely implode under my control in FM many times, FM isnt always sunshine and roses.

[The game is completely broken]

1 minute ago, Ngoc said:

The game is easy in general because is very complex and for a player that tries it for the first time or that hasn't spent 500+ hours is absolutely not easy

for people who play 500+ hours is definitely on the easy side BUT you can make it challenging for yourself and keep it hard if you want to without annoying the majority of people who struggle because they didn't put in the hours to learn it

I know is hard for you to understand that a thing can be easy for a small group of nerds and right for the majority of people as probably you think you are the center of the world and all should be measured by your standard

but things can be easy and not so easy at the same time depending on who is doing it and since it's a game and games are for free time and relaxation I think it's easy enough to be pleasant

And if you want to make it hard for yourself YOU CAN! You can decide to use a strange tactic not shop for the best player not check the stats and make it extremely hard so it's actually pretty decent in the way that allows you to challenge yourself.

As I said I would love SI to add the auto-save and stuff I mentioned 3 posts above but that would be only for a small percentage of us 5%?10% so I rather they focus on stuff that all players (even the new one that find it hard already) can enjoy as I am smart enough to make my game harder if I want.

But I know that name you are not part of the bright one in the forum so I doubt you will understand what exactly I am saying. So I won't bother to answer you directly anymore.

Do you mean not smart by actually noticing the problems that excist in this game, unlike you the smart one that doesnt even acknowledge theres countless problems with the game....The modern setup of this game already makes it easy for all players New and Old, Everything is preset and theres walkthrough turorials on most aspects of the game, this ent no FM2005 where everything was left to the user to figure out themselfs.

[The game is completely broken]

4 minutes ago, Ngoc said:

countless mean 5-10 people over a gamplay of 20.000-60.000 at any time of the day... yep countless oh wait i just counted them,

What are you saying exactly? The game is to easy? Or the game is to hard? Which is your stance on the situation? or do you just enjoy disagreeing without a view or opinion on the matter yourself?

 

Oh wait the guy who said theres nothing up with the Ai making subs, a known problem Si have already acknowledged and my very own game also backs this up, i think ill just ignore your silly comments.

[Why you should choose to play in Zambia for your next FM save]

I Appreciate the work you put into this, i actually had a good read because am a Football Fanatic and like to learn about Football Cultures different to my own, but i doubt i will ever manage there, outside Europe i only manage in south america as i love Boca Juniors.

[The game is completely broken]

1 minute ago, Dadecane said:

I have been playing for 3-4 yrs, over 600+ hours in each edition and have only ever won 3 titles. Lol

La Liga 2 - Ibiza on FM22

Primera rfef (spanish 3rd div) - Ibiza on FM24

copa del rey - betis on fm22

betis is the biggest club ive ever coached on FM

Betis are actually a really good club, i won the champions league with them, Fekir was a beast.

[The game is completely broken]

To be fair even the steam forum has countless people complaining the game is to easy (not the opposite that the game is to hard) maybe there is some truth in that but the game is as easy as you want it be, i have always found success in these games but i usually always manage top teams.

[Football Manager 2024 Official Feedback Thread]

11 hours ago, Freakiie said:

Play a journeyman save.

Apply for better jobs.

Get offered a contract by a bigger club. Accept it.

Can't continue the game due to a board meeting with my old club about my contract situation. Tell the board that I'm leaving.

Game considers that me handing in my resignation, which then apparently terminates both the contract with my old club and the new contract I just signed. Be told a week later that my interview was "unsuccessful" despite actually being offered the job and accepting it.

Ok, now I'm actually annoyed. Especially as it happened just before my auto save kicked in, so I either replay a month, hope that specific coach gets fired again and I get the job again or just go on holiday applying to any random job because I'm unemployed.

Its a bug, happened to me when moving from barcelona to bayern. current club barcelona wanted to convince me to stay just before the news of oliver kahn offering me the position at bayern
(it also had the wiget where i could accept) but me foolishly wanted to talk to barcelona before i accepted it and as i came out the meeting it auto resigned me and the wiget for the bayern job disappeared, a week later it said i was unsuccessfull, its a bug and may never get fixed as i dont think many poeple will encounter this bug and fewer less will report it.

[Football Manager 2024 Official Feedback Thread]

16 hours ago, KeegBCFC said:

Wasn't "better AI management and squad building" used as a part of selling this years edition? All we have to show for that "feature" is that they're working on it so its "coming soon". Embarrassing. 

I do agree with this but the Ai is much more agressive in the transfer market, especially challenging me to my top targets, ive actually missed out on quite a few because the Ai was bidding right along with me and not giving up, so the Ai has been improved in some aspects but no where near the levels we where all expecting.

[Is it worth?]

Bayern is me and the other team is getting hammered 10-0 yet dont make a single sub.....total normal behaviour!

[Is it worth?]

 

1 hour ago, Ngoc said:

I don't even bother I sent a screen shot of my first season and he still writes something so stupid you can always tell who is not even worth an answer.

 

 

[Best Staff Attributes for running training]

Hmm good question, i dont know the exact attributes that would apply directly to the training set up, but i do like Man Management, motivating and tactical knowledge, thats my 3 favourite attributes in my assistant who i always leave to do my training.

[Is it worth?]

3 hours ago, Ngoc said:

It’s funny how you came here saying you don’t have the game and then insist that other team don’t make changes to people that actually is playing the game. Are you trying to convince yourself that is bugged to convince people that likes it that they shouldn’t like it or what is your angle

Are you Denying that there is a problem with Ai teams not making subs during a game? If so i would say it's you who hasn't played the game.....

[Football Manager 2024 Official Feedback Thread]

There is a problem with Ai controlled teams not making subs here is a few examples including Ai teams and Games involving myself.I have way more examples if anyone isn't convinced there is a problem but am not going to bore yous with screenshots.

 

 

[Football Manager 2024 Official Feedback Thread]

My Assistant Manager is not making a single sub during friendlies when i leave him in control, cant remember this ever happening in previous FM's, i know its been raised countless times and will get fixed eventually, but this is really damaging to player fitness and injuries during pre season, something that has always worked just fine in the past but now in apparently the most complete version to date this isn't working.

[Football Manager 2024 Official Feedback Thread]

1 minute ago, GOODNAME said:

For me I'm not noticing any wrong with the ME or a lot of goals in the matches

I really enjoy this version of the ME 

Maybe a little bit tweaks to defending especially the center backs but overall decent and enjoyable ME , way way better than FM 23.

i would second that, way better than FM23!!! to be honest the match engine plays well, its easy on the eye and being successful and watching nice football is all there, my major problem is with the transfer market.

[Football Manager 2024 Official Feedback Thread]

4 minutes ago, kiingallen said:

Nope. Last year was the same. Absolutely no changes to the ME from beta to full release. Same again this year. 

Well i will take your word on that, even thou i purchased FM23, i did not like the Beta version and didnt stick around long enough to notice any changes on full release, i guess they got away with it last year so i guess same approach this year, which btw if the match engine is so perfect in beta and dont need touched for full release then the match engine should never need touched, which isnt the case so not acceptable to me.

[Football Manager 2024 Official Feedback Thread]

1 minute ago, Zek said:

I can't actually remember if there was one for previous releases, but there will be a data update within the next two weeks, won't there?

This is the first time after Beta where it looks like not much if anything at all has been touched, every other FM up untill this point has had at least its ME tweeked on release day. Unless Si are completely happy where the ME currently sits which may well be the case. Data issues are totally different, they should be fixed ASAP, or heads would roll if i was the head of department.

[Football Manager 2024 Official Feedback Thread]

Why is 200 million for a player the new 100 million, like i know inflation happens(which i was told long ago inflation doesnt happen in FM) but neymar was bought for 200 million over 6 years ago and that transfer record still hasnt been broken, but now every good player that is happy at a club takes stupid amount of money to buy, something is really of here. Like top top players go for 300 million, and everyone other good player below that cost up to 200 million, its ridiculous.

[Football Manager 2024 Official Feedback Thread]

1 minute ago, craiigman said:

 

Wait i thought the J league was a new feature being added and licensed, now the head of Si is saying ' data will be added when the league approve it' am i missing something here lol, also wouldn't pictures and badges be easy to get, its not exactly top secret and nobody has never seen them.

[Football Manager 2024 Official Feedback Thread]

1 minute ago, Frederico EJ said:

Started new game after release...

1st opening game - Alisson breaks his arm

2nd game of the season - Adrian breaks his wrist

Surely they would have fixed the GK injury issue as it was reported weeks ago...?

 

This would be really annoying but as they have added the ability of goalkeepers actually getting regular injuries, bad luck will always play a part, really unfortunate for you but this is not the norm all the time.

[Football Manager 2024 Official Feedback Thread]

1 minute ago, Dagenham_Dave said:

What game breaking bugs are there? I've played a full 4 seasons on the game so far, and haven't came across a single bug that's remotely 'game breaking'. The interaction stuff is annoying but can be managed easily enough. Other than that, the game is playing great so far. 

Theres a bug that when you apply for a job when still in the current job, where your current job wants to try and convince you to stay before accepting the approach from the new job, and if you attend and tell them your leaving they cant change your mind, it auto resigns you when you leave the meeting and the accept wiget from the approach of the new club disappears, am pretty sure thats game breaking.

[Football Manager 2024 Official Feedback Thread]

From my experience Si have never released a patch notes on full release, even thou there was changes in the past, its all a bit strange if you ask me because we play beta version, lots of people report bugs and am assuming plenty of bugs are fixed(hopefully) but the player base isn't to know whats been fixed and whats not for whatever reason. Anyway i guess just play and hope for the best is the best policy as there isn't really a alternative is there.