I'm unsure if this a bug or a game design choice.
Playing an online career. I'd say every other game I get the exact same penalty given against me. Everytime my defender wins the ball clearly (replays turned on so I can check) and the referee gives a penalty, with the commentary noting the tackle was very hard.
I thought get stuck in could be the issue. That's been removed and the same issues persist. It can't be a design choice can it? I watch a fair bit of footie and I've never seen a penalty given for winning the ball but the tackle being too forceful.
Any ideas?