Jump to content


  • Posts

  • Joined

  • Last visited


6 "What we've got here is a failure to communicate"

Recent Profile Visitors

The recent visitors block is disabled and is not being shown to other users.

  1. This morning I tried to read your old posts about creating tactics but the pictures are gone. I was desperate as it was exactly what I am looking for, being a beginner who does not want to use the presets. You made my day! Thank you so much to bring this back to life Where am I struggling as a beginner interested in tactics and viewing/reading loads of material about FM tactics? --> I struggle to define my style. How do I want to play? What do I want to do? Hmmm. I don't know. I have no idea to start building something. I read a lot of topics on this forum, watched a lot of good videos from Daljit, and there seems to be a consensus that 442 is the system to study and master when you are a beginner, as it is very flexible. Good, let's go. What kind of 442? I don't know! Should I adapt/build it based on my team? If I start from scratch with a good side allowing me to choose how I want to play, I am even more lost. I then tend to have a tactic where I intend to be good at everything. Let's counter, cross, play some through balls. And of course my tactic is bad everywhere. --> I struggle to fix the tactic after the first draft I make. I watched a lot of "bring your tactics" videos from Daljit and it all makes perfect sense to me when someone explains how to tweak. I understand the role, duties and TIs, why we use them, how to balance them etc. I am able to imagine in my head the different movement of the players when I make the first draft of the tactic. But then during the game, nothing happens, or not in the way I wanted it to be. First of all, I struggle to spot the problem thanks to the replay. I have an attack replay, and it is not fluid, and ends up being a low chance. Where is the problem? Where should I look? When should I look? Is the problem happening during the defense to midfield transition? Is the problem happening from Midfield to attack transition? The only thing I see is that we are not fluid and are creating lame chances (cross from the line and corner, or a shot from far away). If by chance I am able to spot the problem, I then struggle to analyse the problem: is it because of the role combination which is just wrong? Is it because the player is not suited to the role? Is it because I have the wrong TIs? Is it because the opposition is managing to shut down my attacking pattern? Is it because one player is just having a bad day? So much possible causes, so I tinker a lot and in the end I just give up. --> If finally I have something which seems to give not too bad results: should I adapt to the opposition before the game, risking to break the little bit of my tactic which is working ? If yes, how? Should I adapt the mentality each game depending on the team I will face? It seems that if I am using anything else than positive or attacking, I create nothing (probably because my role/duties sucks in the first place). How do I adapt during the game depending on the score and how the opposition is playing? For example, I expected a team to be on the backfoot but instead they are attacking me and I struggle. Should I adjust mentality? TI's? Tinker with roles/duties? Hope it helps you!
  2. My TM is not really good. He has a good jumping reach (14 with 1m88) but he is lacking a bit of bravery and he lacks a bit of physical presence. I switched to DLF and he was participating much more to the game.
  3. OK, if I understand well Oreilly is carrying the ball because he cannot pass. IW su and FB attack will allow following passes options, correct?
  4. Thanks, I will try first the urgency of play instruction, and then the more urgenht press. For the FBa, I do think I need something to create an overload because right now it cannot come from runs of my CMs in the middle, they are only 2 and I prefer having them distributing to the flanks. The wingers are doing very predictable play: get the ball and run a bit, then cross. Hopefully the run of the FBa will help creating the 1-2 sec unbalance on one side so my player can cross. That was one of my idea to try next. Thanks! Not really, he is a natural FB, but he has strong attributes to play in midfield in a defensive duty: I have other good CMs, a bit more creative like him (but he is lacking in some key attributes according to the article of Rashidi about LL key attributes. But he is doing either great games with wonderful through balls or flank distribution, or either very bad games when the opposition is a bit more physical on him. For your information, I replayed (many time) the game lost 4-0 with the modifications I described above: higher tempo, Oreilly as BWM de and my left winger on support. It was much better, I won 2-0 on a 1-1 xg,, had a 1-1 draw on 0.4-0.4xg, and a 0-0 on a 0.2-0.2xg (so I am not creating anything obviously, but I stopped the deadly counterattacks). Oreilly was now out of the pressing zone of the 2 CMs, and a pass was always possible in the area. I saw (comprehensive highlights) some early crosses and long balls above my defense where my GK saved me a couple of time. So I think I might need to play with the defensive line. I still had 60% possession, with nothing created on the long possession phases. I scored on counterattacks, which is good but I need to find a way to score when I am holding the ball. I will try the FBa to make some run. I need to put Oreilly as FB though, as he is the only one who can cross.
  5. Here what I would change: I would like Oreilly to drop further back to have more space. He is already on defense duty, so maybe a BWM de? If the opposite CM is closing down, It makes room for my TM to drop in the space. Then I would drop my left winger to support. Or as suggested by frukox switch to WM. He is too high and not giving a pass option. my right winger seems better placed on the picture above. For the FBs, having the winger a bit lower will probably also avoid him to go too high. And I would up the tempo, as possession is not what fits the team. I would try those changes first and see what happens. I am correct with this thinking? Thanks for your mentoring, I really appreciate
  6. Allright, let's do this. I started with the setup above, balanced and no TI/PI. First game, I lost 4-0 against a 442. A lot of possession, but nothing interesting with the ball from my side. A lot of crosses; but all directly against the defender. Very predictable play I would say They scored 2 goals from counterattacks, and one from a penalty after a counter attack also. Similar thing happened. My CMs just passed the ball laterally to the other, the pressing by the 2 CMs makes him lose the ball (my team in white). I have a nice line of 4 attacking the defensive line but no support to my midfielders/possibility of pass.I also find the fullbacks very high up the pitch The 4th was a 20m shot after a corner kick. I was in struggle on each set piece. I challenged the ball so this was low chances, but still they dominated me. After 55mn seeing no chances (or only small one, see xg curves), I decided to up the tempo a notch because I was going nowhere with this. I think it allowed me to get better chances (a few nice counter attacks or play behind the defensive liner, both with the wingers or the strikers. Unfortunately we did not finish it but I was happy with the decisions taken. I saw a lot of long balls by the goalkeeper and one of the CB (he has very bad composure, vision etc, so a NCB basically). Here are the stats. Let me know if you need something else to help me tweak the tactic
  7. Thank you. It is also a point I know but struggle to remind : setting an instruction does not mean they will only do this even if it makes no sense. Setting instruction means that when the player will chose one option instead of the other if he has many available at hand. Which is also an indication if the players are not doing what you want: maybe the option to do X is not at all there, therefore he decides for the option Y every time even if you tell him to do X...
  8. Thank you for this absolute gem about LLM and team assessment. It is amazing how bright it is when you read such content. I wish I could take the light to my own games but as you said the learn,ing never ends
  9. My CM(su) is too late because busy with the IF and my BWM too deep. Here the no8 goes for the shot, but the pass to no7 was also a great option.
  10. Here are a few screenshots of the situations where I concede: First against a 442: The full back are fairly wide, my winger closes down... But just follows the FB and don't challenge the ball. Here another situation against 433: they are playing with 2 IF. They are focusing play in the middle to make space for their FBs. Please note how my BWM (no8) is sitting deep not really helping. the CMs from IA are doing what they want in front of my 2 lines. Only my wingers seems to be able to help. Is it a situation where I need to change the duty of my BWM to a more positive one? In order to be a bit higher and disturb the opposition? Or should I up the complete defensive line? If I try do sit wider, they will go through the middle like butter thanks to their natural overload in midfield, increased by the IFs Here is how it ended: they had a choice to cross or a choice to go again in center, providing good chance for a long shot by no8:
  11. Thank you for your replies. Here a few comments (my intend is not to be stubborn, I am sure you guys know better. I will try all your suggestions, It is just to help me understand some points and why my thinking is wrong): Here I start to see a pattern in my tactics. I ask my player to do something (through instructions or role), and I ask them something else with some other instructions. I need to be careful about that. Brings me to the why I clicked it and why I clicked "play out of defense": my center backs were kicking the ball every time they had possession, even without pressure and with passing options. That lead to a lot of replay for the IA where it was their MD getting the ball from this long shots and distributing to the sides. So I thought I need to tell them to pass the ball shorter, and the CMs which are more talented can play the killer pass in space to my forwards. Obvioulsy a bad idea. Then, are those lost balls by my CBs a "necessary evil"? I tried with PIs but not so much improvement OK, got it. Then when do you want to click this option on? When you face a team parking the bus and can't go around? Because with the correct role/duty I found this overlap is happening naturally. Is it when you select a role/duty/mentality for defensive purposes which is not making the wingbacks go forward, you can trigger the overlap with this option in offensive phase? Otherwise I don't see why you would need such an option Here I guess the goal is to go faster forward to avoid the other team to regain defensive shape. How do you assess if the tempo is too high? Is there an stat to assess turnover? Maybe intercepted passes? That is an interesting one. I never know when to click it. Without having it on, all replays are already played within space. Is that an indication I should use it more and click the option? Then I guess you don't want to use it against a team parking the bus, because space doesn't exist? Hmm, ok I thought counterpress was in the next few seconds after the loss of ball. Here the long shots are coming after a long possession where they can't go through my compact shape. Some choose to go around to winger and cross, some chose to shoot. A CM with 5 or 6 at long range shooting attributes scores wonderful goals, so I guess it is because they have the eternity to prepare the shoot in the best condition possibles. Same with crossing and below average crossers. OK, but I need to be careful if the guy is a deep lying forward or a TM, he will drop and take one of CBs off position, creating space for a CM to go through in the middle? I will try this. I am semi pro so only a few training a week available. I guess I should keep the general training and swap the specific ones for this? Yes, I will try this. First analyse the type of goal from opposition before game (analyst report), and adjust. A pattern I see with the goals coming from crossing: my winger is pressing the other winger, the IA winger passes back to the full back or CM, my winger regains shape and goes back to narrow position and let the IA winger free to advance, IA fullbacks passes again to winger etc 2/3 times until the winger is in position to cross. So he is always 2 seconds too late on the winger. The width will help to close down faster. I tried man marking, PI instruction to close down more but with no success. I will give defensive width a try. The narrow width helped me a lot for the balls in the middle of the box. So many people here, no chance to shoot from there. I struggle against the 433 (logical for a 442). Because I am sitting deep , the three middfielders are able to do whatever they want. I tried to increase pressing, line of engagement, defensive line etc, but I am always outnumbered. If I go out and chase them with my 2 CMs, they are playing triangles and then it lets my 2 CBs with 3 opponents to deal with. but by writing it I see I can maybe switch to a 4-4-1-1 to have one of the forward support my 2 CMs? Yes, that is exactly my idea to have a tactic more suited to the teams weaker than me and refusing to dicatate the game I am trying to do it, but I think I lack the "eye" to understand where the problem is coming for. It is like chess, sometime the problem is 2 or 3 passes before the assist. But whatever I do, it seems to be too late or not working. Which means I don't react properly. Still need a bit of training here. I generally play with positive mentality. But when I concede a goal, if I switch to balanced or cautious, then I create nothing. If I change nothing, I concede more. Very difficult fo me to decide between trying to catch up or play safe. I read the reports from scout and analyst every time. It helps me to understand if they are playing with crosses or through balls etc, and from which side. I adjust the duty of my wingers accordingly. Sometime I play a good team which can do everything, but this is football and I just hope my strenght are stronger than theirs Don't get me wrong, I really enjoy it. My english is bad, what I wanted to say is I am frustrated because I am not intelligent enough to grasp every aspect of the tactic fast enough I am not blaming the game. I am blaming myself for going through this 10-15 games losing streak by tweaking the tactic in every way without finding the solution because I am too stupid to spot the problem. It is all about compromise and balance, and when I tweak something it improves one point but makes something else worse. Which I need again to tweak, but then something else is not working anymore etc. One tweak will work against a certain shape or type of play but will not work against another one. I haven't found the way to make the tweaks in one shot. But I am severly hooked here. 300 hours in the last 5 weeks on this game. When I spot a problem, and for the rare case I tweak the tactic or make a subsitution which solves the issue and this is leading 15mn later to a goal or a good defensive movement, oh my god. I look at my wife and say "ce jeu est formidable" (this game is wonderful). Thank you all for your time. I will keep posting my questions on these tactics during my save because obviously I am a beginner and there will be many more mistakes/things I can't wrap my head around. And this is only for a simple 442, I can't imagine for more complicated shapes...
  12. Ok so first season I finished 3rd, and lost in half final of playoffs after the penalties. Second season, after a complicated start (probably because of the 7 nex signings), I climbed up and was ranked 3rd again. And then this happened: After the nice 6-2 against hungerford, everything broke appart. I concede a lot of goals from 20m long shots and on crosses. What can I do against that? i tried to press more with my CM and my wingers/fullbacks but I still concede on crosses and 20m shots. Why is my tactic falling appart? My guess is now I am considered as one of the good teams, and everybody is letting me have the ball and wait, not creating the space I need to exploit the force of it. For the 20m shots and crosses which suddenly seems to be deadly everytime I am puzzled. I tried to make the tactic evolve, but it is creating zero chance. And the other team still destroys me. They score even more easily... Can you guide me to understand why it is not working? Here is how I thought about it: I want to play a bit higher and not sit too low to allow the other weaker team to get a chance (I lost a lot of games with 2 or 3 goals on 0.3xg), so I up the defensive line a bit. I want to press more to get the ball and eventually counter attack. I ask ,y player to play with shorter passes to be a bit more patient in the construction. I ask one fullback to go on attack to get the overlap and create something on on side. Here is the tactic: This game can be so frustrating... now with the losing streak whatever I do or say, the players are upset and want to leave. I am still hanging on my playoff place but with 2 games to go and only 2 points ahead of the 7th place, I fear I will not make it...
  13. side referee is heavily sweating every time my CM is approaching the box and do not know what to do with the ball. I mean you know shooting and having the ball constantly 1-2m too high or too much to one side, I can understand. But here every single time the ball is doing something funny. High consistency though
  14. Thanks a lot for your quick reply. I figure out a few tweaks by myself, which corresponds to a few of your comments. I was able to see some very nice counter attacks on almost each replay: CM regaining back the ball, kicking to the DLF, who waits a bit until the poacher makes a nice run, passing the ball into space to get a nice one on one. All counter attacks are hapenning in center of pitch though, which is OK for me, but I was expecting more from my wingers on attack? I am now 4th in league (media prediction: 15th), and I just won against the 1st and 3rd in league with clear counter attack chances. I still feel it needs to be polished. First tweaks I made are more related to some specific player problems. GK and one CB had terrible passing rates. Like really really bad. My DLF is not very big so no chance to get those long balls they threw again and again: I added play out of defense, distribute to full backs, and shorter passing+take less risk as PI, which increased passing rate for them to 60% Before I suffered a lot of counter attacks: as you said, all midfielder were runner. I switched one CM do BWM defense. He is then dropping a touch more out of possession also, providing a bit of coverage between the two defensive line. And I clicked the regroup in transition, as I felt my guys were trying to press the ball carrier on counter attack (which passed the ball and did not wait for our guys to be there) instead of running back to defensive positions. I stopped conceiding on counter attacks. I keep conceeding a lot of crosses. Is there anything I can do against that? I have the impression it is happening when they hit early crossings: my CBS or even FBs are not moving and the striker seems to just move exactly in the space between or behind defenders. Is it linked with your comment about wingers on attack, evenually not able to press the guy hitting the cross? If not, would you mind explaining why it is bad to have both on attack? If yes, should I drop both them to support duties? I unticked the work ball into the box also by myself. I feel the instruction is not only pushing the player to choose the pass instead of the shot, it is also changing somehing else. I don't know, maybe mentality of the player and the one around in some ways, but there is definitely something "under the hood". Now instead of passing laterally my guys are either looking for the through ball or shoot. I think I will give some PI instructions to shoot less though as a lot of shot are hitting the corner flag. Also, I have pressing set on standard setting, should I try to press slighly more urgent? Maybe it can help me to avoid those crosses but also to gain the ball more often to initiate the counter attack? Thanks a lot for your insights, very helpful. I enjoy a lot the thinking involved in that.
  15. Hello everybody, I am seeking a bit of help to understand what I am doing wrong. I am a new player to the game, and I am really interested in the tactics bit. As I like to approach the stuffs logically, I would like to start with the basics: simple 442, before moving to the more complex formations and concepts like overloads etc. Therefore, I am managing Oxford City in Vanrama South. LL is perfect for 442. I restarted 2x the save. First time it went good; until it didn't. I was on losing streak and no way to bring morale back up again. So I restarted and focused on keeping morale high, as I thought I was a bit too focused on going through the games without taking care of that part. But somehow in the new save, whatever I do, I just suck. Which makes me wonder, maybe my good form on first save was just luck, and tactic is basically bad. So what do I want to do? Simple 442 with as less PI/TI as possible and simple roles as I am lower league. It is also a good exercise to really focus on duties Do I want possession? No, not necessarily. I find the nice counter attack with 3-4 passes and nice off the ball work by all these sprinkling guys quite beautiful. But I also want to be able to create something in case the other team let me have the ball (here we can maybe talk about adjusting the tactic after 20-30mn of game) I don't want to have 20 chances, but I want 2 or 3 with good xG Therefore, I need to be very solid in defense. I am not going to score 4 goals and conceide 3. I want to score the 1st one on counter, and then eventually use the space which is opening up through the increase of mentality of the other team to score many more So where do I go from that? I start from defense: I want to be very solid. So I need to be compact (narrow), but also a bit deeper to let them come and avoid over the defense ball (you can find tall guys but slow, or small guys but fast in those leagues) I don't want to win back the ball too much up the pitch: pressing urgency on basic settings to preserve the shape, and lower line of engagement In transition: Counter obviously I used distribute to full backs but I removed it as it might hamper this GK kick above the defense (my GK has a 12 in kicking) I also used distribute quickly but my GK has very bad passing stats in game (40% passes), so I removed it again. In possession: Work ball into box, as my guys started to shoot to the moon in the last 20m while in long possession (but here probably vecause I have not enough movement in such phases) So here we go: CD on defense FB on support. I want them to be focusing first on defense, and make the forward run when it is safe Wingers on attack. By having one of them on Support, nothing happens in the game. No replay except the ones of IA scoring against my frozen CD CM in support. Here I wanted an easy role. For duty I set one on defense at first, but the other CM su was left alone in possession to control midfield. A little bit of pressing and we faced a deadly counter attack (5th tier teams all playing 433 gegenpress ). With both CM on support, I still have the nice 2 lines in front of the box out of possession DLF su and Poacher on attack. AF gave me way too much offside. Probably too low attributes of my players. I feel the DLF is coming too much down the pitch and leaves the P a bit alone. Here are the results: I am again facing a losing streak. I don't want to again tweak and click every single button after every lost game (which is what I always do), as I feel it will confuse my players. I think I made some good signing, here is the report of my assistant: Thank you for any suggestion and advice. I feel I would lose something by downloading standard gegenpress tactics online. I need this intellectual challenge. BUt having a few advices from experienced guy might help me understand where I am missing something. And get better. Long term I would like to get up the divisions and let this 442 evolve with some wing play once I find players able to handle it. By maybe taking control of possession (or at least not let it to the other side on purpose). Creating overload on one side, having the playmaker in midfield to orient the ball to the other empty flank. That is for the long run but I am almost discouraged that I can't handle the simpliest 442 LL counter...
  • Create New...