AFootballManager

Don't trust anyone's opinion. Instead, try out the demo yourself and give yourself an indication of what the game is like. That's what I'm doing right now.

Is it me or do I see alot more lobbed passes than ground passes in the midfield? I understand this was very prevalent in FM16.

Like I said... It's just my first impression based on what I have SEEN in the video. Judging by FM16 defending as a whole was very inconsistent compared to real life and I'm not just talking about defenders themselves.

Well since its in 3D I would expect it to represent whats happening in 3D form. Bad defending includes pressing, player positioning and intelligence (this would be considered most important) and judging by that video there seems like there is no improvement. But like I said I am reserved on making a final judgment till the beta.

I barely see any improvements. Defending still looks woeful again... But i'm reserved on making a proper judgment until I see the beta.

This wasn't even the problem. If you actually read the OP then I think you may understand.

Why have you made FMT seperate btw?

Most definitely wont be pre-ordering after this years edition. Will wait for the full game release/demo before I make a decision.

You can't just not think about weaknesses and flaws when they have a impact on the game and exactly how you want to play and react to certain situations. It seems like the conversation is diverting from the original point made so I'll end it here.

This is basically what I was talking about.

Except you have to use PIs and TIs to counteract the ME's flaws no?

The fact that you have to adapt to the ME is calling for serious concern. Absolutely no manager should really have to do that.

Yes attacking players are more incapable of defending but what about wide players that are actually capable of putting in a shift? Players like Albrighton shouldn't be so incapable of tracking back when he meant to do so and this is where the problem lies at. Overall, I think marking needs to be better looked at in terms of when should a player be marking? In what scenarios should a player be marking? etc. Defending overall should be a serious priority in next years edition and more options should be available for the manager to make decisive decisions in crucial moments as well as focusing on improving player intelligence.

Unfortunately it does not work as properly as it should do as you still see opposition full backs not being marked tight enough and still get simple crosses in.

So are you telling I can use every swear word under the sun without it being filtered?