Cherno Samba - from around 2000. At age 16 he kept Shevchenko out of my AC Milan starting 11!
Robbie Keane - 98/99? Bought from Wolves or Coventry, played behind the front 2 he scored 50 - 60 a season every time. In 2 player mode we banned his purchase!
Tommy Svindal Larsson - CM 2 I think, in the age of super cheap world class scandinavians!
Maxi Lopez - 01/02? My mate bought him for Barca in our 2 player La Liga game and he scored about 60 a season. I hated him.
Kennedy Bakirçioglo (something like that). Absolute legend in 99/00 I think it was.
Ah, such happy memories!