Jump to content
Sports Interactive Community
Freddie Sands

[France] (Official) League Specific Issues

Recommended Posts

1 hour ago, AlienIR said:

Merci. 

J'ai parle au dev, la plupart sont des limitations (ex augmentation des droits tv en saison 2).

Je testerais ce week-end mais dans mes derniers tests, les clubs generaient des budgets transferts coherent en saison 1,2 et suivantes (en prenant reference les rappports DNCG). Ceci peut s'expliquer par le fait que toutes les vraies depenses IRL des clubs sont loin d'etre representables dans le jeu ( par exemple, le jeu est loin de pouvoir representer l'ensemble des personnes remunerees par le club). L'un dans l'autre un 'equilibre' est atteint pour l'instant.

Mais encore une fois je testerais ce week-end. Le plus important etant de nous assurer que les budgets restent equilibres. Si tu augmentes les incomes alors que les depenses ne sont pas realistes tu auras un probleme d'equilibre.

Ca merite d'etre teste. Toutefois, cela demande du temps.

j'ai essayé de trouver quelque lien pour pouvoir vous aider

https://rmcsport.bfmtv.com/football/ligue-1-l-explosion-des-droits-tv-une-aubaine-surtout-pour-les-petits-1732666.html

http://www.madeinfoot.com/infos/article-l1-la-repartition-des-droits-tv-en-2018-2019-275483.html

https://www.90min.com/fr/posts/6359910-la-repartition-des-droits-tv-dans-les-5-grands-championnats-europeens

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Merci @lookiluk, comme je t'ai explique, le changement de droit tv a partir de la saison 2020/2021 est une limitation, nous ne pouvons rien faire de ce cote la.

 

Pour mieux t'expliquer, voici comment est calculee la repartition des droits tv IRL

https://www.lesechos.fr/2018/05/foot-comment-sont-repartis-les-droits-tv-en-france-991358

La part fixe/ la license club / le classement sont representes dans les parties. Ce qui manque c'est la notoriete et le calcul sur les 5 dernieres saison, qui elles aussi sont des limitations (demandes effectues en 2015 aux devs).

 

Mais encore une fois, de l'autre cote de la balance (les depenses clubs) tu as la meme problematique. Les depenses IRL et ingame ne sont pas les memes (ingame elles sont plus basses). Il nous est impossible de toutes les representer pour differentes raisons (eg roles non disponibles, roles non representables, infos non disponibles (ex primes)…) .

Certes les incomes sont plus bas qu'IRL a cause des limitations mais c'est le cas aussi pour les depenses. Encore une fois, les budgets transferts generes par les clubs sont assez coherents (si on les compare a ceux donnes par la dncg.) . Encore une fois, je vais retester ce point, mais en beta cela semblait coherent. Si quelques chose ressort des tests, nous verrons alors si nous pouvons faire quelque chose. Mais augmenter les droits tv sans contrebalancer les depenses (non representables) menerait a detruire l'equilibre des parties tout simplement. Je n'ai aucune envie de voir des clubs de bas de L1 generer 30 Millions de budget par exemple, ce ne serait pas realiste non plus.

 

Tout ce qui est limitation nous ne pouvons rien faire malheureusement, tu m'en vois le premier desole. 

 

J'espere que le feedback te sera utile.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Le 21/11/2019 à 17:24, AlienIR a dit :

Yeah @navas27, it's probably doable, but tbh not sure how it could be done. Could be also not doable.

Don't worry the issue is under review, which means it would be fixed ingame at some point.

all right :)  i'm waiting this to be achieved before starting to play ;) 

Edited by navas27

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 23/11/2019 at 11:22, navas27 said:

all right :)  i'm waiting this to be achieved before starting to play ;) 

Thanks for your patience, shouldn't be too long hopefully. You may still play just to get used to the new game. I'll keep you in touch asap.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have zero black regens in France in 5 years, very unrealistic. Can this be fixed with an editor. Please make notice of this problem, the previous editions were good with the origins, hope this can be fixed. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Currently in 2023 (just after the winter world cup)

Noticed this particular calendar

9d313cf4110ba985df73756bd40ee56a.png

One game every 2 days is may be a bit harsh ;)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Summary: Ligue 1 Loan Rules appear to be broken 

Description of Issue: Im managing in Italy (So a foreign club under the rules) and am trying to renew a loan for William Geubbels from AS Monaco. This loan is getting cancelled as it says Monaco would be breaking the rules that say no more than 7 players OVER the age of 22 can be loaned to foreign clubs in one season. I think this is broken on 2 fronts. 

1. This is a loan renewal so if he was allowed last season, he should already be taking up one of the slots and therefore be able to "renew" his position in that slot. 

2. William Geubbels is currently 19 years old in game so he definitely isn't over the age of 22 and should not count towards the slot either way. 
image.thumb.png.3c2efa34b949657b4c22e7293e124dff.png

 

Steps to Reproduce: Try renewing a loan of a player under the age of 22 from a club that has filled out their "Over the age of 22 Foreign loans" slots.  In my uploaded save just try renew the loan for Geubbels and it should happen and cancel the loan. 

Save Game: Version 2.1.4. Uploaded to cloud as Brian A***** - Livorno.fm (can PM name if needed)

 

EDIT: Appears this happens with any team that has these restrictions. Had it with Man City too (exact same issue other than that). Not sure where to post this now?

Edited by Brian 95

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It's a problem with Coupe de France. Teams from overseas territories can select only 4 players as citizens of New Caledonia, Reunion etc. are counted as foreigners.

Also there are new rules regarding these teams.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2019–20_Coupe_de_France#Notable_rule_changes

http://www.foot-national.com/foot-coupe-de-france-la-revolution-pour-l-outre-mer-121206.html

https://www.footamateur.fr/coupe-de-france-fini-les-voyages-en-martinique-guadeloupe-et-guyane-au-septieme-tour/

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hello.

I finished in third place the first season with Lyon and that should have gave me a place in the Champions League Qualification round but instead i went straight to the group stage? Known bug?

Skärmavbild 2019-12-04 kl. 00.13.19.pngSkärmavbild 2019-12-04 kl. 00.12.33.png

Skärmavbild 2019-12-04 kl. 00.12.14.pngSkärmavbild 2019-12-04 kl. 00.16.45.png

Edited by pontaruff

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
11 hours ago, pontaruff said:

Hello.

I finished in third place the first season with Lyon and that should have gave me a place in the Champions League Qualification round but instead i went straight to the group stage? Known bug?

Skärmavbild 2019-12-04 kl. 00.13.19.pngSkärmavbild 2019-12-04 kl. 00.12.33.png

Skärmavbild 2019-12-04 kl. 00.12.14.pngSkärmavbild 2019-12-04 kl. 00.16.45.png

Good morning - Could I get this save game please? Don't think this is a known issue and would like to take a look. Thanks. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
10 hours ago, Christopher Lewis said:

Good morning - Could I get this save game please? Don't think this is a known issue and would like to take a look. Thanks. 

How do i attach a save-file? I can only attach a file with the size 9.77 mb, the save-file is 178 mb. Edit: I found out how. Save-file incoming.

Edited by pontaruff

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
10 hours ago, Christopher Lewis said:

Good morning - Could I get this save game please? Don't think this is a known issue and would like to take a look. Thanks. 

Lyon! pontaruff.fm is the name of the save-file. Did I do it right?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hey @pontaruff - We've figured out why this has happened. When the Champions League winner and the Europa League winner both qualify for the Champions League group stage through their domestic league, it changes the qualification places. As France is the 5th ranked nation, they are the nation that benefits. It actually happened with the Champions League this year with Liverpool and Chelsea both Qualifying for the Group Stage. (Below copied from Wikipedia as it's a good explanation.)

  • In the default access list, the Champions League title holders qualify for the group stage. However, since the Champions League title holders (Liverpool) have qualified via their domestic league (as second place in the 2018–19 Premier League), the following changes to the access list were made:
    • The champions of association 11 (Austria) entered the group stage instead of the play-off round.
    • The champions of association 13 (Czech Republic) entered the play-off round instead of the third qualifying round.
    • The champions of association 15 (Greece) entered the third qualifying round instead of the second qualifying round.
    • The champions of associations 18 and 19 (Israel and Cyprus) entered the second qualifying round instead of the first qualifying round.
  • In the default access list, the Europa League title holders qualify for the group stage. However, since the Europa League title holders (Chelsea) qualified for the group stage via their domestic league (as third place in the 2018–19 Premier League), the following changes to the access list were made:
    • The third-placed team of association 5 (France) entered the group stage instead of the third qualifying round.
    • The runners-up of associations 10 and 11 (Turkey and Austria) entered the third qualifying round instead of the second qualifying round.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
10 minutes ago, Christopher Lewis said:

Hey @pontaruff - We've figured out why this has happened. When the Champions League winner and the Europa League winner both qualify for the Champions League group stage through their domestic league, it changes the qualification places. As France is the 5th ranked nation, they are the nation that benefits. It actually happened with the Champions League this year with Liverpool and Chelsea both Qualifying for the Group Stage. (Below copied from Wikipedia as it's a good explanation.)

  • In the default access list, the Champions League title holders qualify for the group stage. However, since the Champions League title holders (Liverpool) have qualified via their domestic league (as second place in the 2018–19 Premier League), the following changes to the access list were made:
    • The champions of association 11 (Austria) entered the group stage instead of the play-off round.
    • The champions of association 13 (Czech Republic) entered the play-off round instead of the third qualifying round.
    • The champions of association 15 (Greece) entered the third qualifying round instead of the second qualifying round.
    • The champions of associations 18 and 19 (Israel and Cyprus) entered the second qualifying round instead of the first qualifying round.
  • In the default access list, the Europa League title holders qualify for the group stage. However, since the Europa League title holders (Chelsea) qualified for the group stage via their domestic league (as third place in the 2018–19 Premier League), the following changes to the access list were made:
    • The third-placed team of association 5 (France) entered the group stage instead of the third qualifying round.
    • The runners-up of associations 10 and 11 (Turkey and Austria) entered the third qualifying round instead of the second qualifying round.

Aaa I see! Thank you very much. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Just had the Squad Registration window close before the end of the transfer window in January 2026.

The only squad registration I could do after the transfer window closed was the Euro Cup squad reg.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 10/12/2019 at 18:19, turnip said:

Just had the Squad Registration window close before the end of the transfer window in January 2026.

The only squad registration I could do after the transfer window closed was the Euro Cup squad reg.

Hey @turnip - Could you upload this save game? Thanks. 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
9 hours ago, Christopher Lewis said:

Hey @turnip - Could you upload this save game? Thanks. 

Done. Save is Simon Phillips - Laval.fm

It's from Feb 3rd. I've got another save from 14th Jan if you'd prefer that one. Let me know.

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I won the cup with PSG, where beyond the starting eleven, I did two substitutions, then 13 players participated of the match. And were justly those 13 players that had the cup registered as title in their careers. Is this to work this way? Because in that kind of championship as supercups, all the players subscribed to the match should be awarded and not only who played.

20191222075354_1.thumb.jpg.96a80a6820ce8498088a63b707e2e1c6.jpg

The awarded players

20191222075409_1.thumb.jpg.f807da93c75caed0b1a15bc9cbb39e8c.jpg

Who was subscribed to play the match.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hora atrás, AlienIR disse:

Cheers @tiago_wakabayashi, indeed we should expect all subs to receive the honor. Could be a limitation, @Christopher Lewis , could you check if it is please?

Regards

I suspect that the problem would the "one played match" rule the FM is applying now to get a award. I say that because is what I see when I got a title and comes that award/medal screen explaining that only player that have already played one match at least was be able to get a medal. This could work for league and longer cups, but for supercups or any one single match tournament, it fails.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Yeah this could be the limitation indeed, which means that this won't be fixed for now. Anyway, worth checking and get a future improvement from it if it's the case.

 

Thanks for the report, always appreciated and helpful.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
51 minutes ago, tiago_wakabayashi said:

I suspect that the problem would the "one played match" rule the FM is applying now to get a award. I say that because is what I see when I got a title and comes that award/medal screen explaining that only player that have already played one match at least was be able to get a medal. This could work for league and longer cups, but for supercups or any one single match tournament, it fails.

I've logged this anyway just to see if we can get this changed to all players in the match squad getting the medal. Thanks guys. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hi, got an issue with second team of SM Caen.

As SM Caen 2 isn't included in National 2 championship, I manually have to organize friendly games, usually the day after the first team plays.

Here's the calendar :

nyVl14f.png

Now with a report of one of my player, using 'SM Caen 2' and 'All competitions' :

i4Dp0pK.png

You can cleary see a problem with Nordhausen or Real Pilar ...

And when I look more closely, I can choose 'National 3 - Normandie' in the competition list, and if I do so, I only see the games that do not show up in the calendar ...

SMa3GPP.png

What's going on ?

Thank you

I play on beta with no mods (only a skin)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hey,

Je viens de découvrir un problème dans le championnat français. Sur la saison 2025-2026, la période d'enregistrement des joueurs se termine avant la fin du mercato d'hiver : enregistrement jusqu'au 01/02/2026, mercato du 01/01/2026 au 02/02/2026. Quid des joueurs arrivant le dernier jour et ne pouvant pas être enregistré pour la Ligue 1.

I've just discovered a problem in the French championship. For the season 2025-2026, the registration period for players ends before the end of the winter mercato: registration until 01/02/2026, mercato from 01/01/2026 to 02/02/2026. Quid of players arriving on the last day and not being able to register for League 1.

image.thumb.png.dd0adf5226887c569f1a622eefd9ac3f.png

Thank you

Matt

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

ive noticed my monaco b team & under 19s have not got promoted even though they won both leagues & the under 19s won the playoff part too im pretty sure they should be getting promoted.
the only thing that shouldnt happen is my b team playing in the same division as my 1st team but it has not got that far yet
i have all french leagues playable too .....im in july now where the new fixtures have been announced so its perfect to check the season before on my save....ill leave a few pics below & also upload the save file to the cloud which is called                 Rob Evans - AS Monaco 2023.07.04.fm

Untitled.jpg

Untitled.jpg

Untitled.jpg

Untitled.jpg

Untitled.jpg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hi @robevz, seems logical to me.

your U19 squad is already in the highest league for U19 players.

The playoff you get was a little cup between the first 2 teams of each group to award the best U19 team for the year.

For your reserve squad, same, in France, the B team or Team 2, can’t get higher than the 4th level your currently in. You can see it in your screen, the team that get promoted wasn’t a B/2 team.

Hope I was clear.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
15 hours ago, CWaka said:

Hi @robevz, seems logical to me.

your U19 squad is already in the highest league for U19 players.

The playoff you get was a little cup between the first 2 teams of each group to award the best U19 team for the year.

For your reserve squad, same, in France, the B team or Team 2, can’t get higher than the 4th level your currently in. You can see it in your screen, the team that get promoted wasn’t a B/2 team.

Hope I was clear.

i dont know why that should be though..
i would have thought the under19s would get promoted to group c given they are in the bottom group of a 4 tier section & my   2nd team the same otherwise whats the point of having promotion & playpoff places thats a really bad rule it surely has to be a bug.
so technically only monaco are not allowed to get promoted?
its just the same as say teams in the english conference north/south leagues cant be promoted which is silly because otherwise salford would not be in league 2 ....   how comes ajax and psv have a b team directly below them but french 2nd teams cant move anywhere?

Edited by robevz

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I mean that's just the way it's working in France.

B team can't go any higher than the 4th level, that's it. Your screenshot confirm that, the first 3 teams were B team and it was the 4th one that get promoted.

For the U19, there isn't a pyramid between A, B, C and D. They're all the same. You're already in the highest level for U19 teams. But as there is a lot of team, they get split in 4 groups. After the group phase is over you have a playoff to award the best U19 team of the year.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 hours ago, CWaka said:

I mean that's just the way it's working in France.

B team can't go any higher than the 4th level, that's it. Your screenshot confirm that, the first 3 teams were B team and it was the 4th one that get promoted.

For the U19, there isn't a pyramid between A, B, C and D. They're all the same. You're already in the highest level for U19 teams. But as there is a lot of team, they get split in 4 groups. After the group phase is over you have a playoff to award the best U19 team of the year.

ahh right i got ya now..so its technically not a fight to go up its a fight to win the whole section meaning champion of all 4 groups no matter what group your in........thanks for that haha   i still think its a bit weird nobody gets promoted i wonder how the players in france feel knowing they cant go any higher  :p

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 16/12/2019 at 14:20, Christopher Lewis said:

Thanks @turnip - much appreciated. That save should be enough. 

Was this fixed at some point as I've just had this issue?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

×
×
  • Create New...