Jump to content

[England Premier Division] Data Issues


Recommended Posts

On Liverpool's 'long throws' attribute:

Just heard a podcast with their Danish throw in coach, Thomas Grønnemark.

He said that Andrew Robertson is very bad at long throws (although he obviously improved after being coached by Grønnemark), and that Joe Gomez is the best long thrower in Liverpool.

Current ratings of 13 for Robertson vs 14 for Joe Gomez seem out of place in this context. Based on the length of Gomez' throw (37.2m) compared to other players he mentioned, I'd suggest having Gomez of around 18.

No idea about Robertson but maybe make him the worst at Liverpool.

Here's a link to the podcast. It's an hour long and in Danish so not sure it'll help much, though :)

https://podcasts.apple.com/gh/podcast/troels-bech-i-en-samtale-med-indkasttræner-thomas-grønnemark/id1118913012?i=1000475048211

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • Replies 882
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

14 hours ago, Nørbæk said:

The 'Most overall goals by a player in a season' record is missing for Man CIty.

A large overhaul of records in the DB was carried out in April, but thanks.

Link to post
Share on other sites
11 hours ago, Sean Blinkhorn said:

A large overhaul of records in the DB was carried out in April, but thanks.

Awesome. Look forward to seeing the labour of the hard work :thup:

Link to post
Share on other sites
8 hours ago, Weston said:

I believe Philippe Sandler should also have US citizenship per this article. His US-eligibility is widely discussed.

And South African too, from the look of it! Cheers!

Link to post
Share on other sites

Lewis Freestone (Brighton) is missing some details from his history.

He had a loan with St Albans City from Peterborough in the 2016/17 season and he made 2 league appearances without scoring after joining on 10/03/2017: https://www.stalbanscityfc.com/lewis-freestone/

He is also missing a loan with Nuneaton Borough from Peterborough in the 2018/2019 season where he made 8 league appearances without scoring after joining on 07/08/2018: https://www.pitchero.com/clubs/nuneatonboroughfc/teams/98603/player/lewis-freestone-2052091/51726

Link to post
Share on other sites
Posted (edited)
On 22/05/2020 at 16:13, Nørbæk said:

On Liverpool's 'long throws' attribute:

Just heard a podcast with their Danish throw in coach, Thomas Grønnemark.

He said that Andrew Robertson is very bad at long throws (although he obviously improved after being coached by Grønnemark), and that Joe Gomez is the best long thrower in Liverpool.

Current ratings of 13 for Robertson vs 14 for Joe Gomez seem out of place in this context. Based on the length of Gomez' throw (37.2m) compared to other players he mentioned, I'd suggest having Gomez of around 18.

No idea about Robertson but maybe make him the worst at Liverpool.

Here's a link to the podcast. It's an hour long and in Danish so not sure it'll help much, though :)

https://podcasts.apple.com/gh/podcast/troels-bech-i-en-samtale-med-indkasttræner-thomas-grønnemark/id1118913012?i=1000475048211

"According to Gronnemark, Liverpool left back Andy Robertson has gone from a maximum throwing distance of 19 or 20 meters to 27 or 28, and this gives him many more options to escape pressure situations."

He's improved quite a lot though. I don't think he's our worst player in terms of throw ins at all. I agree that Gomez should have the highest rating in our team though.

 

From https://www.dw.com/en/the-throw-in-coach-how-one-man-wowed-jürgen-klopp-and-helped-change-the-game/a-52407577

Edited by OkMarius
Link to post
Share on other sites
On 07/06/2020 at 11:22, OkMarius said:

"According to Gronnemark, Liverpool left back Andy Robertson has gone from a maximum throwing distance of 19 or 20 meters to 27 or 28, and this gives him many more options to escape pressure situations."

He's improved quite a lot though. I don't think he's our worst player in terms of throw ins at all. I agree that Gomez should have the highest rating in our team though.

 

From https://www.dw.com/en/the-throw-in-coach-how-one-man-wowed-jürgen-klopp-and-helped-change-the-game/a-52407577

Agreed that Robertson improved (which I also wrote in my post). But so did all the others probably so relatively he should still be in the deep end of the squad :)

Link to post
Share on other sites
Posted (edited)

Heung Min-Son is severely underrated as a dribbler.

image.thumb.png.0728d63293ec3349d482801869ae4cd1.png

Of the fifteen 'wingers' in the Premier League top six - this is kind of subjective, but hey - Son completes the joint-third most dribbles, with the sixth best success rate. This shows that's he a pretty damn good dribbler by the standards of the top six wingers, certainly above average. The eye test will also tell you this. Son has a track record of excellent solo goals - most notably against Chelsea and Burnley - and will also frequently use his dribbling to open up space for shots in tight spaces.

And yet of the seven main attributes that influence dribbling, he's got the joint-lowest rating with Dan James. If you look purely at the technical (and mental) attributes, he's thirteenth. If you look purely at the physical attributes, he's joint-twelfth. His attributes don't reflect his real-life dribbling ability.

EDIT: As for what to change, I'd say all of those attributes could justifiably go up by a point, which would put Son on 108. Agility and pace could possibly both go up by two.

Son's player traits don't quite reflect his tendency to take players on with the ball at his feet. As Son's numbers show, he completes a high number of take-ons, and attempts even more. 'Runs With Ball Often' would probably suit him fairly well.

Son is also quite underrated as a goalscorer.

% of over/under-performance of xG since 14/15

Between the start of the 2014/15 season, and 1 April 2020, Son outperformed his xG by more than any other player in Europe's top five leagues. Let's look at his shooting-related attributes, compared to a few of those players, shall we?

image.thumb.png.bab4f8f45a8db1f4614ad7daa0ace55e.png

Of the eleven players in Europe with the highest xG over-performance, a list that Son leads - Son is again, joint-last. His finishing is joint-ninth, his technique is tenth, and his composure is tenth. The composure is particularly glaring - it was accurate two or three years ago, but Son is now a very composed forward with a good record in one-on-ones and in high-pressure games.

Now, you could argue that he outperforms those players because he's particularly elite at scoring from outside the box, rather than at converting chances inside the box. But his attributes don't reflect that, either - fifteen long shots is good, but not exceptional. Across England, France, Germany, Italy, and Spain, there's hundreds of players with at least 15 for long shots - 225 players, to be precise. 88 of those also have at least 15 technique. This means that among the players competing with Son for first place here, almost a hundred had equal or greater ability at shooting from distance. 

EDIT: As for what to change, Son's long shots should go up two or three points - he really is exceptional at shooting from outside the box - and his composure a couple of points. And as mentioned earlier, his technique could go up a point. His finishing is probably fine.

Son's traits are also odd here. He's known for shooting from range often, and yet he doesn't have the 'Shoots From Distance' trait. He makes runs in behind the opposition defence fairly frequently, which his trait 'Like Ball Played Into Feet' limits. I'm also not sure 'Shoots With Power' suits him: while he does shoot with power sometimes, he also likes placed shots across the keeper, and curled finishes from tight angles; and mechanically, his 10 strength means he's not good at doing so in-game.

Edited by Sophos
Link to post
Share on other sites

This post won't be as detailed as my Son post, but I'd like to suggest some changes to some other Spurs players.

Harry Kane

+ 'Tries Long Range Passes'

According to Whoscored, Kane 'plays the ball of the ground often' and 'likes to play long balls.' This video demonstrates him doing so.

Lucas Moura

+ Important Matches (8 -> 14)

Lucas has a really good track record in big games for Spurs - most notably a brace against Manchester United, a late goal in Barcelona to go through to the Champions League knockouts, and his famous hat-trick in Amsterdam. He also scored on his Spurs debut, and in his first game for Jose Mourinho. His 8 rating for Important Matches, then, seems much too low, and could stand to be significantly increased.

- Teamwork (15 -> 12)

Lucas plays with his head down a lot, often going on dribbles or opting for poor shots when there's teammates in better positions. It's been a source of a lot of frustration for Spurs fans this season. He's also got a really low assist return for a winger with Son and Kane to aim for. His teamwork should probably be brought down to reflect this.

+ 'Tries To Play Way Out Of Trouble'

This trait is really perfect for Lucas. Whoscored record that he 'Gets Fouled Often,' and that's in no small part because he always tries to escape pressure through his dribbling skill. 

Giovani Lo Celso

+ 'Runs With Ball Often'

Lo Celso has attempted 4.2 dribbles per 90 this season, which is really quite high for a player who's mostly played as a central midfielder. 

Tanguy Ndombele

+ 'Runs With Ball Often'

+ 'Tries To Play Way Out Of Trouble'

+ 'Tries Killer Balls Often'

This one should be fairly self-explanatory.

 

Link to post
Share on other sites
9 hours ago, Nørbæk said:

Agreed that Robertson improved (which I also wrong in my post). But so did all the others probably so relatively he should still be in the deep end of the squad :)

I doubt the entire team practised it as much as the fullbacks did though. No point in having Firmino work on his long throws.

Link to post
Share on other sites
39 minutes ago, OkMarius said:

I doubt the entire team practised it as much as the fullbacks did though. No point in having Firmino work on his long throws.

You're probably right.

Link to post
Share on other sites
On 08/06/2020 at 13:31, Sophos said:

EDIT: As for what to change, Son's long shots should go up two or three points - he really is exceptional at shooting from outside the box - and his composure a couple of points. And as mentioned earlier, his technique could go up a point. His finishing is probably fine.

EDIT: As for what to change, I'd say all of those attributes could justifiably go up by a point, which would put Son on 108. Agility and pace could possibly both go up by two.

Which of his attributes would you put down to allow this change?

Link to post
Share on other sites
17 hours ago, Dan Ormsby said:

Which of his attributes would you put down to allow this change?

There's no reason Son's Current Ability shouldn't be increased. It's only 160, which makes him the twenty-second best winger in the world - I included anyone with at least 18 at AML or AMR in my search. He's fourteen points behind Sterling, and nineteen behind Salah and Mane - now you could certainly argue that those three are better than him, but that gulf seems excessive. 

Bumping Son up to somewhere around 168-172 CA wouldn't even put him in the top ten wingers in the world, and would keep him behind his 'rivals' in the Premier League. But it would allow a more accurate representation of his excellent dribbling and goalscoring skills. 

image.thumb.png.f76c3ea4d29c89bb0824e95cc184abe7.png

These changes would put him on 172 CA. 

I don't particularly think any of his attributes are too high - perhaps a point off of his teamwork or vision? His set-piece attributes, maybe, as he rarely seems to take free kicks or corners?

Link to post
Share on other sites
16 minutes ago, Sophos said:

There's no reason Son's Current Ability shouldn't be increased.

image.thumb.png.f76c3ea4d29c89bb0824e95cc184abe7.png

 

I'm saying this not as an Arsenal fan - I'd be saying this were you describing a player from any team, even (or perhaps especially!) Arsenal - I'm saying this as a researcher and an employee of SI - I don't think you can be realistically expecting the Spurs researcher to be raising Son's CA by 10-12 points if he's previously deemed him to be at the level he's at as recently as our last data deadline in February, when there's only been a handful of games since then.  Fine to have an opinion and you've been very detailed in your reasoning, but in general we need to be assuming that a player's CA is a player's CA and any attributes raised will need others to be lowered.

Just looking at your suggestions, you're asking for pretty incremental changes anyway, apart from an increase to 18 for long shots, which I don't think is realistic or justified.  I don't think Son is unfairly rated in game and think the Spurs researcher has done a good job.  This is, after all, a bugs forum, for glaring errors in attributes and actual data errors.  There aren't any present here.

I'm sure the Spurs researcher will take your feedback into account when reviewing his squad ahead of next season, but I don't think you should be expecting much change.

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 3 weeks later...
On 04/11/2019 at 15:27, swansongs said:

Premier League teams? Don't think so to be honest. Wouldn't be a regular for a lot of Championship teams, either, based on what I've seen.

;)

Link to post
Share on other sites

I think this is more a data issue than anything else - Bramley-Moore Dock Stadium was built in 2023 in my game but Everton never moved in (I'm currently in 2030). Save uploaded to 1355149 - Hansa Rostock.fm if you need it

Link to post
Share on other sites

One for FM21 - Bruno Fernandes' penalty stat. It's currently set to 14, I think this should be closer to 18/19. He's scored 24 from 26 in competitive games since 2012/13, all bar one came from 2015 onwards. He's the best penalty taker at the club and only Milner, Noble and Milivojević spring to mind as having a similar consistency in the Premier League. Milivojević has 21 from 24 and is rated 17, Milner is also a 17 with 30 from 35 and Mark Noble is an 18 with 38 from 42.    

Link to post
Share on other sites

Is solidarity mechanism counted as a transfer fee? 

Because if so, Manchester United payed 400 000 euros for Łukasz Bejger (when he moved from Lech Poznan).

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 2 weeks later...
On 12/06/2020 at 12:24, Sophos said:

There's no reason Son's Current Ability shouldn't be increased. It's only 160, which makes him the twenty-second best winger in the world - I included anyone with at least 18 at AML or AMR in my search. He's fourteen points behind Sterling, and nineteen behind Salah and Mane - now you could certainly argue that those three are better than him, but that gulf seems excessive. 

Bumping Son up to somewhere around 168-172 CA wouldn't even put him in the top ten wingers in the world, and would keep him behind his 'rivals' in the Premier League. But it would allow a more accurate representation of his excellent dribbling and goalscoring skills. 

image.thumb.png.f76c3ea4d29c89bb0824e95cc184abe7.png

These changes would put him on 172 CA. 

I don't particularly think any of his attributes are too high - perhaps a point off of his teamwork or vision? His set-piece attributes, maybe, as he rarely seems to take free kicks or corners?

Personally, I agree with your logic on all of the above, but bearing in mind @Dan Ormsby's response, I'd say his balance and composure need to be changed the most, with the balance being the more important of the two. I'd also on the flip side argue that Son should have his dribbling/acceleration higher than his pace, because he seems to focus more on that. 

Link to post
Share on other sites
On 06/08/2020 at 10:42, Moondog777 said:

possible to add Susana Ferreras to the Arsenal staff? regarded as top data scientist.

 

https://www.nacsport.com/blog/en-us/News/7-women-blazing-the-trail-for-aspiring-female-analysts-and-performing-at-the-highest-level

This article is over a year old and mentions she was part of Unai Emery's backroom team.  Do you have any evidence she remained at the club and is still there now, even after Emery left?  Will definitely add in if so.  Thanks.

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 2 weeks later...

Not a data issue as such, but I'd suggest deleting 'Pongo' from Tom Waring's name in the most overall goals by a player in a season and most league goals by a player in a season.

We usually don't use such nicknames.

image.thumb.png.43dcf879230299aba10e60f19699a031.png

Link to post
Share on other sites

It seems the 'most overall goals by a player in season' club record has been overlooked.

I've only checked the Premier League so it's likely also an issue in the other divisions.

AFAIK, English football is so well documented so they should be quite easy to find among the clubs' great goalscorers.

Missing club records:

Bournemouth: Most overall goals by a player in a season and most league goals by a player in a season
Brighton: Most overall goals by a player in a season
Burnley: Most overall goals by a player in a season
Chelsea: Most overall goals by a player in a season
Crystal Palace: Most overall goals by a player in a season
Everton: Most overall goals by a player in a season
Man City: Most overall goals by a player in a season (based on Matthew Blinkhorn's post earlier, this has now been added)
Newcastle United: Most overall goals by a player in a season
Norwich CIty: Most overall goals by a player in a season
Sheffield United: Most overall goals by a player in a season
Southampton: Most overall goals by a player in a season
West Ham: Most overall goals by a player in a season
Wolves: Most overall goals by a player in a season
 

Link to post
Share on other sites
20 hours ago, Nørbæk said:

(based on Matthew Blinkhorn's post earlier, this has now been added)

Matthew plays for Lancaster City. No relation - strangely enough!

Link to post
Share on other sites

@diddydaddydoddy

Joe Gomez' is one of our most determined players in the game. I don't think that reflects reality. We have some types who succeed partly through sheer grit (Milner and Hendo comes to mind, Robbo is another), but Gomez rather is just quietly very professional, and does everything by the book. The perfect schoolboy. He's not the iron willed warrior, with nerves of steel and an extreme will to win - he's just a professional footballer doing his job as best as he can because he doesn't know any other way.

Also, like I've previously mentioned, he's done nothing to warrant his high rating in "heading". He's never scored a headed goal in his career.

Suggestion: Lower his determination to 13-14. Lower his heading by several points.

Link to post
Share on other sites
13 hours ago, Nørbæk said:

Might have been covered already, but it seems Mix Diskerus is missing a loan ticker in his 2019 Ulsan history entry, @Sean Blinkhorn

image.thumb.png.88a1901d8d41bd7c1c4fd13ec22ad4da.png

I must have caught that one before sending him off to Sweden, as it's there now. Thanks Nørbæk.

Link to post
Share on other sites
34 minutes ago, _mxrky said:

Anyone going to talk about how ridiculously overrated Bernardo silva is on fm?

Not really, because this is a platform for you to outline what specific, individual, elements are incorrect and why.

The relevant researcher is completely free to ignore your opinion on something subjective like attributes so the onus is very much on you to make a compelling case. 

---

That being said, FM20 is outdated from a research perspective. By its very nature by the time you get your hands on patch its a bit of time on from the research team having set the stats and so the player may not even be set up in the same way as you last saw.

Link to post
Share on other sites
On 04/09/2020 at 11:00, lbowman6 said:

Michael Thomas now has a role in the Liverpool academy.

 

Good to see Michael Thomas still schooling Liverpool over 30 years on ;) 

Link to post
Share on other sites
On 10/08/2020 at 11:23, Dan Ormsby said:

This article is over a year old and mentions she was part of Unai Emery's backroom team.  Do you have any evidence she remained at the club and is still there now, even after Emery left?  Will definitely add in if so.  Thanks.

Her twitter and LinkedIn both have Arsenal listed as her current employer

https://uk.linkedin.com/in/susana-ferreras-56683b4b
https://twitter.com/susanaferreras?s=21

Link to post
Share on other sites
On 09/04/2020 at 10:36, diddydaddydoddy said:

1. They are not stats (statistics) which are factual pieces of data

2. They are attributes that the Spurs researcher has determined to be accurate at the time of the previous datalock

3. Attributes are all about opinion and you have not backed any of your opinions up with reasoning

4. You have not read the first post in the thread that details how to put your difference of opinion across in a constructive way 

Is it all about opinion or is it not? I still say that Son is extremely underrated in game, and that is a fact given his status and stats in real life. I also think players like Liverpool's Henderson and Robertson are too good. It's an opinion of the researcher that Henderson has a silky touch, but I don't know anyone who believes that to be true. 

Edited by V3ntricity
Link to post
Share on other sites
3 hours ago, V3ntricity said:

Is it all about opinion or is it not? I still say that Son is extremely underrated in game, and that is a fact given his status and stats in real life. I also think players like Liverpool's Henderson and Robertson are too good. It's an opinion of the researcher that Henderson has a silky touch, but I don't know anyone who believes that to be true. 

This forum is not for sharing of opinions. It's for database errors.

It can also be a database error that a player is rated wrongly, but as someone already made a judgement of that player and his abilities, if you want to be taken note of, you'll have to try to persuade that person with actual arguments.

Link to post
Share on other sites
9 hours ago, Kanwulf said:

Her twitter and LinkedIn both have Arsenal listed as her current employer

https://uk.linkedin.com/in/susana-ferreras-56683b4b
https://twitter.com/susanaferreras?s=21

Thanks, I have this noted down to get her added to the DB.  Just need to make fully sure her exact role at the club is one that we cater for in FM.  

Link to post
Share on other sites
On 06/09/2020 at 17:32, _mxrky said:

Anyone going to talk about how ridiculously overrated Bernardo silva is on fm?

Bit vague. He didn't have a great season but is this to suggest he is not a world class talent?

Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

×
×
  • Create New...