Jump to content
Sports Interactive Community
Y2Jones

Developing my First Tactic- An Identity Crisis, a 4-1-4-1 and my process to create a successful tactic for the first time

Recommended Posts

Posted (edited)

Pure quality. Amazing post. 

Edited by Gegenklaus

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Welcome to the forum, a great first post. Also great to see someone take elements from all the threads that myself and others use and adapt them into their own ideas and saves. It's rare that we see posts like this.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
3 hours ago, Y2Jones said:

Inspired by articles and threads, and really wanting to improve my understanding and skill at the game, I made the decision to stick to only making my own tactics and if they fail, they fail.

Probably the best thing I've read in a long time.

Great first post :thup:.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

We need more topics like these. Great read and very informative.

Would also love to see a post about the things that went wrong, how you spotted it and how you fixed it.

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This has to be the best post I’ve read for a long time. What I like is how you new how you wanted to play, stripped it back and started again. You took the time to read some very good posts to help implement your ideas instead of being on here asking questions. In my opinion,you’ve done what I think everyone should do who’s quite new to the game and that’s watch matches to see where issues lay. You made in game changes to your tactic which shows that you can’t just plug and play a tactic anymore. By detailing your dilemmas etc.. I really hope that a lot of people read your post and take everything onboard what you’ve done, I’m a believer that the only way you’re going to learn is to work it out and resolve issues yourself, that’s what you’ve done and I admire that.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Great post, logic and results!

IMO nothing beats the versatility of the 4-1-4-1. Looking forward to your future post on the players you brought in to build your squad.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
21 hours ago, Rashidi said:

Nice opening thread for someone's first post. Welcome to the forums.

Thanks very much! I'm glad I finally got involved in the community after all these years!

21 hours ago, Gegenklaus said:

Pure quality. Amazing post. 

Big thank you brother!

21 hours ago, Cleon said:

Welcome to the forum, a great first post. Also great to see someone take elements from all the threads that myself and others use and adapt them into their own ideas and saves. It's rare that we see posts like this.

Thank you for the welcome and response to the post. I also appreciated the tweet you sent with my post linked, really inspired me to continue to write more in the future! It felt logical to take elements from different sources and I'm glad I was able to articulate that well. Thanks again! 

21 hours ago, ianscousemac said:

Very good post.  I'll certainly take some of that onboard.

Thank you very much my friend! I'm happy to hear that.

18 hours ago, herne79 said:

Probably the best thing I've read in a long time.

Great first post :thup:.

Thanks a lot man, really appreciate it! I'm glad I was able to receive such good feedback after just one post. Happy to see you enjoyed and can't wait to continue posting!

18 hours ago, Miek said:

We need more topics like these. Great read and very informative.

Would also love to see a post about the things that went wrong, how you spotted it and how you fixed it.

 

Cheers man, glad you enjoyed. That's definitely something I thought about including originally and I would be more than happy to write up about those things that went wrong and my solutions. Thanks again!

17 hours ago, Robson 07 said:

Welcome to the forum.

Happy to finally get involved in the community!

7 hours ago, luton said:

This has to be the best post I’ve read for a long time. What I like is how you new how you wanted to play, stripped it back and started again. You took the time to read some very good posts to help implement your ideas instead of being on here asking questions. In my opinion,you’ve done what I think everyone should do who’s quite new to the game and that’s watch matches to see where issues lay. You made in game changes to your tactic which shows that you can’t just plug and play a tactic anymore. By detailing your dilemmas etc.. I really hope that a lot of people read your post and take everything onboard what you’ve done, I’m a believer that the only way you’re going to learn is to work it out and resolve issues yourself, that’s what you’ve done and I admire that.

Thank you for your excellent feedback, it really does mean a lot and inspires me to continue! That was one of my main intentions with this post, documenting how I managed to finally find accomplishment, in the hope that other people who might be in similar situations could take onboard things that might work for them. Thank you once again! 

3 hours ago, nugatti said:

Great post, logic and results!

IMO nothing beats the versatility of the 4-1-4-1. Looking forward to your future post on the players you brought in to build your squad.

Thanks man! I definitely agree, the formation allows so much versatility and dynamics in how a side can play, and can easily be played many different ways, even within the same match. I'm happy you enjoyed and that you are looking forward to future posts!

 

 

Hugely inspired from the great feedback I've received so far, it's been really surprising for me to see such great comments! I can't wait to continue posting and becoming more engaged with the community and continue to learn and improve, both in regards to the game and crafting threads and posts. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

First of all: Welcome to the forum!

Thanks for sharing your thoughts. It's a good example how a user can "learn" the tactical side of FM. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Amazing and great work. 

From my understanding, using Much Higher Line of Engagement with Higher Defensive Line will nullify the compact shape to effectively close down quickly. Just my thoughts. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 12/03/2019 at 18:31, Y2Jones said:

know it's a long one and I may of bored a lot

Not at all. Excellent post

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Welcome to the (active) community!

I was kinda like you back in the day, never wanting to post and just reading, but once I did it I enjoyed it a lot so I think you definitely did the best you could. Be sure you'll have tons of fun engaging in conversation with the gents around here and it will allow you also to learn much more.

One thing you constantly repeat through your text explaining your approach is that you still feel that this tactic is not yours, that it is just a combination of other tactics, etc etc... Don't sell yourself so low man! How many real life managers build stuff off their brains without taking ideas from here and there, let alone FM players?

You definitely spent the proper time learning the game as real managers spent it learning the history of football and where this and that system work and don't, then applied what you considered right for your team and players. Don't think it can get any better, and the way you put it all together in the post, along with the use of images was superb, believe me.

No wonder you inspired me getting back to the game after a few months of hiatus. Hope to keep reading you around!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
22 hours ago, Y2Jones said:

Hugely inspired from the great feedback I've received so far, it's been really surprising for me to see such great comments! I can't wait to continue posting and becoming more engaged with the community and continue to learn and improve, both in regards to the game and crafting threads and posts. 

Looking forward to it :thup:.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

@Y2Jones a wonderful collection of useful information and a truly inspiring approach to the game, especially that you managed to make it about the players, which is something that I seem to completely avoid - I guess for the reason of not wanting to depend on them, but it definitely made me think about the issues my approach.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 14/03/2019 at 04:26, jyn1989 said:

Amazing and great work. 

From my understanding, using Much Higher Line of Engagement with Higher Defensive Line will nullify the compact shape to effectively close down quickly. Just my thoughts. 

He also writes that he changes around the line of engagement :)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
5 hours ago, Luizinho said:

@Y2Jones Do you change the system if Bongiovanni is unavailable? If so, then how?

Currently crafting a post about my squad and how it informed my tactic, and this is apart of that. Short answer yes, but it would depend on who we were up against and who we had available to play. I’ll go into much more detail when it comes to my next post which will cover it!

On 14/03/2019 at 21:30, robot_skeleton said:

@Y2Jones a wonderful collection of useful information and a truly inspiring approach to the game, especially that you managed to make it about the players, which is something that I seem to completely avoid - I guess for the reason of not wanting to depend on them, but it definitely made me think about the issues my approach.

Thank you very much!👍🏻

On 14/03/2019 at 10:21, okereke said:

Welcome to the (active) community!

I was kinda like you back in the day, never wanting to post and just reading, but once I did it I enjoyed it a lot so I think you definitely did the best you could. Be sure you'll have tons of fun engaging in conversation with the gents around here and it will allow you also to learn much more.

One thing you constantly repeat through your text explaining your approach is that you still feel that this tactic is not yours, that it is just a combination of other tactics, etc etc... Don't sell yourself so low man! How many real life managers build stuff off their brains without taking ideas from here and there, let alone FM players?

You definitely spent the proper time learning the game as real managers spent it learning the history of football and where this and that system work and don't, then applied what you considered right for your team and players. Don't think it can get any better, and the way you put it all together in the post, along with the use of images was superb, believe me.

No wonder you inspired me getting back to the game after a few months of hiatus. Hope to keep reading you around!

Wow, thank you man! I’m glad I was able to do that.

 

On 13/03/2019 at 20:35, 53bast1an said:

First of all: Welcome to the forum!

Thanks for sharing your thoughts. It's a good example how a user can "learn" the tactical side of FM. 

Thank you man!

On 14/03/2019 at 03:26, jyn1989 said:

Amazing and great work. 

From my understanding, using Much Higher Line of Engagement with Higher Defensive Line will nullify the compact shape to effectively close down quickly. Just my thoughts. 

Thanks brother! Our press usually becomes situational depending on in game circumstances, but always begins high. I can definitely see a big risk in maintaining those TIs for 90 minutes.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 When I read the OP's post I was actually very happy, cos he is one of the few people I have heard off on the forum who treats pressing situationally. I believe that the secret to this game actually lies in how you manage your own defensive shape while retaining your attacking flair. There's something I want to add, people have asked me frequently about the need to sit back and defend deep. To be fair, the only real thing you should be worried about is whether your defenders are capable of sitting back. That does require them to be good at winning those balls dangerously close to goal. They have to deal with every cross. So when I am an underdog, I hate sit back soak strategies. I prefer taking the game to them, trying to dominate the game and keeping it away from them, and being high enough on the pitch so that when the opposition lose the ball in transition we are actually in a position to attack them.

Now just looking at your system, what you can do is spend some time thinking about how Team Mentality affects the 6 factors in the game.  Evaluate your players and your own weak spots. Then go look at your defensive line/LOE split.  Then think of how you can manage games effectively by using all the tools at your disposal. There is a lot possible in the game.

For one thing, prevent short gk distribution, have you seen which players in your team get affected by it? Do you really need it?  Play close attention to when the opposition keeper tries to play the ball from a goal kick, and you will hopefully see what I mean.

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 12/03/2019 at 18:31, Y2Jones said:

I made the decision to stick to only making my own tactics and if they fail, they fail.

Farewell Plug and Play!

@Y2Jones this is such an admirable approach, one I've tried to apply myself recently. Applying aspects of others approaches is also something I've done for years, there's nothing wrong with taking ideas from those much more tactically aware than ourselves.

As Bruce Lee said, 'adapt what is useful, reject what is useless, and add what is specifically your own'

Once again, great post, enjoyable read, and looking forward to future updates :applause:

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Posted (edited)

What if like me, you are hopeless tactically?

I'll admit, despite being a football fan all my life, I have only ever watched it for entertainment purposes. So I'm absolutely useless with tactics, I find it hard to spot things. Is there hope that I can learn as I go? This thread gives me hope! :D

Edited by Gee_Simpson

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, Rashidi said:

When I read the OP's post I was actually very happy, cos he is one of the few people I have heard off on the forum who treats pressing situationally. I believe that the secret to this game actually lies in how you manage your own defensive shape while retaining your attacking flair.

I've thought this for a long while, always made sense to me in real football but was always difficult to implement in previous FM's. I think the new line of engagement has really allowed situational pressing to be accomplished and I'm glad I was able to use it effectively. Also glad to make you very happy haha!:lol: 

Also thank you for the advice, definitely now understand what you are telling me. 

12 minutes ago, TheresOnlyTwoFilipSebos said:

Farewell Plug and Play!

@Y2Jones this is such an admirable approach, one I've tried to apply myself recently. Applying aspects of others approaches is also something I've done for years, there's nothing wrong with taking ideas from those much more tactically aware than ourselves.

As Bruce Lee said, 'adapt what is useful, reject what is useless, and add what is specifically your own'

Once again, great post, enjoyable read, and looking forward to future updates :applause:

 

Great quote! Thank you man, can't wait to continue.

9 minutes ago, Gee_Simpson said:

What if like me, you are hopeless tactically?

I'll admit, despite being a football fan all my life, I have only ever watched it for entertainment purposes. So I'm absolutely useless with tactics, I find it hard to spot things. Is there hope that I can learn as I go? This thread gives me hope! :D

That's amazing to hear:D, thank you very much my friend.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
5 minutes ago, Gee_Simpson said:

So what I'm asking is, is it possible to learn as you go? Can you teach yourself how to start identifying problems without being tactically astute? @Cleon @Rashidi @Y2Jones

Yes the creating a tactic series I've been doing is exactly about this topic

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
5 minutes ago, Cleon said:

Yes the creating a tactic series I've been doing is exactly about this topic

Thanks.

I've only skimmed over it so far. I will read it in depth later tonight :thup:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
7 hours ago, Cleon said:

Yes the creating a tactic series I've been doing is exactly about this topic

That is a very interesting question. I actually had time to help someone who had never played a football game and never watched a football game understand this game using chess. 

You don’t need to be tactically astute, you just need to understand that ultimately it’s how one formation controls space. Then it’s only a question about how well you control it and what you do about the spaces you don’t control.

Over the course of many years this forum has become a treasure trove of information. There are plenty of well written guides. It’s usually the same stuff, rehashed. I wrote a KISS guide a few years back, it’s still relevant. Having a bench strategy is also good. You don’t need to be tactically astute. In fact some people who are usually end up struggling cos they want to translate the depth of their knowledge without understanding the game itself.

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
5 hours ago, Rashidi said:

In fact some people who are usually end up struggling cos they want to translate the depth of their knowledge without understanding the game itself.

This is so like myself... :lol: Approaching it like real life instead of a video game. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
17 hours ago, Gee_Simpson said:

What if like me, you are hopeless tactically?

I'll admit, despite being a football fan all my life, I have only ever watched it for entertainment purposes. So I'm absolutely useless with tactics, I find it hard to spot things. Is there hope that I can learn as I go? This thread gives me hope! :D

What helped me a lot approaching this same problem are these new tactical presets introduced in FM 19. Before it I had no idea where to start, because there are so much team instructions, and I also had no idea what works with what best. Now when you choose certain tactical preset, you get team instructions with it already active. Which is great because it at least gives you a starting point, then you can observe match, try turning something on or off and see how it affects overall action on the pitch.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Posted (edited)
5 hours ago, Santa Claus said:

What helped me a lot approaching this same problem are these new tactical presets introduced in FM 19. Before it I had no idea where to start, because there are so much team instructions, and I also had no idea what works with what best. Now when you choose certain tactical preset, you get team instructions with it already active. Which is great because it at least gives you a starting point, then you can observe match, try turning something on or off and see how it affects overall action on the pitch.

Yeah that's good advice mate. I was excited when I heard that FM19 had tactical presets, it was one of the reasons why I bought it this year. Then though I develop this complex, that if I use the presets then I'm taking the easy route and copying things. I feel like then it wouldn't be my own tactic that has got me positive results, lol. 

Edited by Gee_Simpson

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 minutes ago, Gee_Simpson said:

Yeah that's good advice mate. I was excited when I heard that FM19 had tactical presets, it was one of the reasons why I bought it this year. Then though I develop this complex, that if I use the presets then I'm taking the easy route and copying things. I feel like then it wouldn't be my own tactic that has got me positive results, lol. 

I felt the same way, trust me. Because in previous FMs, when inevitably my tactic fails, I'd try downloaded plug-and-play one, which worked, but didn't bring me as near much enjoyment as when I made one myself. But this is different, really. No preset works perfectly, nothing is "carved-in-stone" so to speak. You need to adapt it based on players you have, strengths of your team, and opponent you are facing. Pick one style, load it, see what's happening. Take note of, for eg, how you lose possession - did your player lost the ball because his role tells him to dribble more? Or maybe he took a shot from distance? Maybe he didn't have viable option to pass to? Observe why his teammates weren't an option for pass - was their movement a problem or maybe simply their role and duty tells them to occupy different position on the pitch? Maybe passing range TI is problem - you have it set as short but there is no one near to receive the ball. Watch closely all those things, start a test save with random club, just to get feel for things. And remember, nothing works instantly, if you are feeling you are playing well and that system is good and it makes sense, stick with it, let players get used to it, results will come eventually. Best of luck :thup:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
3 hours ago, Santa Claus said:

I felt the same way, trust me. Because in previous FMs, when inevitably my tactic fails, I'd try downloaded plug-and-play one, which worked, but didn't bring me as near much enjoyment as when I made one myself. But this is different, really. No preset works perfectly, nothing is "carved-in-stone" so to speak. You need to adapt it based on players you have, strengths of your team, and opponent you are facing. Pick one style, load it, see what's happening. Take note of, for eg, how you lose possession - did your player lost the ball because his role tells him to dribble more? Or maybe he took a shot from distance? Maybe he didn't have viable option to pass to? Observe why his teammates weren't an option for pass - was their movement a problem or maybe simply their role and duty tells them to occupy different position on the pitch? Maybe passing range TI is problem - you have it set as short but there is no one near to receive the ball. Watch closely all those things, start a test save with random club, just to get feel for things. And remember, nothing works instantly, if you are feeling you are playing well and that system is good and it makes sense, stick with it, let players get used to it, results will come eventually. Best of luck :thup:

Yeah I suppose so, none of those presets exploit the match engine either. Thanks for the advice mate, hopefully I can get something working :)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
7 hours ago, Y2Jones said:

I have started the squad building post but work at Uni is piling up so that has to take priority

Ahh those days when I was still new to the game and I also thought FM was a secondary priority :kriss:.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
19 hours ago, herne79 said:

Ahh those days when I was still new to the game and I also thought FM was a secondary priority :kriss:.

Don't know if I should be excited or terrified for the future then :lol:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

×
×
  • Create New...