Jump to content
Sports Interactive Community
knap

FM 19 Wulf 41311 442 PF Pilgrimage 451,4141 442 and Flat 451 Knap

Recommended Posts

thanks for the quick reply. i let a staff member who has the highest motivating attribute. now it's the AM who has 14 motivating attribute

DOF = Director of football?

https://mega.nz/#!wpwV2KrA!bdunhiGzmMsdWhlP4A0wHqMqMEhPkg1TsUYKUeWHVA8 here you can download the save

i don't think it's the tactic because in a different save  with a different tactic i managed to get promoted  in the first season i had the same second season syndrome.

thanks

Edited by DOP

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I would rank Hendon about 14 th in VS so it will be a struggle to do well in the National league.

I will have a good look later.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, knap said:

I would rank Hendon about 14 th in VS so it will be a struggle to do well in the National league.

I will have a good look later.

thanks

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Squad quality appears to be the problem, out of interest Are you using scouting packages?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
9 hours ago, knap said:

Squad quality appears to be the problem, out of interest Are you using scouting packages?

yes, not the youth one package.

any tips on signing quality players after promotion with the scouts i have?

 

thanks

Edited by DOP

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Do you use trials and check players when less than 6mths left on contracts., but this needs to be carried out early. I did a scout package for 1  and found 1 decent player. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

no, i don't use trials, i use scout reports and the  "playing time" they want when offering them a contract. first team/key players are the ones i sign but unfortunately i cant seem to find them so i sign young players that were released from clubs in higher division who are "hot prospects" .

those hot prospects earned me a promotion to Vanarama premier but now it doesn't work. i tried reloading and signing new hot prospects but it didn't work.

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

rials are a very quick way to scout - just invite as many released players as possible for a trial and pick the best .

Scouting early for Hot prospectsshould work but they need to be good enough for the next level as always looking for promotion/

There is a lot of wage budget left so there is a chance to pick up better players during the season.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

sIf you look at GS you can see how far behind the squad is compared to other National sides. If you look at squad and best players they are at South level. The squad needs a lot of improving.

281301250_Screenshot(2402).thumb.png.d60d6dd5bc349cfa8ce1ad41a1332f45.png677708064_Screenshot(2405).thumb.png.5a4531021624852f3bcefa16781d70a6.png2089857838_Screenshot(2404).thumb.png.c8fbf23eacbb91c7bdcd7511ce77044f.png

722662873_Screenshot(2403).thumb.png.7671834ca3dddf9520d4b2a5fb35c881.png

Edited by knap

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Okay, i have a save point the day i won the south league. I'll revert to it and start offering trials to releases players.

 

I'll report back

 

Thanks

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Try and scout players with less tan 3 mths left and with a low wage to fit budget,

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Do you have screenshots of results and player ratings using the tactic? And who would you recommend to take corners?

Thanks!!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Should be some a few pages back as an old tactic that did well in independent tests

I don't allocate (specify a player) corner takers and the game still allocates rather than use nominated. Taker(position) is set up in routine.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

@knap firstly, thanks a lot for your work on these tactics. Each revision of FM I start by trying to create my own tactics and fail. I always use your tactics and start to enjoy the game again!

If I can make one suggestion, it would be this:

Do you think you could develop a clearer naming scheme for the tactics? There are so many revisions its very confusing and hard to find the correct version. Especially when sometimes you load them in the game and they have a different name from the file.

I like the fact some tactics have a name such as Pilgrimage, but its confusing to have different formations with the same naming scheme.

Just some feedback to take or leave, I think your work on these tactics is great and I really appreciate it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The naming system was developed mostly around the old tactic systems of fluid/ flexible and most of the tactics this year were translation from old to new.

If I buy FM 20, FM 19 has been very disappointing, then it would probably be a new naming system

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hi again

The only picture I can find where the 4-1-4-1 tactic is updated is this one. Its from the !!!!!FM19.3.4PILGRIMAGE4141KnapP105EC.fmf tactic. Do you think the P109FA tactic will do a better or at least similar job?? The player ratings are extremely satisfying from following pic: 

knap 4-1-4-1.png

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

My preference is for 4141 is ALL CUPS NO LOSS P106 winning PL with Newcastle or 4132 P112 ALL CIPS NO LOSS winning PL with Wolves.

The P109FA was very good in testing with SUB MID and best Sub Mid Away tactic, the P107 EC is not far behind and the WULF 4141 also works well..

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hi knap. sorry for disturb you. can you help me... i need a tatic for Benfica. i wanted a tactic where João Felix be great. with wingers. and DPL in the defensive midfield. witch of your tactic should be the best?? sorry for bother you

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I don't really bother with roles, compared to how a tactic performs. However, with those roles there is the 4141 P106 ALL CUPS NO LOSS and the(p103) p106 442, but I would not discount the 4132 P112 ALL CUPS NO LOSS

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 12/09/2019 at 00:56, knap said:

I don't really bother with roles, compared to how a tactic performs. However, with those roles there is the 4141 P106 ALL CUPS NO LOSS and the(p103) p106 442, but I would not discount the 4132 P112 ALL CUPS NO LOSS

hello knap, you have a 451 with poacher ? please for 19.3.5 ?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

General FM 19 problem and a PF tends to be a more defensive.. It is not the optimum tested option and will change the tactic structure so It may or may not work.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Knap, the one and only FM tactical legend! I have ordered a new laptop so will be getting FM20 when it comes out and getting on FM after about a 5 year absence! First thing I will be doing is looking out for your excellent plug and play tactics 😉

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I used the tactic !!!!!!!!!19.3.5WULF442PFPWMKnapP110ECCC for 3 months and I only have one thing to say: congratulations!

I saw mediocre teams winning everything in different countries and divisions during this period.

i will test !!!!!!!!!!!19.3.5PILGRIMAGEKnapCD4141P106ALLCUPSNOLOSS by now...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Second season with Huesca

After the great first season we were able to win everything in our second season.

The first season I used the PILMARGE4141 only and the season season I used at home the BEOWULF442P110 and away the PILMARGE4141.

I think this combination is the strongest in FM19. Look at my transfers, I was able to get some loans and some career-ending players :)

Will update you guys here how it's going in my third season :)

20190918174213_1.thumb.jpg.1dcc2a4673b393a40dca60b33bc0b449.jpg20190918174625_1.thumb.jpg.11d450abc43b063d170b3ad96ac5c31d.jpg20190918174610_1.thumb.jpg.3b8c6d615a86cb6604a790ee0e50fa95.jpg20190918174615_1.thumb.jpg.a60ef2a484ab11681b771dc4568c0573.jpg20190918174618_1.thumb.jpg.cdd8817cbfdb75942077dcd02290bb26.jpg

Edited by solounamigo

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
5 horas atrás, solounamigo disse:

Second season with Huesca

After the great first season we were able to win everything in our second season.

The first season I used the PILMARGE4141 only and the season season I used at home the BEOWULF442109 and away the PILMARGE4141.

I think this combination is the strongest in FM19. Look at my transfers, I was able to get some loans and some career-ending players :)

Will update you guys here how it's going in my third season :)

link please there are 3 109

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
В 18.09.2019 в 01:37, vitorkessler сказал:

I used the tactic !!!!!!!!!19.3.5WULF442PFPWMKnapP110ECCC for 3 months and I only have one thing to say: congratulations!

I saw mediocre teams winning everything in different countries and divisions during this period.

i will test !!!!!!!!!!!19.3.5PILGRIMAGEKnapCD4141P106ALLCUPSNOLOSS by now...

 !!!!!!!!!19.3.5WULF442PFPWMKnapP110ECCC Link please

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
7 hours ago, solounamigo said:

Sorry I'm using the 110 and not the 109.

Home this !!!!!!!!!19.3.5WULF442PFPWMKnapP110ECCC.fmf

Away this !!!!!!!!!!!19.3.5PILGRIMAGEKnapCD4141P106ALLCUPSNOLOSS.fmf

That's an amazing combination for me. I'm in my third season with Huesca and I'm never spending huge cash.

 

20190919111631_1.thumb.jpg.c8e38029f863a33b32c7dea62fb9d42c.jpg20190919111624_1.thumb.jpg.65d01bb9e38985376856b3f2db939761.jpg20190919111603_1.thumb.jpg.08f712ea064a6c161aa758ef3955d63e.jpg

Do you use the 442 for every home game and 4141 for every away game? Just wondering if it changes depending on the opposition?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
vor 16 Stunden schrieb Sith Lord:

Do you use the 442 for every home game and 4141 for every away game? Just wondering if it changes depending on the opposition?

Exactly, I don't care for the opposition. Of course if the match doesn't go so well I'm switching sometimes to get something new in that match.

 

I finished my third season with Huesca (could not repeat that CL win this time)

What I've recognized in this years FM is that the away matches are letting me struggle often. I you've got a look at my results this season or the seasons before you will see that it's nearly unbeatable at home.

I only had a draw vs Valencia and a defeat vs Paris (we dominated both matches extremly).

Away we lost 7(!) matches and had  two draws. I nearly lost every CL away match in the final rounds.

 

@knap As I can see you tested many of your tactics with the Wolves.

What is your experience in this case? I would like to know, if it should be better to use the 4141 or the 4132 or any other tactic as an away solution?

20190920114523_1.thumb.jpg.afbcf8eb9d62d7680f73a970283f14da.jpg20190920114531_1.thumb.jpg.ee13e34048a5e243712717f827d280bc.jpg20190920114542_1.thumb.jpg.747c66800b036065bdc64ebd44ee9457.jpg20190920114547_1.thumb.jpg.20c74c23dd917170094318b0d00ca6cc.jpg20190920114551_1.thumb.jpg.3d32fff863730e7858ade62feb679aae.jpg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Apart from the home bias I've not seen the effect of reputation working in the sae way as in past years and the AI are getting as good results using attacking mentalities. On the basis that very attacking mentality can work well there is more opportunity for the AI at home.

Any high pt P&P tactic has to be strong away but with weaker teams it is tactics  that use a DM that dominate. Wolves work well with 4132 but Newcastle find 4141 the better option, but I would tend to start with a 4132 and change to 4141 to be more defensive.  

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
vor einer Stunde schrieb knap:

Apart from the home bias I've not seen the effect of reputation working in the sae way as in past years and the AI are getting as good results using attacking mentalities. On the basis that very attacking mentality can work well there is more opportunity for the AI at home.

Any high pt P&P tactic has to be strong away but with weaker teams it is tactics  that use a DM that dominate. Wolves work well with 4132 but Newcastle find 4141 the better option, but I would tend to start with a 4132 and change to 4141 to be more defensive.  

Thanks you mate! I'll try it like that in my fourth season with Huesca :)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 18/09/2019 at 17:51, solounamigo said:

Second season with Huesca

After the great first season we were able to win everything in our second season.

The first season I used the PILMARGE4141 only and the season season I used at home the BEOWULF442P110 and away the PILMARGE4141.

I think this combination is the strongest in FM19. Look at my transfers, I was able to get some loans and some career-ending players :)

Will update you guys here how it's going in my third season :)

20190918174213_1.thumb.jpg.1dcc2a4673b393a40dca60b33bc0b449.jpg20190918174625_1.thumb.jpg.11d450abc43b063d170b3ad96ac5c31d.jpg20190918174610_1.thumb.jpg.3b8c6d615a86cb6604a790ee0e50fa95.jpg20190918174615_1.thumb.jpg.a60ef2a484ab11681b771dc4568c0573.jpg20190918174618_1.thumb.jpg.cdd8817cbfdb75942077dcd02290bb26.jpg

Hi Mate!

Who are corner taker and thwow-in? Do you us any OI or ass. ass. man. did?

 

THX

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I did pretty much the same thing (4141 Away, 442 Home) with also using the 4141 against the stronger teams for the most part.

 

Had no money so I couldn't bring anyone in, didn't really sell anyone.  Porto crushed me 5 (!!!!) times (2 in league, 3 in cup) like 3-2 or 4-2 each time.  Still a successful season.  Lots of turnover for nobody good coming in.  We're still poor.

fm_TCpGtHbnX0.png

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 10/09/2019 at 19:17, knap said:

The naming system was developed mostly around the old tactic systems of fluid/ flexible and most of the tactics this year were translation from old to new.

If I buy FM 20, FM 19 has been very disappointing, then it would probably be a new naming system

You've got to buy FM20, the last 4 years I've pretty much exclusively used your tactics, its amazing work and I think you for it!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

×
×
  • Create New...