Knap - FM24 and FM23 FM22_FM 21 - FM 20 -FM 19 Tactic List

[marksmithlfc1234]

What was the best 4321 again please ?? 

[gooders11]

5 minutes ago, RDF Tactics said:

Here, i noticed Meyer and Townsend have most assists sign next to their name...i figured there weak posts. Meyer has low Bravery, Determination, Flair and Balance. as he's their key man in the middle, i have pressing "always". Townsend has "moves ball to left football before dribble" so i put "show on to right foot"

it was Meyer who passed the ball to Townsend and he lost the ball, we countered and scored within 1st 15mins

Do you find it's best to have right footers on the right or play them where they feel more comfortable? For example Yarmolenko all left foot but prefers playing on the right.

[RDF Tactics]

4 minutes ago, gooders11 said:

Do you find it's best to have right footers on the right or play them where they feel more comfortable? For example Yarmolenko all left foot but prefers playing on the right.

i find its best to play them on the side they prefer.

[knap]

@jamie2

Do you have a save jst before the 1st game of 2nd season?

[grff]

2 hours ago, RDF Tactics said:

the PIs. i love the fact it has less PIs, i feel in more control when i tweak a TI

Do you tweak the tactic for away games? Big games? etc.

[adlyd90]

@RDF Tactics

By the way, when it comes to OI, in my opinion, it really works ... I created my own tactics and divided my best coach to OI, which has good determination, motivation and discipline as well as a very good tactical knowledge, player 
potential and player's skills assessment.

[adlyd90]

@RDF Tactics

And if it would work with any knap tactics then I think PI should be removed.

[WKTHFC]

4 hours ago, RDF Tactics said:

i can't live without it haha....honestly bro, i don't see me using another tactic this year of FM...maybe 4312 but with the same instructions lol

Which tactic are you referring to?

[PauloTerroso97]

 

like to know what is the best tactic to use with the city of leicester, i'm desperate i can't find a tactic that works

[knap]

TEA Tactics do not use many PIs

[jamie2]

2 hours ago, RDF Tactics said:

could you post your team?

hi rdf, below you can see my team

thanks

[jamie2]

1 hour ago, knap said:

@jamie2

Do you have a save jst before the 1st game of 2nd season?

no, i haven't 

last save is 8 october 2020 in the game

[knap]

There is not a problem using OIs but it is up to you to manage them. In fact some of the tactics include specific OIs

[knap]

I am sure there was a request for a 451 using IFs. I will post a 451 IF tactic tonight.

[Amnesia92]

Thank you so much for all your tactics @knap

You've made this years edition of FM enjoyable again!!

 

[knap]

@Sith Lord

The Tomaka game has progressed

[solounamigo]

vor 4 Stunden schrieb RDF Tactics:

i put my crossing on floated

1951257932_!!!!FM20.4.0FireandWater4321OXP101ECCC.fmf 45 kB · 77 downloads

35499664_!!!!!!!!FM20.4.1FireandWaterVOL24312P101EC.fmf 45 kB · 64 downloads

@RDF Tactics is there any reason for using the 20.4.0 instead of the 20.4.1 version?

[andre62]

need a good tactic for home and other for away or against big teams for afc wimbledon please

 

and thanks ;)

[Sith Lord]

4 minutes ago, knap said:

@Sith Lord

The Tomaka game has progressed

Cheers.  Is this with the Oxford 4321?

[jamie2]

36 minutes ago, jamie2 said:

no, i haven't 

last save is 8 october 2020 in the game

SORRY @knap can you give me i tip? if you can

thanks a lot

[andre62]

@solounamigo can you share your tweak away version of fire and water with a dm please for give a try

thanks

[knap]

@Sith Lord

Sicilian and Venom 1st season, which will give you time to build squad for FIRE or Kashmir 4321 oxford

[knap]

@PauloTerroso97

Have you tried BEOWULF 442 P105

[knap]

• M 20.4 and 20.3 me 2040  Tactics  (includes FM 20.2 Beta tactics and FM 20.2.4)

TACTIC LINKS AND TACTIC RANKINGS FROM THE INDEPENDENT TESTS (MR L & FM BASE) ARE NOW ON GOOGLE DOCS LINK BELOW

http://bit.ly/knaptactics

Because I test with top, the pts total in tactic name will give an idea of what is best for top club, Top Clubs should be able to use all of the tactics.

Can also use Top and Sub Top a Home Tactic Underdog Away or

Top Favourite Sub Top Evens Underdog if Underdog

FOR SUS AT END OF GAME TRY - REGROUP AND HOLD SHAPE

 

ROBER GUIDE TO CLUB SET UP 

1826670185_NewGame.pdf 338.59 kB · 259 downloads

RDF TRAINING

Summary by Rober

1. Get a lot of great fitness coaches, I have six. Three on each category. Put yourself and ass man at normal training categories, add 2 gk coaches for gk. If still room, find some normal coaches with model citizen personality.

2. Instead of training in position, add double intensity on individual training. Then select area which is lacking, f ex final third, that trains decisions and composure like shown here. These will increase very much. I think Almada started with 10 and 13, so +2 and still only 7months of season played.

3. This can be automated under rest in training tab. Select automation on all in individual, then they change according to his fitness levels to protect from training to hard when low fitness after matches, and get injuries.

4. If coaches have Model citizen personalities, you will also have increase in determination for many players. But not always so easy to find.

5. With this we recommend letting ass. man. handling normal training, and not combining this with other schedules, as we have hired may fitness coaches and have just you and ass man on normal categories.

 

 

 

 

MAIN RDF DEVELOPMENT THREAD

 

RDF TWEAKS

 

 

CROSSING CONSIDERATIONS

 

 

MENTALITY MATTERS GUIDE

FRENCH UNDERDOG TESTS

 

 

 

 

RECOMMENDED TRAINING SCHEDULES

 

 

C

SHOuTS

Demand More when we are winning by 1 goal.

Show Some Passion when we are back at score.

Praise when winning 2 or more goals.

--

FA Trophy and if we make League 2 promotion, who knows.

 

MRr Hough recommended shouts

Use shouts Show Some Passion and Demand More. Also concentrate if leading by a few goals

[mickyt11]

3 minutes ago, knap said:

@PauloTerroso97

Have you tried BEOWULF 442 P105

Where is the link to this? Going to try it out with my man united save as struggling.

Any tips using this?

[mickyt11]

1 minute ago, mickyt11 said:

Where is the link to this? Going to try it out with my man united save as struggling.

Any tips using this?

Sorry just seen the above!

[PauloTerroso97]

could you point me or link there are so many

[knap]

@PauloTerroso97

 

ID 1371

[knap]

@PauloTerroso97

This is Spurs with the BEOWULF P105 442

 

[Filipezepp]

any plug and play tactic?

[sergiolagartija]

hace 2 minutos, knap dijo:

@PauloTerroso97

This is Spurs with the BEOWULF P105 442

 

Is this  BEOWULF 442 P105 EC CC?? 

[mickyt11]

8 minutes ago, knap said:

@PauloTerroso97

This is Spurs with the BEOWULF P105 442

Sorry can this be used on the latest patch (20.4.1?)

 

[knap]

The Spurs season was today and earlier I was using a FM 19Tactic.

[MrGreen555]

57 minutes ago, knap said:

@Sith Lord

Sicilian and Venom 1st season, which will give you time to build squad for FIRE or Kashmir 4321 oxford

Which Kashmir is this? 41221? Vol 6?

[MrGreen555]

Also, I don't get the training, anyone care to explain? It seems counter productive LOL

[Rain Man]

First of all thanks for all the effort you guys put in this community.

I want to ask any advice on squad re-building process?

Which specific attributes to look for, is scout reports reliable, can we do our search based on position/role/duties and their key attributes etc?

@knap I know you pretty much test a tactic for a season and just keep on testing new ones but if you decide to play a long-term save somehow, can you explain your go to's in terms of re-building briefly?

@RDF Tactics From the training guide post, I know you primarily look for physical, then mental and last technical attributes. But can you explain maybe a bit more? Which attributes you look for specifically and how you judge a player's ability generally?

Thanks in advance

[jonnysnipe]

16 hours ago, Earnie is God! said:

Kashmir scored 172 in one of them.

 

That was with a 2nd season super squad for United I've managed to get to 200 goals scored in a season the past few FMs would want to try again this year 

[MrGreen555]

To put both my posts in to one...
 

I've been promoted from the championship with Middlesbrough, I am doing a HGC only save, gradually moving all none home grown players out.

Ive been using a variant of 4321 and wouldn't mind continuing that shape, I hear Kashmir Vol 6 is the way to go? I am going to be by far the worst team in the league.

 

I need help developing my players QUICKLY but I don't fully understand the training methods described, can someone please advise?

 

 

[knap]

@MrGreen555

There is a summary in google docs

[knap]

FM 20.3.1

ARGUS 451VOL 3 P104 EC

!!!!!!!!!FM20.4.1ARGUSknap451VOL3P104EC.fmf

[jonnysnipe]

Knap any tips for hitting that 200 mark with goals scored - even if in some games I sacrifice the points I would like to hit it again.

 

Currently using Kashmir at home but away not creating many chances - crazy how the match engine changes so much home and away

[knap]

@jonnysnipe

There is a home bias.

Let me try something

[jonnysnipe]

35 minutes ago, knap said:

@jonnysnipe

There is a home bias.

Let me try something

Keep me informed you helped me achieve it the other year the key is big wins at home and 2/3 goals away from home I think 

 

Edit: this was a close game....

Edited April 21, 2020 by jonnysnipe

[PAFC_Dugout]

3 hours ago, knap said:

@PauloTerroso97

This is Spurs with the BEOWULF P105 442

 

only 4 goals conceded in 20 games on this match engine is insane! 

if this isa tactic from FM19 on the list on your first post is it the  !!!!!FM19.3.4BEOWULF442KnapP106ALLCUPS.fmf 45.23 kB · 41 downloads

or this one

!!!!!19.3.4BEOWULF442WAFKnapP103ECCC.fmf 44.96 kB · 43 downloads

thanks @knap

 

Edited April 21, 2020 by PAFC_Dugout

[knap]

@Filipezepp

All p&P

[knap]

@PAFC_Dugout

FM 20 BEOWULF P105

The FM 19 Tacti cwas Beowulf p106 all cups

[knap]

@Rain Man

I seldom bother with top clubs.

With LL I use attribute masking and rely on scout reports

[Smokedsalmon]

Hi guys. What's the best way of deciding which tactic is the best to use? The list on the OP seems really confusing and I'm not sure what each different name means for the tactic. Thanks!

[knap]

@Smokedsalmon

Depends on your squad and your preferred formation.

Try Fire and Water 4321 oxford P103 or BEOWULF 442 P105

[RDF Tactics]

10 hours ago, MrGreen555 said:

Also, I don't get the training, anyone care to explain? It seems counter productive LOL

i got results using this training method so i shared. its nothing complicated, nothing game breaking, no exploits, just the way i did my training. but i can try and explain a bit more because i can see my people are curious, as i was when i first tried this method

Training roles and positions isn't needed, though, we assumed it was. Players will always train a position and role in training, you're not taking that away from them. giving them a specific role gives them even more training to do, which can give them too much. which, that would be counter productive.

this method doesn't guarantee you great results, it gives you better control over your players training and development 

say Troy Parrot has a PA of 200...training him on CF will spread out his attribute increases though thats not what i want. he already has good heading, finishing and technique, but what he does have is poor movement off the ball. i want to focus on that so when he does reach his PA, he's more a complete player....example, he has finishing of 15 and off the ball of 10, instead of have finishing 20 and off the ball 10...he can have finish 17 and off the ball 13

players are still likely to develop without this method, this method gives you better control.

in my experience, this method has giving me better training ratings, attribute increases rapidly and just good performances on the pitch. Thats not to say you won't win without this, thats not the case at all...i've only been training like this for a week now, i never thought i had training problems before, but now i can see what i could've done to improve things....ever since this method, i have 4 saves. Man Utd (i signed nobody for 4 years, only sold and used youth players) won the league 4 years in a row...2 seasons with Bournemouth, 1st season finished 2nd and won FA Cup, 2nd season won the league...1st season with Hoffenheim, won the league. 1st season with Brescia finished 2, 2nd season, was 2nd in Jan....1st season with Tottenham is my current save, and i'm 1st in Dec, 7 points ahead....in each of these saves, i've have come across a single player training bad. literally 0 times someone has had training ratings from training.

@Cadoni done a test, with this method, he finished 13 places above when he tried the general method. This CAN be luck/RNG, also can be players morale were better because training at a good rate everyday...we don't actually know for a fact. but its just advice we wanted to give