Jump to content
Sports Interactive Community
wwfan

Stupid Questions Thread (Tactic and Training Questions Only)

Recommended Posts

Hi

I know it is, I am not saying it's the same, perhaps I should re-phrase it:

Does anyone ever tweak passing settings in the TC based on duty/role?

For example do you prefer short passing at the back to then more direct passing up top or the opposite so direct passing at the back to short up top?

I am talking about the TC in FM16

That's how mentality works. Defensive mentality sets long passing at the back, short passing for more advanced players by default. Attacking mentality is the opposite. Each mentality change is just a step change in progression.

If you want to know a more about what mentality does, read the new FAQs sticky or any of the creating a tactic guides for greater detail.

Equally, you can easily change individual player passing settings using Player Instructions if that is how you want your system to play. And that's the key point - it's completely irrelevant what other people do, it's entirely up to you and what you want from your system.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hi

Yeah I have spent most of the week reading things from that section, just so much to absorb.

Thanks for that, so in other words then there's no need to tweak PI's for passing settings really, so just leave them on default and use strategy to implement that style?

I am trying to learn what people do so wanted to ask, it's not irrelevant as it would mean me getting some other ideas because as yet I am not sure how I want to play, I have just been testing things in FMT.

So I am right in my assumption say on defensive it would mean short passing for advanced players as you kindly stated, does that simply mean if on that mentality I was to then go into PI's and set advanced players to shorter passing it would simply go from short to shorter?

Please say I am right otherwise I have learned nothing! ha :)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have done this LEEMOD, when on Standard and Flexible - as a test mind you - and set no T.I for Play Out of Defence or Work Ball Into Box etc. and relied on Player Instructions for passing. Set Defenders to Short Passing and Attacking Midfielders/Wingers to Direct Passing.

Also, if using Bonucci type defenders, I have set his as CD(d) with Direct Passing and then if using Messi type attackers set Short Passing.

I see where you're coming from and it may be worth more thought as I do think if executed properly with a good team/players it can be really effective. You do need to offset this with other T.I's & P.I's and Mentality changes though and then it gets extra complicated. But it's not really necessary as the T.I's/ Player Roles can do it for you far simpler - and at the moment I think you need to Keep It Simple.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
So I am right in my assumption say on defensive it would mean short passing for advanced players as you kindly stated, does that simply mean if on that mentality I was to then go into PI's and set advanced players to shorter passing it would simply go from short to shorter?

Yes, of course this is correct. You're asking players to pass short-ER than their default.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest

What's causing my keepers to kick the ball long and how do I stop it? They do it under no pressure and with the fullbacks readily available.

gEctDfi.png

Here's the team and keeper tactical instructions.

lowpvIe.png

GRjgQH4.png

I've got them on 'slow pace down' because I'm assuming that'll make them hold the ball a little longer, which usually ends up with the opposition retreating back into their shape and leaving my fullbacks free. I'm one of the top teams in the world so opposition teams don't really ever push up high against my defence when I have the ball. I've got two playmakers in my team, one DLP defend and one wide AP support, but they never aim it at them, just to the attacking midfielder and forward. No target men in the team.

I'm wondering if adding 'be more disciplined' as a team instruction would help, or would that be more likely to make them stick to the more direct approach of the attacking mentality and ignore the short passing instruction.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

You might need to help us a little more here as I'm not seeing an issue.

Pretty much every single kick or throw the keeper makes is towards the flanks with only 6 long kicks?

You'll never stop every single long kick and just 6 doesn't seem too bad to me. Plus you use an Attacking mentality which could encourage long kicks - but again, just 6 seems fine to me. And, even better, out of all of the kicks/throws he made, only 5 went astray.

I'd be well happy if that was my keeper.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Another one from me. What are the perfect attributes for scouts and physios? e.g does determination effect physios in any way?

I moved this into the Stupid Questions thread as it isn't really a "frequently" asked question, although I will include some info on ideal coach attributes in the FAQs.

Scouts - Judging Ability and Potential are the only 2 attributes you need. Tactical Knowledge may be useful if you want to set a scout to scout your next opponent.

Physios - Physiotherapy is the only attribute needed. Working with Youngsters is useful if you want a dedicated Youth Team physio, therefore Man Management may also be useful for your senior squad physios. Fitness also used to be a suggested attribute given in the FM online manual but that seems to have disappeared now. TL;DR, get the physio with the highest Physio attribute you can afford, nothing else really matters.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
You might need to help us a little more here as I'm not seeing an issue.

Pretty much every single kick or throw the keeper makes is towards the flanks with only 6 long kicks?

You'll never stop every single long kick and just 6 doesn't seem too bad to me. Plus you use an Attacking mentality which could encourage long kicks - but again, just 6 seems fine to me. And, even better, out of all of the kicks/throws he made, only 5 went astray.

I'd be well happy if that was my keeper.

It's mainly because I don't concede many chances, but when I do they usually stem from my players hitting it long when I don't want them to. Also I'm a perfectionist.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
It's mainly because I don't concede many chances, but when I do they usually stem from my players hitting it long when I don't want them to. Also I'm a perfectionist.

You only mentioned your keeper though & not all players?

I'd be happy with that if it was my keeper

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
You only mentioned your keeper though & not all players?

I'd be happy with that if it was my keeper

Yeah other players do it too randomly but I'm generally happy with how the team is playing and the keeper is easier to isolate with regards to tactics.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Yeah other players do it too randomly but I'm generally happy with how the team is playing and the keeper is easier to isolate with regards to tactics.

Remember you use an Attacking mentality as well.

How crazy is using this formation?

Very.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Because it only uses 1 CD?

The channels between the CB and FB's just wont be closed. Come up against a 4-4-2 and your FB's will be in a 1-v-1 (possibly even 2-v-1 as you wont use Wingers or Wide Midfielders yourself) situation with their Wingers, leaving their strikers in a 2-v-1 against your CB.

Even if your FB's sit narrow to mark a Striker it will leave the Wingers (and Full Backs) in a 1-v-0 (or 2-v-0) situation.

The only time I've ever seen this remotely work was when I was Barcelone and had a Pique as Sweeper and Alaba and Alves as FB's with Busquets as a central HB. Even then I had to rely on scoring more than opponents.

It's FM suicide mate.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
The channels between the CB and FB's just wont be closed. Come up against a 4-4-2 and your FB's will be in a 1-v-1 (possibly even 2-v-1 as you wont use Wingers or Wide Midfielders yourself) situation with their Wingers, leaving their strikers in a 2-v-1 against your CB.

Even if your FB's sit narrow to mark a Striker it will leave the Wingers (and Full Backs) in a 1-v-0 (or 2-v-0) situation.

The only time I've ever seen this remotely work was when I was Barcelone and had a Pique as Sweeper and Alaba and Alves as FB's with Busquets as a central HB. Even then I had to rely on scoring more than opponents.

It's FM suicide mate.

Thanks for your reply. I noticed that after a few games, the gap is too big. I thought that the use of two defensive midfielders could help with that but it didn't happen.

I guess this one is balanced, defensively and ofensively?

abLom5LadF.png

Both wingers have PI to act as inside forwards in attack

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I guess this one is balanced, defensively and ofensively?

Only one way to find out ;).

I'd keep a close eye on the movement of those 2 CD stoppers though.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks.

I've never used 3 CD system and i've seen many people using that setup in defense. Let's see if it works!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have a question about staff members. Lets say I would like to set my team to press heavily, does having staff with the pressing style of closing down is important, or at the very least helpful?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I have a question about staff members. Lets say I would like to set my team to press heavily, does having staff with the pressing style of closing down is important, or at the very least helpful?

As far as I am aware it has zero impact. I rarely (if ever) look at any coach attributes other than those mentioned in the FAQs sticky at the top of this forum.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Currently got a fantastic game ongoing at the moment with Newcastle sitting top of the league, but I'm having some troubles when playing against teams using a 4-4-2. I always use a 4-1-2-3 DM Wide, Control with the TI's of Lower Tempo, Close Down More & Play Out Of Defence. What would be the best way to break the dreaded 4-4-2 down, I thought play wider might help but no joy.

Any tips would be greatly appreciated.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Easy one for you guys ;) I'v set team insructions to shorter passing. However i want 1 or 2 players to be a bit more expansive with mixed passing, when i go to the player insructions though it only has short/direct but the bar seems shorter than usual. Is it possible for me to choose mixed? Or is direct mixed because of the shorter passing t.i? Is it better to go by the images rather than the description in these situations in general e.g closing down, d-line

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This one is really :rolleyes:

I'm being asked to provide the squad numbers, but when I click on reply instead of being able to see the team squad with numbers I can only choose the players position and I can't move on because I have to reply. What's going on here ?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hi.

Do you guys think it makes sense for a lone DLF(s) move into channels when there is an IF(a) and an CM(a) running into the space?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Hi.

Do you guys think it makes sense for a lone DLF(s) move into channels when there is an IF(a) and an CM(a) running into the space?

Depends on the timing of the runs and how the opposition is set up. Why not try and see what happens? That will answer the question far better than any forum speculation could.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
This one is really :rolleyes:

I'm being asked to provide the squad numbers, but when I click on reply instead of being able to see the team squad with numbers I can only choose the players position and I can't move on because I have to reply. What's going on here ?

No idea, this is probably a tech support or GD question.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Easy one for you guys ;) I'v set team insructions to shorter passing. However i want 1 or 2 players to be a bit more expansive with mixed passing, when i go to the player insructions though it only has short/direct but the bar seems shorter than usual. Is it possible for me to choose mixed? Or is direct mixed because of the shorter passing t.i? Is it better to go by the images rather than the description in these situations in general e.g closing down, d-line

The adjustments are relative, so you have shorter passing, but want mixed, then you would set them to direct, and they will effectively be mixed, which is why the bar appears shorter. The best way to think of these things is as stackables. Direct team, then a shorter PI will in very basic terms be like +1 and -1, cancelling each other out, and putting the player back to mixed. It works like that with pretty all of the layered instructions.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Currently got a fantastic game ongoing at the moment with Newcastle sitting top of the league, but I'm having some troubles when playing against teams using a 4-4-2. I always use a 4-1-2-3 DM Wide, Control with the TI's of Lower Tempo, Close Down More & Play Out Of Defence. What would be the best way to break the dreaded 4-4-2 down, I thought play wider might help but no joy.

Any tips would be greatly appreciated.

With the usual caveats in place, I would say that against the 4-4-2 your best approach is to go where you have them outnumbered which is in the center of the park. I would look to exploit the middle. Because the 4-4-2 is so stable though, if you slow down play, it give it time to collapse into a shape to deny you space pretty easily. Maybe a faster more direct attack up the gut would answer for you.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

How different is a B/II team vs. a U21 team? I've only manager in England really, so I want to make sure I get the most out of my II team. (I'm managing Stuttgart). Should I have the guys I want developed on my main roster for tutoring/training and make them "available for Stuttgart II" or just move them there?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Depends on the timing of the runs and how the opposition is set up. Why not try and see what happens? That will answer the question far better than any forum speculation could.

You're right. Thanks

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
How different is a B/II team vs. a U21 team? I've only manager in England really, so I want to make sure I get the most out of my II team. (I'm managing Stuttgart). Should I have the guys I want developed on my main roster for tutoring/training and make them "available for Stuttgart II" or just move them there?

Well the obvious difference is the B/II team I think have no age restrictions, but I also understand that in FM those teams are not under user control in the way a u20 or u18 squad is. So, the football is probably a good deal better because they play in real leagues but the price is losing developmental control. In a nuthsell, I would treat them just like you would a U20 if you are okay with ceding control to the B/II team AI manager, if you aren't good with that (I wouldn't be) then tutor, train PPms and whatever else you need, then once that is done if they aren't ready to make your subs bench, you can job them out to the II team.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
You're right. Thanks

You're welcome. I didn't mean to be short with you at all, but really that was the absolute best answer i could give because of the sheer number of variables in that mix :)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Well the obvious difference is the B/II team I think have no age restrictions, but I also understand that in FM those teams are not under user control in the way a u20 or u18 squad is. So, the football is probably a good deal better because they play in real leagues but the price is losing developmental control. In a nuthsell, I would treat them just like you would a U20 if you are okay with ceding control to the B/II team AI manager, if you aren't good with that (I wouldn't be) then tutor, train PPms and whatever else you need, then once that is done if they aren't ready to make your subs bench, you can job them out to the II team.

Ok, then I think it's how I thought. Keep them on the main team and just available to play for the II team.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
You're welcome. I didn't mean to be short with you at all, but really that was the absolute best answer i could give because of the sheer number of variables in that mix :)

Yes of course, i will test it and see it for myself :thup:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

What does the setting 'Use Offside Trap' do, apart from the obvious? I'd like to know the mechanisms of that setting. Does it only increase the attempts of the defence to set a striker offside, or are there other 'under the hood' instructions or consequenses kicking in? (E.g. the flat back 4 playing more as a unit, operating more in line, playing more zonally instead of tracking an attacker...) And when exactly do defenders try to set an attacker offside then?

(I know those questions sound a bit stupid, but hey, this is the stupid questions thread, so...)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
What does the setting 'Use Offside Trap' do, apart from the obvious? I'd like to know the mechanisms of that setting. Does it only increase the attempts of the defence to set a striker offside, or are there other 'under the hood' instructions or consequenses kicking in? (E.g. the flat back 4 playing more as a unit, operating more in line, playing more zonally instead of tracking an attacker...) And when exactly do defenders try to set an attacker offside then?

(I know those questions sound a bit stupid, but hey, this is the stupid questions thread, so...)

Me as well, as I remember Cleon discussing recently how it specifically works in FM is its own thing. Might also be something to add to the FAQ thread. :)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Is the PI "hold position" the equivalent of setting forward runs to rarely? Or does it just prevent roaming?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Is the PI "hold position" the equivalent of setting forward runs to rarely?

Yes, that's correct. You should still be able to get a player to Hold Position, but also Roam, so while he won't attempt forward runs, he'll still try and find space around him.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If you want to try and train a player to be a goal scoring midfielder, given a CM(a) role, what schedule would be best to use that doesn't also try and improve unnecessary defensive or creative attributes?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Which skin(s) for FM16 can show the opposition players roles and duties on the tactical screen?

Unless someone can give a quick answer, you're probably better off asking in the Skinning forum.

If you want to try and train a player to be a goal scoring midfielder, given a CM(a) role, what schedule would be best to use that doesn't also try and improve unnecessary defensive or creative attributes?

In my opinion a CM(a) needs defensive and creative attributes as well as being able to score goals, so not improving these areas may not be a good idea.

If you really want to just focus on his ability to score, set him up in a similar way you would a Poacher, but I really wouldn't recommend it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Dunno if it belongs here or in 'general questions' but...

Does Adaptability matter at all for a scout that is intended to work solely in his home country? For example, an English Scout scouting in England? The manual doesn't really say on this.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Dunno if it belongs here or in 'general questions' but...

Does Adaptability matter at all for a scout that is intended to work solely in his home country? For example, an English Scout scouting in England? The manual doesn't really say on this.

Check the FAQs.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hi,

I play the touch version on a Ipad, so i have the option to make a quick match. In there i have two options: simulate or instant result.

When i choose simulate, i believe that the game is played with my current tactic, but my question is... will my Assist Manager make any changes during the game?

Yes, No?

And if Yes, what kind of changes? Will he change the formation, players roles, or only the team mentality?

Anyone knows?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Hi,

I play the touch version on a Ipad, so i have the option to make a quick match. In there i have two options: simulate or instant result.

When i choose simulate, i believe that the game is played with my current tactic, but my question is... will my Assist Manager make any changes during the game?

Yes, No?

And if Yes, what kind of changes? Will he change the formation, players roles, or only the team mentality?

Anyone knows?

You may be better off asking this in the FMT forum.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I got a question regarding Shape. I know that the more Fluid you play, the more compact your team becomes, but are we talking about with the ball or off it?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hi,

what does the ppm dwells on ball effectuate? My player has also trys killer balls often. Is this not the exactly the difference from the first?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


×
×
  • Create New...