Jack Rodwell or Sakho?

[OohAahCantona]

I need to spash my transfer kitty on either a young DC or DMC.

I can't decide between Rodwell or Sakho, either one would benefit my team but can only afford one!

[Chalky1989]

I've never signed Sakho, but on my game, Rodwell was my England captain till about 34-35, and got 132 caps, and was the heart of his Everton team. So I'd sign Rodwell.

[AcidBurn]

I would go for Rodwell, he is a brilliant player was just as good at DC, DMC or CM for my Real Madrid side.

[jod123]

If I was an English club, then I'd definitely go for Rodwell.

[scoot4nat]

+1 Rodwell - Captain for my Chelsea team, England captain, consistent, brilliant as deep-lying playmaker, scores the odd goal and is versatile.

[edgar555]

Wrong forum. Good Player and Team Guide is the place for this. Specifically the 'Should I buy/sell thread'. Player naming is (or at least used to be) frowned upon in GD.

[ArsenalFan7]

Sakho.

0-ph;;hgjh.

[SynysterGates17]

i bought sakho for my R.Marid team and it was pretty decent

[Thandui]

if your an English club go for Rodwell if not I might go for Sakho, but they're different players, if you want a versatile centre back who can create and push forward go for Rodwell, if not go for Sakho, a no nonsense centre back

[lee50_11]

Jack Rodwell every time

[DougyMarshall]

Heres both compared in my 2015 save.

If you want the player to defend then Sakho, if you want someone a bit more versatile then Rodwell, he done well for me at Rangers before i sold him on to Juve.

[poola21]

Sakho is rock

[Onyewu]

It's apples and oranges........Sakho all the way if you need a stud central defender.........if not for his defensive ability at least for the haircut.

[aaron1606]

Jack Rodwell every time. Always brilliant for me in defence or midfield.

[antonyhoggan]

Which side of the defence do you want to play him on? Left / right? Do you need additional cover for the left back or defensive midfield positions?

[lawd]

+1 for Rodwell. He was the best player in my England world cup winning side, and I was so impressed I tok him to Barcelona when I left England, and now je is my captain at City. Only time I can remember signing the same player for multiple clubs throughout a single career. I had Sakho at Inter and tbh I wan't massivley impressed.

[Llew_Arshavin23]

English club - JACK RODWELL

Foreign club - MAMA SAKHO

Simple as.

[PitchPosh]

Put me down for Rodwell as well. The only thing I've ever had a gripe about with him is that I can't get him to unlearn "plays a simple passing game." Other than that he's absolute quality.

[Mikelsoul]

Rodwell for me. Pretty much as good at CB as he is at CM according to my coaches. Quality player. Captain for my Everton side, and has something like 50 caps for England at 22 years old.

[oranjeman]

neither get Federico Fazio instead

[Chochip]

I've never used Rodwell before but Sakho always seems to perform at around 6.7-6.8 even after a few years in England.

I would go for Pique if he has a decent transfer clause like $30-40m

[mufc-paton]

Sakho was rubbish in my Bayern save. Rodwell from me

[andyeverton]

rodwell is class solid dc and an amazin deep lyin playmaker

[England4Ever]

i would have to go with Rodwell as well.. Ooozes calss on the field.

[mista T]

Sakho. Possibly one of the best future defenders on the game.

[Becksmania]

Rodwell definitely, he's english (:

[tommo12345]

rodwell hes the best dm in the game if developed well

[edgar555]

rodwell hes the best dm in the game if developed well

Really? Better than Sandro? Better than Moussa Sissoko? Better than Zuculini? Better than Annan? Better than Veloso? No is the answer to all of those and more probably.

[Purefun]

Guys, should I buy/sell thread maybe.