My impressions so far are mixed.
I love a lot about the match engine, especially the fix for the cross to far post goal every time feature. It is smoother, some cool new player moves, etc.
Very realistic that Ed Woodward can't get any deals over the line too.
BUT... Players still make stupid decisions all the time. Especially the famous "Messi under zero pressure decides to head the ball aimlessly towards the opposition, instead of taking the ball down and starting a counter attack" It looks tremendously silly still.
Players have no situational awareness in terms of weather