Oh sad to read that... I'm a Boca Juniors fan, I wish you bad luck at the "superclasico" when you return to Primera División Other thing is that in the game economics turns VERY unrealistic in Argentina, in the future seasons you will see clubs buying local players for US$ 20 million or more. Now in the year 2019 I have a transfer budget of US$ 200 million!!!
Now on topic: I'm in the 9th season off my career with Boca, I won the league for 8th straight years and being undefeated for very long periods, the longest being 80+ games, all of this with my "tactics creator and shouts only" tactic (I don't touch sliders) I think that the key to success at this game is to keep the club organized and play every player in a comfortable position, I never go "tweaking-mad" with tactics, and in the long term you will start to win a lot.
After reading the entire SI Sports Centre thread I think that I could make a tactic the way you do and create the "perfect" tactic for my team, so in my 9th season after selling the half of my team I make a formation, put basic roles and duties and started to watch the games on full, I can recognize and detect things that I don't like in the way my team play. It goes really well for the first 2 matches, but in the 3rd game I play vs San Lorenzo an strong opponent in the league and my team struggle I see things that I don't like in the way of play but I can't fix them.
So my question is will you post how do you finish your tactic, because I can't totally understand how you do it, and can't get the changes you make in your successful FA Cup games. It would be very nice to see the "complete" process of how you adapt your tactic to it final shape and how you improve and maintain it.
PS: Keep the good work and sorry for my poor English.