Jump to content

Sandy Tait

Members+
  • Posts

    57
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Sandy Tait

  1. Just run into this bug as well - I'm importing the training schedules that I've used for all my other careers so far in FM24, hitting confirm, then save, as usual, but they're not showing up in the list. Have tried restarting the game to no avail.
  2. Tell us something we don't know? Not wanting to be unkind or rude, but this is just more stating the obvious. Obviously previous fixes haven't worked, and obviously something more substantial is needed. This has been an issue for a decade or, to put it another, half the existence of the Football Manager franchise (not including the CM days here, clearly). If a bug is present for that long without being fixed, I can't help but seriously question the actual interest the team has in fixing it. Not expecting you to come back with an exact timeframe, I'm just hoping you can convince us that progress is being made and that maybe when FM25 comes out we won't be talking about this yet again.
  3. Of all the bugs encountered in the Football Manager series, this one is by far the most persistent and ridiculous. A game as advanced as this, that gets significant overhauls on an annual basis (and multiple patches in-between), still cannot handle the seemingly simple matter of having resizable columns that actually work. It's just mind-boggling. Yeah, the match engine's great and the database is amazing and so on but can SI please just fix the sodding interface? FM24 was supposed to be "the most complete edition in the series' history", yet still struggles with something this basic. Honestly, if the entire sales pitch for FM25 was just "WE FIXED THE COLUMN RESIZING PROBLEM!!" I would buy it without a moment's hesitation
  4. Has there been any joy in fixing this? Been a bug for a few versions now. Similarly the nonsense with "auto-size" thinking the screen is about twice as wide as it actually is and shoving half your columns out of view.
  5. @Zachary Whyte A little extra info that may or may not be helpful with this bug - it seems the column only vanishes the next time you start the game after loading a custom skin. I removed the customs skins I had while the game wasn't running, deleted my cache as per the guide, started the game and loaded a save and saw that the Rec column was back, put a custom skin back into the skins folder and loaded it, and the column was still there. The next time I booted FM up it had gone. Obviously the solution here is never close FM
  6. I'm noticing messed up player ratings, too. For me, only two of my defensive players (i.e. full backs, centre backs, defensive mids) averaged over 7.0 for the season, despite us winning the league and finishing with the second lowest GA, just 8 behind City. I remember inaccurate DM ratings being an issue in FM23 but I thought it was patched out eventually. Defensive players highlighted below, and the distribution is clear.
  7. Hi Zach. I've uploaded the save "Sandy Tait - Tottenham.fm" but as I say it's happening in every career so I don't think it's anything to do with the saves.
  8. I am using a custom skin but it's also happening with the default skin. I've tried deleting my cache per the guide but the issue persists. Happens across all my save files, both new ones and ones imported from FM23, and across all skins.
  9. Vanished from mine, too! Thought maybe it was my custom views, or the skin I'm using, but switched to the default skin and checked the default views and it's gone from all of them.
  10. Academies are, IMO, the most underdeveloped part of the game and it's been due an overhaul for a long time. You get an inbox item in the first half of the season with a vague prediction of what you'll get, then in the second half of the season they all turn up for a trial and that's it, leaving the whole thing feeling like a glorified die roll. It's particularly out of place when you're managing the likes of Ajax or Barca who famously have absolutely enormous youth academies that have many, many levels as well as youth camps and satellite academies in other nations. I'd love to see: * The Youth Academy getting its own page in the Development Centre section * Multiple youth levels visible, as you suggest, with the number and the size being tied to the club's youth facilities and recruitment ratings; it wouldn't even need to be a full team page like with the U18s, but perhaps just a section on the new Academy page briefly outlining the player names, positions, etc. like we currently get on the Youth Candidates page in the Development Centre * Youth players below U18 not having precise or fixed positions, and your Head of Youth being able to suggest that a player might benefit from playing a different role (either permanently because it better suits their ability or, as Ajax do, short-term to help them round out their skills; e.g. playing centre backs in midfield for a season to develop their technique, passing, etc.); player positions and roles are generally way too permanent in FM and you just don't get the natural drift that many players have over their careers (attacking mids becoming centre mids, then defensive mids as they get older and slower, etc.) or younger players being tried out in a different role and sticking with it because it actually suits them better (TAA as you mention, Mousa Dembele going from a forward to a midfielder, Gareth Bale from wingback to winger, Danny Rose going from winger to wingback, Jan Vertonghen moving from midfield to defence, etc., etc.) * The option for youth camps and satellite academies overseas, a bit like affiliated clubs except it doesn't require a pre-existing club and would be solely for getting youth players into your academy - at the very basic level this could simply be an item in the Development Centre noting that you have a youth camp in, say, South Africa, and the game reflecting this by boosting the club's scouting knowledge for South Africa and increasing the chance of South African players coming through in your Youth Intake (or into the Academy)
  11. Great suggestion! Would love to be able to tell my assistant "Don't use this guy in this position/role". Having the assistant be aware of the pecking order for players would be great, too.
  12. Update: I now have the rest of the team complaining that I didn't let Frendrup leave, when he's gone out on loan with a mandatory future purchase!
  13. Feels weird to be discovering a new (to me) bug in May but here we are! xD Received a loan deal offer with an optional future fee for a transfer-listed player, and I negotiated it to a mandatory fee, then accepted their counter-negotiation. However, the player was upset because I had "priced [them] out of the move", even though I had ultimately accepted the offer. I didn't worry about it too much as, assuming he accepted the contract, he was gone anyway, so I just said I was sorry and promised to accept any future offers. Another offer then came in, and the exact same scenario played out - they offered an optional fee, I counter-offered a mandatory fee, we negotiated a bit, then I accepted their offer. And the player reacted as if I'd broken the promise, so looks like there's a persistent issue there with changing an Optional Fee loan to a Mandatory Fee loan being seen by the player as the offer being rejected rather than negotiated or something along those lines. On the bright side for me, because of him kicking up a fuss the first time I somehow talked him into doubling his asking price so I'm now set to make £48m from the deal instead of £24m! xD Uploaded save file is just as the second offer comes in, so fingers crossed if you negotiate it to a mandatory deal (I went for £20m for the mandatory fee and left the instalments as-is, then asked them to pay his full wages and accepted their counter-offer of *most* of his wages) you should get the same reaction from the player.
  14. Not sure if this is to do with the match engine or something else, but Harry Kane - one of the most successful penalty takers in the world - has missed *six* penalties this season in all competitions (including international fixtures), which is the same number he's missed in real life in the last seven seasons, or more than half as many as he's missed in his entire career! (source: Harry Kane - Penalty goals | Transfermarkt)
  15. I'm going to guess someone missed a zero when putting Lo Celso's salary in?
  16. Not a bug exactly but after selling a low potential 20yo from our reserves for a modest sum I had this weird question come up: If I'm reading this right, they're asking me why I sold a player for money instead of just paying their wages for the rest of the year and letting them go for free, which ranks pretty highly in the "Stupid Question" stakes. Am I misreading this or is it triggering incorrectly or something?
  17. In relation to Jermain Defoe and Yaya Touré, there's also this...
  18. I have a youngster out on loan who has just won the European Golden Boy award, after scoring 33 goals in 39 games. Which sounds fair enough, except that only 5 of those goals were scored in a top tier division - 11 of them were during a loan at a 2.Bundesliga side, and 17 of them were for my second team, who play in the 3.Bundesliga. It seems that the award is looking at *all* competitive goals scored over the calendar year by players currently in a tier 1 division, rather than just those that were actually scored in a tier 1 division.
  19. Further info: I've gone back to autosave from 12th June 2025, which is before I spotted the player, and he doesn't appear in the database at all! Wondered if it might be something to do with leagues being added/removed, or the season refresh date, so holidayed until 30th June and lo and behold he's there, as a free agent who's at the club but not appearing the team list - search for him and you'll find him though. Also, "a wider range of saves" uploaded: "Journeyman - Dinamo (v03)" - Player not at club and does not appear to be in database "Journeyman - Dinamo (v02)" - Player at club but has no contract and is not showing in the team list; can be searched for "Journeyman - Dinamo" - Player is at club, still has no contract (two offered), and appears in team list twice Hope these are of use!
  20. Update: using the in-game editor to move him to my club, then dropping him to the reserves and promoting him straight back to the first team seems to fix both the contract issue and the multiple listings on the team list, though it does make his career history look a bit screwy (three entries for the same club during the same season) but assuming this doesn't cause any further issues it's a workable fix.
  21. Managing Dinamo, in my 2nd season at the club, I stumbled upon this player in my team. The weird thing is, he wasn't there last season and I didn't sign him. He also doesn't show up in my team list and I only spotted him by chance while using a scout prog. Note also the "Available on a free transfer" bit and the lack of even a rolling contract. Anyway, seeing as how he's a fairly decent left back and I needed cover in that position, I offered him a new contract in the hope that this would resolve the issue of him being there-but-not-there. And it did, sort of. He started showing in the team list, and his history updated for him to be at my club. Only... he was still without a contract and on a free transfer, and while I offered him a contract I never had any notification that he accepted - he just appeared in the team list. So I offered him another contract. Again, no notification of any acceptance, but now he's in my teamlist twice, valued as "not for sale", and still marked as being available on a free transfer and not having a contract. I then tried using the in-game editor to move him to my club in the hope that this would fix it. It sort of worked, because he's no longer available on a free transfer and he has a contract. But... Any ideas??
×
×
  • Create New...