Vader17
-
Posts
25 -
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Football Manager 2024 Official Feedback Thread
Vader17 replied to Kyle Brown's topic in Football Manager General Discussion
Mate of mine sent me RDF's post This! What RDF described here happens way too often, I can not ever remember how many games I am the better team, I play beautiful football, create a lot of chances, opposition scores during the sole counter attack they produce, while being on negative x.G, after that, their goalkeeper turns to prime Buffon, and if that's not enough, the goalposts will do the job for him. Can it happen in real life? of course, but not as often as it happens in FM. The ME can not understand the difference between a very good possession based team vs an average team that also happens to play tiki-taka for example, doesn't matter if you have world class players, you will share possession no matter what. These are just examples of match engine issues (and there are a lot more of them), let's talk about the actual game and interactions. You have players literally complaining about anything, from wanting a new contract 4 months after you signed them! I had my right back at a point complaining he wanted more game time after 15 games in the season. He started 12 of them. Assistant manager suggestions about training, opposition or whatever is just practically a joke now. Example " let's ask our goalkeeper to start using both feet, despite he can only use his left one to get on the bus. So after he successfully learns to use both feet, our dear assistant manager will suggest to make sure we train our keeper to avoid using his weaker foot" and this endless cycle never ends. This is not something new by the way, it has been part of the FM series since forever. I am actually scared of what is waiting for us in FM 25 with a new engine. God help us all. -
Thank you for the skin update. One minor bug, to report. As seen in the picture below, the player who scored during the game has now a ball next to his profile (which is a welcome change), however it overlaps with the condition icon.
-
Vader17 changed their profile photo
-
Any chance we can can make this amazing skin a bit more 2560 x 1440 friendly? Notice the big gaps on the Clun Info page, especially the kits and the stadium photo areas. And on the second screenshot, the background photo does not cover the whole screen. Obviously these are like, minor thing, but it would really nice for the skin to work a little bit better on bigger screens Thanks a ton for your work though!
-
First of all, huge shoutout to the entire ME development team, the new ME is amazing, way more realistic than ever before. One big issue I've encountered during the beta is, as the title suggests, IFs are acting more like wingers rather than an actual goalscoring threat. PSG save, trying to recreate Pep's Man City tactics, using Mbappe as a left Inside Forward on Attack, he is basically usually lost somewhere between the touchline and the left side half space. When he receives the ball he drifts wide and when he decides to actually cut inside (which rarely happens) he is very easy to defend against. I even received a report from my assistant manager that we are lacking penetration from the left. Initially I believed that it was due to stay wider instruction, but even when I removed it, he can't cut inside and score. 22 appearances in L1 sitting at just 9 goals as an inside forward, my central midfielders have more goals than him
-
I always have either my assistant manager or Head of Performance Analyst informing me about which individual training should be assigned to players. It would be nice not to have the same exact person, 3 days after, warning us that the training he told us to assign is not beneficial to the player. Typical example of this (though this is a player preferred move but the notion is the same): GK Coaches will tell you to teach your GK, to avoid using his weaker foot. Once he finally develops that trait, you GK Coach will ask you to teach the same GK to use both feet. This has been happening for years, half if not all the staff recommendations are completely irrelevant or contradicting to say the least. Likewise, your AM or HoPA, will ask you to train a player to improve his Attacking Movement for example. You apply the training as instructed, 3 days later, the same staff person, you should remove said training because it is not producing any results (after 3 days), or he will ask you to pick another individual training assignment. And this goes on forever.
-
My favorite skin, game feels super weird without it, only "major" issue I found so far, in the club info page, stadium picks do not show despite having a stadium background pack installed, not sure if it's the pack issue or the skin's. (I ve tried using several different stadium packs, none seems to be working)
-
Currently managing Man Utd (first season of the save), using a pretty intense pressing tiki taka based tactic. I've managed to get some very good results (despite not having a really good roster) which had my team at 1st place by 9-11 points before world cup break. Squad comes back from World Cup, I am expecting a somewhat drop off to the performance but this is unreal. In the span of 3-4 games I have lost all my points advantage, only 3 points ahead from 2nd Liverpool, almost every single player in the roster is under 6.90 rating, players underperforming both on and off the pitch (poor training ratings out of nowhere), can't create chances thus I can not score goals, concede goals even from Fleetwood. Best way to describe it is like after the WC, I am managing a whole different team with players that have never played with each other again. This used to happen too in FM 2022 after the Winter World Cup but not to this extend.
