Jump to content
Sports Interactive Community

Danziel

Members+
  • Content Count

    28
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Danziel

  1. Makes sense what you guys say. I though about it like this:
  2. Yes, that is a good point. Both scenarios can be visual I am thinking. It should be live decision making. Though game and the player is important, you seriously don't want take him off, you are getting updates that appear in writing from your physio who is watching him and you are watching the game overall not just your injured player. He can't convince you. And it gets to the point of a obliged live sub in writing in which you have to pick a player in 10 seconds while he is limping off the field in order to bring your sub on before the ball comes back into play. You didn't send someone to warm up or make your call in over 5 seconds? No time to undress, so the sub will be on the sidelines until next whistle.
  3. I want to know what his star rating is, not what his star rating is in comparison to others.
  4. This brought to my mind the image when a player falls down injured and the staff waves stuff at you he "he will recover"/"sub him" this would be nice in the future.
  5. How about this, we talk about Joey Barton as above and I am bottom league and I think he is 5 star rating because Football Manager tells just that. And then we thing to ourselves that reality is that, Joey Barton is a 3 star, 15 or 75 level, a C or an Established Footballer. And that Cristiano Ronaldo is the 5 star, 20 or 99 level, an A or a Legendary Player. I agree, FM has to implement it right if they do decide to do it. I believe that the range of reputation, wages and fees should be determined by the player's overall rating, character, qualities for a certain position or for more. Say a player can vary even up to 40% in value (just a thought) You may buy a player that has good character traits has been playing constantly for his team for three years in a Top 3 league And then you have another one, who is the worst character to work with and is a rising star in a top 10 league Level/star rating/Mark/Status would be same but the price won't be the same.
  6. I think the whole idea of the star/level system is outdated. What it reflects to me is something like there is no internet and no TV and you have to deal with values of other teams and players in comparison to your own. That is real to some extent but except we know which is the highest level of football now. So the real stars/levels should come first, comparisons second.
  7. Thank you for your answer! Hope maybe they add it in the future or Fifa Manager comes back to life or PES Club Manager makes something for PC or Mac. Other than that my passion regarding playing a soccer manager game is left unfulfilled and that makes me sad...
  8. Do players have a numerical level yet based on an algorithm for each position? (such as Fifa or Pes)
  9. Same wish as last year. I wish that FM would give players a level made out of a number for each position. The level to be composed out of an algorithm of his skills. I noticed a screenshot I think in which the game editor has that available already but as for now, the game is still unplayable for me without player levels. The star level is non sense since it adjusts depending on what teammates a player has, so it's not his real level, it's a level in comparison to his teammates. I guess you don't need 55$ from me for implementing that option. Fifa Manager's system of level 0 to 99 plus talent made up of stars was brilliant, PES Club Manager is coming strong with that system on mobile devices. You should implement this soon or you might lose many if PES Club Manager decides to compete or Fifa Manager comes back. I'll be checking FM 17...
  10. If a player has a certain level for each position he plays in; composed out of a number.
  11. Do players have overall level in Football Manager 2016?
  12. thanks but that's not what I want... I want an algorithm that based on his skills from 1-20 to have a rating of 1-20 for each position...
  13. why not make a player's overall rating for each position?
  14. Ok now that I said it another year of waiting for me for the next big thing in football management because it would be a miracle if they put an overall level for this year...
  15. I don't want a change, I want an option... And who said anything about definitive? The 16 overall level can change according to the attributes, the training and all.
  16. Assess, scout everything that is needed but the final result to be a figure. As the attributes range when a player is not scouted properly so should the overall level of the player be at first 15-19 for the example above. After scouting you see he is 16 there 18 there...
  17. I want to easly decide on a 1 to 20 as the attributes are between a player that is 16 as a left wing back and 18 as a left back and a player that is 16 as a left back and 18 as a Left Wing Back I want to have control over buying a player suited to my team's needs and tactics without having to guess. An overall system is needed at least as an option at the begining of the game. And of course with the potential 1-20 as well.
  18. Welshace, even Apple decided to make wider screens due to competition recently, even Blackberry decided to switch to touch screen all I am asking is for some options.
  19. Thank you for your answer forameuss, I'd still like it unhidden though...
  20. Greetings to SI, Football Manager team and fans, Few days ago I decided to give Football Manager 15 Demo a try. I like what I see to a certain point but I want to see more in order to buy the game. So here are my requests or needs for the future of this series and I am sure they will attract other fans to this series and I hope you won't choose to be conservative about it: 1. Players should have an overall level for their favourite positions, you already have an option to highlight the player's attributes for these positions, why let the series players calculate or create their own algorithm which might be inaccurate, create the algorithm for each position based on the player skills and supply the level at least as an option, your competition until last year did that and had the option to play with or without, I know they are not on the market anymore but that doesn't mean you should limit yourselves to one way of doing things. 2. Players should have their level for a number of positions they are used to very well at full potential and others that they have the ability to play in but they are not yet used to. 3. The algorithms for the overall level should be visible and each attribute should be allocated a percentage for the position you are checking to see if a player is suited to play in. 4. Add the option to create a club, create kit, team logo and all the implications of creating a club. 5. Unlimited seasons. Why have a 30 year limit? Increase please! 6. This goes without saying for me, overall rating should be the same for everybody, not like the star system that you have right now that is according to the team. 7. Own a club or buy a club when you make sufficient money, or create a club when you have sufficient money after starting a career. 8. Faces, the graphic part that puts the cherry on the cake for me. Faces like in reality, creating them, seeing them when the player scores a goal, when he is defending, when he gives a throw in is superb. I was a face maker for Fifa series, I've never been for a football management series, would love to... 9. Spreadsheets and financial tools to give you an image of what you are doing especially when you own the club and options to make budgets for each little thing. 10. Would be nice to get a message to know if any of this will be at least proposed. I don't want to wait around. You either want my money or you don't. There are other people that love the things above mentioned, for sure. So meet some new needs if you can and want to do so. I'll be the first to buy when I see on the main website page "new overall level system".
  21. Greetings to SI, Football Manager team and fans, Few days ago I decided to give Football Manager 15 Demo a try. I like what I see to a certain point but I want to see more in order to buy the game. So here are my requests or needs for the future of this series and I am sure they will attract other fans to this series and I hope you won't choose to be conservative about it: 1. Players should have an overall level for their favourite positions, you already have an option to highlight the player's attributes for these positions, why let the series players calculate or create their own algorithm which might be inaccurate, create the algorithm for each position based on the player skills and supply the level at least as an option, your competition until last year did that and had the option to play with or without, I know they are not on the market anymore but that doesn't mean you should limit yourselves to one way of doing things. 2. Players should have their level for a number of positions they are used to very well at full potential and others that they have the ability to play in but they are not yet used to. 3. The algorithms for the overall level should be visible and each attribute should be allocated a percentage for the position you are checking to see if a player is suited to play in. 4. Add the option to create a club, create kit, team logo and all the implications of creating a club. 5. Unlimited seasons. Why have a 30 year limit? Increase please! 6. This goes without saying for me, overall rating should be the same for everybody, not like the star system that you have right now that is according to the team. 7. Own a club or buy a club when you make sufficient money, or create a club when you have sufficient money after starting a career. 8. Faces, the graphic part that puts the cherry on the cake for me. Faces like in reality, creating them, seeing them when the player scores a goal, when he is defending, when he gives a throw in is superb. I was a face maker for Fifa series, I've never been for a football management series, would love to... 9. Spreadsheets and financial tools to give you an image of what you are doing especially when you own the club and options to make budgets for each little thing. 10. Would be nice to get a message to know if any of this will be at least proposed. I don't want to wait around. You either want my money or you don't. There are other people that love the things above mentioned, for sure. So meet some new needs if you can and want to do so. I'll be the first to buy when I see on the main website page "new overall level system".
  22. Fifa Manager series had something similar but they gave the option to have a general level and a talent level which by the way, just the talent was made out of ten stars and the overall level 1 to 99 far better option far better way of assesting a player can be 82 as a right back and 85 as a right wing back, in Football Manager I see 3.0 stars and 2.0 stars for the same thing and the player has the qualities to play there. Also the accuracy was made by the potential of the player to play there, he might've been playing a offensive midfield and he would be even better as a winger if he got match experience, you could see that as in reality you could realize on the training pitch that he is. All this needs to be implemented at least as an option in my opinion. I really hope this things will get promoted and if they do I'll be a fan of the series, hopefully till the next big step when they'll have more licences maybe that day I'll propose something else for the series. Until than maybe get some more second leagues, third leagues, forth leagues of other championships that you didn't get the first league please, I will write in the forum designated for proposals as well.
  23. Well the overall level is made out of stars and there is no explanation what is the difference between gold and silver stars. Also, I don't think Randolph who plays at Birmingham in the second league is a four star player compared to Neuer five star. The difference is far greater! It's not a question of genre, it's a question of accuracy. A player's level should be unkown when he is not scouted at all or not scoted enough. In reality you can see a player's quality by how he moves touches the ball, running off the ball etc... You can't expect the same to assest in the same way for a game at this point. It's far away from reality. I hope somebody reads this and they make the overall level as an option. I takes a lot of time to create an algorithm for each position that is relevant, I hope they'll make it for 16 or something at least since I noticed producers of games don't like to introduce new options as a patch. It's needless to say for me that a player needs an overall level in a game, I don't know what to call make the overall level out of stars, just weak stuff...
×
×
  • Create New...