Jump to content

{FM23-24} Union Berlin: The Terrifying Prospect of Success


Matty Aqua
 Share

Recommended Posts

First and foremost, what a book! I read it this summer and thought long and hard about starting a Union Berlin save.

Have a document full of quotes which I thought I could pull for the save to add useful context about the club...happy to share. 

Keen to see how the tactic plays out, are you instructing those wing-backs to deliver their crossed at anywhere specific? Have seen to find within my save that adding this as a PI makes a real difference.

Will this save take centre stage now? 

Link to post
Share on other sites

On 27/11/2022 at 19:58, Deisler26 said:

Good luck with this! I had a fabulous career on 22 with Viktoria Berlin and I hope yours is as good!

Thanks, I did read it you did about 14 seasons with Viktoria Berlin, will be trying to take care of clubs in Berlin in this save - I just scheduled an away friendly against them to help there finances

On 27/11/2022 at 21:34, Oppiiz said:

What some great opening posts! Really looking forward to see how it goes! 
After reading I had to search Union up on YouTube. Totally understand why you went with them now! 

Thank you kindly, more to come! - Incredible club on and off the field!.

20 hours ago, MattyLewis11 said:

First and foremost, what a book! I read it this summer and thought long and hard about starting a Union Berlin save.

Have a document full of quotes which I thought I could pull for the save to add useful context about the club...happy to share. 

Keen to see how the tactic plays out, are you instructing those wing-backs to deliver their crossed at anywhere specific? Have seen to find within my save that adding this as a PI makes a real difference.

Will this save take centre stage now? 

I'm about half way through and enjoying it!, would love to read through them if you're happy to share.

Played a few games with it, in some matches it works perfectly as it should and other times we get done by opposition quality. I generally have the crosses set to the opposite side of the WB, 

Example: WB (Left) to aim for far side

Absolutely, I really wanted to do this save in FM22 and couldn't move passed it until I did it!, I'll shelve the Czech save for now!.

Edited by Matty Aqua
Link to post
Share on other sites

Really enjoyed the write up! Great depth and looking forward to more 
 

love the club. Their stadium is fantastic in the forest. It’s gave me one of the best football experiences ever. Being from Edinburgh we don’t get treated anywhere near as good as football fans do in Germany. 
 

me and my wife visited Berlin when they were still 2.bundesliga and watched a game against Bochum. Free travel to the game the journey through the woods to the group was magical and the atmosphere was incredible at the game. Throw in some German pints and it was the best place I’ve been to for a game. Hands down beats anywhere else I’ve visited for games.  

Edited by SixPointer
Link to post
Share on other sites

2013609696_UnionBerlinLogo.png.572a66efdbb3b6b118e83e27b321c742.png

Preparing Union Berlin for 2022/23

So you've received the job, shaking the hands with the chairman, posed for your announcement photos, done your media duties, now you're in the drivers seat and ready to guide the club to success!, but where do you start?. Football Manager has forever been terrible at explaining to it's players - how to actually play Football Manager!, this isn't a 'what you should' and 'shouldn't do' blog, but more how I will handle my first day on the job at Union Berlin, after all, you can leave majority of this stuff to your backroom staff and spam that space bar!, but running a well run club requires attention from top top to bottom and as the saying goes - "failure to prepare, is preparing to fail"

---

COACHES

Luckily, I have a small but decent backroom staff to get me started, it feels like a necessary place to introduce some key backroom staff members that will be helping me for the upcoming season. Long serving staff member Sebastian Bönig is my assistant manager and will be my right hand man throughout the season. The backroom team is an area I will look to expand when the finances are in better shape, I know some FM players brutally wield the axe and immediately terminate members of the backroom team, I do not!.

The first thing I want to do is gain support of the playing group and supporters and firing staff can lead to upset and disgruntled players before I have even played the first match!. Also, amortisation!, there's a financial aspect most people don't consider, that's amortisation, mutual termination fees are very costly and replacing them with new staff on potentially higher wages, means your paying both old and new staff members to do the same job, so amortisation is something to consider especially if you're managing a club with debt!. I personally let contracts expire if the staff member isn't someone I deem useful for the long term plans, as most likely there will be a changing of squad players after the first few seasons anyway, so why pay more to train players who might not be here in the future?, just food for thought!.

I want to focus on helping veteran players transition into life after football by becoming part of the club as backroom staff. There's nothing more satisfying than having a player join backroom team and then go on to forge his own managerial career in your universe. Just as players have current ability and potential ability so do your coaching staff and often you will receive an inbox message notifying you that a member of staff is studying for a coaching course, this will increase there attributes as a staff member. Occasionally a player will make a start on gaining his coaching badges while he is still active as a player. Christopher Trimmel is the perfect candidate for a future staff role, and you can even have the conversation gauging a players interest in a role for the future. I don't have any evidence as to what makes a coach attributes improve over time, a combination of coaching courses and potentially allowing the coach to manage academy matches is all the knowledge have, but I figure it's a great place to document the Union Berlin backroom staff development as the save progresses.

728892598_ChristopherTrimmel.thumb.png.53e62b904b216c15cb264bec2281704c.png

*tip! - you can set all your coaches in the pre-season to focus on fitness in the coaching panel, it's not a necessary thing to do, but if you're not training any defensive or attacking drills during the first few weeks, why not have them join in with the fitness drills?, after all they're getting paid right so might as well put the to productive work!.

---

TRAINING

One of the first things I do when taking the position of a club is create training schedules based on the style of play I am trying to play, there is a lot written in other threads about training but this is just the way I approach it, some prefer to simply leave it to the assistant manager. I don't think there is a wrong way to train players, but I do believe you can get the maximum potential out of your players with specific training schedules and balancing rest, training, matches and recovery, again I emphasise that you can train your players how you wish and there is no right or wrong way.

As detailed above we're playing a 3-5-2 system with a heavy emphasis on defensive shape and structure, I'm looking to be leading the league in tackles, blocks, and aerial duels so training should be designed for players to reflect the style of play.

But first lets focus on pre-season were I have built three different schedules solely based around fitness, tactical familiarity and team cohesion, these are the three most important aspects to focus on when taking a new job in my opinion, as a good start to the season is imperative to shaping the season for success.

FOCUS

  • Fitness
    • Pre-season is all about getting those kilometres in the legs, from my experience unfit players don't hit the season in good form and tend to become a bit fatigued and jaded in the February/March months. You don't want your promotion push to be hampered by players being to tired to play, do you?.
  • Tactical Familiarity
    • Getting players to 100% tactical familiarity as soon as possible is crucial, I focus on one tactic and one mentality for the first few weeks to make sure that the base of what we are trying to achieve on the pitch is understood, then create the same tactic with a different mentality and train that as a secondary with some tweaks and adjustments (ex: width, tempo, passing, defensive lines) to make sure players have familiarity with alternative instructions, should I need to make in game changes.
  • Team Cohesion 
    • I put so much importance on team cohesion when joining a new club and there are multiple reasons as to why. Team Cohesion can influence how your team gel together on the pitch, without team cohesion you will see players give away free kicks, penalties, set piece goals, and miss passes and goal scoring opportunities which can result in bad morale and players losing support in the manager quickly. There's also a chance your managing in a country where you don't have language fluency, and potentially neither do some players, this has an effect on the pitch as players will often have neutral or bad body language and not feel comfortable on the pitch, so it's important to have a culture where players are all on the same page and have support the manager.

Pre Season (Light)

1246093534_PreSeasonLight.thumb.png.0c75420537bca7431d2be84beba4df55.png

  • The lighter pre-season schedule has two days of moderate intensity and two days of higher intensity, I use this during the first week and second week of pre-season camp as I want to push the players a bit but not overload them and risk injuries. Also there is three session dedicated to tactical training to balance the load, Building fitness levels and tactical knowledge is key here.

Pre Season (Heavy)

1999675571_PreSeasonHeavy.thumb.png.ac006c306c95e79e3df2ff7ba66b1a6f.png

  • The Heavier pre-season schedule is focused more on pushing the players phsycially. This is the bulk of the pre-season where players build fitness levels with sessions focused on Endurance, Strength and one session dedicated to quickness. Here I also focus more on Match prep sessions and teamwork to help the team gel together. At the end of a heavy week there are two dedicated sessions to recovery and a mutch needed team bonding session.

Pre Season (2 Matches)

1870602746_PreSeason2Matches.thumb.png.abd5b3bedac1e2ad51e12b197190d23d.png

  • The two match schedule is not ideal, but created to gain a little bit of physical output and more sessions dedicated to recovery and match prep. I follow a similar pre-season structure to ** who recently has written an article for View from the Touchline detailing how he goes about setting up his pre-season. I prefer to keep my players on the pitch as much as possible during pre-season which is why I prefer to only play 1 match per week instead of  spending pre-season session in recovery and match review sessions as you can see from the schedule above how much training players are missing in a two match scheduled week.

---

I generally like to push the physical boundaries of my players by switching to Double Intensity for players that have no fatigue and are at 100% conditioning, but of course everything should be monitored by Injury Risk which you can monitor via the medical center.

354874363_DoubleIntensity.thumb.png.bd4a566d3b9f7226c9df5f321f06b1f9.png

*tip! Youth players generally have lighter match schedules therefore spend more time training and developing attributes. (It's widely known that players from the ages of 15 to 18 benefit more from focusing on training). I like to sort the contenders and pretenders out early by setting Double Intensity to players 75% and above to push them a bit more. I would only do this if you have Physio's and Sports Scientists  at your club as the work load is demanding.

1834951168_Under19strainingintensity.thumb.png.c7719122cc93fad8894eb38159c7a729.png

I generally focus my first few matches on weaker opponents just to build some fitness and  sharpness among the squad, rotating heavily and usually playing a side of similar quality every 3 games to get an understanding of the tactic, focusing more on movement, shape and weakness. I can make adjustments to the tactic as I see fit which is why I play a team of significance every 3 matches.

During the season I break my training down into three phases, it might be a bit time consuming to set it up, but there is a methodology involved, below is how I have set up the Low Block training in three different phases of the season at Union Berlin for the season. 

UNION BERLIN - LOW BLOCK TRAINING (PHASE 1)

1592259413_LowBlockPhase1.thumb.png.7af3d46cdc7654aa2cd66f9c6f83df5e.png

  • MONDAY
    • Heavy emphases on Physical training for players not involved in the weekends match followed by Outfield training and some Tactical training.
  • TUESDAY
    • As the team recovers to 50% - 75% conditioning the focus is on our core defensive unit with Aerial training and Ground Defense combined with benefits of the Tactical Familiarity included with Defending Engaged.
  • WEDNESDAY
    • Most of the group should be at 90% - 100% conditioning, three training programs to focus on Phase 1 which is more Tactical Familiarity and General Training (Blue sessions).
  • THURSDAY
    • Again with everyone now at 100% and involved in training, two sessions focused on Tactical Familiarity and a match buff to make sure we give ourselves the best chance not to concede a Set Piece Free Kick.
  • FRIDAY
    • A lighter session focused on the Defensive Shape (giving us a boost in Def Positioning and Marking) and a session on Defending Corners.
  • SATURDAY
    • Match Day!.
  • SUNDAY
    • Recover, Review, Regroup (You can also manually rest players for an extra day or two if they need it) .

As you can see I focus heavily on Tactical Familiarity in Phase 1, almost all sessions will have a component of Tactical Familiarity and Team Cohesion, I generally use a Phase 1 schedule for the first 2 months of the season post pre-season, or until Tactical Familiarity is reached.

UNION BERLIN - LOW BLOCK TRAINING (PHASE 2)

1391358927_LowBlockPhase2.thumb.png.3e028d9c694f2af52a5d3f960af38848.png

  • MONDAY
    • Heavy emphases on Physical training for players not involved in the weekends match followed by Outfield and One on Ones which also allows players to focus on Individual Training.
  • TUESDAY 
    • As the team recovers to 50% - 75% conditioning the focus is still on the core defensive unit with Aerial training and Ground Defense combined with benefits of the Tactical Familiarity included with Defending Engaged
  • WEDNESDAY
    • A slight change in Phase 2 as I focus more on adding some general Physical training along with more attribute specific training for Defensive Attributes.
  • THURSDAY
    • With everyone now at 100% and involved in training, Just one session now on Tactical Familiarity followed by a Goalkeeping session to focus on individual training and a match buff to make sure we give ourselves the best chance not to concede a Set Piece Free Kick. (you can swap out the Goalkeeping session for an extra Match focused session if needed).
  • FRIDAY
    • With Familiarity gained by now we can swap some sessions out for Match Day boosts!, Attacking and Defending Corners gives us an edge as well as works on Heading, Anticipation and Off the Ball for 60% of the session to outfield players.
  • SATURDAY
    • Match Day!
  • SUNDAY
    • Recover, Review, and Regroup (You can also manually rest players for an extra day or two if they need it).

Phase 2 swaps a few sessions focused on achieving Tactical Familiarity for more Individual training attention and some match day boosts!. I would use Phase 2 sessions in the middle of the season possibly resting players logging heavy minutes.

UNION BERLIN - LOW BLOCK TRAINING (PHASE 3)

1225191823_LowBlockphase3.thumb.png.65b24d2ee8fd80a7a66bf3ded904116d.png

  • MONDAY
    • Still an emphases on Physical training for players not involved in the weekends match but also some Overall training and a chance to get out into the community
  • TUESDAY
    • Aerial training and Ground Defense training remain as they solely focus on attributes with a light afternoon session focused on Attacking Movement for some extra match day boosts.
  • WEDNESDAY
    • A much lighter session focused on maintaining attribute growth and players individual training programs
  • THURSDAY
    • Focusing more match day boosts there is just 1 session dedicated to attribute growth for the attacking unit.
  • FRIDAY
    • Delivery and Attacking Corners makes us dangerous as we now can focus on more match day specific sessions.
  • SATURDAY
    • Match Day!
  • SUNDAY
    • Recover, Review, Regroup (rest players for an extra day or two if they need it).

Phase 3 allows me to focus more on attribute development and match day boosts, as this phase is used in the later months of the season, keeping sessions well balanced reduces injuries and allow sessions to be focused mostly on attribute growth for all players but mostly the players in the defensive unit.

Of course there are many ways to gain the most out of the training feature but this is how I do do it. Alternatively you can swap certain sessions for whatever works best to fit your team and design specific schedules for your play style and what you want your players to focus on development wise.

---

JULY 2022

PRE SEASON

Having a 29 man squad meant I had to allow for adequate fitness among all players, rotating line ups as much as possible building up sharpness. I set up matches against a few local clubs in Berlin to help bring in some gate receipts and raise conditioning and sharpness among the group. Overall, I'm happy with the pre-season despite a few injury set backs and looking forward to getting into this save with Union Berlin. I'll be writing more in depth pieces like this one here and there throughout the journey and posting regular updates in this thread. It's through reading threads over the years that I am a better Football Manager, that being said there is one thing left to do and that is play a match!.

286277584_Pre-SeasonFixtures.thumb.png.b6939030048c7231291925a1fbf7315f.png

The season begins in 7 days against our rival Hertha Berlin where I officially make my Bundesliga management debut. I'm going to try and utilize the data hub a bit more in FM23 and gain a better understanding of that side of the game as the season progresses.

But most of all I am glad to have found a save I am invested in and enjoying!.

Thank you for reading!.

 

Edited by Matty Aqua
Link to post
Share on other sites

 

That clip is pretty indicative of how Union Berlin play irl lol. 

What I like about your tactic, Matt is that it has pretty minimal instructions throughout the tactic. Like the training setup (especially for Low Block training)  you created for pre-season as well.

In a Union Berlin save I did recently, I had the Haberer role more of a MEZ-S or CM-A bc of his support of the strikers in the final third &  late runs to the box. But i'll try the regular CM-S role since he & either Thorsby or Schafer are  the swarming central mid pair. 

Link to post
Share on other sites

A great write up, a long but enjoyable scene-setter, and passion that really comes through. A perfect fit for Union Berlin and a club that does deserve the attention you're giving them after their wonderful progression in recent years. Agree on what is said above, no better way to start than with a spicy inter-city derby!

Link to post
Share on other sites

On 03/12/2022 at 04:59, Vico Vito Pep said:

 

That clip is pretty indicative of how Union Berlin play irl lol. 

What I like about your tactic, Matt is that it has pretty minimal instructions throughout the tactic. Like the training setup (especially for Low Block training)  you created for pre-season as well.

In a Union Berlin save I did recently, I had the Haberer role more of a MEZ-S or CM-A bc of his support of the strikers in the final third &  late runs to the box. But i'll try the regular CM-S role since he & either Thorsby or Schafer are  the swarming central mid pair. 

@Vico Vito Pep Thanks!, the tactic is mostly focused on defensive shape, there's not a need for a lot of instructions - I recently actually made a change to the tactic and wanted to see more attacking threat from the midfielders, so I changed the CM to CM-Att for more attacking threat!, so maybe you were onto a good thing all along!.

On 03/12/2022 at 14:54, SixPointer said:

Berliner derby to kick things off! Love it!! I love derbies, football rivalries especially from the same city are something very special! 

@SixPointerthanks for reading as always!, I have a write up coming up next on the Derby!.

5 hours ago, Jogo Bonito said:

A great write up, a long but enjoyable scene-setter, and passion that really comes through. A perfect fit for Union Berlin and a club that does deserve the attention you're giving them after their wonderful progression in recent years. Agree on what is said above, no better way to start than with a spicy inter-city derby!

@Jogo Bonito maybe a bit long, but I wanted readers to understand the club for what it is!, and once you understand Union Berlin you cannot help but be passionate and give the ultimate attention to detail! - thanks for reading and bring on the Derby!.

Link to post
Share on other sites

1507148938_UnionBerlinLogo.png.f26474fc30107f5f6c99fcd0307970d9.png

'THE HISTORY OF THE BERLINER DERBY'

Perhaps the biggest match on our calendar is the Berliner Derby, which is when I will be making my official Bundesliga managerial debut, so it feels necessary to dive deeper into the origins of the Berliner Derby.

I think it's important to give some context to the derby as there is just so much history within Berlin to go alongside the Football Manager aspect of this thread, so I hope you enjoy the history lesson and can learn a little more about football in Berlin, as in Berlin, politics is inextricably linked to football.

---

The city of Berlin was the epicentre of not only one of the most venomous fascist uprisings in human history, but also the symbolic political division of West versus East, 'America versus the Soviet Union' or, 'capitalism versus communism'. The political history of Berlin has shaped the football culture of its people too. It’s evidenced in the vastly differing Hertha Berlin from the west, and Union Berlin from the east.

1652689705_BerlinWallOldSchool.png.ed8b0cd5cd2a04d65a744a47d4f031df.png  1040729297_Unionfans.png.e35fba122e489c387288cff5f6f898f3.png

During the Second World War, Hertha Berlin was the club endorsed by the Nazi party. The 74,000-seater Olympiastadion was built by Hitler’s chief architect Albert Speer in 1936, and the club’s president in the pre-war era was Hans Pfeifer who was a member of the Nazi party installed by Hitler to maintain ideology. Before the reunification of the East and West in 1989, Union and Hertha were effectively located in different countries, Hertha Berlin from West Germany and Union Berlin from East Germany, they were divided into East and West Germany by the Berlin Wall. The Berlin Wall ran through the heart of the city, splitting communities, families, friends and, of course football clubs. The Berliner Derby doesn't just include Hertha Berlin, it also includes BFC Dynamo an east German football club who are currently playing in the fourth tier of German football.

The rivalry between BFC Dynamo and Union Berlin began in the mid-1960's and intensified in the 1970's as players of Union Berlin would often insult BFC Dynamo players with slurs such as "Stasi-pigs", the Stasi was the Ministry of state security also known as the 'Stasi secret police'. The Stasi was a highly effective secret police organization within East Germany and it sought to infiltrate every institution of society and every aspect of daily life of people in East Germany, even including intimate, personal and familial relationships. The "Stasi" is short for the term Ministerium für Staatsicherheit and was one of the most hated and feared institutions of the East German communist government. Erich Mielke was the Head of State Security (The Stasi secret police) and also the president of BFC Dynamo. Between 1979 and 1988, the East German juggernauts BFC Dynamo won 10 straight league titles and twice reached the European Cup last eight, BFC Dynamo were the Bayern Munich of the East. 

1925402221_BFCDynamoplayers.png.7775512a312bc00bca38e9fd2c399a8d.png

During the 1970s, the best team in East Germany was Dynamo Dresden, who had won five Oberliga titles, so Erich Mielke forced their players to move to the capital and turned BFC Dynamo into an overnight success. Players weren’t transferred between teams in the German Democratic Republic (East Germany), but delegated. You could leave your club at any time, but you’d need permission from the GDR to sign for a new one. BFC Dynamo always got the best players and if you were too good to play against them, you joined them, It was that simple.

If a successful team hoovering up all the top talent from their rivals sounds familiar, it was small fry compared with BFC Dynamo's other alleged infringements were. BFC Dynamo played all of their games at the same ground, it didn’t matter what the fixture list said – home or away, they played at Stadion der Weltjugend. Other teams would have to travel to Rostock, Magdeburg, Dresden but everyone had to play at BFC’s ground of choice twice. And if they weren’t winning, the games were extended and referees were ordered to keep adding time on until BFC Dynamo scored.

For a long time, Hertha Berlin and Union Berlin were not always fierce rivals, they were considered "friends behind barbed wire" as a lot of people on both sides longed for a united Germany while the Berlin Wall was standing and even used to show great support to one another on match days. Some Union fans even listened to Hertha’s matches on transistor radios and celebrated whenever a goal went in and there is still a fan friendship group called 'Hertha Union Fruende', as traditionally Union Berlin's rival is the other Eastern Berlin club BFC Dynamo.

On 27 January 1990, just 79 days after the wall fell, Hertha played Union for the first time. It was only a friendly, at the Olympiastadion, but there was no hatred, no violence, no cross-town abuse. Instead, fans congregated communally, symbolically paying their entrance fees in different currencies, singing songs of a reunified city. This was the start of a divided city uniting. Union Berlin and Hertha Berlin didn't actually play a competitive match against each other until the 2010/11 season after Hertha Berlin got relegated to the 2.Bundesliga, Union Berlin fans sang songs mocking the Hertha's relegation but they managed to get promoted that season. Sparking small signs of rivalry Hertha would again be relegated in the 2012/13 season which meant two more derby days!. If Berliners could point to a day when the friendship was destroyed forever, it might be September 3, 2012. That marked the third competitive clash between the teams. An early-season showdown at a full Försterei and the day Union Berlin midfielder Christopher Quiring decided to get personal. The winger notched Union Berlin's consolation goal in a 2-1 loss, he then gave an explosive interview after the game.

474710518_ChristopherQuiring.png.58c1855275660cc3702533cb22b8dd78.png

“They cheer in our stadium,” he spat at TV cameras post-defeat. “That makes me puke! I don’t give a s**t about my goal. When the Wessis cheer in our stadium, I get sick.”

Christopher Quiring was born after the wall came down in a unified Berlin, so it was a change in the way the younger generation was starting to see the derby between the two clubs, no longer with the same global political view of we are fighting the same enemy but a politically football focused view of, you are from the West and we are from the East, and we are different!. He was also talking about ‘Wessis’ which is a semi-derogatory term for those who hail from West Germany, and deemed a step to far.

As with everything in Berlin, the football culture is rapidly changing. Hertha and Union are the two big teams nowadays in the Bundesliga, but the clubs around them are consistently emerging. The number of teams founded by ethnic minorities is exceptional, there are Turkish clubs, Türkiyemspor Berlin and AK Berliner 07, a Jewish club, TuS Makkabi Berlin, a Polish club, FC Polonia Berlin, and a Croatian club, SD Croatia Berlin. Although some of these were founded nearly a hundred years ago, they add to the new face of Berlin, defined by cohesive diverse ethnicities of a once broken city. 

The football culture in Berlin is like no other city in the world, seemingly divided and united at the same time, where there are things more important than red versus blue it’s not everywhere that the games of a cross-city rivalry can be counted on one hand, but this is the uniqueness of Berlin.

No city has been torn apart more than Berlin in the 20th century.

 

---

 

Edited by Matty Aqua
Link to post
Share on other sites

21 hours ago, Matty Aqua said:

1507148938_UnionBerlinLogo.png.f26474fc30107f5f6c99fcd0307970d9.png

'THE HISTORY OF THE BERLINER DERBY'

Perhaps the biggest match on our calendar is the Berliner Derby, which is when I will be making my official Bundesliga managerial debut, so it feels necessary to dive deeper into the origins of the Berliner Derby.

I think it's important to give some context to the derby as there is just so much history within Berlin to go alongside the Football Manager aspect of this thread, so I hope you enjoy the history lesson and can learn a little more about football in Berlin, as in Berlin, politics is inextricably linked to football.

---

The city of Berlin was the epicentre of not only one of the most venomous fascist uprisings in human history, but also the symbolic political division of West versus East, 'America versus the Soviet Union' or, 'capitalism versus communism'. The political history of Berlin has shaped the football culture of its people too. It’s evidenced in the vastly differing Hertha Berlin from the west, and Union Berlin from the east.

1652689705_BerlinWallOldSchool.png.ed8b0cd5cd2a04d65a744a47d4f031df.png  1040729297_Unionfans.png.e35fba122e489c387288cff5f6f898f3.png

During the Second World War, Hertha Berlin was the club endorsed by the Nazi party. The 74,000-seater Olympiastadion was built by Hitler’s chief architect Albert Speer in 1936, and the club’s president in the pre-war era was Hans Pfeifer who was a member of the Nazi party installed by Hitler to maintain ideology. Before the reunification of the East and West in 1989, Union and Hertha were effectively located in different countries, Hertha Berlin from West Germany and Union Berlin from East Germany, they were divided into East and West Germany by the Berlin Wall. The Berlin Wall ran through the heart of the city, splitting communities, families, friends and, of course football clubs. The Berliner Derby doesn't just include Hertha Berlin, it also includes BFC Dynamo an east German football club who are currently playing in the fourth tier of German football.

The rivalry between BFC Dynamo and Union Berlin began in the mid-1960's and intensified in the 1970's as players of Union Berlin would often insult BFC Dynamo players with slurs such as "Stasi-pigs", the Stasi was the Ministry of state security also known as the 'Stasi secret police'. The Stasi was a highly effective secret police organization within East Germany and it sought to infiltrate every institution of society and every aspect of daily life of people in East Germany, even including intimate, personal and familial relationships. The "Stasi" is short for the term Ministerium für Staatsicherheit and was one of the most hated and feared institutions of the East German communist government. Erich Mielke was the Head of State Security (The Stasi secret police) and also the president of BFC Dynamo. Between 1979 and 1988, the East German juggernauts BFC Dynamo won 10 straight league titles and twice reached the European Cup last eight, BFC Dynamo were the Bayern Munich of the East. 

1925402221_BFCDynamoplayers.png.7775512a312bc00bca38e9fd2c399a8d.png

During the 1970s, the best team in East Germany was Dynamo Dresden, who had won five Oberliga titles, so Erich Mielke forced their players to move to the capital and turned BFC Dynamo into an overnight success. Players weren’t transferred between teams in the German Democratic Republic (East Germany), but delegated. You could leave your club at any time, but you’d need permission from the GDR to sign for a new one. BFC Dynamo always got the best players and if you were too good to play against them, you joined them, It was that simple. If a successful team hoovering up all the top talent from their rivals sounds familiar, it was small fry compared with BFC Dynamo's other alleged infringements were. BFC Dynamo played all of their games at the same ground, it didn’t matter what the fixture list said – home or away, they played at Stadion der Weltjugend. Other teams would have to travel to Rostock, Magdeburg, Dresden but everyone had to play at BFC’s ground of choice twice. And if they weren’t winning, the games were extended and referees were ordered to keep adding time on until BFC Dynamo scored.

For a long time, Hertha Berlin and Union Berlin were not always fierce rivals, they were considered "friends behind barbed wire" as a lot of people on both sides longed for a united Germany while the Berlin Wall was standing and even used to show great support to one another on match days. Some Union fans even listened to Hertha’s matches on transistor radios and celebrated whenever a goal went in and there is still a fan friendship group called 'Hertha Union Fruende', as traditionally Union Berlin's rival is the other Eastern Berlin club BFC Dynamo.

On 27 January 1990, just 79 days after the wall fell, Hertha played Union for the first time. It was only a friendly, at the Olympiastadion, but there was no hatred, no violence, no cross-town abuse. Instead, fans congregated communally, symbolically paying their entrance fees in different currencies, singing songs of a reunified city. This was the start of a divided city uniting. Union Berlin and Hertha Berlin didn't actually play a competitive match against each other until the 2010/11 season after Hertha Berlin got relegated to the 2.Bundesliga, Union Berlin fans sang songs mocking the Hertha's relegation but they managed to get promoted that season. Sparking small signs of rivalry Hertha would again be relegated in the 2012/13 season which meant two more derby days!. If Berliners could point to a day when the friendship was destroyed forever, it might be September 3, 2012. That marked the third competitive clash between the teams. An early-season showdown at a full Försterei and the day Union Berlin midfielder Christopher Quiring decided to get personal. The winger notched Union Berlin's consolation goal in a 2-1 loss, he then gave an explosive interview after the game.

474710518_ChristopherQuiring.png.58c1855275660cc3702533cb22b8dd78.png

“They cheer in our stadium,” he spat at TV cameras post-defeat. “That makes me puke! I don’t give a s**t about my goal. When the Wessis cheer in our stadium, I get sick.”

Christopher Quiring was born after the wall came down in a unified Berlin, so it was a change in the way the younger generation was starting to see the derby between the two clubs. He was talking about ‘Wessis’ which is a semi-derogatory term for those who hail from West Germany and deemed a step to far. As with everything in Berlin, the football culture is rapidly changing. Hertha and Union are the two big teams nowadays, but the clubs around them are consistently emerging. The number of teams founded by ethnic minorities is exceptional; there are Turkish clubs, Türkiyemspor Berlin and AK Berliner 07, a Jewish club, TuS Makkabi Berlin, a Polish club, FC Polonia Berlin, and a Croatian club, SD Croatia Berlin. Although some of these were founded nearly a hundred years ago, they add to the new face of Berlin, defined by cohesive diverse ethnicities of a once broken city. The football culture in Berlin is like no other city in the world, seemingly divided and united at the same time, where there are things more important than red versus blue. It’s not everywhere that the games of a cross-city rivalry can be counted on one hand, but this is the uniqueness of Berlin.

No city has been more torn apart than Berlin in the 20th century.

 

---

AUGUST 2022

657677300_UnionBerlinvsHerthaBerlin.png.92094ecdd0950f0fd4e17c6b46cdd4a1.png

An early pass at 7' by Khedira to Sheraldo Becker proved all the work in the system during pre season was paying off as we launched a counter attack early, however Becker was flagged offside and the fans of Union Berlin had to take a breather and calm down....So did I!.

But not for long!, as we continued to break up play scrap for set peaces, Sheraldo Becker leapt up above the pack like a salmon!, scoring a nice header off a corner routine!.

But the elation wasn't for long with Hertha equalizing a few minutes later with a GK mishap we went into half-time 1-1, frustrating!

We broke almost even on possession at half time, so I decided to drop the mentality from Cautios down to Defensive to focus less on retaining the ball and more on shape and quick attacks, until Niko Gießelmann got a red card early in the 2nd half which through all my tactical plans into disarray.

The intensity of the derby was obviously making an impact as Morten Thorsby got show a red card 66' leaving us to 9 men!, followed by an unbelievable 3rd red card of the game this time to Hertha Berlin as Suat Surder takes an early shower, Feisty game indeed!.

But wait there's more to this crazy opening match, as Hertha in all sorts of unorganised defensive chaos play a long goal kick, Diogo Leite heads it on and András Schäfer quickly flicks it onto none other than Sheraldo Becker - who bangs home a wonderful goal! giving us the 2-1 win!

We won the match!, and I am happy with the victory!, naturally momentum charts and XG charts will sway against us in most cases, as we don't focus on possession or retaining control of the ball.

1039558220_HerthaBerlinresult.thumb.png.a0e2ba1ba82b6aab084667fc7bf32060.png

We won the match!, and I am happy with the victory!, naturally momentum charts and XG charts will sway against us in most cases, as we don't focus on possession or retaining control of the ball.

After doing some post match analysis, I thought the defensive line was a little high and possibly could sit deeper at times considering I am playing on cautious or defensive mentality at times, but the image on the right shows promising signs we are winning tackles in wider areas and keeping the area in front of our box clear from play making threats.

AVERAGE POSITION WITHOUT THE BALL vs TACKLES WON

963229966_vsHertha-Averagepositionwithouttheball.png.b6fe9de3cf96a36cc4c47db336495365.png  875132434_vsHertha-Tackleswon.png.69b7b2f31c76efdccff5e8ef74cb7b7b.png

Thanks for reading, I feel as though I have given a good amount of background information into the club and can now start to focus more on the season and matches!

Matty, mate. Wow. What a sensational update. The way you’ve been able to combine the real life stories and history with the action in the game has made this a must read. 
 

I was so enveloped in the history section of this that I’d even forgotten there was a game to play and a congratulations on the result. 

Link to post
Share on other sites

4 hours ago, SixPointer said:

That Berliner posts is one of my favourites ever on the forum.

I love city Derby's and you’ve capitulated it perfect in your update!!

what a result as well and even more so what a bloody battle!

@SixPointerthanks that's a very big compliment!, I spent a bit of time reading up on it and took a bit of time to write a piece like that!.

 

2 hours ago, _Ben_ said:

This is sensational writing Matty! Loving every minute of it.

Cheers @_Ben_ ,no to try and incorporate some stats into the save to make it all come together!. Appreciate you reading!.

51 minutes ago, FM Eire said:

Loving this. ❤ 

 

I think it's nearly everyone's dream to find a club through FM and develop a deep attachment to them. Sadly, I haven't found mine yet but it's great to hear people write about theirs! 

@FM EireI know what you mean, I've had my moments where I have felt a bit directionless with FM. I planned on this save for FM22 and never got around to it, so I had almost an extra 12 months of research into Berlin to make this all come together!.

@MattyLewis11 I hope so!, Imagine a team from Easter Berlin, given all the context of what the city has been through becoming a Champions League winner?...the power of fantasy in Football Manager hey? haha

Seems readers have enjoyed some history incorporated into the writing, I'll punch out a few updates with the season kicking off now, but I'll try and add in some more fascinating and educational writing within the thread as I've enjoyed learning the history of the city too, and find writing about it cathartic!.

Appreciate all the thumbs up and responses! 

Link to post
Share on other sites

On 11/12/2022 at 20:48, MattyLewis11 said:

Plenty of games played, you had quite the baptism of fire. How reliant do you think you are on the goals of Becker? 

Enjoying the detail and seems like you are also buying into what looks like will be a good long term project. 

Given the tactic, I'm very reliant on Becker and Siebatcheu, tho a few role adjustments in the next update will add some more threat from others!

I'm fully invested!, I want this to be a long term save as there are objectives I want to achieve outside of Union Berlin, I would love to see other sides from Berlin start to rise up the ranks also!.

On 11/12/2022 at 21:37, Carambau said:

Fantastic read! Wishing you good luck for your career with die Eisernen  😀

Thank you kindly!.

Edited by Matty Aqua
Link to post
Share on other sites

JANUARY 2023

521225156_Januaryresults.thumb.png.38fb4c08c2fa70d26a23dc9d06089edd.png

We came out of the World Cup break firing on all cylinders, picking up five wins on the bounce and progressing through in DFB-Pokal and we're still in the Europa League, Jordan Siebatheu found incredible form scoring 6 goals in 3 games and picking up a hayrick against Hoffenheim. I also made some transfers looking to sure up the defence for the future. Unfortunately the squad is just to big and some players will have to be moved on this window or in the summer transfer window.

659622569_TransferDeadlineDay.png.0c02b3c3889315c9aba43fbd07a246aa.png

 

TRANSFERS OUT

290770075_TransfersOut.png.a152da2c7c749c6c68a01818e77f73d2.png

TRANSFERS IN

39113922_TransfersIn.png.2662bec754d4573bdc045574258fe697.png

I feel pretty happy with the business we got done, Patric Pfeiffer was dominating the 2.bundesliga and Leandro Morgalla is an 18 year old Model Citizen from 1860 Munich and definitely one I will try to develop for the future, I did try and bid for Ronnie Edwards from Peterborough United but he joined Newcastle as they offered a larger transfer fee.

1595109472_RonnieEdwards-TransferTarget.thumb.png.33c700cedd6ff771a553d94438cdb68d.png

We currently sit 7th in the league but I suspect Bayern, Dortmund and Leipzig will have strong finishes to the season. Jordan Siebatcheu has picked up 6 Man of the Match awards already!.154560641_EndofJanuaryTable.thumb.png.486625b0bfb4f6bcbd247d01a0b67b61.png

That catches it up on the Project re-start, I'll hopefully be able to blog more consistently.

Edited by Matty Aqua
Link to post
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Matty Aqua said:

---

DECEMBER 2022

The World Cup has been and gone, it came home finally to England and Harry Maguire was the key player...who knew!.

As league football starts to resume around the globe it's also that time of year, the January transfer window!, so I'll be writing about the details of january as they come up as I play through the save!.

1321144157_WorldCupfinal.png.e4b9639545bd012c25a390c5878c66d9.png

1259572533_WorldCupresult.png.8b46042a436df850ddf90c26b3669266.png 

---

JANUARY 2023

Typically Union Berlin don't spend outrages amounts of money, and the club still services a heavy debt so it's common for Union to sell and replace players. I have sent my scouts to collect data on leagues in Poland, Switzerland, Netherlands, Austria, Denmark and England which are usual territories Union look to explore, and new scout Eric Gerets is gaining knowledge of Croatia and Hungary which are also areas I will start exploring for young player with potential. The club currently has a few players on higher wages that I will look to move on through out the transfer window as they are not contributing enough to warrant a place in the squad anymore, bigger clubs have started to take notice to a few players within the squad, being the financial position we are in we may have no choice but to sell some key players to generate money and also cut down the debt.

380662144_UnionBerlinFinances.thumb.png.0fc501cb14d7fb63184dd154a996ed4c.png

1162963149_UnionBerlindebt.thumb.png.4614d02976d4545c2a96170ee7586080.png

Backup Goalkeeper Lennart Grill on loan from Bayer Leverkusen on decent wages €15,250 per week which is a lot to sit on the bench. There's no termination option in his contract although he could develop into a decent keeper in the future should Frederik Rønnow decide to not sign a new contract or request a transfer.

507926975_FredreckRonnow.png.df20f9ba25a767bf03fa6f7cc8082e37.png   1145938639_LennartGrill.png.3eba1d2426c1051517f696b61597e1bb.png

241291622_RonnowvsGrill.thumb.png.372dc65bdf6615a43c5b9678f47ac4cd.png

---

1002390245_vsDortmundresult.png.1618801d146b96d8277f6d126d8a8f15.png

We managed to catch Dortmund off guard early but Jordan Siebatcheu couldn't capitalise on two early chances, and although we managed 13 shots to vs Dortmund's 14 we didn't really get many opportunities on target.

The Pass map above reflects how we got caught in Dortmund's press often and created little.

---

As mentioned above, the financial side of Union Berlin is something that needs to be monitored as the club carries a lot of debt which also makes us a selling club, Paul Jaeckel was a player I wanted to keep, he initially wanted a new contract but wanted over €30,000 per week which was far to much for someone who hadn't locked down a spot in the starting 11, he decided he wanted a transfer once contract negotiations broke down and our financial situation leaves us with little transfer budget as the board only initially gave me €549,000 to spend and no room in the wage budget.

1788465478_TransferBudget.png.92b372ee2aebd0b90b9e98d85fa20d3a.png

Arsenal we're sniffing around but it was rivals RB Leipzig who came forward with an offer €6.25M which was an offer I accepted as his contract expires in 2024, the board added €3.2M of the sale to the transfer budget.

2115811127_PaulJaeckeldeal.thumb.png.58319512f4ffb0207748757f38185e5a.png

Kevin Möhwald also joined San Jose Earthquakes for €600k as there was no real future for him at Union Berlin, with two quick sales done at the beginning of the window I had a bit of financial wiggle room to maybe get some deals done. There are areas of the squad that need some attention particularly Left back, Right Back, and Defensive Midfielder as there is a lack of youth coming through in those positions.

2100257099_KevinMohwalddeal.thumb.png.0641f53aef128e6c5a60fd25b7dead34.png

---

1745813762_Pfeifferdeal.thumb.png.851a9ec62f827991d2dd8ab8fa13edd5.png

Having progressed a few days it was time to make the first signing for Union Berlin, I had been tracking Patric Pfeiffer all season so far and he was the best candidate financially available.

€1.8M potentially rising to €3.2M I felt was a good deal and fits the tactic nicely

  • Great height for a CB - 6'5
  • Determined - 17
  • Consistent Performer
  • Enjoys Big Matches
  • Has decent passing, vision, and dribbling for a Center Back
  • Very Strong Left and Right foot!

1610623302_PatricPfeiffer.thumb.png.36fa0f1e9e3857d96aae700f38013f63.png

---

997287083_vsHoffenheim.png.d653f52b8b6f6b26688d519c7a0b1534.png

A match we needed to win, rarely do we win the possession battle, XG and shots on target, and despite conceding two goals we controlled the momentum of the game.

Interestingly we seem to concede almost directly after we score, and this has happened in multiple games I've noticed. A good 3 points after the Dortmund loss!.

  • Jordan Siebatcheu picks up another MOTM 
    • Average Rating 9.0 
    • 1 Goal and 1 Assist
    • 13.7km covered
    • 76% Aerial battles won (13 attempts)

---

1714911034_vsWBresult.thumb.png.2dd45523ecc7a18cdce410ac00068b91.png

Continuing the good form with a classic Union Berlin victory away from home, despite conceding (again, directly after we score!) it as one of the best performances tactically we have given.

Conceding 60% possession and scoring two goals with an XG of 0.76, Sven Michel scored his first Bundesliga goal for the season and Sheraldo Becker scored his 11th and is still leading the goal scoring in the Bundesliga in scoring.

Six points from two games shoots us right up the table!.

---

690204320_vsHB2result.png.49e3d798dcce476ed21df57f083d6b12.png

Derby Day!, I wrote extensively on the history of the Berlin Derby in earlier post.

A good performance but again scoring and then conceding leaves us coming out of the Olmpiastadion with a draw, and potentially three points dropped here.

Timo Baumgartl scored a header of a corner, which is something I am tinkering with as we haven't taken advantage of set piece situations this season.

---

Genki Haraguchi deal.png

Unfortunately I had to make the tough cal to sell Genki Haraguchi, the Japanese International has made quite an impact since arriving in Union Berlin becoming a fan favorite, he was in the final year of his contract and only managed 5 games this season. I accepted the offer as I wasn't planning on re-signing him. Looking ahead to the future I still had some funds left over from the Paul Jaeckel sale and there is currently no real prospect in the defensive mid role as Rani Khedira is 29 and Paul Seguin is 27 and wanted a massive contract to re-sign. I've been scouting the Championship and League One in England for some potential players, as it seems a realistic pathway for young English players caught between - not being good enough for the Premier League, but to good to be left developing in the lower divisions, and came across Peterborough's Ronnie Edwards.

Listed as a Center Back but capable of playing in the Defensive Midfield role, he was a bit short at 5'11 to be a Center Back but already has 15 composure, I think he could develop nicely into a DM and worth the €2.8M investment, he will be mentored by Morten Thorsby.

95796669_RonnieEdwardstransfer.thumb.png.bc4a79b65fc7f631ce7e665dcd433874.png

1633159346_RonnieEdwards2.thumb.png.8ed71f6ea57a9230c9295db78c5e0318.png

---

DEADLINE DAY DEAL

A rather quiet deadline day for Union Berlin but managed to get one final deal over the line signing released Manchester United Center Back Axel Tuanzebe on a free.

With Timo Buamgartl and Diogo Leite on loan I opted to have some security at the CB position going into next season as there release clauses are unlikely to be met due to limited finances.

At 25 years old, I'm giving Axel Tuanzebe a lifeline after a rather injury ravaged career, and could be sold for a good profit in the future.

932793135_AxelTuanzebedeal.thumb.png.f37307133ecc55e5fa75ce9770e69a57.png

1461348315_AxelTuanzebe2.thumb.png.57f0ddcdbbc9f2ac3839efc48061ffb1.png

---

PLAYERS OUT

732229048_PaulJaeckelRBLeipzig.png.b4506efd51b21c076a46cddee4c542b5.png  709592951_KevinMohwald.png.7c0d33a02a96a6c394162d3e7f2d7bad.png  Haraguchi.png.39f02088c2495fcd1697fcd340123907.png

PLAYERS IN

878825127_PatrickPfeiffer.png.e821dfab509e938147ba925f7486f229.png  1451222739_RonnieEdwards.png.09e5be15e79830994807d7402a1d549d.png  1936472369_AxelTuanzebe.png.f944f8082caafa71924e809098f01bf7.png

---

That concludes January, three players out and three players in!, a decent first window in my opinion, topping it off with 35 year old club captain signing on for another year!.

1017262687_Trimmellnewcontract.thumb.png.e09ff7ca20ea6a000872dc29fed738a8.png

Looking forward to getting the players settled in and hitting the back half of the season!.

Next update will be the February/March period, as we prepare for the run into the end of the season!

Thanks for reading!.

I snapped up pfeiffer on a free for Sv Ried second season and he looks a great bit of business. Ronnie edwards as well is someone I see popping up all over the forums.

Have you any ideas why you concede right after scoring? They do say it’s the weakest moment and highest chance to concede. But so regularly I wonder if you could do something tactically and set up a match plan for it. 

Link to post
Share on other sites

@SixPointerPatric Pfeiffer has been a good signing, I scouted him extensively. Ronnie Edwards is kinda new to my knowledge as I haven't done a Peterborough save since FM20!, his development will be key!.

I honestly have no idea!, I think it may be a factor with Team Cohesion not being very strong. I will try and come up with a solution!

Link to post
Share on other sites

52 minutes ago, Matty Aqua said:

@SixPointerPatric Pfeiffer has been a good signing, I scouted him extensively. Ronnie Edwards is kinda new to my knowledge as I haven't done a Peterborough save since FM20!, his development will be key!.

I honestly have no idea!, I think it may be a factor with Team Cohesion not being very strong. I will try and come up with a solution!

Intrigued to see what you come up with. I always find it useful watching back goals conceded. Without the emotion of the match in real time i tend to notice more. Sometimes I switch it to 2d as well to look at positioning and patterns 

Link to post
Share on other sites

34 minutes ago, SixPointer said:

Intrigued to see what you come up with. I always find it useful watching back goals conceded. Without the emotion of the match in real time i tend to notice more. Sometimes I switch it to 2d as well to look at positioning and patterns 

Not bad ideas there mate!

Link to post
Share on other sites

On 25/12/2022 at 12:12, Matty Aqua said:

Not a lot to write about to be honest as the Youth Intake was below average. which sums up the current state of youth football in Berlin and also a bit of 'meh' in terms of results over the last two months.

I'm still really enjoying the save tho and looking towards the off season to move on some players and bring in some new players!

Thanks for reading!, here's to a strong end to season one!.

...Eisern Berlin!

Through the natural ups and downs of the season, you keep your posts informative and great to read. I know you’ll come back stronger. Keep it up Matty!

Link to post
Share on other sites

  • 2 weeks later...
Posted (edited)

Apologies for lack of updates, I've hit a bug in the save and it wont progress past a certain date so i have to go back and replay fixtures from before the World Cup!

 

 

 

Edited by Matty Aqua
Link to post
Share on other sites

21 hours ago, Matty Aqua said:

Apologies for lack of updates, I've hit a bug in the save and it wont progress past a certain date so i have to go back and replay fixtures from before the World Cup!

 

 

 

Nightmare Matty. Takes a lot of energy to do this when it happens so much respect. I’ve seen me throw saves away when it does it. 

Link to post
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, SixPointer said:

Nightmare Matty. Takes a lot of energy to do this when it happens so much respect. I’ve seen me throw saves away when it does it. 

Very annoying, thankfully I had a back up save from just before the transfer window, so I'll have to re-write some updates!

Link to post
Share on other sites

  • 5 weeks later...
  • Matty Aqua changed the title to {FM23-24} Union Berlin: The Terrifying Prospect of Success

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...