Jump to content

The FM23 Youth Academy Challenge


Recommended Posts

AO22YLD.png

2024/25 Midseason Review:

6v6vd5T.png

Multiple things happening here: 1 - the old team aged in dog years over the offseason. 2 - Three long-term injuries for key players. 3 - The youth players are no where near ready yet. Staying up looks like it's going to be a real battle.

Intake Preview:

9yXuJnW.png

Really strong preview. Hopefully at least one player comes in ready to play.

Link to post
Share on other sites

  • Replies 6k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

8 hours ago, Neo_Geo said:

@XaW what is Camara like? I love getting players with a high current ability from an intake, its such a rarity

Ybf0hyw.png

He is good for this level, but I don't like his mix of being an attacking player and the trait of coming deep. So I'm going to try to get that trait removed. Very intelligent player, but not exactly a physical specimen....

Link to post
Share on other sites

2 minutes ago, XaW said:

Ybf0hyw.png

He is good for this level, but I don't like his mix of being an attacking player and the trait of coming deep. So I'm going to try to get that trait removed. Very intelligent player, but not exactly a physical specimen....

Very nice :thup:

Definitely potential for a retrain as a deep lying playmaker, then that trait is an excellent fit. There isn't much of a difference between a DLP and AP just dribbling and flair swapped for tackling and positioning (which you can cover in the one training focus for defensive positioning). This of course still relies on you playing out from the back and not just going over the top of your midfield :D

Link to post
Share on other sites

Was looking to see about having an intake overview with my top 8 intake, but I think I'll reduce to 5 since when I tried posting it there my message needed approval

 

Edited by Neo_Geo
Link to post
Share on other sites

4 minutes ago, Neo_Geo said:

Was looking to see about having an intake overview with my top 8 intake, but I think I'll reduce to 5 since when I tried posting it there my message needed approval

 

If you get it, just leave it for a bit and some of us mods will approve it. There are some stuff that is flagged automatically, either through text or images and we don't really know why at times. So if you do, I'll just accept it as soon as I spot it.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Would people be interested in my yearly update having a 4th infographic that showed the top 5 graduates? If it's overkill I will leave it, just realise that some (like me) like to see the attributes of the best intake. This is what it might look like (started with 8 but the image was too big that it caused my original message to be flagged to be approved :lol: so I reduced to top 5 but just cut off the last 3 so the 5 shown probably aren't the best 5 and its in season 2 rather than just after the intake came in):

760897395_S1_IntakeTop5.thumb.png.d9b068d337de4c0e8475c12cb080bb45.png

Link to post
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Neo_Geo said:

Would people be interested in my yearly update having a 4th infographic that showed the top 5 graduates? If it's overkill I will leave it, just realise that some (like me) like to see the attributes of the best intake. This is what it might look like (started with 8 but the image was too big that it caused my original message to be flagged to be approved :lol: so I reduced to top 5 but just cut off the last 3 so the 5 shown probably aren't the best 5 and its in season 2 rather than just after the intake came in):

760897395_S1_IntakeTop5.thumb.png.d9b068d337de4c0e8475c12cb080bb45.png

Checking the intake players attributes is the most fun part of the whole challenge IMO. It's like unpacking Christmas presents every season. In most posts, it's the first thing I check.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Hello everyone,

I've been reading through all of the 62 pages of this topic and decided to give it a go myself. I had a try with Oriental in Portugal, was at top of my group the entire 2nd season, but lost my last two games and missing out of the promotion group... and the board decided to sack me! I had a A+ rating from the board before those losses  :(. I was really gutted as I was really enjoying the save.

So I want to try again but this time in the Serie D. However, after holidaying for a season I noticed that there are no promotions to Serie D... Is it then allowed to pick one of the teams that finished last in their respective groups?

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

10 minutes ago, Riebow said:

Hello everyone,

I've been reading through all of the 62 pages of this topic and decided to give it a go myself. I had a try with Oriental in Portugal, was at top of my group the entire 2nd season, but lost my last two games and missing out of the promotion group... and the board decided to sack me! I had a A+ rating from the board before those losses  :(. I was really gutted as I was really enjoying the save.

So I want to try again but this time in the Serie D. However, after holidaying for a season I noticed that there are no promotions to Serie D... Is it then allowed to pick one of the teams that finished last in their respective groups?

 

Italy should be ok to play with serie C and up and play with newly promoted clubs there (without using any mods to alter the leagues)

Link to post
Share on other sites

Grosseto 2030/31

20230117175809_1.thumb.jpg.63b67a5c9e04f7d05a18cd378c169515.jpg

20230117175822_1.jpg.311319a123c5701507f0c8e5012d97b7.jpg

We managed to get the last play-off spot which seems to be a good season, but in fact it was a heartbreaking one. We where in second place halfway trough the season but then the board decided to sell the only capable box to box midfelder I had and everything went down the toilet. Such a shame because the starting XI we had in the first half of the season were fantastic.

Squad

20230117175846_1.thumb.jpg.39ebf7fd2e93662051b035b7e9eab79a.jpg

Top players

20230117175939_1.thumb.jpg.1a44c1e3ed4fd937667baff8854fac7d.jpg

The only really good defender we have.

20230117175957_1.thumb.jpg.c8faf0e1d7db8d148a831e0239bc2680.jpg

20 goals in serie B this year. If I know my board well they will sell him for peanuts this summer and leave us useless for next season.

Youth Intake

20230106214729_1.thumb.jpg.90d3f584a2f79fca71d85c6bbdd3d75a.jpg

20230106214737_1.thumb.jpg.61c8482dfbe5ae9f46c171d0f55b870c.jpg

History

20230117175920_1.jpg.338804780ffa6c105c433ba0afe69272.jpg

 

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Hi again,

For my 2nd try I'm moving to la dolce Italia. 

RIno Cosino is taking over:

2026544015_Screenshot2023-01-20at17_25_57.thumb.png.a29c40ebac28c9c7474a4ce4fd46fb09.png

 

My manager profile:

928362413_Screenshot2023-01-20at17_25_43.thumb.png.c75164df7509373e1b549a405d875d4c.png

 

Facilities:

1243561511_Screenshot2023-01-20at17_25_37.thumb.png.91eded94261db64ce596bb29f87e539e.png

To be honest, I've never heard of this team, so we'll see how it goes :-). Hopefully they're more patient than in Portugal

Link to post
Share on other sites

spacer.png

Season 2
Division 2 South Svealand


spacer.png

Super close season! 9 points between 1st and 9th
We changed tactic this season and i think its for the better, but i think its good we dident get promoted this season. Since this season we dident use any of the youth academy players we got last season. Hoping to get some good youth soon, the starting squad isent getting any younger.

Promotion Race:
 

Spoiler

f93734f6cc7cf5380e24025fdba02f2f.png


Season Preview:
 

Spoiler

16ba055cb92228602cffc206ca076b9d.png



Coaching course:
The board is really generous with the courses already studying for continental B!

Spoiler

spacer.png


Youth Preview:
 

Spoiler

aba33f11411211acd0ec88a064776bd6.png


Youth intake squad:
 

Spoiler

55f758293700791ffa5e29c1a8c87846.png

Transfers:
 

Spoiler

30598c2d897790f0ecd128e3cff4dfb9.png


Season Squad:
 

Spoiler

9cc261cfaa5cd797cf1e762acaa7d78a.png


Youth U19 league:
 

Spoiler

4a684ca3323c076f3e6186b4b9cd79e7.png

a7d58b3a547a97b31db1d621deb0a108.png

Link to post
Share on other sites

44 minutos atrás, ludak disse:

5410640.png.89dfe9baa3dbde087fd152903cb5c06c.png

ND Dravinja Slovenske Konjice Season I

 

Squad  I  Transfers  I  Finances

 

 

spacer.png

 

A wild season really, we win a game 6-1, then lose 5 in a row, and it was up and down mostly. But in the end we stayed in the league which was the goal.

 

spacer.png

 

Baranja   Majcen

 

The intake was really bad, I expected much better when I got Pušnik as HOYD. but maybe we'll have more luck next year.

 

spacer.png

 

 

I guess that's all for now, until the end of next one!

I hope your second season goes a way better than mine.

Edited by The7Striker
Link to post
Share on other sites

AO22YLD.png

2024/25 Season Review:

ONZmiIy.png

X1A9E1y.png

A weird season where at times we were actually midtable, but then faltered down the stretch. As stated before the players are either too old and regressing or too young and facilities aren't helping development enough. There are a few good players in prime though.

QdfgP6o.png

cF8yVcO.png

Not included in this info are three players that retired and two I released as they were older and not good enough. I'd rather give younger players playing time. At the end of the season there was a takeover, but the finances boost came from a loan so we'll be back to underwater fast. 

Youth Intake:

c5Alu9d.png

zP43TKD.png

A good crop of talent, but none ready to play now and develop will be slow at the club.

2025/26 Season Preview:

Cp51Dn2.png

GUygDWQ.png

Looks like a struggle season again. I don't see an immediate path forward, and the recent movement here on completing in new countries has peaked my interest in something else. I'm pausing this save and will come back to it later. I'll post later with the new one :)

Link to post
Share on other sites

9 horas atrás, Daddy disse:

AO22YLD.png

2024/25 Season Review:

ONZmiIy.png

X1A9E1y.png

A weird season where at times we were actually midtable, but then faltered down the stretch. As stated before the players are either too old and regressing or too young and facilities aren't helping development enough. There are a few good players in prime though.

QdfgP6o.png

cF8yVcO.png

Not included in this info are three players that retired and two I released as they were older and not good enough. I'd rather give younger players playing time. At the end of the season there was a takeover, but the finances boost came from a loan so we'll be back to underwater fast. 

Youth Intake:

c5Alu9d.png

zP43TKD.png

A good crop of talent, but none ready to play now and develop will be slow at the club.

2025/26 Season Preview:

Cp51Dn2.png

GUygDWQ.png

Looks like a struggle season again. I don't see an immediate path forward, and the recent movement here on completing in new countries has peaked my interest in something else. I'm pausing this save and will come back to it later. I'll post later with the new one :)

Well, I bet it will be in Romania. You still have some accounts to settle :cool:

Link to post
Share on other sites

image.thumb.png.9f07f85f92f73c1966b860add4058f14.png

Cardiff Corinthians - Season 2047/48 Review (s26)

Similar season to last season.  We failed to qualify for the group stage of the Champions League for the second season in a row but did manage to make it out of the group stage of the Europa League and through to the second knockout round, where we lost 2:6 on aggregate to Brentford.

The biggest thing to happen this season was our average attendance in the league.  We managed an average of over 1,000 per game for the first time, which is also the first time any team in Wales has achieved this.  I am hoping this is a sign that the league reputation is growing and that this might be seen in our intakes in time.

A I mentioned a few updates ago, I am not bothering showing loads of screenshots as not much is happening but have shared the summaries below.

image.thumb.png.1d3bb23fedf127843aede9382be33615.png

image.thumb.png.7e23eb1cce035887879c850ddd0abc34.png

image.thumb.png.207f93402e69f298550c7b9f8e4fcc46.png

image.thumb.png.5039e64c0baa0266dcbb149f91394568.png

Fans Player of the Season

image.thumb.png.48b4e6c6508e54f5aec3cd3f89ea5ab2.png

image.thumb.png.22b3187a3ff8d5a47474ce7bbcb63c29.png

Link to post
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, the_hdk said:

@libbyshuss finally CL! great progress. congrats.  alo Gio looks amazing. That speed!!!

yeah, Gio is the main reason I'm still going with this save. I wanna see how good he gets! my AssMan still thinks he can improve a lot so it should be fun finding out. hopefully he can lead us to glory!

Link to post
Share on other sites

image.png.318445b7caaf02e0f1265969898a54e2.png

image.png.70b13cb6d0eb90af700ff4409368eee1.png

image.png.aac647439b7ce49460edb604fdb5d33e.png

... and no option to improve youth facilities.  This just needs sorting out (I understand this still isnt fixed in FM23)!

We're spending a fortune on youth coaching and recruitment each year.  Our last youth facilities upgrade was about 8 years ago (up to Great, now back down to Good) and cost £2m, so ~250k per year.  Our youth costs (training and recruitment) are costing over £3.5m per year!

Shambles.

Spoiler

image.png.85927979c6dd4c20901eced9e84f07ee.png

Spoiler

image.thumb.png.d3b2eed03d6c7152d50b24e15019557e.png

Link to post
Share on other sites

24 minutos atrás, JAwtunes disse:

image.png.318445b7caaf02e0f1265969898a54e2.png

image.png.70b13cb6d0eb90af700ff4409368eee1.png

image.png.aac647439b7ce49460edb604fdb5d33e.png

... and no option to improve youth facilities.  This just needs sorting out (I understand this still isnt fixed in FM23)!

We're spending a fortune on youth coaching and recruitment each year.  Our last youth facilities upgrade was about 8 years ago (up to Great, now back down to Good) and cost £2m, so ~250k per year.  Our youth costs (training and recruitment) are costing over £3.5m per year!

Shambles.

  Mostrar conteúdo oculto

image.png.85927979c6dd4c20901eced9e84f07ee.png

  Mostrar conteúdo oculto

image.thumb.png.d3b2eed03d6c7152d50b24e15019557e.png

Tbh I dont know how you still have the energy to keep that save going. That bug is really holding you back. :(

I hope 23.3 can fix that and a bunch of other stuffs already reported.

Link to post
Share on other sites

FHOLvDJXoAcI2q3.png.8aba2ee95b7c94e3fc502336aa928a9f.png

                                                                             Season 2023 / 2024

                                                          3rd in Serie C / C - Won promotion playoff

 

Dont like failing so started over with Catania trying to not repeat my mistakes :) 

20230121213141_1.thumb.jpg.13b13619a3cdfb0e326183630186218a.jpg

20230121213052_1.thumb.jpg.fbc296fcf5690b9866c842fd86ed8735.jpg20230121213117_1.thumb.jpg.dde60fbcf2616cd6538f85baeb8e2a12.jpg

 

GL ALL !! :) 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Chernomorets 1919 Burgas - Vtora Liga (Bulgaria)

Chernomorets_1919_new.png.185077264912f3f0315d85655b0a905c.png

 

I have decided to park my Sacavenense save for the moment in favour of tackling one of the nations that is still not yet completed. I toyed with a couple of other leagues, namely Romania and a return to Hungary but ended up settling on a place I have never managed, Bulgaria.

141118074_Screenshot2023-01-22at11_31_11.thumb.png.89f8c7ad3e595d5502b6a8d580f1a5c2.png

Chernomorets 1919 Burgas look an ideal candidate for the challenge, starting with decent training facilities and above average youth recruitment coupled with a 22,000 capacity stadium giving us a solid base to work from. We are already fully professional which always helps developing academy graduates early on in a save. The club itself was 'founded' in 2015 following financial struggles of their predecessor Chernomorets Burgas. Interestingly FM seems to have kept the old club's history on the screenshot above even though by rights they are a different club entirely. The Bulgarian second tier has four relegation spots, with a straight 30 game season and no splits or playoffs as far as I can tell. We have the biggest squad of the four promoted sides but with the squad's average age pushing 30 it won't be long before we start to rely on the older players. One small item of concern is that although we have a £8,600 weekly wage budget and decent facilities our ticket prices are £1 and with only 200 season ticket holders I'm not sure how we plan to fund what looks like a high outlay at this level.

 

914697764_Screenshot2023-01-22at11_30_52.thumb.png.ecda6beddef5d8e6c0553c2148c38aa2.png

1287569213_Screenshot2023-01-22at11_31_33.thumb.png.364468eebfee890b55238dc32dcd0faf.png

 

Edit - I've just noticed that the game is for some reason showing the greyed out in-game editor option on my screen, but it is disabled in my settings. Does anyone know why it's showing as used when it isn't even enabled?

77121226_Screenshot2023-01-22at12_07_35.thumb.png.08b3b12b6e748017237a8ea1d36b78de.png

 

Edited by officiallydeej
Link to post
Share on other sites

9 minutos atrás, officiallydeej disse:

Chernomorets 1919 Burgas - Vtora Liga (Bulgaria)

Chernomorets_1919_new.png.185077264912f3f0315d85655b0a905c.png

 

I have decided to park my Sacavenense save for the moment in favour of tackling one of the nations that is still not yet completed. I toyed with a couple of other leagues, namely Romania and a return to Hungary but ended up settling on a place I have never managed, Bulgaria.

141118074_Screenshot2023-01-22at11_31_11.thumb.png.89f8c7ad3e595d5502b6a8d580f1a5c2.png

Chernomorets 1919 Burgas look an ideal candidate for the challenge, starting with decent training facilities and above average youth recruitment coupled with a 22,000 capacity stadium giving us a solid base to work from. We are already fully professional which always helps developing academy graduates early on in a save. The club itself was 'founded' in 2015 following financial struggles of their predecessor Chernomorets Burgas. Interestingly FM seems to have kept the old club's history on the screenshot above even though by rights they are a different club entirely. The Bulgarian second tier has four relegation spots, with a straight 30 game season and no splits or playoffs as far as I can tell. We have the biggest squad of the four promoted sides but with the squad's average age pushing 30 it won't be long before we start to rely on the older players. One small item of concern is that although we have a £8,600 weekly wage budget and decent facilities our ticket prices are £1 and with only 200 season ticket holders I'm not sure how we plan to fund what looks like a high outlay at this level.

 

914697764_Screenshot2023-01-22at11_30_52.thumb.png.ecda6beddef5d8e6c0553c2148c38aa2.png

1287569213_Screenshot2023-01-22at11_31_33.thumb.png.364468eebfee890b55238dc32dcd0faf.png

GL. I had a nice save there a few months back. Hope you can complete there :D

Link to post
Share on other sites

33 minutes ago, officiallydeej said:

Edit - I've just noticed that the game is for some reason showing the greyed out in-game editor option on my screen, but it is disabled in my settings. Does anyone know why it's showing as used when it isn't even enabled?

77121226_Screenshot2023-01-22at12_07_35.thumb.png.08b3b12b6e748017237a8ea1d36b78de.png

 

It's a bug that I've seen from FM 22. I'd recommend sending a screenshot of that SI for a bug report. They'll ask for the save file as well, but there's not much you can do outside of that.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Agora, officiallydeej disse:

Thanks @The7Striker. I was annoyed that I didn't push on and finish the challenge in Portugal but we'd stopped progressing and I lost my love for the save. Looking forward to this one and the added challenge of it being a non-completed country provides extra motivation!

True, hope you beat Ludos and CSKA :cool:

Link to post
Share on other sites

10 minutes ago, JLAB said:

It's a bug that I've seen from FM 22. I'd recommend sending a screenshot of that SI for a bug report. They'll ask for the save file as well, but there's not much you can do outside of that.

Thank you. From what I can work out it's because I was playing on a different save this morning with the editor enabled then set up this one as a new game, which seems to have confused the game into thinking it was used on this save when it wasn't.

I've restarted the game and setup a new game again and it's now behaving correctly so just holidaying back through to get Chernomorets again.

 

Edit - Sorted - Restarting the game and starting a new save fixed it, rest of my first post still stands!

 

1191061321_Screenshot2023-01-22at12_43_38.thumb.png.eee42241cd3f6e99a5d942f02e278ab3.png

496870736_Screenshot2023-01-22at12_43_51.thumb.png.05f27cc0b3b57fcf5547ad1bd504644c.png

Edited by officiallydeej
Link to post
Share on other sites

 

Well, I'm surprised it took as long. We just were terrible. We had 7 points in our first 3 matches and I though we would be better than expected, but our defence was just sooo bad. We had no shot in most games. 

Up to greener pastures!

1480983512_Screenshot2023-01-22at14_53_31.thumb.png.00d93dd3a123ee14be33ed801492132c.png

Link to post
Share on other sites

I decided to move to Bulgaria as well. My girlfriend is Bulgarian and I spent most of my summers in Varna. I reloaded a couple of times and I decided on this squad: Sevlievo Rakovski. They have good facilities for this level. However all my players are on amateur contracts and most of them are not interested in signing new deals... This might be a very short save :-D 

1007370579_Screenshot2023-01-22at00_56_04.thumb.png.d1f4653f988dcc061cae9b3860caddd3.png

Link to post
Share on other sites

MIPW92l.png

2023/24 Midseason Review:

TUXBeUU.png

Off to a real good start and promotion is a real possibility. 

ae3FaAX.png

p32eAQR.png

A good start and good finances here meant I could get some upgrades.

Intake Preview:

bWYD6yA.png

No immediate weaknesses I can see right now. Lacking depth at fullback so it's good that's A rated. 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...