Jump to content

[Germany] Data Issues


Recommended Posts

  • Replies 779
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

The Managing Director at Schalke isn't Peter Peters. He left schalke earlier this year. He also wasn't the Managing Director he was the chief financial officer. 

https://schalke04.de/verein/finanzvorstand-peter-peters-verlaesst-fc-schalke-04/

The closest Schalke has to the Managing Director is the "Aufsichtsrat vorsitzender/ chairman of the supervisory board". Until 2022 Dr. Jens Buchta tkes this position after Tönnies resignation. 

https://schalke04.de/verein/schalke-04-e-v/aemter-und-raete/aufsichtsrat/

https://schalke04.de/verein/dr-jens-buchta-aufsichtsratsvorsitzender-s04/

Link to post
vor 23 Stunden schrieb 30plp:

Almost every Herta BSC player is considered as a star player with a maxed-out potential. We can't see their current ability either. I'm not quite sure if it's data-related or not, sorry if it isn't or if someone already reported it!

 

Capture.PNG

It seems that for some reason your assistant manager is sacked when you take over Hertha right now, that explains the inaccurate ratings. Had the same when i took over Hertha but the DB ratings aren't like that.

Link to post

HI, not sure if this is a data issue, but i have seen friends of mine in the game buying Haaland in the first transfer window (Playing as Man Utd & Chelsea). Given he has only just signed for Dortmund in January why is it so easy for them to sign Haaland in the first window?  surely he would be like every other player that has just signed for a club recently and be unwilling to discuss terms? 

also i understand that he might have a £68m release clause in his contract but it is rumoured that the clause wouldn't kick in until summer of 2022 so surely when people are buying him for as little as £70m this is unrealistic especially in the first window. 

 

Link to post
23 hours ago, Reddiablo said:

Several adjustments have obviously been made,
However we can still use someone to help us out with Stuttgart - so could you provide some useful info? Give it a shot please.

I've sent you a detailed pm about this yesterday. Hopefully it's of help. :)

Link to post

Hello, I think there are some issues with the stats (and potential) of some of the Bayern Munich II and U19 players:
B-Team:

  • Angelo Stiller

He is the outstanding player of the B team and his stats should reflect that.
All play goes through him, so  "Off the ball"  needs to be a lot higher, aswell as "Composure", "Concentration" and "dribbling". "Starmina" also should be higher, he plays every game, for 90 minutes (except injuries of course). As he is the set piece taker, "free kicks" and "corners" should also be increased. "Determination" of 4 is too low, he seems to be leaving Bayern at the end of the season, due to lack of 1st team minutes. This alone should make his determination higher from my understanding.
His current ability should probably be among the highest in the squad (I'd say a Bundesliga 2 player easily) and potential ability should not be (much) lower than Adrian Feins.

  • Fiete Arp

His free kicks are much better than 10. He scored 1 this season, hit the post with another and they are always dangerous in general. The issue with him being unable to play, has already been adressed from what I have read.

  • Chris Richards

It has already been adressed, that he needs the ability to play RB. But also hist stats should be higher to reflect that. Higher crossing and ball controll (see Bayern game vs Hertha). Determination 10 also seems low for him. He should be closer to the 1st team in gernal.

Obviously I cant see the exact potential ratings, but Zaiser shouldnt be one of the better talents and in the same range as Dantas and better than Richards, Kühn and especially Stiller, as they are MUCH better.

U19:

  • Jamal Musiala

Has already been mentionend, should be better in general (but I think has already been adjusted)

  • Bright Arrey-Mbi

He should be able to play LB. He was tested there for the 1st team just before the UCL knockout tournament, and then went to Portugal as part of the squad as a LB. Mainly his technical stats should be bumbed up, so he can play there.

  • Malik Tillman

IG he is much more of a CM than a striker (deep lying forward), the position he has always played in mans football. He also scored at an impressive rate, so his "Finishing", "Dribbling" and "Off the ball" should be increased to make him more of an attacker than a (defensive) mid.

  • Lasse Günther

While his stats seem good to me, I think his potential should be better. He is considered one of the better talents from Germany, born in 2003. (potential might be at the lower point of its range tho, but it should be high enough to become a Bundesliga player at least)

  • Jamie Lawrence

So far this season he has been a starter for Bayern II and has looked good. He should be much more of a ball playing CB than he is, so increases in his technical stats aswell as his general defensive stats are needed. Determination 5 also seems randomly low, same goes for his potential (similar to Günther, but he has proven more so far).

At last, some of the better talents are missing. Luca Denk, Armindo Sieb (who already had his debut for the 1st team), Mamin Sanyang. I understand that its hard (impossible) to do the research for all the players, but I feel like these should be in, as they are some of the best talents.

If needed, I can go into more detail regarding some of the players.
Thank you for your work!

Edited by Fabi
Link to post

Lukas Spalvis (1. FC Kaiserslautern):
Lukas Spalvis has had cartilage damage on his knee for a relatively long time. Unfortunately this has been removed from the current database.

Elias Huth (1. FC Kaiserslautern):
His contract runs until 2021 in the game, but in reality until 2022.

Link to post
3 hours ago, Reddiablo said:

This commercial is nice - but it tells absolutely nothing valuable for FM :(

 

But I have looked into it and will add a cooperation. Thanks.
 

To add to this... this article gives more detail and mentions youth development.

https://www.indiansuperleague.com/news/fc-goa-announce-strategic-partnership-with-bundesliga-outfit-rb-leipzig
 

Here is the article for Hyderabad and Dortmund..

 

Link to post
22 hours ago, Fire_03 said:

Yes and thats correct

Fiete Arp decided at start of the season, that he will not play in any match for Bayern Munich. He will only play for the II team in the 3.Liga.
So we have set this correctly .

https://www.sportbuzzer.de/artikel/bericht-fiete-arp-bayern-profis-zweite-mannschaft-hsv-talent-flick-reaktion/

Probably said already but looks like arp has gone back against his decision and played for the first team

 

https://www.google.co.uk/amp/s/www.bavarianfootballworks.com/platform/amp/2020/10/16/21519050/bayern-munich-hansi-flick-fiete-arp-robert-lewandowski-joshua-zirkzee-eric-maxim-choupo-moting

Link to post
1 minute ago, Wtfisgoingon said:

Florian Wirtz needs to be better, he's a key player for Bayer Leverkusen. Players like Weiser and Dragovic need to be downgraded a lot. Weiser was recommended as Important Player, in rl even CB Dragovic plays as RB instead of him and he's not even registered for Europa League.

You are not telling us WHAT and WHY, so this is not very helpful I'm afraid.

Please note that Wirtz has been mentioned around 5 times here. He has been looked at for final release.

Link to post
2 hours ago, rooneyknott89 said:

Dayot Upamecano release clause on the game is £91m

However his actual clause is around £50-55m and drops down to £38m next summer

We know. This will be fixed as best possible. Thanks :)

Link to post
11 minutes ago, Reddiablo said:

You are not telling us WHAT and WHY, so this is not very helpful I'm afraid.

Please note that Wirtz has been mentioned around 5 times here. He has been looked at for final release.

Wtf what? If you are responsible for Bundesliga ratings you should be aware that Weiser is RB #4 or 5 in Leverkusen and wasn't even included in the EL squad even though they rotate their entire back 4 every game. He shouldn't be a player that is better than Bender and is recommended as Important Player.

Also Arias has a optional fee in the game while it's mandatory after 15 games in real life. If you are so aggressive for pretty obvious observations, do you even watch Bundesliga in real life?

Link to post

Heidenheim

-          Johannes Gessler could be added as a Physio (https://www.fc-heidenheim.de/profis/kader.html)

Nürnberg

-          Nathaniel Weiss, Florian Klausner and Fabian Gerber seem to no longer be with the club, at least the current Staff list doesn’t include them (https://www.fcn.de/profis/team/trainer/)

-          Tom Krauß is on loan from Leipzig, he is not permanently at the club (https://www.transfermarkt.de/tom-krauss/profil/spieler/405687, https://www.transfermarkt.de/klauss-holt-rb-leipzigs-krauss-nach-nurnberg-bdquo-musste-nicht-lange-uberlegen-ldquo-/view/news/367276)

Darmstadt

-          Sven Thur is no longer with the club (https://www.sv98.de/home/lilien/kader/)

Braunschweig

-          Marcel Goslar should be a Performance Analyst, not a Coach (https://www.xing.com/profile/Marcel_Goslar, https://www.transfermarkt.de/marcel-goslar/profil/trainer/69594)

Aue

-          Marco Kämpfe should be a Fitness Coach, not a Coach (https://www.fc-erzgebirge.de/teams/1-mannschaft/mannschaftsfoto/)

FC St. Pauli

-          Christoph Hainc Scheller could be added as a Fitness Coach (https://www.fcstpauli.com/teams/profis/christoph-hainc-scheller/)

-          Jannik Niden could be added as a Performance Analyst (https://www.fcstpauli.com/teams/profis/jannik-niden/)

-          Dominik Körner could be added as a Physio (https://www.fcstpauli.com/teams/profis/dominik-koerner/)

-          Martn Stawoswki should be Martin Stawowski, probably a typo

Hannover 96

-          Ralf Blume is no longer with the club (https://www.sportbuzzer.de/artikel/veganer-kult-physio-schluss-nach-einem-halben-leben-hannover-96/)

-          Thorsten Klopp could be added as a Physio (https://onefootball.com/de/news/nachste-verstarkung-hannover-holt-klopp-26111012, https://www.transfermarkt.de/thorsten-klopp/profil/trainer/26995, https://www.hannover96.de/saison/unser-team-202021.html)

Holstein Kiel

-          Fabian Franzen could be added as a Physio (https://www.holstein-kiel.de/spieler/fabian-franzen/)

-          Maurice Johnson could be added as a Physio (https://www.holstein-kiel.de/spieler/maurice-johnson/)

-          Timo Syroka could be added as a Physio (https://www.holstein-kiel.de/spieler/timo-syroka/)

-          Marco Komenda (https://www.transfermarkt.de/marco-komenda/profil/spieler/335631) and Ioannis Gelios (https://www.transfermarkt.de/ioannis-gelios/profil/spieler/156676) could maybe get upgraded a bit, since they both have been regulars this season and start the game at Kiel II, but I don’t know the players well enough to offer suggestions on specific upgrades

Karlsruher SC

-          Jean-Marc Gobin seems to no longer be working for the club (https://www.ksc.de/profis/sportliche-leitung/funktionsteam/)

-          Johannes Haberlandt could be added as a Physio (https://www.ksc.de/profis/sportliche-leitung/funktionsteam/)

-          Jörg Jäckh seems to no longer be U19 Assistant Manager, Transfermarkt still lists him in that role (https://www.transfermarkt.de/jorg-jackh/profil/trainer/42022), Karlsruhes homepage does not (https://www.ksc.de/akademie/mannschaften/u19/team/)

-          The same goes for U19 Fitness Coach Max Kuberczyk (https://www.transfermarkt.de/max-kuberczyk/profil/trainer/49833, https://www.ksc.de/akademie/mannschaften/u19/team/)

SC Paderborn

-          Johannes Dörfler was retrained as a Right Back and has played some game there this season (https://www.transfermarkt.de/johannes-dorfler/leistungsdatendetails/spieler/329324/wettbewerb/L2/saison/2020)

-          Thomas Henning is no longer Head Performance Analyst at Dresden, he is now Chief Scout at Paderborn (https://www.scp07.de/Teams/Profis/Mannschaft/, de.linkedin.com › thomas-henning-80a68a9b)

Greuther Fürth

-          Fürth has no Coach called Petr Roman, he is probably the same person as Fürth II Manager Petr Ruman who used to also work as a coach for the First Team, but he no longer does so, at least the homepage only has him as Fürth II Manager (https://www.sgf1903.de/de/teams/profis/trainer, https://www.sgf1903.de/teams/nachwuchs/mannschaften/u23/)

-          Carsten Klee should be Head Physio, not just a simple Physio (https://www.sgf1903.de/teams/profis/betreuer/)

-          U19 Manager Marco Ried could be added (https://www.transfermarkt.de/marco-ried/profil/trainer/20527)

-          The AI puts Daniel Adlung in the U19 at the start of the game, he should be a Player/Assistant Manager at Fürth II (https://www.sgf1903.de/teams/nachwuchs/mannschaften/u23/)

-          Roberto Hilbert is not a Fürth II Fitness Coach, he is Fürth II Assistant Manager (https://www.sgf1903.de/teams/nachwuchs/mannschaften/u23/)

Sandhausen

-          Rick Wulle should be better than Philipp Heerwagen, he has been the Nr. 2 ahead of him since last season already (https://www.transfermarkt.de/rick-wulle/leistungsdatendetails/spieler/302388/wettbewerb/L2/saison/2020, https://www.transfermarkt.de/rick-wulle/leistungsdatendetails/spieler/302388/plus/0?saison=2019&verein=&liga=&wettbewerb=L2&pos=&trainer_id=)

VfL Bochum

-          Jörn Menger could be added as a Fitness Coach (https://www.vfl-bochum.de/profis/mannschaft/trainerstab/)

-          Norbert Lemcke is Rehtrainer and could be added as a Fitness Coach, Sports Scientist or Physio (https://www.vfl-bochum.de/profis/mannschaft/trainerstab/)

-          Rexhep Kushutani could be added as a Sports Scientist (https://www.vfl-bochum.de/profis/mannschaft/trainerstab/)

-          Niklas Honnete could be added as a Performance Analyst (https://www.vfl-bochum.de/profis/mannschaft/trainerstab/)

-          David Siebers is U16 Manager so he should probably be an U19 Coach, not a Coach (https://www.vfl-bochum.de/talentwerk/unser-konzept/personal/trainer/)

-          Heiko Butscher should be U19 Manager and Assistant Manager, not only an Assistant Manager (https://www.vfl-bochum.de/talentwerk/unser-konzept/personal/trainer/)

-          Marc-Andre Kruska could maybe be added as U19 Assistant Manager, as he is a pretty well-known former Bundesliga player (https://www.vfl-bochum.de/talentwerk/uebergangsbereich/u19/team/, https://www.transfermarkt.de/marc-andre-kruska/profil/spieler/20264)

Vfl Osnabrück

-          Mathis Beckmann is a Rehatrainer, he could maybe be added as a Sports Scientis, Fitness Coach or Physio (https://www.vfl.de/spieler/mathis-beckmann/)

-          Björn Ernst and Günther Schröder seem to no longer work for the club, at least the current Staff page doesn’t list them (https://www.vfl.de/profis?id=profikader&ucat=98)

-          Jannik Weber could be added as a Physio (https://www.vfl.de/spieler/jannik-weber/)

-          Julius Ohnesorge is Leiter Lizenzbereich, he could maybe be added as a Chief Scout (https://www.vfl.de/spieler/julius-ohnesorge/)

Würzburger Kickers

-          Agenieszka Tobiasz-Kolodziej seems to no longer work for the club, at least the current Staff List doesn’t list her (https://www.wuerzburger-kickers.de/de/kickers/profis/trainer-betreuer)

And of course, as very recent developments that couldn’t have been in the database yet, just for completions sake

-          Marco Antwerpen is no longer Würzburg Manager (https://www.sport1.de/fussball/2-bundesliga/2020/11/2-bundesliga-wuerzburger-kickers-entlassen-marco-antwerpen-trares-nachfolger)

-          Bernhard Trares is now Würzburg Manager (https://www.wuerzburger-kickers.de/de/kickers/profis/trainer-betreuer)

-          Benjamin Sachs is now an Assistant Manager (https://www.wuerzburger-kickers.de/de/kickers/profis/trainer-betreuer)

Link to post

Eintracht Frankfurt

 

Ragnar Ache is a very fast player and in your data it's same like the not fast Andre Silva

David Abraham leave the city End of January 2021 ( today he told it to press)

Rodrigo Zalazar should be better, than a Regionalliga Player and plays 3 of 7 games as a AMC, so i think he should be become the position from you.

 

Thank you so much for your great work and your coolness :)

 

 

Link to post
Am 11.11.2020 um 17:24 schrieb ˇdetz:

Aleksandr Sapovalov is not added to SC Freiburg. A prospect who was chased by top English clubs for years before he turned 16 and had a change to move abroad. At the end he chose SC Freiburg over Arsenal because its easier to reach top level football in Germany. He didint score much this season but neither did his teammates. Please add him and dont do us dirty with a terrible PA, we dont have good players in Estonia but this guy has it to become one. Thx

Done

Link to post
35 minutes ago, Wtfisgoingon said:

Wtf what? If you are responsible for Bundesliga ratings you should be aware that Weiser is RB #4 or 5 in Leverkusen and wasn't even included in the EL squad even though they rotate their entire back 4 every game. He shouldn't be a player that is better than Bender and is recommended as Important Player.

Also Arias has a optional fee in the game while it's mandatory after 15 games in real life. If you are so aggressive for pretty obvious observations, do you even watch Bundesliga in real life?

I don't think having a spat is of any use here. No need to be rude, I'm sure they are doing their best to get the changes in game. Information is important, so provide reasonably and pack in the toxic behavior.

Edited by KeemDreamStar
Link to post
38 minutes ago, Alzraum said:

I don't think anyone mentions what needs to be improved for Wirtz because it is just too much to list. every stat he got is in real life probably better since he isnt (like the game tells you) a 3. Liga player but an actual decent Bundesliga player.

True i think they need to do something with Wirtz in many stats + i think Katterbach should be better too since these 2 are called wonderkids

Link to post
25 minutes ago, KeemDreamStar said:

I don't think having a spat is of any use here. No need to be rude, I'm sure they are doing their best to get the changes in game. Information is important, so provide reasonably and pack in the toxic behavior.

this guy is rude, not me. He can't understand that the players are way overrated and if he'd watch any games he'd know that

Link to post

Ridle Baku from Wolfsburg could use a bump. In real life he played 30 Bundesliga matches for Mainz last year and played full time in every match this year so far. Also started for the German national team yesterday In my save he only started 1 game and 12 sub ins over an entire season.

I feel that his passing, crossing and flair should be higher and maybe some of the mental attributes needs a bump.

Link to post
1 hour ago, Wtfisgoingon said:

Wtf what? If you are responsible for Bundesliga ratings you should be aware that Weiser is RB #4 or 5 in Leverkusen and wasn't even included in the EL squad even though they rotate their entire back 4 every game. He shouldn't be a player that is better than Bender and is recommended as Important Player.

Also Arias has a optional fee in the game while it's mandatory after 15 games in real life. If you are so aggressive for pretty obvious observations, do you even watch Bundesliga in real life?

Read the first post of this thread.
 

Link to post
1 hour ago, Alzraum said:

I don't think anyone mentions what needs to be improved for Wirtz because it is just too much to list. every stat he got is in real life probably better since he isnt (like the game tells you) a 3. Liga player but an actual decent Bundesliga player.

You already know we have improved Wirtz - no need to keep coming back to this (and without actual suggestions.)

The same for the other players you have already mentioned - they have all been tweaked.

Edited by Reddiablo
edit - sorry, mixed one post up with Davies.... so better to adjust that
Link to post
21 minutes ago, AlanusMaximus said:

True i think they need to do something with Wirtz in many stats + i think Katterbach should be better too since these 2 are called wonderkids

Again, we have already covered Wirtz.  Katterbach already has an excellent PA as well. :)

Link to post
8 minutes ago, Woodrow F. Call said:

Ridle Baku from Wolfsburg could use a bump. In real life he played 30 Bundesliga matches for Mainz last year and played full time in every match this year so far. Also started for the German national team yesterday In my save he only started 1 game and 12 sub ins over an entire season.

I feel that his passing, crossing and flair should be higher and maybe some of the mental attributes needs a bump.

Yes, good call. I have already improved Baku. You will see a good improvement in him for the final release. :)

Link to post
9 minutes ago, AlanusMaximus said:

True i think they need to do something with Wirtz in many stats + i think Katterbach should be better too since these 2 are called wonderkids

I think his Attributes are absoluty fine (Stamina upgrade could be considered 7 ist little bit low for Bundesliga ). He is 17 years old in his first full Bundesliga Season. In most cases it is better not to make a player too good. The researchers do a good job. Talents should not get too strong values directly, like in other countries.

Link to post

Maybe Marcus Thuram, Jonas Hofmann and Florian Neuhaus could us a small bump as they are all really good players IRL and they have all 3 made their debuts for National Team this season. 

You are doing a good job, thank you and see you soon.

Link to post

 

Hi team,

Can you consider adding the right back position to Guðlaugur Victor Pálsson (Darmstadt) since he mainly plays there with Iceland (7 times out of his 10 last caps, including tonight)? 

Can be confirmed here: https://www.transfermarkt.com/victor-palsson/nationalmannschaft/spieler/97241/verein_id/3574

Thanks for your work (and your patience :D)

Edited by Gdj
Link to post
17 minutes ago, Gdj said:

 

Hi team,

Can you consider adding the right back position to Guðlaugur Victor Pálsson (Darmstadt) since he mainly plays there with Iceland (7 times out of his 10 last caps, including tonight)? 

Can be confirmed here: https://www.transfermarkt.com/victor-palsson/nationalmannschaft/spieler/97241/verein_id/3574

Thanks for your work (and your patience :D)

He has come a long way since his NEC days. Are there right back injuries for Iceland? I will check the first half of the game at least.

Link to post

I hate to say this but I am really disappointed with overall quality of the job in FM21.

The table below shows some of Schalke players in FM21 compared to 20.4 database in FM20. I am sorry but it is unacceptable not seeing a single change in attributes and I suspect this is the case for most of the players in Germany. Young players on the other hand assigned completely random I guess in both games since their attributes are totally different. 

It just won't work pointing every single player out here and telling what their attributes should be. 

image-2020-11-12-225016.png

Edited by elazulreal
Link to post
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

×
×
  • Create New...