Jump to content

Knap - FM24 and FM23 FM22_FM 21 - FM 20 -FM 19 Tactic List


Recommended Posts

  • Replies 37.3k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

I took the two most downloaded (arguably most popular - From baden powell site) knap tactics, both 4-2-3-1.

  • Echoes 4231 P111
  • Parisienne SS IF TH P93

I assigned one to real madrid, the other one to barcelona and went on holiday for 12 seasons

  • All tasks were delegated except 'Makes Team Selection' and 'Provides Opposition Instructions'
  • No freezing of attributes/morale/...
  • Normal holiday in full fat

It's amazing how close the results were after twelve seasons....

image.png.e57ee0fa941eea02259db00f324620ed.png

 

After twelve seasons, both teams look quite familiar in tactic score, my FM Lineup Tool rates R. Madrid with Echoes a 95.2 and FC Barcelona a 94.5 with Parisienne,
Which shows to me that it was a good test to compare both tactics, as both teams are very even in quality over all those years

Real Madrid in Season 12 with Echoes tac

image.png.6dcd4f27c4dac4603f8b25ac19161b90.png

Barca in Season 12, with Parisienne tac:

image.png.1666db7f418b92b6f0be3187ebbca4dc.png

 

 

Edited by DavyDepuydt1
Link to post
Share on other sites

Another test with Argus the Great, 

Champion with Ossasuna in Spain first season,

Almost 100% plug and play, the only thing i was doing when playing away to strong teams with AM position was adding Man marking to my DLP, to mark opponent AM.

 

Fantastic job as always Knap:applause:

credit to user Bonio to point at this tactic;)

20210916110009_1.jpg

20210916110028_1.jpg

20210916110034_1.jpg

20210916110039_1.jpg

20210916110054_1.jpg

20210916110107_1.jpg

20210916110130_1.jpg

2134853407_ME21.7ARGUSknapVOL23523MUP102CCP229.fmf

Link to post
Share on other sites

il y a une heure, Black Africa a dit :

Another test with Argus the Great, 

Champion with Ossasuna in Spain first season,

Almost 100% plug and play, the only thing i was doing when playing away to strong teams with AM position was adding Man marking to my DLP, to mark opponent AM.

 

Fantastic job as always Knap:applause:

credit to user Bonio to point at this tactic;)

20210916110009_1.jpg

20210916110028_1.jpg

20210916110034_1.jpg

20210916110039_1.jpg

20210916110054_1.jpg

20210916110107_1.jpg

20210916110130_1.jpg

2134853407_ME21.7ARGUSknapVOL23523MUP102CCP229.fmf 43 Ko · 27 downloads

Hi, I see you have great results with this tactic ... It's weird, I've tried it a few times and for me it doesn't work at all.
Link to post
Share on other sites

3 minutes ago, Filip974 said:
Hi, I see you have great results with this tactic ... It's weird, I've tried it a few times and for me it doesn't work at all.

Make sure you have fast and tall defenders best and fastest in the middle, at least one pacey strikers (best if two with pace, acceleration and work rate,

Good DLP in the middle with defensive skills and of course passing, vision, decision.

Tactic was tested by two users with Weder, Cagliari and Osasuna with great results.

Link to post
Share on other sites

On 16/09/2021 at 07:43, DavyDepuydt1 said:

I took the two most downloaded (arguably most popular - From baden powell site) knap tactics, both 4-2-3-1.

  • Echoes 4231 P111
  • Parisienne SS IF TH P93

I assigned one to real madrid, the other one to barcelona and went on holiday for 12 seasons

  • All tasks were delegated except 'Makes Team Selection' and 'Provides Opposition Instructions'
  • No freezing of attributes/morale/...
  • Normal holiday in full fat

It's amazing how close the results were after twelve seasons....

image.png.e57ee0fa941eea02259db00f324620ed.png

 

After twelve seasons, both teams look quite familiar in tactic score, my FM Lineup Tool rates R. Madrid with Echoes a 95.2 and FC Barcelona a 94.5 with Parisienne,
Which shows to me that it was a good test to compare both tactics, as both teams are very even in quality over all those years

Real Madrid in Season 12 with Echoes tac

image.png.6dcd4f27c4dac4603f8b25ac19161b90.png

Barca in Season 12, with Parisienne tac:

image.png.1666db7f418b92b6f0be3187ebbca4dc.png

 

 

This is really cool mate!

Link to post
Share on other sites

@knap

I have a little bit of a problem, and i hope you can help me

Today i promoted with C.S Lebowski to the Serie A, I used in the Serie C & Serie B the '' 21.5 HolyGhostFireKnap41212THPLP90 '' tactic.  Works quitte wel.

But now in the Serie A, i lost mij first  matches in a row :(

Is there a good underdog tactic for a newcomer in the Serie A. (I get a rating of 3001-1 for winning the Serie A.... LOL) . My squad is i think a little below avarage to play a attacking formation. 

But overall i think i can stay in the Serie A with a decent tactic, so i hope you can help me with it. 

Thanks!! :) 

Link to post
Share on other sites

@Beekimov

It appears a lot harder this year to bring in quality players.

The tactic on the LL Tab have kept  Hamlet in PL and I only use DOF Transfers. I would probably use a 442

As an example this is Preachin Blues

784888432_Screenshot(1496).thumb.png.fcb8dd69bf1ebc9fb3371eb17da071e8.png

 

706312003_Screenshot(1494).thumb.png.012c818312d0b68fc38788e8bd122d96.png

 

1671291671_Screenshot(1495).thumb.png.31ab47f1bdad7de25675462d371446c5.png

Edited by knap
Link to post
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, knap said:

@Beekimov

It appears a lot harder this year to bring in quality players.

The tactic on the LL Tab have kept  Hamlet in PL and I only use DOF Transfers. I would probably use a 442

As an example this is Preachin Blues

Thanks @knap

I will give it a go, also i play with the legends database, so the Serie A is a verry tough competition with great players :lol:

1 hour ago, knap said:

 

 

 

 

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Hello Mr Knap @knap and well done for your perfect job here! What should we do when we receive red card on this ME21.7ARGUSknapVOL23523MUP102CCP229? Remove a striker and place him on central position? Just remove a striker? Or something else? Thank you in advance for your answer!

Link to post
Share on other sites

@sk39

Depends - If all going well in match they just remove striker as above. If needing to protect a lead then also drop to control or SUS  as well.

Another way would be to change to a 4141 and take off a MC as this protects wings.

Link to post
Share on other sites

@knap

Hey man,

Thoroughly enjoyed using your tactics in this years game, so thanks for all the work.

Im having an issue with the IF on support, specifically in the Echoes 4231 P111 tactic. Even with the best players for that position they're always very inconsistent and on average are getting 6.5/6.4 ratings. Do you recommend any tweaks that I could make? Apart from that (and the well catalogued issues with DLP's in this years game) its a great tactic.

Cheers!

Edited by wylie24
Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share

×
×
  • Create New...