Jump to content

FM14: Rate My Regen Thread


Recommended Posts

Signed this world class keeper on a free :lol:

ocSjzeQ.png

Christopher has been progressing really well, basically won France the world cup by himself. Although he only scored 34 goals last season, not good enough I think.

EMqa59K.png

After winning the everything with Nottingham Forest I just splashed out money on players for fun. Bought this guy for 60m :lol: He had a poor first season, but he's been on fire this season.

mxCMEAO.png

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • Replies 230
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

Got a few talented youngsters from my first batch of youth players.

http://imageshack.us/f/202/6p81.png/

http://imageshack.us/scaled/thumb/547/e2hn.png

Picked up a couple of players from Southampton, Beech tipped as future World Class.

http://imageshack.us/f/36/wez9.png/

http://imageshack.us/f/600/mf2t.png/

and one from some random club in Norway, tipped as future World Class

http://imageshack.us/f/59/fcib.png/

Link to post
Share on other sites

Been a while since I've been on here, here are my three main regens that I've got on my current Southampton career; all three on the verge of breaking into the first team.

9d315b1c5dbe85c93679cda6daf412f6.png

(Yes his contract is ridiculous but I had to get him from United)

8411adbab55fb7f554a1d6bfcb96fa83.png

(Once again, not the best contract negotiator it seems)

4e5c8543361f70ec55ce9da1f1b34823.png

Those are the three, all look pretty decent I'd say? Holloway especially I keep bringing on in place of Pjanic whilst starting him whenever I can in the cups.

Link to post
Share on other sites

9ES8Ca9.jpg

cWPTZ07.jpg

Jordi was signed for just £200k from Prat. He looked decent, but didn't expect him to become a world class striker. After a year of tutoring he went to Twente on loan. He was promised first team football but only played 9 games. Still, his development was through the roof. He spent one year on the fringes in my team, but still managed 18 goals. Since then he has played 3 seasons getting around a goal pr game. He frustrates me a little bit through, because when he is 'on' he is unstoppable, but he goes on goal drought where he get's rating of 5 for 3-4 games in a row, where he can't score despite getting plenty of easy chances.

Mesquida was a Monaco product and thus had to fork out a lot more, £7.75m. I play him in a deeper role and he does scores a a lot of goals, but has a few weaknesses like only a weak left foot and lack of bravery. He does better when he covers for Jordi as an advanced forward.

gYzRqcr.jpg

I have high hopes for this lad. Amazing level at such a young age. Signed for £15m from Malaga. He played 32 games last season and chipped in with some crucial goals and assists.

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 2 weeks later...
can anyone tell me if this could be a good choice?

they ask me 10M and i don't know what to do :/

how many leagues do you have selected?

No way in he'll is he worth £10mil, imo. He might have huge PA but he doesn't have any good weighting in the key areas for a forward. Terrible composure, can't jump, can't run, can't finish. You could find far better.

I have around 20 leagues loaded I think, maybe more.

Are my scouts on drugs? I just don't see 5* potential in this guy! I know he's only 15, but I don't see it

Remember he's rated 5* PA, it has nothing to do with whether the key attributes will be high. I think his CA star ratings would suffer if you selected different roles, as he fails to have a good weighting in the key technical areas for most forward roles. However, he's only 15 and those can easily be increased. He's got really good composure, off the ball, and teamwork/work rate for a youngster. Plus he's quick.

Link to post
Share on other sites

This lad came up in my first Cardiff intake - looks really good and should get more game time this coming season. Currently trying to train his weaker foot to make him truly class.

E31FC0F95C1B9B9314BE43131937FB7F618620BB

Link to post
Share on other sites

My other regen, whom I have had for sometime. 10x better then Mat Hummels.

http://s1284.photobucket.com/user/PeterPistola/media/Screenshot2013-12-19at14556PM_zpse671cb39.png.html

Yes I know natural fitness is low, which scared me away originally, but he had a 5 star future potential and his stats to begin with were awesome. I mean at 15 he had 18 for bravery and 16 for determination. I couldn't pass up on him.

So purchased for £6.5M, and he's worth every penny. And been barely injured in the 3 years with me. Biggest injury was 2 weeks with a twisted knee. Not missing Balanta or Doria at all at the minute.

Link to post
Share on other sites
No risk at all, as he's from Oxford he won't cost you much at all in compensation and with those starting stats you'll definitely be able to make a profit regardless.

Yeah thats why I went for it only 56k compensation... scouts reported 4 stars but the scouts are really poor. I was just thinking he would be a world beater if the at any physical attributes at all. I also bet his injury proneness is through the roof!..

On another note i nicked a kid of west ham with impeccable mental attributes its unreal..

Link to post
Share on other sites
Lets hope he has 5 star potential.. :cool:

Just read the description. If it says has the potential to be a Premier League star, then you're onto something. Sometimes it just says has a lot of potential to improve, but you can find some that state the level he can achieve even in lower leagues.

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 3 weeks later...

Exactly, he isn't worth £30M. When you bought him, for £30M he wasn't worth it.

What, you gonna come back 3/4 years later when he's practically been fully developed and say ha ha told you so ???

In my first season for AC Milan Andrea Poli was worth £22M and PSG came for an offer of £41M. He wasn't even playing that well, only avg rating of 7.02, what I'm saying is you could play a player regulary and get more for him than what he's really worth. Another example, Niang sold him to PSG for £23M, Sampdoria 4 seasons later have bought him for only £6M.

Back to your Frenchy, is he worth £63M ???? HELL NO !!!!!

I only keep strikers who I develop no older then the age of 19 with finishing, composure and off the ball all a minimum of 19. He wouldn't even make my reserve team.

So back to the story months ago, was he worth £30M ??? NO. Is he worth £30M now ??? YES.

Too the person who said Francois wasn't worth 30m :lol: :lol:

Updates on Francois:

Stats1:

NCVg0H2.png

Stats2:

qmftEHD.png

Link to post
Share on other sites

Mario Gozte eat your heart out. Almost Messi like.

http://s1284.photobucket.com/user/Pe...36b45.png.html

My other regen, whom I have had for sometime. 10x better then Mat Hummels.

http://s1284.photobucket.com/user/Pe...1cb39.png.html

Yes I know natural fitness is low, which scared me away originally, but he had a 5 star future potential and his stats to begin with were awesome. I mean at 15 he had 18 for bravery and 16 for determination. I couldn't pass up on him.

So purchased for £6.5M, and he's worth every penny. And been barely injured in the 3 years with me. Biggest injury was 2 weeks with a twisted knee. Not missing Balanta or Doria at all at the minute.

Fernando Couto eat your heart out. And just like Oliver Schwarz above, he's very similiar. Gee my centre pairing is deadly.

http://s1284.photobucket.com/user/Pe...660bf.png.html

Link to post
Share on other sites
Exactly, he isn't worth £30M. When you bought him, for £30M he wasn't worth it.

What, you gonna come back 3/4 years later when he's practically been fully developed and say ha ha told you so ???

In my first season for AC Milan Andrea Poli was worth £22M and PSG came for an offer of £41M. He wasn't even playing that well, only avg rating of 7.02, what I'm saying is you could play a player regulary and get more for him than what he's really worth. Another example, Niang sold him to PSG for £23M, Sampdoria 4 seasons later have bought him for only £6M.

Back to your Frenchy, is he worth £63M ???? HELL NO !!!!!

I only keep strikers who I develop no older then the age of 19 with finishing, composure and off the ball all a minimum of 19. He wouldn't even make my reserve team.

So back to the story months ago, was he worth £30M ??? NO. Is he worth £30M now ??? YES.

But the value of someone that young is surely measured by potential, not ability?

He was always going to be world class with those attributes at 17 and a determination attribute of 20, so I'd say he was absolutely worth what was paid.

Link to post
Share on other sites
Mario Gozte eat your heart out. Almost Messi like.

http://s1284.photobucket.com/user/Pe...36b45.png.html

My other regen, whom I have had for sometime. 10x better then Mat Hummels.

http://s1284.photobucket.com/user/Pe...1cb39.png.html

Yes I know natural fitness is low, which scared me away originally, but he had a 5 star future potential and his stats to begin with were awesome. I mean at 15 he had 18 for bravery and 16 for determination. I couldn't pass up on him.

So purchased for £6.5M, and he's worth every penny. And been barely injured in the 3 years with me. Biggest injury was 2 weeks with a twisted knee. Not missing Balanta or Doria at all at the minute.

Fernando Couto eat your heart out. And just like Oliver Schwarz above, he's very similiar. Gee my centre pairing is deadly.

http://s1284.photobucket.com/user/Pe...660bf.png.html

None of your links seem to work for me. You don't have to come back here and have a go at FloydRix, he clearly proved that his signing was worth every penny. Please keep it friendly in here.

Link to post
Share on other sites

iy67usH.jpg

L54TTuD.jpg

dF4a7qO.jpg

tBbmKzL.jpg

EJkhFnV.jpg

bR8XnGZ.jpg

Ales Maly - Hit 40 goals in the league last season.

David Artega - Came through my youth system, Ballon d'or winner 2 years running.

Jefferson Canales - 14.5 million bargin from Schalke, might not look that special but has over 50 assists over last 2 seasons in all competitions.

Link to post
Share on other sites

No player at 17 is worth £30M, he'd have to have ridiculous stats to be worth £30M. Yes potential, correct, but his ability at 17 wasn't worth it. No way shape or form.

But the value of someone that young is surely measured by potential, not ability?

He was always going to be world class with those attributes at 17 and a determination attribute of 20, so I'd say he was absolutely worth what was paid.

Link to post
Share on other sites

No one is having a go at anyone, if you want to interpret it that way then that's your issue not mine.

None of your links seem to work for me. You don't have to come back here and have a go at FloydRix, he clearly proved that his signing was worth every penny. Please keep it friendly in here.
Link to post
Share on other sites
No player at 17 is worth £30M, he'd have to have ridiculous stats to be worth £30M. Yes potential, correct, but his ability at 17 wasn't worth it. No way shape or form.

I think they are.

Say when said player Turns 21, what do you think teams will ask for him then? In my save, world class Regens get asking prices of $50m+, and that is non negotiable. So if you can snag a player you know s going to be world class, $30m is a fair price, because if you want him, you will have to pay it, or pay double that later on.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

×
×
  • Create New...