Scouting help

Hi, I was just wondering if Scouts with high JPA & JPP can sometimes get it wrong about players,

For example if my scout had 18 for both and said sign player as a last resort, but I thought he looked good, is it poss that he could be wrong or is it just the lower the JPA & JPP the worse they are or is it something else?

Thanks in advance

The way I look at it is that each additional point in a scouts judging ability and potential equals a five per cent chance of getting his assesment exactly right, so a scout with 18 for judging ability and potential would be around 90 per cent accurate in his assesment of a player and would have a 10 percent margin of error.

Ok thank you very much, think i'll treat it like that, cheers

slipknot - whilst I don't necessarily disagree with your method, I'm interested to see how you got to that?

Was this a completely random method that you yourself use or did you read similar information about it along the way? i've always gone for high ranked scouts without understanding the reasonsing really.