Both of these players are very similar with regards to CA, the only difference is each player's comfort with using their feet.
So, how to fix this?
Separate Footedness CA and attribute CA. Adding a separate CA count of 40 points for footedness would allow great players to look similar whilst still having the advantage of being able to use both feet.
It would also allow us to more accurately judge how good a player actually is by looking at their profiles, because currently it's impossible to tell due to how much they are distorted.