+ Reply to Thread
Results 1 to 89 of 89

Thread: This Game is a Complete Joke!

  1. #1
    Banned
    Join Date
    1st December 2008
    Location
    Edinburgh
    Posts
    1,048

    Default This Game is a Complete Joke!

    I've had enough of this game. Too Many Bugs, Crash Dumps and Injures. This is the worst Football Manager Game ever made. I have been playing these games since Championship Manager days. This is the first FM game i have to give up. I'am going back to FM 10.

    Also an idea for FM 12. Fix all the Bugs and Crash Dumps before it gets released.

  2. #2
    First Team Squad Member
    Join Date
    31st December 2006
    Posts
    18,677

    Default


  3. #3
    Semi Pro
    Join Date
    4th April 2009
    Location
    Sheffield
    Posts
    3,083

    Default

    Have you tried reporting these bugs and crash dumps to help assist the developers understand what is going wrong? They may be able to give you some advice, or will know of changes they need to make for the next version.

    With regards to injuries, I was unaware there was a problem with their being too many injuries? I certainly haven't had anywhere near the number of injuries in game that Middlesbrough have had in real life this year for example.

  4. #4
    Banned
    Join Date
    1st December 2008
    Location
    Edinburgh
    Posts
    1,048

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by tom_15390 View Post
    Have you tried reporting these bugs and crash dumps to help assist the developers understand what is going wrong? They may be able to give you some advice, or will know of changes they need to make for the next version.

    With regards to injuries, I was unaware there was a problem with their being too many injuries? I certainly haven't had anywhere near the number of injuries in game that Middlesbrough have had in real life this year for example.
    I started a new game yesterday with Hibs and on the first day of my new save my best midfielder Liam Miller gets injured in training for two months.

  5. #5
    Part-Timer
    Join Date
    2nd July 2007
    Location
    Los Angeles
    Posts
    1,938

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by MAINBOY View Post
    I started a new game yesterday with Hibs and on the first day of my new save my best midfielder Liam Miller gets injured in training for two months.
    Thats not a bug. But it does bug.

  6. #6
    Amateur
    Join Date
    14th October 2009
    Posts
    309

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by MAINBOY View Post
    I started a new game yesterday with Hibs and on the first day of my new save my best midfielder Liam Miller gets injured in training for two months.
    That is not a bug.

  7. #7
    Lurker
    Join Date
    15th April 2011
    Posts
    1

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by MAINBOY View Post
    I started a new game yesterday with Hibs .
    Theres your problem

  8. #8
    Semi Pro
    Join Date
    25th April 2009
    Location
    Melbourne, Australia
    Posts
    3,476

    Default

    no game is ever bug free, and a vast majority of crash dumps occur as a result of too much editing especially with the likes of FMRTE, that's how I get most of my crash dumps. And for god sake don't give up, it's a damn good game.

  9. #9
    Amateur
    Join Date
    11th December 2003
    Location
    Newcastle, NSW, Australia
    Posts
    15

    Default

    How is a player getting injured a bug?? I seem to remember players getting injured from time to time in real life - so it sounds like the simulation is working correctly!

    Now - go get the toys you thru out of the pram, put them back in their box, jump in their yourself, and play quietly please!!

  10. #10
    Semi Pro
    Join Date
    27th July 2008
    Posts
    3,011

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by MAINBOY View Post
    I've had enough of this game. Too Many Bugs, Crash Dumps and Injures. This is the worst Football Manager Game ever made. I have been playing these games since Championship Manager days. This is the first FM game i have to give up. I'am going back to FM 10.

    Also an idea for FM 12. Fix all the Bugs and Crash Dumps before it gets released.
    You're sick of the bugs and you're going back to FM 10? Good luck with that, though I'd probably describe that decision as being like lighting your hair on fire because you're sick of having a burning sensation on your scalp.

    Anyhow... People post threads like this every single year, but hey...

  11. #11
    Amateur
    Join Date
    7th May 2003
    Posts
    144

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by thenwhc View Post
    Theres your problem
    LOL..........Try the jambos fella, way better chance of doing something!

  12. #12
    Amateur
    Join Date
    30th November 2009
    Posts
    149

    Default

    I had no problems at all with 11.2 but since 11.3 two "gamebreaking" bugs is making the game less enjoyable for me. I still think FM11 is way better than FM10.

  13. #13
    Part-Timer
    Join Date
    9th December 2010
    Location
    sat on my butt
    Posts
    1,892

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by hejh0pp View Post
    I had no problems at all with 11.2 but since 11.3 two "gamebreaking" bugs is making the game less enjoyable for me. I still think FM11 is way better than FM10.
    what "gamebreaking" bugs?

    Being a crap football manager isn't a bug, it's just you...

  14. #14
    Youth Team
    Join Date
    19th March 2011
    Posts
    4,566

    Default

    There are more injuries now than before, especially if you count knocks.

    If you feel that one injury follows another, save and reload the game. It may be only superstition but I actually feel this helps! I still think that the game is unbalanced with the huge bonuses given by successful team talks.

  15. #15
    Amateur
    Join Date
    1st March 2008
    Location
    keeping the faith in the prem with the mighty darwin
    Posts
    117

    Default

    WHY OH WHY DO PEOPLE MOAN ABOUT INJURIES?in the save im playing at the mo ive had a few matches where ive had eight first teamers out.get with the programme its a TEAM effort not just 11....

  16. #16
    Amateur
    Join Date
    23rd June 2008
    Location
    Holker Street, Home of the Bluebirds.
    Posts
    204

    Default

    How do people get lots of injuries? the most I've ever had at one time is 4. It is really beyond my understanding as a person how people get upto double figures.

  17. #17
    Semi Pro
    Join Date
    27th July 2008
    Posts
    3,011

    Default

    I'd assume they over play players too often. I keep my injuries down by rotating my squad, and I know that in the cases where the going gets tough and that's not an option I do get dogpiled with injuries. In any case the worst in memory for injuries was FM09 after the release day patch. I swear they had snipers in the stands or something...

  18. #18
    Sports Interactive Neil Brock's Avatar
    Join Date
    6th June 2005
    Location
    Gary Busey's dustbin
    Posts
    50,236

    Default

    As we've said on a number of occasions, injuries are in line with real life figures. Sometimes sadly players get injured, that's just football I'm afraid. If you feel that injuries are excessive note how many you've had over the season and then compare it with real-life figures and see how accurate they are.

  19. #19
    Moderator
    Join Date
    19th June 2009
    Location
    I am the greatest, I said that even before I knew I was.
    Posts
    18,057

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by Neil Brock View Post
    As we've said on a number of occasions, injuries are in line with real life figures.
    If anything Neil, they are below the real life figures.

  20. #20
    Semi Pro
    Join Date
    27th July 2008
    Posts
    3,011

    Default

    They probably are, but hey... It's a game. I have a feeling the reason they'd be below though is the number of people complaining about too many injuries. Statistically you're always going to have a few people getting dogpiled at one time, and hence you get a stedy stream of these. However, you're unlikely to get enraged posts complaining that their star players have been injury free all season. Still, I like it where it is. It's not quite the FM09 craziness and it's not too few.

  21. #21
    Amateur
    Join Date
    5th December 2009
    Location
    Queensland, Australia
    Posts
    496

    Default

    If injurys affect the other teams as much as they affect you then everybodys equal right?

  22. #22
    Moderator
    Join Date
    28th June 2004
    Location
    Guess you only get one chance in life to play a song that goes like this.
    Posts
    35,437

    Default

    Currently in 2043 and I can legitimately say I've had an injury crisis twice in all that time.

    I've also had one player (my best player as it happens) miss an entire season with two separate injuries.

    That's football.

  23. #23
    Semi Pro
    Join Date
    10th February 2004
    Posts
    2,028

    Default

    The injuries are a little "unlucky" as we say from time to time. I bought Sime Vrasalijho and within 3 days of being at the club he went down with a "viral infection" that kept him out for 6 months. Joe Cole joined at the same time and before he kicked a ball he was out for 2 months with a hip injury. Then I purchased Nigel De Jong in January and two minutes into his debut he breaks a leg and it out for 8 months!!!

    However I think injuries are ok on the whole. The only think I would say though is it seems there are an awful lot of in match injuries, especially when you have used up all your subs!!!!!

  24. #24
    Semi Pro
    Join Date
    27th July 2008
    Posts
    3,011

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by Johnjo View Post
    If injurys affect the other teams as much as they affect you then everybodys equal right?
    Yeah, but if there's too many it just gets annoying and may require you to sign more players. Either that are it becomes are game of who can limp over the line first.

  25. #25
    Part-Timer
    Join Date
    2nd July 2007
    Location
    Los Angeles
    Posts
    1,938

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by Lazaru5 View Post
    what "gamebreaking" bugs?
    There are one or two gamebreaking bugs obvious to all but the most syopic fanboy/fangirl..

    1)The referee bug where one ref seems to officiate over most of a teams games..its game breaking for teams stuck with the most card happy refs and game breaking for those happily stuck with the most lenient refs because it distorts the game. Heavily carded teams will lose key players for many more games.

    2)The Italian AI non EU player issue and the overpoweredness of rival teams can be seen as game breaking for users who love to play in that league.

    3)Managers getting sacked for no reason whatsoever can also be considered a gamebreaking bug

  26. #26
    Reserves
    Join Date
    8th January 2004
    Posts
    11,928

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by Bababui View Post
    There are one or two gamebreaking bugs obvious to all but the most syopic fanboy/fangirl..

    1)The referee bug where one ref seems to officiate over most of a teams games..its game breaking for teams stuck with the most card happy refs and game breaking for those happily stuck with the most lenient refs because it distorts the game. Heavily carded teams will lose key players for many more games.

    2)The Italian AI non EU player issue and the overpoweredness of rival teams can be seen as game breaking for users who love to play in that league.

    3)Managers getting sacked for no reason whatsoever can also be considered a gamebreaking bug

    1) Is an issue although I thought it had been resolved for the most part. Aside from that its hardly gamebreaking.

    2) Again I thought this was an issue that fixed itself for the most part. Even if not I wouldn't consider it gamebreaking, there are plenty of EU players to be signed. I haven't even seen the rival team issue mentioned anywhere.

    3) Seems to be very rare and was tweaked in the last patch I believe.

  27. #27
    First Team Squad Member
    Join Date
    9th November 2010
    Location
    Standing free, wherever i may be
    Posts
    15,244

    Default

    watch Cougar, you dont want to been see as being a fangirl........:P

  28. #28
    Part-Timer
    Join Date
    2nd July 2007
    Location
    Los Angeles
    Posts
    1,938

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by Cougar2010 View Post
    1) Is an issue although I thought it had been resolved for the most part. Aside from that its hardly gamebreaking.

    2) Again I thought this was an issue that fixed itself for the most part. Even if not I wouldn't consider it gamebreaking, there are plenty of EU players to be signed. I haven't even seen the rival team issue mentioned anywhere.

    3) Seems to be very rare and was tweaked in the last patch I believe.
    1)It was resolved but has returned and it is groundbreaking; whether it works for or against you. Key players end up missing matches that they shouldnt be missing..many matches after the 10th yellow. Its absurd to look at a league card history and have the top 2 teams have twice the cards as the league median.

    There should be no groundbreaking issues at this point in the release. Thats the point. Just because they dont happen to any one of us doesnt mean they arent ruining someone elses gaming experience.

  29. #29
    Sports Interactive Neil Brock's Avatar
    Join Date
    6th June 2005
    Location
    Gary Busey's dustbin
    Posts
    50,236

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by Tyoldinho View Post
    If anything Neil, they are below the real life figures.
    That they are, but you tell that to people who are complaining about injuries they don't tend to take it too well!

  30. #30
    Part-Timer
    Join Date
    10th February 2008
    Location
    York
    Posts
    1,180

    Default

    To be honest I tend not to notice many bugs with the game, maybe the odd crash dump if im playing with FMRTE but thats it.

  31. #31
    Banned
    Join Date
    16th November 2010
    Posts
    200

    Default

    Injuries aren't a big problem, but I have one big issue with them:

    You can't request snow delays. With the AI's overuse of hard tackling, you're lucky if you get through a snow game without 1 or 2 of your first 11 being put out for 2 or 3 months. Last time I played in the snow, I lost both van der Vaart and Modric for the rest of the season after about 20 minutes. In real life, if conditions were that bad, both teams would have just postponed the game instead of sending their players out to die.

  32. #32
    Youth Team
    Join Date
    19th March 2011
    Posts
    4,566

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by chob View Post
    To be honest I tend not to notice many bugs with the game, maybe the odd crash dump if im playing with FMRTE but thats it.
    bug = crashes and nothing else?

    Not in my language

  33. #33
    Banned
    Join Date
    9th September 2008
    Location
    Manchester
    Posts
    3,958

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by BiggusD View Post
    bug = crashes and nothing else?

    Not in my language
    and where did chob say a bug was a crash and nothing else?

  34. #34
    Amateur
    Join Date
    28th December 2008
    Posts
    106

    Default

    That actually made me LOL!

  35. #35
    Reserves
    Join Date
    8th January 2004
    Posts
    11,928

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by Bababui View Post
    1)It was resolved but has returned and it is groundbreaking; whether it works for or against you. Key players end up missing matches that they shouldnt be missing..many matches after the 10th yellow. Its absurd to look at a league card history and have the top 2 teams have twice the cards as the league median.

    There should be no groundbreaking issues at this point in the release. Thats the point. Just because they dont happen to any one of us doesnt mean they arent ruining someone elses gaming experience.

    Part of managing a team is controlling that number of cards.

    If you know you have a card happy ref you need to make tactical adjustments to minimise their effect.

    Lets be honest even if it happens its only for a session - so one session you get a card happy ref another session you don't. How many games do you play in a session 10? 20? at most. Its swings & roundabouts just like other things.

  36. #36
    Part-Timer
    Join Date
    2nd July 2007
    Location
    Los Angeles
    Posts
    1,938

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by Cougar2010 View Post
    Part of managing a team is controlling that number of cards.

    If you know you have a card happy ref you need to make tactical adjustments to minimise their effect.

    Lets be honest even if it happens its only for a session - so one session you get a card happy ref another session you don't. How many games do you play in a session 10? 20? at most. Its swings & roundabouts just like other things.
    Its Oct 29, 2011 in my current game..checking the league I won promotion from..Northern League First Division North..I see Lancaster City is leading the league with 24 yellows while AFC Hornchurch only has 5. There is a problem here.

  37. #37
    Youth Team
    Join Date
    19th March 2011
    Posts
    4,566

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by StevoRobbo View Post
    and where did chob say a bug was a crash and nothing else?
    What he said amounts to that, if you read between the lines. I read that post as someone mis-reading posts about bugs in the game on purpose, and maybe it is not fair of me to extrapolate - but then again I don't really care.

  38. #38
    Reserves
    Join Date
    8th January 2004
    Posts
    11,928

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by Bababui View Post
    Its Oct 29, 2011 in my current game..checking the league I won promotion from..Northern League First Division North..I see Lancaster City is leading the league with 24 yellows while AFC Hornchurch only has 5. There is a problem here.
    Urm the number of yellows cards AFC Hornchurch & Lancaster City have neither proves nor disproves the bug even exists.

    Lancaster are maybe a more aggressive side, Hornchurch maybe hold possession and make fewer tackles during matches.

  39. #39
    Part-Timer
    Join Date
    9th December 2010
    Location
    sat on my butt
    Posts
    1,892

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by Bababui View Post
    There are one or two gamebreaking bugs obvious to all but the most syopic fanboy/fangirl..

    1)The referee bug where one ref seems to officiate over most of a teams games..its game breaking for teams stuck with the most card happy refs and game breaking for those happily stuck with the most lenient refs because it distorts the game. Heavily carded teams will lose key players for many more games.

    2)The Italian AI non EU player issue and the overpoweredness of rival teams can be seen as game breaking for users who love to play in that league.

    3)Managers getting sacked for no reason whatsoever can also be considered a gamebreaking bug
    1. It's your tactics!
    2. Dunno what this is...
    3. Yeah, was game-breaking for Pardew and Hughton too...


  40. #40
    Part-Timer
    Join Date
    2nd July 2007
    Location
    Los Angeles
    Posts
    1,938

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by Lazaru5 View Post
    1. It's your tactics!
    2. Dunno what this is...
    3. Yeah, was game-breaking for Pardew and Hughton too...

    1)Its nothing to do with tactics; its about a goofy bug that assignes the same official to ref many of your matches.

    3)This is a game; a game that should produce happiness. The passive/aggressive types who hint that the game should only be played their way dont help matters.

  41. #41
    Semi Pro
    Join Date
    4th April 2009
    Location
    Sheffield
    Posts
    3,083

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by Bababui View Post
    3)This is a game; a game that should produce happiness. The passive/aggressive types who hint that the game should only be played their way dont help matters.
    No it isn't. It's a simulation. It should aim to replicate the real world.

  42. #42
    Part-Timer
    Join Date
    9th December 2010
    Location
    sat on my butt
    Posts
    1,892

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by Bababui View Post
    1)Its nothing to do with tactics; its about a goofy bug that assignes the same official to ref many of your matches.
    I accept that having the same ref can be an annoyance, however I doubt that a different referee would result in a lower card count, hence "it's your tactics" (I have the same referee occasionally, one in particular that I recall dished out 6 yellows and 2 reds in one game, the very next match I think it was 3 yellows in total...)

  43. #43
    Amateur
    Join Date
    30th November 2009
    Posts
    149

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by Lazaru5 View Post
    what "gamebreaking" bugs?

    Being a crap football manager isn't a bug, it's just you...
    I asked my board for a feeder club to whom I could send my players on loan and they could only find amateur or semi-professional teams. My club has got worldwide reputation, that shouldn't happen.

    Also withdrawing players for international friendlies makes them unavailable for coming international matches.

    I just said that those bugs made the game less enjoyable, I didn't say that the game is a crap.

  44. #44
    Third Team
    Join Date
    7th March 2007
    Location
    Pro-consumer, anti-DRM. Never be satisfied with any answer. Dig until you drop.
    Posts
    6,670

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by tom_15390 View Post
    No it isn't. It's a simulation. It should aim to replicate the real world.
    Regardless of what Miles says, it is a game at its most fundamental level because there is absolutely no way all the realism features (i.e. going to the bathroom, watching all your training sessions, progressing as if one second in the game equals one second in reality, etc. etc.) will be implemented, and that the software is judged as how fun it is to play, with realism being good up to a point, but nothing more.

    Quote Originally Posted by Lazaru5 View Post
    I accept that having the same ref can be an annoyance, however I doubt that a different referee would result in a lower card count, hence "it's your tactics" (I have the same referee occasionally, one in particular that I recall dished out 6 yellows and 2 reds in one game, the very next match I think it was 3 yellows in total...)
    It's not your tactics since there is no problem with your tactics - the problem lies with the referee. Yes, you can faff around and use a workaround to use different tactics but this impacts the next season should you get a very different referee, and your tactics base should be for an average-case scenario, using extreme referees as a rare chance to change your tactics slightly to accommodate for this.

    Let's say there is a problem with transfers where teams do not sign any players at all, except the human player. This argument is a bit like saying there is no problem with transfers because it's your tactics - because you can deliberately weaken your team to make up for the AI's weakness. Pure rubbish.

  45. #45
    First Team Squad Member
    Join Date
    9th November 2010
    Location
    Standing free, wherever i may be
    Posts
    15,244

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by x42bn6 View Post
    Regardless of what Miles says, it is a game at its most fundamental level because there is absolutely no way all the realism features (i.e. going to the bathroom, watching all your training sessions, progressing as if one second in the game equals one second in reality, etc. etc.) will be implemented, and that the software is judged as how fun it is to play, with realism being good up to a point, but nothing more.
    Doesnt matter about all that, when you play a flight simulator you dont also simulate driving to the airport and going through security clearance, just like when police train on driving simulators they dont have to fill up with petrol or check their tyre pressure. Just because you do not do every single thing involved in being a manager, or by your examples, a human in general, doesnt mean its not a simulator.

  46. #46
    Amateur
    Join Date
    29th December 2007
    Posts
    390

    Default

    FM11 is a 100% miss

  47. #47
    Third Team
    Join Date
    7th March 2007
    Location
    Pro-consumer, anti-DRM. Never be satisfied with any answer. Dig until you drop.
    Posts
    6,670

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by milnerpoint View Post
    Doesnt matter about all that, when you play a flight simulator you dont also simulate driving to the airport and going through security clearance, just like when police train on driving simulators they dont have to fill up with petrol or check their tyre pressure. Just because you do not do every single thing involved in being a manager, or by your examples, a human in general, doesnt mean its not a simulator.
    No, flight simulators simulate flight, while football management sims simulate being a football manager. A flight simulator does not simulate a pilot's life - it simulates flight. A flight simulator simulates the action of flying. Football Manager simulates a human-being.

  48. #48
    First Team Squad Member
    Join Date
    9th November 2010
    Location
    Standing free, wherever i may be
    Posts
    15,244

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by x42bn6 View Post
    No, flight simulators simulate flight, while football management sims simulate being a football manager. A flight simulator does not simulate a pilot's life - it simulates flight. A flight simulator simulates the action of flying. Football Manager simulates a human-being.
    no football manager simulates being a football manager, not being a human being.

  49. #49
    Third Team
    Join Date
    7th March 2007
    Location
    Pro-consumer, anti-DRM. Never be satisfied with any answer. Dig until you drop.
    Posts
    6,670

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by milnerpoint View Post
    no football manager simulates being a football manager, not being a human being.
    Part of a manager involves looking at every single training session. Why is this not in Football Manager?

  50. #50
    First Team Squad Member
    Join Date
    9th November 2010
    Location
    Standing free, wherever i may be
    Posts
    15,244

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by x42bn6 View Post
    Part of a manager involves looking at every single training session. Why is this not in Football Manager?
    I dont work for SI so i cannot say, but if champ man is anything to go by then its a very difficult aspect to get even remotely correct.
    Its a simulator, there is no getting away from that.

  51. #51
    Part-Timer
    Join Date
    9th December 2010
    Location
    sat on my butt
    Posts
    1,892

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by x42bn6 View Post
    It's not your tactics since there is no problem with your tactics - the problem lies with the referee. Yes, you can faff around and use a workaround to use different tactics but this impacts the next season should you get a very different referee, and your tactics base should be for an average-case scenario, using extreme referees as a rare chance to change your tactics slightly to accommodate for this.

    Let's say there is a problem with transfers where teams do not sign any players at all, except the human player. This argument is a bit like saying there is no problem with transfers because it's your tactics - because you can deliberately weaken your team to make up for the AI's weakness. Pure rubbish.
    My "it's your tactics" comment refers to the amount of cards the referee shows. In my example the same referee in consecutive matches was completely different... the tactics I used were not. In one game he was waving cards around like nobody's business, the next he was more lenient - the difference was the tactics employed by the opposition... they were hard tackling in the first game, less so in the second...

  52. #52
    Youth Team
    Join Date
    19th March 2011
    Posts
    4,566

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by Lazaru5 View Post
    My "it's your tactics" comment refers to the amount of cards the referee shows. In my example the same referee in consecutive matches was completely different... the tactics I used were not. In one game he was waving cards around like nobody's business, the next he was more lenient - the difference was the tactics employed by the opposition... they were hard tackling in the first game, less so in the second...
    Or people were fired up or over-fired up in one match and complacent in the next.

  53. #53
    Third Team
    Join Date
    7th March 2007
    Location
    Pro-consumer, anti-DRM. Never be satisfied with any answer. Dig until you drop.
    Posts
    6,670

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by milnerpoint View Post
    I dont work for SI so i cannot say, but if champ man is anything to go by then its a very difficult aspect to get even remotely correct.
    Its a simulator, there is no getting away from that.
    The training module is already in place and overseeing the training is just another abstraction of training, in the same way that 2D and 3D are different ways of looking at the match.

    Why is this abstraction not in game? The underlying training engine is in place. Watching training is just another way of looking at things. See Model-View-Controller.

    Quote Originally Posted by Lazaru5 View Post
    My "it's your tactics" comment refers to the amount of cards the referee shows. In my example the same referee in consecutive matches was completely different... the tactics I used were not. In one game he was waving cards around like nobody's business, the next he was more lenient - the difference was the tactics employed by the opposition... they were hard tackling in the first game, less so in the second...
    On average, it will even itself out to the extent that strict referees show more cards than lenient referees - swings between matches are largely immaterial.

    Over a whole season, the effects will be felt.

  54. #54
    First Team Squad Member
    Join Date
    9th November 2010
    Location
    Standing free, wherever i may be
    Posts
    15,244

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by x42bn6 View Post
    The training module is already in place and overseeing the training is just another abstraction of training, in the same way that 2D and 3D are different ways of looking at the match.

    Why is this abstraction not in game? The underlying training engine is in place. Watching training is just another way of looking at things. See Model-View-Controller.
    What would be gained from watching a 3D rep of your players training in its current state? I'm sure if its as simple as you make out Si will have considered it and will have good reasons for not putting it in the game, the con's will out weight the pro's at the moment. thats not to say this wont come later in the game when they either have a better 3D rep or a better training module.
    I never said it was a complete sim of being a football manager, but it definitely is one, as you say games are a lot more accesable to the common person, this is a simulator where you have to have a keen knowlage of the subject before you can get the fullest out of it, otherwise its a mess of numbers and stats useless to anyone who doesnt follow football.

  55. #55
    Third Team
    Join Date
    7th March 2007
    Location
    Pro-consumer, anti-DRM. Never be satisfied with any answer. Dig until you drop.
    Posts
    6,670

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by milnerpoint View Post
    What would be gained from watching a 3D rep of your players training in its current state? I'm sure if its as simple as you make out Si will have considered it and will have good reasons for not putting it in the game, the con's will out weight the pro's at the moment. thats not to say this wont come later in the game when they either have a better 3D rep or a better training module.
    I never said watching training had to be 3D. Just that we have to be able to watch training as it is more realistic.

    There are no cons - it is realistic, and as you said, it is a simulation therefore it has to be in. No pros, no cons - it's realism.

    Another realistic feature would be that the game time must pass in exactly the same way as real-time. 1 second in-game is 1 second in reality. Why is this not implemented? It's more realistic.

    Quote Originally Posted by milnerpoint View Post
    I never said it was a complete sim of being a football manager, but it definitely is one, as you say games are a lot more accesable to the common person, this is a simulator where you have to have a keen knowlage of the subject before you can get the fullest out of it, otherwise its a mess of numbers and stats useless to anyone who doesnt follow football.
    Care to show me where I said that? A simulator can be accessible to the common person - look at simulation of fractals, for example, generating pretty patterns. A video-game can appeal to research and work, in the same way that some FPS games have been used in studies, and have been modified for war scenarios in armies.

    A game is designed for one purpose and that is fun. Football Manager is not a simulator - it is not designed for educational purposes, modelling or design. It is meant to be fun to play. What you put into the game you cannot really take out - you don't learn anything from playing Football Manager, but you learn a lot by using a flight simulator.

    Football Manager is a game, not a simulation. It is just that it is a game that has realism as a key factor. And there is a big difference between a realistic game and a simulator. Football Manager falls in the former - otherwise it would be in scientific or engineering journals, rather than Gamespot or IGN.

  56. #56
    Part-Timer
    Join Date
    14th July 2008
    Posts
    1,416

    Default

    Quote ' This is the first FM game i have to give up. I'am going back to FM 10. '




    I have had no crash dumps on this version of the game but on FM2010 I had loads. If I were you I would learn how to manage your players and training correctly this is not a bug. Players do get injured. In my last season however my team remained injury free apart from the odd niggle which kept them out for a few days at a time. Lucky I guess.

    Anyway go back to FM2010 which for me was alot more buggy than this version of the game and with crash dumps. So good luck on your venture to find a bug free game.
    Last edited by wazza; 06-05-2011 at 19:15.

  57. #57
    Amateur
    Join Date
    9th July 2009
    Posts
    561

    Default


  58. #58
    Amateur
    Join Date
    6th September 2009
    Location
    Nottingham
    Posts
    94

    Default

    A second of life for a second in game is a laughable idea.

  59. #59
    Amateur
    Join Date
    24th January 2009
    Location
    Fauldhouse!
    Posts
    54

    Default

    I liked the jambos love in earlier in the thread, at least some people out there have sense

  60. #60
    Third Team
    Join Date
    7th March 2007
    Location
    Pro-consumer, anti-DRM. Never be satisfied with any answer. Dig until you drop.
    Posts
    6,670

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by FrazerBleedsLiverpoolRed View Post
    A second of life for a second in game is a laughable idea.
    Of course it's laughable - which is why Football Manager is a game not a simulator.

  61. #61
    Part-Timer
    Join Date
    30th September 2007
    Location
    Portman Road :) (I wish)
    Posts
    1,739

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by x42bn6 View Post
    Of course it's laughable - which is why Football Manager is a game not a simulator.
    Ok so are you saying the first flight simulators were not simulators? As they were not as complicated as the newest flight simulators?


    Also i am wondering if any flight simulators are actually simulators as they do appear on websites like IGN metacritic etc....maybe i am just wrong?

    http://pc.ign.com/objects/792/792287.html
    So do my eyes decieve me? Or is this a simulator on IGN? Or maybe according to you flight simulator x is not a flight simulator and just a game?

    PS: Football Manager 2011 (abbreviated to Football Manager 11 or FM11) is a football manager simulation video game
    You better run to wikipedia and ask them to quickly change this before people get confused and call football manager a simulation again....quick....
    Last edited by glennuk; 06-05-2011 at 22:12.

  62. #62
    Semi Pro
    Join Date
    25th October 2008
    Location
    The District Line
    Posts
    2,499

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by x42bn6 View Post
    Of course it's laughable - which is why Football Manager is a game not a simulator.
    Please, Continue?

    EDIT: to Glen: isn't the point of Flight Simulator games, that you fly the plane real time? e.g Flight to place X takes 8 hours, so in-game it takes 8 hours?

    Probably not the best example to support your argument

    Double Edit: just to clarify, i support the suggestion that FM is both a game and a simulation.
    Last edited by Insert_Goal_Here; 06-05-2011 at 22:22.

  63. #63
    Moderator
    Join Date
    28th June 2004
    Location
    Guess you only get one chance in life to play a song that goes like this.
    Posts
    35,437

    Default

    FM is a simulation game.

    Flight Simulators released on PCs are also games.

    Flight Simulators used for Air Force training are actual simulations.

  64. #64
    Third Team
    Join Date
    7th March 2007
    Location
    Pro-consumer, anti-DRM. Never be satisfied with any answer. Dig until you drop.
    Posts
    6,670

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by glennuk View Post
    Ok so are you saying the first flight simulators were not simulators? As they were not as complicated as the newest flight simulators?
    No, I'm saying that Football Manager is a game.

    Quote Originally Posted by glennuk View Post
    Also i am wondering if any flight simulators are actually simulators as they do appear on websites like IGN metacritic etc....maybe i am just wrong?
    Strictly-speaking, most are flight-simulator games.

    http://pc.ign.com/objects/792/792287.htmhttp://pc.ign.com/objects/792/792287.html
    So do my eyes decieve me? Or is this a simulator on IGN? Or maybe according to you flight simulator x is not a flight simulator and just a game?[/quote]

    The Microsoft Flight Simulator series is a unique series in the sense that it is one of the few flight simulators (originally marketed as a game, mind), that has been successful as a pure simulator. It is an exception, not the rule.

    Quote Originally Posted by glennuk View Post
    PS: Football Manager 2011 (abbreviated to Football Manager 11 or FM11) is a football manager simulation video game
    You better run to wikipedia and ask them to quickly change this before people get confused and call football manager a simulation again....quick....
    Do you see the "video game" at the end of that sentence?

    It simulates reality to some extent - this does not necessarily make it a pure simulator as such. It just happens to attempt to model reality quite a bit.

    Most games have some degree of reality - Grand Theft Auto uses an Earth-like world with human beings and Earth physics, for example, but this doesn't make it a simulator.

  65. #65
    Semi Pro
    Join Date
    25th October 2008
    Location
    The District Line
    Posts
    2,499

    Default

    "It just happens to model reality quite a bit?"

    Seriously?

    Oh dear.

  66. #66
    Amateur
    Join Date
    13th April 2010
    Posts
    117

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by Bababui View Post
    1)It was resolved but has returned and it is groundbreaking; whether it works for or against you. Key players end up missing matches that they shouldnt be missing..many matches after the 10th yellow. Its absurd to look at a league card history and have the top 2 teams have twice the cards as the league median.

    There should be no groundbreaking issues at this point in the release. Thats the point. Just because they dont happen to any one of us doesnt mean they arent ruining someone elses gaming experience.
    chiek tiote in real life has ammounted up 13 yellows this season so far and if he gets 2 more by the end of the season he will miss another 3 games

  67. #67
    Third Team
    Join Date
    7th March 2007
    Location
    Pro-consumer, anti-DRM. Never be satisfied with any answer. Dig until you drop.
    Posts
    6,670

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by Insert_Goal_Here View Post
    "It just happens to model reality quite a bit?"

    Seriously?

    Oh dear.
    What's wrong with that?

    A lot of games model reality, but are games in their own right - for example, The Sims models life, but with lots of twists for gaming purposes. Few games are based on no reality at all - for example, Rez.

    However, they are not considered simulators.

  68. #68
    Amateur
    Join Date
    17th November 2008
    Posts
    681

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by x42bn6 View Post
    What's wrong with that?

    A lot of games model reality, but are games in their own right - for example, The Sims models life, but with lots of twists for gaming purposes. Few games are based on no reality at all - for example, Rez.

    However, they are not considered simulators.
    I think whats wrong is that above you were vehemently arguing it was purely a game and to simulate reality it needed to simulate pointless stuff like driving to work and 1 second in game = 1 second in real life.

    Its very much a simulation game, its not just a game in the sense you were suggesting. There have been pure game footie managers made, like that weird EA one about 5 years ago from some German dev team which had no basis in reality except for the names and clubs. It was kinda fun in a perverse way but totally silly, and clearly showed the difference between Sim-game and pure game.

    Similar parralels can be seen in many other genres, games like Forza and Gran Turismo are racing sim games, where as burnout and drift (etc) are pure games.

  69. #69
    Third Team
    Join Date
    7th March 2007
    Location
    Pro-consumer, anti-DRM. Never be satisfied with any answer. Dig until you drop.
    Posts
    6,670

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by Avelives View Post
    I think whats wrong is that above you were vehemently arguing it was purely a game and to simulate reality it needed to simulate pointless stuff like driving to work and 1 second in game = 1 second in real life.

    Its very much a simulation game, its not just a game in the sense you were suggesting. There have been pure game footie managers made, like that weird EA one about 5 years ago from some German dev team which had no basis in reality except for the names and clubs. It was kinda fun in a perverse way but totally silly, and clearly showed the difference between Sim-game and pure game.

    Similar parralels can be seen in many other genres, games like Forza and Gran Turismo are racing sim games, where as burnout and drift (etc) are pure games.
    A simulation game is not a simulator though - a simulator is meant to purely simulate, while a video game has a purpose to entertain.

    If you want to use "simulator" in a broader sense, then pretty much every game nowadays is a simulator, which nobody considers in that way.

  70. #70
    Amateur
    Join Date
    18th November 2008
    Posts
    474

    Default

    the amount of time i read the " i have played this game since the championship manager days" what has that got to do with anything, also this is a very big game fair enough some bugs are amazing how they havnt seen them, but theres going to be bigs theres bugs on all games and to be honest i have put a lot of hours into this game with top teams and lower teams and its all been fine for me

  71. #71
    Banned
    Join Date
    16th November 2010
    Posts
    200

    Default

    What makes FM11 frustrating at times is that it tries to be both a game and a simulator. A game can be mastered and beaten whereas a simulator is intended to closely model real world results. Since players can largely figure out the part of the game that is based mainly on their input (i.e., tactics), their input can grossly disrupt the sense of "realism" central to a simulation. To remedy this, SI have placed increasing importance on areas of the game where player input produces more random and obscure results (e.g., team talks and press conferences) and introduced mechanisms that render player input increasingly irrelevant if it veers too far away from "realistic" results (e.g., complacency, nerfed one-on-ones, lower reputation team super goalies). The reason this is frustrating is that it makes the player feel as if his input doesn't really matter and that the initial effort he put into the game was, more or less, a waste of time.

    This is why it's imperative that SI get back to basics with FM12 and really focus on beefing up the tactical AI. I don't know anyone who finds the so-called "psychological" aspect of the game to be either fun or particularly realistic, and yet, FM11 focused primarily on expanding these tedious aspects and greatly increasing their influence on the match engine.

  72. #72
    Youth Team
    Join Date
    19th March 2011
    Posts
    4,566

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by sando123 View Post
    the amount of time i read the " i have played this game since the championship manager days" what has that got to do with anything, also this is a very big game fair enough some bugs are amazing how they havnt seen them, but theres going to be bigs theres bugs on all games and to be honest i have put a lot of hours into this game with top teams and lower teams and its all been fine for me
    I have played CM/FM for 17 years and I have never heard anyone else say that in here!

  73. #73
    Tactics and Match Engine Moderator
    Join Date
    3rd December 2003
    Location
    Sydney
    Posts
    7,408

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by Ego Scriptor View Post
    This is why it's imperative that SI get back to basics with FM12 and really focus on beefing up the tactical AI. I don't know anyone who finds the so-called "psychological" aspect of the game to be either fun or particularly realistic, and yet, FM11 focused primarily on expanding these tedious aspects and greatly increasing their influence on the match engine.
    The effect of motivational elements has been reduced in MEs over the last few years. The bolded statement is pure nonsense.

  74. #74
    Amateur
    Join Date
    9th December 2008
    Posts
    915

    Default

    Some people will never agree that the game is realistic, because they do not want it to be so. They would prefer noone to ever be injured, their star striker to score in every single game, and their team to never lose.

    This debate happens about twice a day on here, I don't get why so many people rise to the bait.

  75. #75
    Moderator and Technical Support
    Join Date
    27th December 2003
    Location
    Half the lies I tell aren't true
    Posts
    33,228

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by BiggusD View Post
    I have played CM/FM for 17 years and I have never heard anyone else say that in here!
    Believe me, a large % of complaint/rant threads start with this

  76. #76
    Youth Team
    Join Date
    23rd March 2005
    Posts
    4,780

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by MAINBOY View Post
    This is the first FM game i have to give up. I'am going back to FM 10.
    .
    I bet half of the guys saying that said"This is the first FM game i have to give up. I'am going back to FM 09" last year.

  77. #77
    Amateur
    Join Date
    26th July 2008
    Posts
    8

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by Neil Brock View Post
    That they are, but you tell that to people who are complaining about injuries they don't tend to take it too well!
    When is the problem of owning a team in every category but ending up losing or drawing going to be fixed

    The amount of games where you outshoot the cpu heavily and have a high on target and clear cut chance rating compared to the cpu who seems to score on every little chance on target. It happens all the time far too often to be realistic in any way.

    Do the ratings of players shot accuracy mean anything in this game? of course there are other factors but they musn't mean crap if players seem to score all their chances when playing the the user.

  78. #78
    Part-Timer
    Join Date
    9th December 2010
    Location
    sat on my butt
    Posts
    1,892

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by z1co View Post
    When is the problem of owning a team in every category but ending up losing or drawing going to be fixed

    The amount of games where you outshoot the cpu heavily and have a high on target and clear cut chance rating compared to the cpu who seems to score on every little chance on target. It happens all the time far too often to be realistic in any way.

    Do the ratings of players shot accuracy mean anything in this game? of course there are other factors but they musn't mean crap if players seem to score all their chances when playing the the user.
    This is either a motivation issue or a tactical one... I'd say the former, others would say the latter, perhaps it's a mixture of the two?

  79. #79
    First Team Squad Member
    Join Date
    9th November 2010
    Location
    Standing free, wherever i may be
    Posts
    15,244

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by z1co View Post
    When is the problem of owning a team in every category but ending up losing or drawing going to be fixed

    The amount of games where you outshoot the cpu heavily and have a high on target and clear cut chance rating compared to the cpu who seems to score on every little chance on target. It happens all the time far too often to be realistic in any way.

    Do the ratings of players shot accuracy mean anything in this game? of course there are other factors but they musn't mean crap if players seem to score all their chances when playing the the user.
    I would imagine as soon as FIFA introduce a rule that states the dominate team must be awarded a win because its unfair otherwise......

  80. #80
    Youth Team
    Join Date
    19th March 2011
    Posts
    4,566

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by FrazT View Post
    Believe me, a large % of complaint/rant threads start with this
    believe me, I was ironic-sarcastic

  81. #81
    Amateur
    Join Date
    23rd August 2009
    Location
    Lurgan, Co. Armagh
    Posts
    301

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by milnerpoint View Post
    no football manager simulates being a football manager, not being a human being.
    Lulz.

    I don't get comparing the Leicester card example as a bug. one team has 23 cards. One team has 5 cards. Median is what? 14? Thats not bad for October if you look at real life. 23 cards in what? ~12 games? 2 per game? I've seen worse IRL.

  82. #82

    Default

    The only bad thing about the game is that it gets really slow after 4 seasons (regens and staff overload) its really annoying, my computer keep on crashing

  83. #83
    First Team Squad Member
    Join Date
    9th November 2010
    Location
    Standing free, wherever i may be
    Posts
    15,244

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by aditya View Post
    The only bad thing about the game is that it gets really slow after 4 seasons (regens and staff overload) its really annoying, my computer keep on crashing
    Thats not really a problem with the game tho, thats your computer being rubbish, or your trying to run too many leagues at once. I am now 16 seasons in, the game still runs at a good speed for me.

  84. #84
    Part-Timer
    Join Date
    9th December 2010
    Location
    sat on my butt
    Posts
    1,892

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by Ego Scriptor View Post
    What makes FM11 frustrating at times is that it tries to be both a game and a simulator. A game can be mastered and beaten whereas a simulator is intended to closely model real world results. Since players can largely figure out the part of the game that is based mainly on their input (i.e., tactics), their input can grossly disrupt the sense of "realism" central to a simulation. To remedy this, SI have placed increasing importance on areas of the game where player input produces more random and obscure results (e.g., team talks and press conferences) and introduced mechanisms that render player input increasingly irrelevant if it veers too far away from "realistic" results (e.g., complacency, nerfed one-on-ones, lower reputation team super goalies). The reason this is frustrating is that it makes the player feel as if his input doesn't really matter and that the initial effort he put into the game was, more or less, a waste of time.

    This is why it's imperative that SI get back to basics with FM12 and really focus on beefing up the tactical AI. I don't know anyone who finds the so-called "psychological" aspect of the game to be either fun or particularly realistic, and yet, FM11 focused primarily on expanding these tedious aspects and greatly increasing their influence on the match engine.
    I love it... I find it immensely rewarding and fun to "get it right"...

    In any case, everybody is focusing on the wrong things... the biggest issue with this game is the flaming match-odds... they dictate your players beliefs...

    If you are odds-on favourites, then your players expect to win (and expect you to demand of them); if you are big outsiders then your players expect to lose, or at least struggle, and expect you to take the pressure off them; if it's tight (i.e. 6/4 home 7/4 away) then your players expect a close game and for you to offer them encouragement...

    Now you might say that is fine... until you are the team at the top of the league and romping it and you come up against that oh so tough away game v the bottom team who have yet to register a point and the flipping match-odds have the home team as odds-on favourites... say what? This is where the game's biggest flaw is, because the match odds have a massive influence on your players yet they are seldom right...

    In real-life if Manchester United were playing West Ham at Upton Park on Saturday, they would be BIG favourites... in FM the Hammers would be odds-on...

    If anything at all needs changing within the game it is the match-odds and the influence they have on your players, get them right and the game becomes easier because how many would ignore the match-odds and "expect a win" against a winless team with a dominant one? Most people? Exactly! And then they would complain that their team played like my local pub team whilst the winless team played like Barcelona and it would all be because of the match-odds...

    Fix the match-odds SI!

  85. #85
    Youth Team
    Join Date
    19th March 2011
    Posts
    4,566

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by Lazaru5 View Post
    I love it... I find it immensely rewarding and fun to "get it right"...

    In any case, everybody is focusing on the wrong things... the biggest issue with this game is the flaming match-odds... they dictate your players beliefs...

    If you are odds-on favourites, then your players expect to win (and expect you to demand of them); if you are big outsiders then your players expect to lose, or at least struggle, and expect you to take the pressure off them; if it's tight (i.e. 6/4 home 7/4 away) then your players expect a close game and for you to offer them encouragement...

    Now you might say that is fine... until you are the team at the top of the league and romping it and you come up against that oh so tough away game v the bottom team who have yet to register a point and the flipping match-odds have the home team as odds-on favourites... say what? This is where the game's biggest flaw is, because the match odds have a massive influence on your players yet they are seldom right...

    In real-life if Manchester United were playing West Ham at Upton Park on Saturday, they would be BIG favourites... in FM the Hammers would be odds-on...

    If anything at all needs changing within the game it is the match-odds and the influence they have on your players, get them right and the game becomes easier because how many would ignore the match-odds and "expect a win" against a winless team with a dominant one? Most people? Exactly! And then they would complain that their team played like my local pub team whilst the winless team played like Barcelona and it would all be because of the match-odds...

    Fix the match-odds SI!
    Yes I have noticed this too. Another thing is that if a club like Manchester United finds themselves in mid-table positions for years on end, they are still very hard to beat! It is like having skilled players and a high reputation just trumps anything else. Form and morale doesn't seem to matter for the AI teams, hence, the winless team playing fantastic football scoring fantastic goals as you say. So on one hand you have underperforming super-teams playing like they always do against you, and on the other hand you have awful teams playing fantasticly against you... I don't get it! Is it the team tallks, or the tactics - or both? Or none?

  86. #86
    Amateur
    Join Date
    15th October 2008
    Posts
    603

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by Neil Brock View Post
    That they are, but you tell that to people who are complaining about injuries they don't tend to take it too well!
    Yesterday Sanchez broken for 7 months and Abdi discovered a heart problem, so out for 12/13 months. I don't complain this (it happens I mean), I complain the fact that Abdi, who was co-owned with Milan, was bought by Milan at the end of the year ahahahaha

  87. #87
    Amateur
    Join Date
    15th February 2008
    Posts
    20

    Default

    I am beginning to think this game is a joke. In FM 2008 and 2009, crash dumps kept on occouring, I would have thought you would have reduced this however I moved on to FM2010 and thought there would be reduced crash dumps but I am extremely dissappointed to find they are still occouring and by browsing the forums they are as common as ever. If you do not do something to remedy this and soon you will start to lose many players who have been loyal to this game for many years. I spend hours on this game but it is beginning to **** me off and I know talking to others that thei fool the same.

  88. #88
    Amateur
    Join Date
    19th November 2005
    Posts
    196

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by MAINBOY View Post
    I started a new game yesterday with Hibs and on the first day of my new save my best midfielder Liam Miller gets injured in training for two months.
    Ah - that definitly proves that injuries are bugged then!.....

+ Reply to Thread

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts