Closed Thread
Results 1 to 30 of 30

Thread: ok, so whether you get warned for complaining is entirely random.

  1. #1
    Amateur
    Join Date
    18th January 2008
    Posts
    81

    Default

    whats the point of it then?

  2. #2
    Amateur
    Join Date
    18th January 2008
    Posts
    81

    Default

    whats the point of it then?

  3. #3
    Youth Team
    Join Date
    26th January 2007
    Location
    stop feeding the trolls
    Posts
    4,179

    Default

    helps build relationships with your players, affecting their morale according to whether they think you were right to do it, or didnt stick up for them, or whatever...

  4. #4
    First Team
    Join Date
    12th January 2006
    Location
    We Never do anything together anymore.
    Posts
    23,175

    Default

    Rinso, lets be honest here. This is a pretty useless feature. Apart from an odd change in morale once in a blue moon from this feature, it does nothing.

  5. #5
    Youth Team
    Join Date
    21st January 2005
    Location
    I used to chase eggs. Now I am just trying not to respond to eegits.
    Posts
    5,007

    Default

    I don't think it's entirely random at all.

  6. #6
    Youth Team
    Join Date
    26th January 2007
    Location
    stop feeding the trolls
    Posts
    4,179

    Default

    lol fair pint i spose, it doesnt really do much...

  7. #7
    Amateur
    Join Date
    18th January 2008
    Posts
    81

    Default

    either that of the match screen displays it wrong

  8. #8
    Youth Team
    Join Date
    26th January 2007
    Location
    stop feeding the trolls
    Posts
    4,179

    Default

    could be a fair point too....

  9. #9
    Reserves
    Join Date
    14th March 2004
    Location
    Phnom Penh!
    Posts
    10,418

    Default

    I don't think that it's random - the AI knows if the ref was right and you were wrong or vice versa.

    The problem is, we have no way of knowing from the 2D engine or commentary whether we're justified in complaining or not. Furthermore, there is next to no advantage in complaining and ever disincentive to do so.

    Thus, although you selected the wrong term, I know what you meran and I'm in agreement with you. SI need to make the option more effective.

  10. #10
    Third Team
    Join Date
    5th November 2007
    Posts
    7,335

    Default

    I like this option but only because I take the Fergie and Wenger stance and always back up my players but deal with them behind closed doors (oo-er). It really should have more effect though.

    We should be able to tell if the decision was right or wrong though. The easy way round it is to have a definate answer in the commentary/match report, offsides could be made more interactive with someone proposing a 2 coloured lines option on the replays to show if he was or wasn't offside. I think that would be a nice feature too.

  11. #11
    Youth Team
    Join Date
    9th May 2003
    Location
    Wembley, Block 133, Row 23, Seat 296 - COME ON YOUR SPURRRRS!!!!
    Posts
    4,279

    Default

    quote:
    Originally posted by Jimbokav1971:
    I don't think it's entirely random at all.


    It may not be, but when you complain for say an offside that from the match replay never was and still get fined etc then it does prove to be a bit of a lottery as to the effects of the feature.

  12. #12
    Amateur
    Join Date
    10th November 2006
    Posts
    0

    Default

    quote:
    Originally posted by George Graham:
    quote:
    Originally posted by Jimbokav1971:
    I don't think it's entirely random at all.


    It may not be, but when you complain for say an offside that from the match replay never was and still get fined etc then it does prove to be a bit of a lottery as to the effects of the feature.


    I have a decade old career game. Everytime there's a controversy that I'm asked to make a comment on, I check the match report. I have never been fined all these game years. It's not random at all.

    I've learned never to bother looking at the 2d screen when trying to detemine fouls/offsides/whatever.

  13. #13
    Amateur
    Join Date
    3rd November 2006
    Posts
    252

    Default

    I'd like to know the logic behind why you are in trouble for complaining if it turns out you're wrong, but alls fine in the world if it turns out you're right.

    Either complaining about the officials to the press is deemed wrong by the footballing powers, or it is tollerated. Especially when you choose the less extreme option when criticising officials rather than the blow-your-top option.

    This is one of many features that make it more like a superficial kids game than a proper simulation. Either do it properly or bin it.

  14. #14
    Youth Team
    Join Date
    21st January 2005
    Location
    I used to chase eggs. Now I am just trying not to respond to eegits.
    Posts
    5,007

    Default

    quote:
    Originally posted by nax:
    quote:
    Originally posted by George Graham:
    quote:
    Originally posted by Jimbokav1971:
    I don't think it's entirely random at all.


    It may not be, but when you complain for say an offside that from the match replay never was and still get fined etc then it does prove to be a bit of a lottery as to the effects of the feature.


    I have a decade old career game. Everytime there's a controversy that I'm asked to make a comment on, I check the match report. I have never been fined all these game years. It's not random at all.

    I've learned never to bother looking at the 2d screen when trying to detemine fouls/offsides/whatever.


    Exactly. People are just lazy.

  15. #15
    Amateur
    Join Date
    22nd July 2005
    Posts
    860

    Default

    What I dislike about this feature is that there is no "date of expiry". You can complain three times over twenty seasons and you'll still get a touchline ban.

  16. #16
    Youth Team
    Join Date
    21st January 2005
    Location
    I used to chase eggs. Now I am just trying not to respond to eegits.
    Posts
    5,007

    Default

    quote:
    Originally posted by endtime:
    What I dislike about this feature is that there is no "date of expiry". You can complain three times over twenty seasons and you'll still get a touchline ban.


    Is that right?

    I didn't realise it was a 3 strikes and you're out rule .

  17. #17
    Amateur
    Join Date
    22nd July 2005
    Posts
    860

    Default

    I think it's four actually; first complaint - warning, second - further warning, third - fine, fourth - ban.

  18. #18
    Semi Pro
    Join Date
    21st September 2005
    Location
    Netherlands
    Posts
    2,596

    Default

    It is not entirely random, if it is clearly offside and I complain the fa remain silent. That doesn't mean the feature can be attacked as it is too predictable what the consequences are, happens too often and can't be judged in a lot of cases. That makes that features more irritating than useful. In this state it should be removed or, as that won't happen, tweaked down a lot.

  19. #19
    Third Team
    Join Date
    5th November 2007
    Posts
    7,335

    Default

    quote:
    Originally posted by nax:
    I have a decade old career game. Everytime there's a controversy that I'm asked to make a comment on, I check the match report. I have never been fined all these game years. It's not random at all.

    I've learned never to bother looking at the 2d screen when trying to detemine fouls/offsides/whatever.


    I dunno how this worked for you because I always checked the match report in my first few games and still got fined.

    "Do (team) have a right to feel aggrieved" isn't particularly definate.

    Also i've been in the situation where I have checked the match report re: a red card and have fined the player because it says the pushed the victim, he accepts the fine, I then I lamabast the ref and the FA stay silent over my criticism. It would seem from the FA stance that the ref got it wrong but if that's the case why did the player accept his fine?

  20. #20
    Youth Team
    Join Date
    21st January 2005
    Location
    I used to chase eggs. Now I am just trying not to respond to eegits.
    Posts
    5,007

    Default

    quote:
    Originally posted by endtime:
    I think it's four actually; first complaint - warning, second - further warning, third - fine, fourth - ban.


    endtime.

    Do you know this to be true?

    Do you think this to be true?

    Do you think you know this to be true ?

    Seriously, if you tell me 100% it's true I will believe you(ish) .

  21. #21
    Amateur
    Join Date
    22nd July 2005
    Posts
    860

    Default

    I think I'm right I'm positive that the game doesn't "forget" that you complained ten years ago, so the only thing I'm not sure of is how many complaints it actually takes to land a touchline ban.

  22. #22
    Reserves
    Join Date
    21st July 2003
    Location
    Hiding in the Editor
    Posts
    11,417

    Default

    If the opening poster is saying it's random, I assume he's done some extensive testing and has stats to back up his statement?

  23. #23
    Youth Team
    Join Date
    21st January 2005
    Location
    I used to chase eggs. Now I am just trying not to respond to eegits.
    Posts
    5,007

    Default

    endtime. I usually keep my mouth shut unless it's blatant. I will attempt to complain more to test your theory .

  24. #24
    Youth Team
    Join Date
    21st January 2005
    Location
    I used to chase eggs. Now I am just trying not to respond to eegits.
    Posts
    5,007

    Default

    quote:
    Originally posted by Super Bladesman:
    If the opening poster is saying it's random, I assume he's done some extensive testing and has stats to back up his statement?


    Don't be ridiculous.

  25. #25
    ryjoco
    Guest

    Default

    If the commentary says "It looked offside to me!" then I complain. Likewise, if it was blatantly in my favour, I say the opponent's are unlucky but it happens, and most times my player praises my courage and honesty.

  26. #26
    Youth Team
    Join Date
    9th May 2003
    Location
    Wembley, Block 133, Row 23, Seat 296 - COME ON YOUR SPURRRRS!!!!
    Posts
    4,279

    Default

    quote:
    Originally posted by nax:
    quote:
    Originally posted by George Graham:
    quote:
    Originally posted by Jimbokav1971:
    I don't think it's entirely random at all.


    It may not be, but when you complain for say an offside that from the match replay never was and still get fined etc then it does prove to be a bit of a lottery as to the effects of the feature.


    I have a decade old career game. Everytime there's a controversy that I'm asked to make a comment on, I check the match report. I have never been fined all these game years. It's not random at all.

    I've learned never to bother looking at the 2d screen when trying to detemine fouls/offsides/whatever.


    Well obviously you cannot tell whether a foul is a foul from the 2D.

    But offsides are a totally different matter- its pretty much black and white in this area, and the game is getting it wrong where players are obviously on or off, and it is a lottery as to whether the engine gets it right as regards your complaints.

    Hopefully this will be fixed- as offsides in FM08 in general are woeful, even if you take into consideration asst refs making mistakes.

  27. #27
    Youth Team
    Join Date
    21st January 2005
    Location
    I used to chase eggs. Now I am just trying not to respond to eegits.
    Posts
    5,007

    Default

    I like the fact that Ass Refs make mistakes, (as they do in reality), but I have never complained, (when I know it to be a poor decision), and not been backed by the FA.

    I must say that I don't often complain though, so maybe I just haven't come across this yet.

  28. #28
    Part-Timer
    Join Date
    4th July 2007
    Location
    The Wirral.
    Posts
    1,444

    Default

    Offsides aren't that random - because you can actually see if they were/were not offside.

    But i often don't bother comenting on fouls, simply because no matter how many times you look at the incident you still haven't got a clue.

    Something that could be sorted by your assman saying "it was a foul" or "it wasn't" just to let you know how to proceed.

    Also, relating to the "4 strikes" idea above, i went through a whole season giving the "sounds like sour grapes" response, then with my very first complaint towards the FA, i was given a touch line ban - do the FA hold all negative comments against you?

    Also, relating to real life - look at david moyes comments regarding the idiot that is mark clattenberg (sp). Moyes was right, it could not be argued any other way, yet the FA still charged him - something that FM fails to appreciate, is that criticism of refs, even if justified, is not accepted in real life.

  29. #29
    Amateur
    Join Date
    22nd July 2005
    Posts
    860

    Default

    Oh yeah, and another thing: I wish there was a corellation between the complaints and the reaction from the FA. As it is now, the FA "remain silent" when you complain about having a player sent off, indicating the referee's decision was incorrect, but the next day reject you appeal, saying that the red card was valid.

  30. #30
    Youth Team
    Join Date
    21st January 2005
    Location
    I used to chase eggs. Now I am just trying not to respond to eegits.
    Posts
    5,007

    Default

    Yeah, I do agree with that. I don't appeal any more even though I have heard that someobody was once succesfull .

Closed Thread

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts