PDA

View Full Version : crowd disruptions



Stevicus
25-01-2009, 19:30
it seems to me that throughout the last 30 or so years, the crowd also like to be involved in some way, be it streakers, crowds throwing objects, dogs running onto the pitch, people running on the pitch (with the decency to be clothed). just wondering would anyone love to see that in the game? adds realism and (depending on your mood with the game), humour!

Harryseaess
25-01-2009, 19:32
Doubt it would be introduced in FM due to it being a part of football that many people don't like. Plus it doesn't add anything to the game so there would be no need IMO.

Bazib
25-01-2009, 19:34
doesnt really add anything to the game in my opinion....

Stevicus
25-01-2009, 19:35
Doubt it would be introduced in FM due to it being a part of football that many people don't like. Plus it doesn't add anything to the game so there would be no need IMO.

you have a point but the crowds throwing objects is quite a frequent event these days, and could lead to player injuries, people may not like it, but its likely to happen

Neji
25-01-2009, 19:36
I think we should keep the unsavourary parts of football out of the game.

It may be realistic but thats not a good enough reason alone to include something.

Stevicus
25-01-2009, 19:39
I think we should keep the unsavourary parts of football out of the game.

It may be realistic but thats not a good enough reason alone to include something.

i uppose your right, i just wanted someones opinion on it, its just i really love realism lol

Clark123
25-01-2009, 19:45
http://i101.photobucket.com/albums/m58/12clark12/Untitled-27.jpg

Isnt it already a feature?

Stevicus
25-01-2009, 20:06
http://i101.photobucket.com/albums/m58/12clark12/Untitled-27.jpg

Isnt it already a feature?

oki wtf, are you sure they are not physios? or a bug to do with substitutes warming up? im sure if they were spectator disruptions, something would be said durin commentary

jod123
25-01-2009, 20:06
i uppose your right, i just wanted someones opinion on it, its just i really love realism lol

There is a limit to the amount of realism the game should contain though.

By the way with your suggestions the rating for the game would have to be increased no doubt due to the violence and nudity. :p

tansrb
25-01-2009, 20:07
http://i101.photobucket.com/albums/m58/12clark12/Untitled-27.jpg

Isnt it already a feature?

those are medics.

DanGLiverpool
25-01-2009, 20:10
Yeah, they are the physios.

Stevicus
25-01-2009, 20:11
There is a limit to the amount of realism the game should contain though.

By the way with your suggestions the rating for the game would have to be increased no doubt due to the violence and nudity. :p

hahaha i wasnt suggesting the nudity thing, just pointing out that its happened, but if that ever happened in the game, no guys!! lol

Clark123
25-01-2009, 20:15
Yeah, they are the physios.

I thought medics had to be off the pitch tho before the game resumed.

Stevicus
25-01-2009, 20:20
I thought medics had to be off the pitch tho before the game resumed.

fair point but i dunno, it might be a rule that SI accidentally overlooked but they are probably medics, you should have saved that match and see what happened beforehand

StephenIrelandIsAGnome
25-01-2009, 20:20
IIRC a player got sent off the other week for taking a streaker out, i for one wouldn't be impressed if my star striker got sent off for attack a nude fan! On the other side though could be quite comical if it happened to your opposition!

Darn Owens
25-01-2009, 20:38
Sorry to be off topic but what does " IMO " Mean

lol

:D

rancer890
25-01-2009, 20:40
Sorry to be off topic but what does " IMO " Mean

lol

:D

IMO = in my opinion

(beat jod to helping out a forumer to a little detail finally :p)

Crowd disruptions (along with death) will never be in FM. Period.

Harryohh
25-01-2009, 20:52
What a ridiculous idea OP.

peter-evo
25-01-2009, 21:01
What a ridiculous idea OP.

At least post something worth reading (add a reason)

I don't see why not, add a bit of harmless humour which wouldn't affect anything game related :)

Nomis07
25-01-2009, 21:01
What a ridiculous idea OP.

I don't think this idea is ever likely to be in the game, but disagreeing with OP should come hand in hand with reasoning.

There's no place for crowd violence or disruption in real life football and it's not something a majority of fans want to see, having it as a feature of a light hearted and supposedly enjoyable computer game is in no way appealing. I think the clubs would have something to say and the defamation of their fans btw.

Clark123
25-01-2009, 21:06
I don't think this idea is ever likely to be in the game, but disagreeing with OP should come hand in hand with reasoning.

There's no place for crowd violence or disruption in real life football and it's not something a majority of fans want to see, having it as a feature of a light hearted and supposedly enjoyable computer game is in no way appealing. I think the clubs would have something to say and the defamation of their fans btw.

What does OP stand for?

jackripper
25-01-2009, 21:13
original poster i think and why dont si add fans throwing pigs head wen ur madrid and signn a bara player .....im being sarcastic btw (by the way)

stvndysn
25-01-2009, 21:13
Opening Post dude

i also think its a part of football that should be kept out of game

wyrley_saddler
25-01-2009, 21:21
I think you need the crowd in the stadium first :D

Seriosly though, I think it would be a nice feature but it does seem very pointless.

BobMUFC08
25-01-2009, 21:26
There isn't any need for it to be in the game to the extent of having streakers but maybe there could be news items saying there was crowd trouble at the last game if it was a big derby or something

DietSpam
25-01-2009, 21:34
Can't really see what it would add to the game, and thus wouldn't want SI wasting their time on adding it in.

Pacman Jones
25-01-2009, 23:57
In CM3 I think, bloody long time ago, Im sure there was text at the bottom saying Streaker on the field saying she was a woman etc etc.

matt_132
26-01-2009, 00:09
after we get fans, baloons and flares and streakers would be a good addition

trueblue
26-01-2009, 02:42
Should definately be crowds added IMO,,and stuff like flags ,banners etc ,,flares would be good in places like italy too ,where so common there,, would add to the effect,, although when playing in the SPL some might argue that empty stadiums at places liike Rugby park DOES add to the realism lol,,

Has anyone ever had any different weather conditions rain or snow ??? or night games with flood light ,,esp for Euro footie which is always played in the evenings



Although the more they add to stuff like that,, the more the demand on graffics cards and memory and so on

Ediocy
26-01-2009, 06:44
When the 3D engine has evolved up to a point where crowds will be introduced, then maybe such cosmetic effects as balloons, flares, toilet papers and yes even streakers could be further added to give the game some visual flavor. There is nothing wrong with wanting eye-candy, but definitely not at the expense of having a solid match engine first.

As for more serious crowd trouble like fighting in the stands and mass pitch invasions, that is way more controversial and I would rather it be left out since it might lead to possible legal action against SI? No club would like their fans to be purposely represented in a game as being unruly and causing havoc, even though those fans might indeed behave as such in real-life.

phnompenhandy
26-01-2009, 07:10
SI have always clearly stated that crowd disruptions in any guise will never be in the game. End of.

sthptngomad76
26-01-2009, 11:53
A nice touch I feel would be a just a simple text string following a last gasp survival on the final day of the season saying "Its all over! {Team X} have survived and their fans are streaming onto the pitch in celebration!". It might also be mentioned in news items following it- all fairly harmless stuff.


A representation in the 3D match engine I feel isn't really necessary (one of the reasons I dislike the 3d is that youre limited in what you can depict rather than previously where only your imagination was the limit- text was endless in what it could depict...but that's a different argument)

R-dizzle
26-01-2009, 11:55
http://i101.photobucket.com/albums/m58/12clark12/Untitled-27.jpg

Isnt it already a feature?

I was looking at the comment saying one player got robbed and that he was running away from him because he nicked something lol.

Bababui
26-01-2009, 12:02
There is a limit to the amount of realism the game should contain though.

By the way with your suggestions the rating for the game would have to be increased no doubt due to the violence and nudity. :p

No violence..but some nudity wouldnt be a bad thing. After all, there is plenty of nudity during pre and post game talks. :p

phnompenhandy
27-01-2009, 06:11
I was looking at the comment saying one player got robbed and that he was running away from him because he nicked something lol.

Good spot!! :D